Topic: Game vs. Game

Super Metroid, for being on the whole more consistent in its level of atmosphere, more vibrant and in having more varied and enjoyable gameplay

i love both games, but arrrgh! so hard to choose. if i had to pick one, it would be super metroid in terms of the story and gameplay.

that and as i prefer 2D metroid.

I haven't played Metroid prime yet so I vote for Super Metroid.

Super Metroid: 14
Metroid prime: 13

Metroid Prime

Super Metroid: 14
Metroid Prime: 14

I gotta say, I prefer the 2D Metroid games as well - they feel like they're at the heart of how the series began. So, SUPER METROID all the way.

Metroid Prime, being my favorite game of all time

Metroid Prime: 15
Super Metroid: 15

30 votes, but for the first time in this thread, its an even 15-15 score.
Should we just keep voting or should I change it?

@Strongo9, I think I'll have the votes go a little longer. It doesn't seem fair to have it be decided by just one vote. Thanks for voting though

Keep voting!

Metroid Prime: 16

Super Metroid: 16

Super Metroid is clearly superior people that is a scientific fact, though I will admit the prime series is great if your having trouble sleeping always put me to sleep anyway.

My god they're tied...

Makes sense since they are both awesome!

Metroid Prime: 17
Super Metroid: 16

While I understand Super Metroid's appeal, I never actually liked the game. Metroid Prime got my vote.

I think I've played Super Metroid a whole two times! I've probably owned it for three years at least... I've never understood the appeal of 2D Metroid, they're so restrictive, you spend so much more times hooting walls to find passages than you do doing anything fun.

Metroid Prime is actually really cool.

Metroid Prime: 18
Super Metroid: 16

Since there hasn't been a new vote for 5 days, the winner is :

Metroid Prime winning by 2 votes!

NEW Games!

The Legend of Zelda : Twilight Princess VS. Wind Waker

I'll vote for both

Twilight Princess : 1
Wind Waker : 1

Start voting now!

Twilight Princess: 1
Wind Waker:
Skyward Sword: 1

I know, I know, but you can't blame a guy for trying.

The one where you save the princess and fight gannondorf.

Wind Waker is a masterpiece, and Twilight Princess is utter cr*p. Wind Waker gets my vote.

Twilight Princess, but it's close.

Twilight Princess: 2
Wind Waker: 1
Forfeit: 2

In seriousness Twilight Princess. I love the fact that both games are happening at the same time in different time periods.

@G4L, I'm saving Skyward Sword for going up against whichever wins this one

Twilight Princess : 3
Wind Waker : 2

Edit : You can vote for both if you really want. In fact, I'm voting for both. Because I love them both equally, they're just too different for me to decide