The Game Awards — Geoff Keighley's pet project that's a bit like the Oscars and a lot like a three-hour advert with the actual awards hastily shoved in the cracks — took place last night, and although a lot of things happened during those three hours (plus the 30-minute pre-show), not much of it was destined for the Nintendo Switch.
We recently looked back over Nintendo's best and worst years at The Game Awards since its inception, and with Breath of the Wild and Super Smash Bros. Ultimate dominating proceedings in past years, we expected something from Nintendo — some nugget of a first-party announcement or other.
But no. Here's a brief summary of what was announced for Switch (or assumed to come to Switch):
- Sonic Frontiers (Holiday 2022)
- The Lord of the Rings: Gollum (2022)
- Cuphead's 'Delicious Last Course' DLC (30th June, 2022)
- Persona 4 Arena Ultimax (2022)
- Monster Hunter Rise: Sunbreak DLC + amiibo (Summer 2022)
- A Plague Tale: Requiem - Cloud Version (2022)
Of course, there were plenty more games that didn't announce platforms just yet, and we'd love to see games like Thirsty Suitors and Have A Nice Death in our hands some day, but otherwise, the showing over those three hours wasn't particularly thrilling for Switch-only owners.
Alongside the game announcements, there was also a trailer for the Sonic the Hedgehog movie sequel, and Metroid Dread won Best Action/Adventure. Shockingly, despite dominating the shortlist, Nintendo did not win Best Family — that honour went to It Takes Two, a game that unflinchingly deals with the impending divorce of two parents, and has a bit where they kill a stuffed animal while it begs for mercy.
All in all, my general take is that it really didn't need to be that long. Three hours is a lot of time to spend doing anything, let alone at a time that was pretty darn late in the day for almost everyone — setting a live event at 5pm on almost the very last time zone on Earth is going to be inconvenient for pretty much anyone east of Los Angeles. It's an odd choice for an event with such a global reach.
Plus, I know it's not really news at this point, but if something bills itself as an awards show, it's a bit strange to treat those same awards as a mild inconvenience in-between trailers and movie adverts.
And to relegate some of those awards to a less-than-a-minute long feature in the pre-show just shows the true sentiment behind The Game Awards: Despite being nominally an awards show for games, the people in charge evidently don't consider things like Games For Impact, Audio Design, and eSports worth their time, since they weren't even in the main show.
Another topic that caused a lot of anger on social media was Geoff Keighley's approach to the reckoning going on in the industry right now. At the top of the show, Keighley spoke out against harassment, albeit non-specifically (transcription by IGN):
"The games we play and the games that we love teach us that we can impact the world around us, and tonight I call on everyone to do their part to build a better, safer video game industry. Speak out online, vote with your time and with your dollars, empower these world builders who are creating the future of all entertainment."
This mealy-mouthed statement was then followed-up by games and announcements from Quantic Dream, Bungie, Ubisoft, Riot, and Naughty Dog.
The show wasn't without the odd highlight. We're big fans of Supergiant Games and Darren Korb, for instance. And Doug Bowser looked positively pocket-sized standing on stage beside 6-foot 8-inch basketball player Paul George.
But it was hard to come away from the show without feeling short-changed and disappointed at best, or angry at worst.
But tell us: What were your thoughts on this year's Game Awards? Did you feel satisfied at the end of the show? What would you change for next year?
Comments 87
Truly...it was..."The Game Awards...2021."
I'm just baffled by how all those charming celebrities were so cringe as presenters. I actually lost some respect for Will Arnett as a comedic actor last night.
I just wished we didn't get the Ad awards, and more of well, Video games, Its why we Watch the thing to begin with LMAO.
Also I didn't need to hear about how Inclusive said Awards are, I hear that everyday, Its about video games, so maybe, you know, do that.
Other then that its a good 6.7/10
I want more variety in game reveals. A lot of it seems to be either open world or very linear story-driven games.
I want it less to be "The Ads Awards plus Games" and more so actual game awards.
I also think they could just ditch most if not all the unneeded celebrity cameos that just made some segments awkward.
And the music sections can go too, I came to see some games this isn't the Grammys.
I would rate the overall Awards show a 6 or 7/10, still better than E3 this year.
@iLikeUrAttitude This.
