I don't know much about wine, but I sure like to pretend I do, and I bet I'm not alone. Who else here — of drinking age, that is — has bought a red wine to accompany dinner, because it "goes well with pasta"? How many times have you been poured a glass of wine to "taste" in a fancy restaurant, going through the whole rigmarole of smacking your lips together and saying "oh yes, lovely" even though it just tastes like wine? And, be honest now, do you do that thing where you try a new wine and then try to guess the random assortment of fruits on the label to show off in front of your friends? "Oh, yes, plum, see, I did mention stone fruits, didn't I, Janice?" Yeah, we're all the same, and we all have no idea what we're talking about.
But here's something I do know about: Video games. I've been doing this job for a while now, and I've played quite a few of them. I am no sommelier of digital media, mind you, but I'm definitely knowledgeable enough to be able to recommend you a hearty, robust RPG or a nice indie palate-cleanser, depending on your taste. But I would like to propose a change to the way we talk about games, at the risk that it's going to make me sound like the kind of person that won't shut up about wine.
There are some video games that are brilliant, but even more so when paired with a book, or a movie, or a TV show. There are many reasons: A book can tell you more about the historical setting; it can get you into the mood for the particular genre; or it can make you see the characters or the location in a new light. The right book can elevate the subject matter of a game far beyond the world on-screen, or help you understand its subject even better. And sometimes, it's just nice to fully immerse yourself in a sub-genre that you really enjoy.
With that in mind, I propose that we discuss our favourite "wine pairings" of games and other media. I'll go first!
Hades + The Iliad / The Song of Achilles
We'll start off easy. Hades, Supergiant's brilliant narrative roguelite, is heavily based on Ancient Greek myth. No myth in particular, of course, but a lovely smörgåsbord of bits from all over the place.
My instinctive recommendation would be The Iliad — the colossal war epic that describes the end of the Trojan war, but mostly the anger of Achilles following some prize-related beef with his commanding officer — but honestly, it's a bit weighty. There are entire chapters that just list all the boats that are present, or long passages describing shields. It's a brilliant story, but it's much better as something to listen to, rather than something to read, in my opinion.
(In fact, a bunch of Hades fans got together to read out The Iliad, with a foreword from Hades scribe Greg Kasavin. What serendipity.)
You might fare better with a more modern, novel-like approach to the Trojan war, which will give you a greater insight into Hades' treatment of Achilles and Patroclus, his lover/cousin depending on which scholars you believe (but the more interesting reading is the former, of course). Madeline Miller's The Song of Achilles is the perfect companion to Hades, because it takes the same approach: Star-crossed lovers, torn apart by fate and fortune. Good luck getting through the gorgeous prose without sobbing, though.
Life Is Strange + Twin Peaks
If you're in the mood for some unnerving goings-on on the West Coast of the United States, then you really can't go wrong with this double-feature. Life Is Strange may not quite reach Lynchian heights of weird, but it takes more than just a light sprinkling of inspiration from the '90s TV drama.
Who killed Laura Palmer? What happened to Rachel Amber? The answer to the latter is a little more straightforward than the former, of course, but you'll have to journey through supernatural events, prophetic nightmares, and time-hopping manipulation to get there.
Mix with Alan Wake and Silent Hill for an even stronger effect.
Heaven's Vault + Arrival
Alien civilisations and decoding language. Both are prominent plot threads in both Heaven's Vault and Arrival, but it's not just a surface-level similarity that they share: Both are also about communication, translation, and how imperfect it can be in creating a shared understanding between two factions.
Heaven's Vault is focused on the past, through history, archaeology, and anthropology; Arrival is more focused on the present and the future through actively trying to speak to an alien race. But both are concerned with what it means to communicate, and why we do it in the first place. They both come together in a shared appreciation and understanding of linguistics, and how it impacts philosophy.
One for language nerds, definitely.
Disco Elysium + Dungeons & Dragons: Player's Handbook
Non-fiction and reference books are still books, and I think this one is an excellent pairing. Disco Elysium is an incredibly complex take on RPGs that borrows heavily from the tabletop roleplaying world, most specifically the Planescape setting of Dungeons and Dragons.
Now, I could recommend a ton of books from D&D, but I think the easiest one to get into and find is probably the Player's Handbook, which will introduce you to the world, the races, the classes, and the general vibe of D&D. Understanding a game like Dungeons and Dragons — and how to play it well — will give you a great amount of insight (WIS) into how a game like Disco Elysium works.
Pair this one with Citizen Sleeper or Divinity: Original Sin 2 if you really like a TTRPG-style game.
The Legend of Zelda + Second Quest
Second Quest is a graphic novel by David Hellman and Tevis Thompson which seeks to explore "what it really means to have courage". It questions adventure, legend, and even gaming itself, and you will see not only Link and Zelda in its pages, but yourself, too.
