Topic: What is the point of Kinect?

Many people have been praising Kinect as 'a revolution in gaming' because of its controllerless control method and voice...er...control.
In my opinion, though, Kinect is a step backwards. Firstly, I think the voice control is plain pointless. It's easier to press a button to play a movie than to say "Xbox, play". And, in the words of the brilliant Charlie Brooker, "talking to your Xbox makes you look like a dork".
I also think the motion control limits the kind of game you can play. In some cases, like the dancing game shown at E3, it works well, but wouldn't you rather turn a steering wheel to drive a racecar than use your bare hands? And how would you play a game like Super Mario Bros without a controller? Does anyone else feel the same way I do about Kinect? I have nothing against motion-controlled games, but to me Kinect is just a gimmick.

You're pretty much saying all the things everyone else was saying back during E3. You can also post your thoughts about Kinect in these two Kinect-discussing threads if you like.