Did not care for the award show this year. I wish they would take out all the ads and performances , and just concentrate on the awards and trailers, and make it 2 hours long. Then I could enjoy the show more.
The Game Awards is exactly only an advert for games except only acknowledging that it involves more than the audience that it typically is associated with it - that being only kids. It's a celebration for the gaming industry expanding more into universal popular culture.
I would like it if it just wasn't so bloated. Not seeing anything from Nintendo at all was disappointing on its own, but seeing so many ads and generic shooters just really tainted the experience. I will definitely not be watching next year's show.
It was pretty gross honestly. Loaded with PR garbage and honestly only 1 prospective game being sonic and I don’t even like sonic but I’d play an open world sonic game. Overall do less awards more showing 1 hour only no PR crap we’re honestly just there for reveals can we just get that and move on.
There were two good things about it...
It has literally zero relation to why I game. I'm sure folk here know what I think of it and I'll be blunt, I can't see why anyone would watch it.
Geoff Keithly tweeted he couldn't believe he's back. Yeah...me neither.
This year is Nintendo showing us what the Awards should really be about. Awarding games. That's it. One of the biggest issues is the level of expectations set on what sort of games will be announced, when the whole point of watching this was for what awards each game got.
Game announcements ended up being more of the focus, pushing the awards to be something rather falsely supplementary. As a result, many people including myself have a level of expectations from Nintendo to at least announce one thing. 2019 was mainly just all the Switch-exclusive 2nd party stuff. 2020 only had Sephiroth. This year, absolutely nothing from Nintendo.
This is where I want to draw the line. Either have game announcements or don't have game announcements. Otherwise, some people would feel obligated to watch something for 4 hours, not knowing whether or not Nintendo will make a reveal.
4/10.
The older I get, the less I care about celebrities. I really don't need to see them try to be hip and act like they care about gaming. It just turns me off.
The "Big 3" (Nintendo, Sony, Microsoft) were pretty much AWOL. Microsoft probably had the biggest presence of them all, but still... they didn't bring their "big guns" to the show.
I'm glad they mentioned the ongoing Activision Blizzard situation. That isn't "being woke," that's a terrible company being called out for being terrible. The rest of the virtue signaling throughout the show though I could do without...
3 hours is too long.
Like video game music, but don't need it to be THAT long.
Most of the reveals were... eh at best. Mostly FPS, free to play and Assassin's Creed-like games that I couldn't care less about.
Happy Metroid Dread won an award.
It Takes Two was a solid win. A very unique, innovative idea in an industry that more and more these days is far from that.
I don't think I'll watch next year.
I made my own game awards awards if anyone is interested
Best award winner- Metroid Dread Action Game
Worst award winner- GotG Narrative
Best announcement- P4AU on switch
Worst announcement- FF7R still not on xbox
and exclusive to epic games
Best surprise- Wonder Woman
Worst surprise- No new Nintendo
announcements
Biggest snub- NEO The World Ends With You
best soundtrack and narrative
Best trailer- Suicide Squad for actually showing
interesting gameplay
Worst trailer- all of them that didn’t include
gameplay
The most disappointing thing about the show was that in the “biggest night in gaming” the big final announcement was a showcase of a movie trailer presented by big movie actors. I thought this was the game awards.
But we did see BOTW2. Nothing new...but we saw it, for a few seconds.
I don't love any type of award show, although It's always slightly interesting to see what wins, especially as someone who only really plays games on Switch. Happy to see at least one Nintendo game win even if it probably should have been 2 with a fairer voting/ranking method. On the other hand, games vary so much even in one genre it can just be hard to fairly compare them.
I honestly kind of prefer events just for announcing games. These mixed ones are too long for what they do. Still nice to see the sonic announcement though.
Also, Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook/Meta/whatever they call themselves anymore can drop dead, as far as I'm concerned. They were ALL OVER the show last night.
It's usually a 5/10 average, so I'd give it an honest 3/10 this year
I was disappointed Chrono Cross remaster wasn’t announced as rumored.
I honestly didn’t expect much going into the VGAs, these past two years have been a bit rough in terms of solid / major releases and that’s to be expected thanks to the pandemic.
