Topic: Super Mario Odyssey

@Woomy_NNYes Yeah the Wii's the only console with two 3D Mario games. The N64, GameCube, Wii U, and Switch each have one.

@NorseGamerTommy Yeah me too, I'd love an Odyssey 2. I wanna see more kingdoms (maybe like 15 more full-sized kingdoms) to play around in, each with their own set of Power Moons to collect. They could do just that, and add some more enemies to capture, and I would be perfectly happy!

Yea, I think Odyssey 2. I just hope they come up with a bigger hub world this time. But I guess that's not really the Odyssey game design, though.

I still think Mario 64 was the perfect 3D Mario.

I want a Breath of the Wild sized world for Odyssey 2. It's won't happen, but I want it.

@Woomy_NNYes

I can't imagine a world that big actually working for a platformer. There's no way they could fill the entire world with platforming challenges, so you'd end up with big stretches of land between them. That would seem a lot weirder in a platformer than in an RPG or adventure game, given the more abstract and focused nature of most platformers.

Think of the Sand Kingdom in Odyssey. That was probably the biggest in total area and it meant you just had large stretches of nothingness between landmarks.

I FAR preferred the Metro Kingdom. Which was a lot smaller in scale but much more focused and dense.

Actually Sand Kingdom was probably my favorite kingdom in the game.

@Dezzy My logic was, in botw they linked different climates and towns, and divided them with trees, mountains, cliffs, plains, water features. And in odyssey, you can get around with Jaxi or a moped. They could even replace shrines with haunted mansions or toad mushroom houses. If you think that sounds crazy, perhaps it is

@Woomy_NNYes

I think huge open-worlds only really work in games where there's either a big incentive for exploration OR games where the story and lore are benefited by having the huge world. The rest of the time they're kinda pointless.

I can't help feeling Mario going open-world would be a bit like Metal Gear Solid 5 going open-world, in that it added almost nothing to the experience. Almost no-one says it was better than the earlier games because of that.

That's so different from something like Witcher 3 or Final Fantasy XV, which benefited massively from going open-world.

I agree that massive "open" worlds don't usually jive for platformers. I just thought Odyssey was a bit too..."hoppy." I mean, it pretty much lacks a hub world of any sort, so it just kind of turns into a menu, and that's a bummer. Just something like the castle from Mario 64, but a bit bigger with a bit more going on. That's all, nothing crazy.

@iKhan

But was it because of the horizontal size of it, or was it because of the visuals and platforming design. Because they could've fit that same thing into half the area and it would've been fine.

I think it had a lot to do with the sheer amount of content. But I think the size was part of it. I loved roaming the desert trying to find neat new things to do.

I have like 770+ moons and don't really care to finish the collection of the moons. Is there a reason to hop back into the game and 100% it?

That depends if 100% a game is a must for you, or that you just enjoy SMO that much. Some of the moons require dedication and repetition a lot of times!

I finally got the last moon yesterday, so it was worth it to me. I really like doing those harder moons, as I see it as a good challenge. And seeing what happened to Peachs castle when I did finish was pretty funny!

Edit 2: Took me a little more than 70 hours, according to my switch profile.

@ThainEshKelch took me forever to beat the game, but it was so worth it in the end. Lovely game to relax over and forget about the stress of the work-force.

@Apportal I'm replying here to avoid off-topic. Okay, so I want to get 69. WOODED KINGDOM MASTER CUP moon (on Switch Lite). I'm supposed to do a very complicated move in the air LOL.

EDIT: Got it.

@Apportal It took me a while to fully complete it too. I got all the Power Moons throughout the course of two years since launch day. And yeah I agree with you - it felt nice to have SMO fully completed, too.

@MarioLover92 still trying to 100%.

@MarioLover92 @Apportal @Snatcher @Slowdive Finally, I got all the moons, except The Darker Side. I died in the lava and stopped, it's late here so I'll try tomorrow. I still have some purple coins to find but getting all moons but the last one is something I didn't expect to do 😄.

After thinking through things. There are actually quite a few 3D Mario’s that I like more. I feel like this game is a little too open world for my tastes. It’s still a great game no doubt, but galaxy 1, 2, 64, and 3D world are all more fun IMO

@BlueOcean Darker Side is mega tough for sure - finishing it felt real good for me. lol

Best of luck for when you get another shot at it!

Its going to take me a long time to 100%