Topic: BIS vs. Scribblenauts: Which is better?

I only got BIS (FREAKING AWESOME), and was wondering what you guys/girls was thinking about either. Scribblenauts is currnetly looking great for me, and though I will get it October 11, I'm still not sure if can get it before.
My current rating of BIS: 10

Haven't picked up Bowsa yet, but I'd say it probably depends on the game type one is in the mood for. Scribblenauts is for when you just want to sort of fool around for a minute, trying to come up with cleverly bizarre ways to solve the little stages, but it's not really something you settle in to play for a longer period the way I'm guessing BIS is.

Scribblenauts is amazing but it has some annoying control problems. Which is a better game? Probably Mario & Luigi 3. Which is one of the most innovative and creative games ever? Scribble--but it ain't perfect.

I haven't played inside story yet. But so far I give scribble an 8 out of 10. Maxwell only has one speed of movement, and his jumping and just overall control feel awkward. I've also found that even though the game recognizes tons of different words, a lot of them share items. For example, scimitar and katana, two totally different looking swords, bring up the same sword.

Only played BIS soo....

Scribblenauts is for making a whole crap load of random stuff and having fun BIS is for having a good ol mario& luigi rpg time! The both PWN DONKEY BUTT!

Completely separate genres, so it'd be impossible to really compare them. However, Scribblenauts definitely wins the "most creative" award. BIS, while, of course, I expect to be excellent simply cannot match Scribblenaut's innovation.

That said, BIS may end of being the better "game." Only time will tell.

I've played neither, but I'd say BIS is the better game. It's (supposedly) the greatest entry in the greatest RPG series ever. I may have considered Scibble superior, but it doesn't allow any dirty words, so it gets knocked down a few pegs in my book.

I'll get back to you.

squirbblenauts is a disappointment. somehow it just isnt as easy to create fun sitiuations as it looks in the trailers

Scribblenauts is awesome. It's only flaw is controlling Maxwell.

@briunji04: Then your not very fun.

Lets see...an over hyped game that has bad controls, or a soon to go down in history RPG that is considered the best in the series?

Beats me!

Scribblenauts is a very fun awesome game! type in "obl"
BIS is also very awesome. it probably stand better as a game but scribblenauts is very creative and original

I might get scribblenauts then get bis in a couple of weeks

BIS 10 Scribble 10

BIS is perrty good, I've yet to play Scribblenauts, but those controls will likely be an achilles heel for many.

I haven't played BIS yet but I'm going to buy it soon, Scribblenauts was kind of a critical flop for all the hype that surrounded and its not as good as I thought it would be but its still pretty fun.

BIS. It's so fun...I can barely put it down.......

Both are truly great in my mind. As of right now if I could only keep one it would be Scribblenauts, but I'm only about an hour into BIS atm, so...

Is both an option? I haven't played Scribblenauts yet, but everyone says it's amazing.

And I can tell you without a doubt that BIS is one of most favorite DS games...it beats New Super Mario Bros. as my top game!