What I didn’t not expect however was a billion announcements for shooters…. Apparently that’s all gamers want now days? Wth…. We got like maybe 5 other games announced/shown then shooter city…. Lordy… Not sure if more ads or shooters were shown?
Nifty to see Reggie on stage, and for Nintendo to take best Action/Adventure. And for the most part I agreed with all the games awarded.
Otherwise it was a blah affair; and a lot of previous years were better.
I did find it surprising that Elden Rings got Most Anticipated. Not saying it was given wrongly, I’m anticipating it myself. I just, incorrectly, assumed that more people would be looking forward to Starfield or BotW2…. I mean both of those are likely to be much more accessible to most, whereas Elden is likely to be a hard game like most FromSoft titles. Interesting.
Edit - Meant to add, you know it’s an oddity when one of the top 5 moments from the whole show was the Sonic 2 trailer. Looked fun, and excited me for the Mario movie.
Does it still have Geoff corporate schill, dished faced c*nt Keighley involved? If yes then I will keep dipping my balls in molten lava for fun on game awards nights.
@Noble_Haltmann I get what you mean but even real gamers get cringe when they are as scripted as this.
I like Will Arnett as a (voice)actor but outside of that I do not really care about him.
This entire thing just feels like a ridiculous concept. I have no idea why it's been hyped at all.
I went into TGA with exactly zero expectation of ANY Nintendo announcements, so I wasn't let down in that regard. Part of the problem was that websites like this one were pushing the baseless rumors that Breath of the Wild II or some other big Nintendo game would be announced / revealed.
One need only look back at the previous seven TGAs to see that Nintendo usually doesn't make big announcements at the event. I think they feel burned by revealing Bayonetta 3 in 2017 and then making us wait nearly 4 years for a trailer. A few years prior, they tried to create buzz around a big, exclusive announcement at TGA that turned out to be... "You can play as Cranky Kong in Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze."
Aside from the new BotW trailer in 2016 and the Sephiroth Smash reveal last year, Nintendo has not had a particularly strong presence at TGA. With that in mind, I went in expecting it to mostly be a PC / PS5 / Xbox show, and I was mostly satisfied with what I got.
(It helped that I watched the stream as co-hosted by Jess Adel, a.k.a. JustJesss, my favorite YouTuber and Twitch streamer, because she was live-reacting and making fun of it the entire time. Highly recommended!)
@SuperZeldaFun I think this is largely because the developers licensed the property directly from the Tolkein estate and not Warner Bros. This means they can't use the character designs from the movies that we all know and love.
I suppose seeing an off-brand Frodo, Gandalf, Aragorn, etc. would turn away a lot more potential players than a "discount Gollum" who kind of looks and sounds like the movie version.
I watched the entire show as it was streaming and enjoyed it. Alan Wake II was my favorite premiere because I've been waiting 11 years for that. I wish Resident Evil Village would have won GOTY since Doki Doki Literature Club Plus wasn't a nomination. At least Life is Strange: True Colors won games for impact category.
I saw nothing during the awards that had me going, "Yo! I'll be getting that!"
Some interesting games were shown, just nothing that wowed me. The influx of utterly pointless filler, especially the constant focus on developers and streamers that had nothing to show but just needed to be there to talk about their experiences was the worst part of the show for me. Muted the TV dozens of times as a result.
It was probably the most meh Game Awards yet, I didn't get excited for anything I saw.
The handling of the statement about harassment was poorly done because Geoff didn't call out specific companies like Activision Blizzard for their actions and having a Quantic Dream game announcement very soon after undermines the statement.
As for the awards it was nice seeing Metroid win Action/Adventure and a general varied list of games winning compared to last year's TLoU2 winning virtually everything.
Regarding game announcements, it was cool seeing a new Monster get announced for MH Rise Sunbreak (wasn't expecting more news on that until the next Direct), a release date for the Cuphead DLC (and hence physical version) and a few other announcements but for the most part it was disappointing though the Nintendo Life chat made the show more entertaining.
The biggest advantage of Nintendo being mostly absent from the Game Awards is we may not have to wait until mid-February for the next Direct as the only Nintendo published game for Japan that has a release date is Pokemon Legends Arceus on January 28th (Triangle Strategy is published by Square Enix in Japan).
