Topic: Game vs. Game

The Wind Waker. Completed it 100% four times. Everything negative said about this game is actually undeniably positive to me.

I´ve grown to like Twilight Princess too, after the initial disappointment. I completed it once. It felt unfinished in a few places. Now I take it for what it is. And for just 20 bucks now you can´t miss it!

Wind Waker.

Wind Waker: 13
Twilight Princess: 7

Both are really good, but I have to go for Wind Waker.

Wind Waker: 14
Twilight Princess: 7

Do you need to have played both of them? If not, i vote on TP (i have played about an hour on WW but i'm pretty sure i'll still like TP bether).

I think it's too soon for you to judge Wind Waker. At first I hated it because I was stuck in the Forsaken Fortress but I grew to love it once I got to Windfall.

I guess i'll force myself to play it then.

Maybe so - but if first impressions of the game arent good then he has every right to put a vote on Twilight Princess, especially considering some voters havent played both games.

Twilight Princess : 7
Wind Waker : 14

@Oddy, I had updated it though. It should be right

Edit : For me, I like Wind Waker better because it never tries to be dark like Twilight Princess does. Maybe I just like happy games more, b Twilight Princess got a little too depressing for me at times.

The ratio between the two is now 2 : 1 Wind Waker

Twlight Princess for me.

I highly doubt it's required. This is about what game you like more, essentially, and if you already like TP more, you have every right to judge it based on your current experience, should you choose to.

Twilight Princess : 9
Wind Waker : 14

Added @Josher744 and @Xilef's votes

TP: 10
WW: 14

Wind Waker

Yeah @Emann1. It'll be much easier to count the votes, if you post an update after every count. Then you'll know exactly when you stopped tallying the votes.

How about a Kirby poll next?

TP- 11
WW- 15

@G4L

I can't tell if you're being serious or sarcastic
I was just saying I wanted other people to update the vote count as they vote, which people seem to be doing now. Anyways.

@Chrono_Cross

I was thinking about that, just didn't think of the 2 games yet

Kirby Super Star and Kirby's Return to Dream Land.

@G4L If he's serious, I agree. You should be could be counting them yourself, it's your thread, and you're responsibility. Plus, it'll be easier on the people posting, and you don't have to worry about anyone else screwing things up. More cogs in the machine make it more likely to break down.

@Mickeymac

I realize its my thread, but clearly other people are involved here. Its not like you all are posting for my sake, its just a discussion / poll for everyone to be in on. Its not much to ask for people to update it when they vote.

Twilight Princess for me.
TP - 12 (I think?)
WW - 15