Topic: would a Super Smash Bros Maker be a good idea?

this is a long shot, but what if Nintendo made a game with Super Mario Maker Creations and use it for a Super Smash Bros Maker?

Basically a better level editor? I don't like the current one, liked Brawl's level editor more, so I would like an improved level editor.

What's to make? The game (the Wii U version at least) already has a level editor, as lacklustre as it is. They could improve it with a future patch, but there's really nothing that users can "make" that won't require programming experience.

I would appreciate the ability to customise Mii fighters with custom cries (though I strongly doubt that it will ever happen).

No.

A Mega Man or Zelda Maker on the other haaaand...

Oh god, like community-based animation creators? Why don't you just let the merchants into the temple already!?

I'd say Zelda too, but after watching one of GameXplain's videos on Pikmin 4....I Want Pikmin Maker. lol
Don't care what anyone says, but I enjoyed those underground sections in Pikmin 2.

How would that even work? If you mean a grid-based stage editor with predefined elements, Brawl had that already.
But if you suggest that people could actually create fighters, attacks, or somesuch thing, no. HELL. NO.

The Super Smash level editor is dull. There should have been a few more features at least.
It would be nice if making a level in SMM could be transfered over to SSB4 as a map.

@Kaze_Memaryu: oh no i mean the stages that you can make, not editing fighters or anything.
although i guess them going back brawl's stage editor would be similar of using.if there was a Super Smash Bros Maker.
but what i mean is. using other Nintendo game stuff that you can put on the stage (like put Villager's House on the stage, or have an item to add on you're stage, like baseball bat, and the banana, or stage hazers, put wherever you want player to be, that kind of stuff, although to be real im sure Nintendo would disallowed a bunch of bombs, or having Smash Balls at start, something more of line of weapons that you melee with,)

It...would just be a stage builder...right?

Nah

@Aozz Ah, okay. Now I understand what you mean. I do like that idea, but considering how obsessed Nintendo is with arbitrary RNG in Smash, I doubt such a thing would ever happen, unfortunately.

I don't think a full-out SSM would work, but we could use a good level editor. The one for Samsh 4 fixed some things wrong with Brawls but then turned around and made it less usable and took away options for some reason.

I would like a SmashBros Brawl stage builder but with more options and content.
Able to make side Scroller's, Waters, Mission's/events you can create and share, create chapters like subspace emissary and play characters through the stages, etc.
This overall would help a good learning curve for people into game development and level making.