It was a terrible show for Nintendo as they announced nothing and got far too few third party announcements, Sonic Frontiers was the highlight for me. Don't care about the actual awards because they tend to be biased in favor of AAA generic movie games, but the announcements weren't good.
Okay yeah Metroid Dread is a decent enough game but winning awards? Lol this is a niche game that nobody outside of the hardcore Nintendo fanbase would care about. Nobody is about to go purchase a Switch for a game you can finish in a single weekend.
The Game Awards is never really a great time for Nintendo unless they released a Zelda or Mario game that year.
@Gamer_Zeus
Metroid Dread has sold more than several of the other GOTY nominees.
What value is this particular awards show? I can't seem to find who determines the award winners. A cursory search seems to only get "industry experts" and "influencers" and 10% fan vote. Should I respect these people's opinions and consider the games they chose as "the best"?
A lot of people seem to be complaining about the amount of ads in the show. I suspect the entire thing is an advertisement: the ads, the awards and the game announcements.
They could fix it by making it an awards show. Remove all the ads, musical numbers, celebrates, and even the game trailers. Maybe have two reveals, one in the middle and one at the end.
I didn’t watch it but when I looked at the round up today I was underwhelmed
This was the worst VGAs so far for me. I’m fine with what they are; I really don’t care for award shows in general since they mean basically nothing (though they are good for bringing attention to projects that people may have missed during the year) and so having a mini-E3 of sorts at the end of the year is a fun thing to have. Just didn’t care for a lot of the announcements this year- just felt like shooter after shooter for the most part. Alan Wake 2 was a great reveal but nothing much beyond that for me- was also really surprised to see Nintendo drop nothing at all given they usually have something for these shows.
Also I know the whole thing is really just an ad campaign but man…it’s such a constant barrage of them, right down to some awards being sponsored. Watching ads while you wait to watch some ads just felt dirty after a while.
@StarPoint Nintendo does their own stuff mainly. I would t expect anything from them unless it is e3 or their own showing.
@Gamer_Zeus actually people buy systems all the time for one game you can beat in a week. They do it with playstation and Xbox every release. Your comment is completely false. The game awards is all about which company pays enough to win. It has never been about the games.
I didn’t watch, although I wanted to, and it seems like I really didn’t miss much. I really did expect to hear something ground breaking, and although there were some great announcements, there wasn’t anything worth talking about for me. I guess except how amazing that Star Wars trailer was. And the Sonic trailer… really that’s it for me. It’s not that I don’t think anything else was bad I just… I dunno. It’s like watching a movie and not caring or being invested in any of the characters whatsoever.
Lol didn't watch
I was initially upset we didn’t get anything on the Sonic Origins collection, as Sonic was going to be a big part of TGA, but getting more Cuphead dlc footage let alone a RELEASE DATE made up for all of that
Pretty poor show, but didn't expect much either. Three hours is way too long, two hours would be more than plenty. Even if I had another console, I couldn't get too excited for a bunch of these non gameplay/CG reveals. Sonic might turn out good, but I can't bring myself to get hyped for Sonic games. Best announcements for me was Persona 4 Arena on Switch and Cuphead DLC. Cuphead DLC was one of the few new releases that actually got snippets of gameplay.
Metroid winning best action-adventure and It Takes Two winning GotY were surprises to me.
It was boring, cringeworthy, and as usual, a complete waste of time and money.
This is only the second time I've ever watched the awards. I watched the original, thought it was a waste and never watched it again until last night.
I'm not sure why I watched last night. Probably because I've been a bit disinterested in actually playing games lately and needed something to entertain me while relaxing after work and eating dinner.
The only good thing about the awards was the fun I had texting back and forth with my brother about how bad everything was. 🤷♂️
I liked the metriod music being preformed by the orchestra and that’s about it.
Not sure why anyone would watch this when you can just watch the trailers after the fact.
But the most important thing is Space Marine 2
2/10
There were way to many ads I subconsciously order GrubHub (a sponsor) which forgot my fire sauce for my black bean CrunchWrap.One thing you don’t do and that’s forget sauce in tacos. What an abomination. So I new TGA were going to be a pile of vile. The Kpop performance was not it. I could of hurled Crunchwrap vomit at my Mac. There were so many frivolous trailers with NO gameplay as Geoff just Casually read the awards and then offered us more ads. Oh it was very Vomitus Glutinous Maximus. Was I disappointed that I did not get an announcement or some small nugget from Nintendo? Yes, It was a three grueling hour bore fest sponsored by corporate greed and sauce-less tacos.
Meh. It was okay, but not for me. Needs more weeb games.
I'll go against the grain and say that I love that "ads/ game announcements" feature so heavily in the show. I have zero interest in what other people consider the best games of the year. But the hope of an interesting game ad keeps me intrigued.
I feel like everyone forgot that excellent Cuphead trailer!! Definitely a highlight for me. It was also a testament to how ORIGINAL that game feels in a sea of sameness.
Honestly, after all the other trailers I was so unenthusiastically limp I was starting to wonder if I qualify as a “gamer” at all.
if we could use an ad blocker on the game awards we would have a 7 min show.
It takes two looks bad. I haven't played it so I can't judge it too harshly. I expected any of the other titles to have won instead, and even hoped for it to have been Psyconauts 2. Alas
My advice for the show though: women dressed beautifully! Every man had the same stupid jeans t shirt and blazer combo and looked like trash. Do better!
Except Doug Bowser who is surprisingly my type
It was an okay show. Better than last year overall, but it was super top heavy. All the amazing trailers and reveals were in the first hour and preshow. I watched the whole thing in Horizon Venues on Oculus Quest, so it was cool talking games with strangers during the show.
@Donutsavant We did get Jacksepticeye showing everyone up in a snazzy suit though.
I think Nintendo needs to make an effort to have more of a presence at the Game Awards. It's great that they have their Directs but I think it would be good if they have at least one World Premier for all Nintendo fans who tune in and watch the show.
@Donutsavant I'd love the return to formal ware. Too many guys anymore who don't get haircuts, don't shave and wear clothes that look like they are from the Goodwill.
I wouldn't have bothered to watch the game awards, if it weren't for my friends attending the show in person.
I just find it ironic that this things lasts 3 hours, and yet they somehow don't have time to announce all the awards properly, instead just having Geoff rapid-fire them out unceremoniously.
If I remember, best multiplayer and best family game gets this treatment, yet apparently best content creator is just too important to pass up.
I've never watched this and never will. I'm not a fan of TV in general, and industry awards are a total bore. If there are any cool announcements I'm going to catch them on Reddit or some gaming site. NL alone will probably run at least five more articles from this show.
The games I'm most excited for have got the least exposure.
Have a nice Death looks amazing.
So too Planet of Lana.
I can't believe you guys just skip over Have a nice Death.
It was a one big long advertise, and the part that was supposed to be About the awards they rush it in favor of more "world premier" that did nothing for me. At one time they premier a game for the creator of silent hill and it was painful to watch, I did not expect anything and even so walked away disappointed and scratching my head in confusion
@Dirty0814 I mean, Nintendo has shown off stuff in at TGA in the past, so it is possible. I was at least expecting a little something, but it does make sense for them to limit things to Directs. Keeps it consistent.
I will tune in when J.D. Roth is hosting. Otherwise, it's rubbish.
There just aren't going to be a lot of AAA Switch ports coming in at this point. Nintendo will obviously keep its remaining arsenal of 1st party titles for future directs. What can you do? TGAs had two very exciting Smash announcements in the past, but DLC is finally done, so I never thought there'd be much to see on the Nintendo side. Plus Best Action Game is really nothing to sneeze at.
The point about the actual awards being an afterthought half the time is completely valid - it's downright insulting to those nominated, and some of us would actually really like to hear speeches from the devs.
What's really missing is a "best DLC expansion" award, since major updates have become such a huge part of modern games. The Animal Crossing update was massive and breathed new life into a game that had just about gone stale. It would've been a contender!
Dream won content creator of the year. I am officially dead inside (He's completely terrible, and I still would have rathered one of the other no names win. Who voted in the nominees? Where was Scott The Woz?!)
@Turnip_Knight
I also want to point out that there should really be more diversification in terms of genres. Part of me wants to see games like Persona 5 Strikers and Age of Calamity get recognition for being great half-sequels to their respective games, ESPECIALLY since both are follow-ups to GotY nominees.
Game industry shouldn't have award shows. It's not the film industry, there's no attractive celebrities - they have to borrow them to attend. There's no glamour in the game development, award show like this always end up cringy.
Just like the Oscars, I stopped noticing years ago.
This year was actually one of the better years for the game awards... but i was very disappointed that there was essentially nothing from nintendo. I do not expect a lot, just something small but there was really nothing at all
Personally, anything beyond 90 minutes becomes a chore whether that's award shows, movies, dinner, a bus ride or sex. For game awards in particular, I can't see how you fill more than 90 minutes. Movie awards actually have plenty of awards, and there can be performances of best song nominations to fill the time.
@jojobar Nintendo is in it's own space, this isn't a direct competition for them.
Pretty rubbish overall imo. GotY winner was a joke choice, the “interviews” segments were terrible, a lot of games got snubbed in categories they really should have won, plus some of the categories are completely stupid, the ads were frustratingly annoying and Nintendo’s presents this year was so minimal, that it was disappointing.
The only thing that got me excited was WH40K Space Marines II and Alan Wake 2 was pretty neat as well.
@Borland
and thats the reason they essentially showed every year something except of this year ?
There’s something about gaming shows that strip the humanity out of them. People seem weird and stilted, jokes are terrible and forced, trailers seem overwrought and fake… it’s like an awards show made by AI.
What was the game rumoured to be Zelda?
How about Nintendo Life Awards?
Didn't watch it and seems I didn't miss anything noteworthy.
I'm really pissed and this year was easily the worst show of all time. 4 hours of my life wasted for something I could have watched/read about the next day in a simple recap. Most trailers were CGI cutscenes and very few announcements were new or original. Absolutely no new Nintendo news was incredibly frustrating. Yes, BOTW 2 would have been nice but I would have taken literally any new announcement (even in 2019, Nintendo's previous weakest showing we got announcements for Bravely Default 2 & a cool No More Heroes 3 trailer). Worst thing is I have this feeling of regret for watching the show every year and this year was especially terrible.
I mean, I'm glad Genshin Impact got Best Mobile Game, and I'm glad to see my favorite Irish YouTuber jacksepticeye make an appearance as an award presenter (ditto with Reggie).
But it ran for three hours, late at night (and I live in the Chicago area, well east of Los Angeles), so I was definitely inconvenienced there, especially considering I had to be up early for work.
I actually ended up going to bed before the show ended, I was just too tired. And I then had to set my alarm for about 30 minutes before I usually leave for work and get breakfast at McDonald's.
I only stayed up for the off-chance that a Nintendo reveal would happen (BOTW 2 or otherwise). But considering how Nintendo always keeps their cards close to their chest, I should not be surprised that Nintendo showed nothing at The Game Awards.
My guess is BOTW 2 will be properly revealed at E3 2022, with a Holiday 2022 release (unless it gets delayed like the first BOTW did, as Nintendo is notorious to do).
the lack of diversity and inclusiveness is appalling
Just this:
I CAN'T BELIEVE YOU IDIOTS THOUGHT WE'D SEE BOTW2
But referring to myself.
they could have shown footage of prime4
jk
@CartoonDan have you seen any awards show in the last 20-30 years because they are all like this (generally with less trailers, too!)
@somebread Most other shows have the winners come up and say something. In this three hour show only a few of the winners were allowed to come on stage. Most of the awards were covered rapid fire in 30 seconds with a simple on screen list.
It just did not feel like the awards were an important part of the ad.
@Noble_Haltmann I will echo that sentiment. It's wild how badly otherwise good actors were as presenters.
The FACT the hotest selling console Switch didn't get it's own lineup is a disappointed in how the American one sided multimedia misses out and always end up last. Ads where more distraction then entertaining.
I ended up missing the stream because I had to attend a meeting. And I TRIED to watch it. But because of. A.my internet is god awful. B. It kept rewinding. And c. Every five minutes I get a ad. I was so determined to watch the game awards so I can be surprised but every time the video buffers I ended getting an AD that ruins everything. I swear I’m gonna start becoming ticked off every single time I hear “never not working” ugh.
Oh and I just looked up a list of stuff that were reveled during the awards I was that sick of the ads.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...