The book comes from Hellman and Thompson's dissatisfaction with Zelda in the Wind Waker and Skyward Sword years, during which Nintendo veered away from the sense of discovery present in the early years, and towards more traditional, linear games. Hellman and Thompson instead imagined a world more like Zelda 1, where mysteries go unanswered, in a world that has already been saved. It's a mature, thoughtful and thought-provoking take on the Zelda mythos that asks the question: What happens after the credits roll?
Haven + Saga
This one's easy. A couple on the run from forces who want to tear them apart, with themes of queerness, found family, freedom, and love in the face of hate. Is that exploration game Haven, or is that sci-fi graphic novel Saga? Trick question! It's both!
Haven and Saga is an extremely good pairing, almost too good, like wine and chocolate. It feels like cheating. It helps that they're both gorgeous, too.
The Binding of Isaac + Midnight Mass
Not everyone is familiar with the themes of Catholic guilt and religious persecution that Edmund McMillen's gory dungeon-crawling roguelike The Binding of Isaac draws from. The very beginning of the game sees the protagonist's mother receiving a message from God to sacrifice her son as proof of her faith, and the rest of the game is all about Isaac trying to escape, confronting death, birth, and other heavily-religious themes based on McMillen's own familial experience.
The obvious pairing is The Bible, since, you know, that's where all the religion came from in this instance, but I reckon that Midnight Mass might get the horror across more efficiently. After all, The Binding of Isaac isn't about the source material, it's about the misappropriation of it to commit abuses, and the ways religion can be twisted into a weapon. Fun!
Metro 2033 + Roadside Picnic
Roadside Picnic is a 1972 Soviet Russian novel by Arkady and Boris Strugatsky which takes place in the aftermath of an extraterrestrial event which left behind several "Visitation Zones", in which strange and unexplained phenomena occur. Scavengers — known as stalkers — enter these zones to pilfer artifacts for profit. It is these stalkers that eventually inspired the game S.T.A.L.K.E.R., among many other films, books, and video games.
Metro 2033 is not based on Roadside Picnic. It's actually based on a different novel by a different Russian author, Dmitry Glukhovsky, called Metro 2033 — but since Metro 2033 (the book) was also influenced by Roadside Picnic, it's clear that they're all in the same family, at least. There's even a reference to Roadside Picnic in Metro 2033!
If you're a fan of post-apocalyptic, melancholic Russian stories that are all about trying to eke out an existence in a nearly-uninhabitable, miserable world plagued with scarcity and uncertainty, then, uh, have fun with this pairing!
Ace Attorney + Better Call Saul
Let's have a fun one to round this off, shall we? Everyone knows that Ace Attorney is not an accurate portrayal of the legal system, and that's part of the reason it's so fun. Cross-examining a parrot? Proving that an orca is innocent? Magic being admissible in court? Sure, why not! This is Phoenix Wright's baffling world, where your prosecutor is more likely to be the real murderer than your friend!
Better Call Saul, on the other hand, deals with the grimy, ineffective nature of the court in a town where all the crimes are either white-collar boring ones, or straight-up drug manufacture, smuggling, and cartel murders. You don't get these stories in Ace Attorney, and likewise, you'd never see Saul Goodman or Jimmy McGill trying to accuse a ghost of murder.
But sometimes it's fun to see the law from multiple angles. Death in Better Call Saul is a horrific thing that tears apart families; death in Ace Attorney doesn't even stop people from turning up to their job the next day, thanks to the Fey family's ability to channel spirits. But the one thing that Jimmy and Phoenix have in common is their ability to turn a case around in a split second, and it's a thrill to watch them both.
I may not know much about wine, other than the fact that it is very nice to drink a sangria in the sun, but I like to think that a good video game/book/movie/TV pairing is just as satisfying as a Rioja that goes really nicely with steak. I hope you've found some appealing pairings on this menu, too — and I'd love to know what your recommendations are in the comments!
Comments 69
God I love Saga. Don’t really pair these different media together unless subconsciously but Saga deserves more shoutouts.
For a millisecond there, seeing an image of Saga on NL, I thought there would be an official Saga game coming out.
While my dreams were quickly dashed, at least now I'm interested in checking out Haven.
Saga is one of the best and most important comic series of the 21st century. It's so good to see the series shouted out here, and the comparison to Haven has inspired me to move it from my "I'll play it one day" list to the "I'll download it ASAP" list.
My pair:
Cartoon kids games by OG Games + Nickelodeon Jr channel
If you like Sonic The Hedgehog, you'll love this movie! It's called Sonic The Hedgehog, it's a blast! Then you can watch this show called The Adventures of Sonic The Hedgehog, and then read this comic called Sonic The Hedgehog!
Disco Elysium and New York Trilogy?
Mario Kart and Cannonball Run?
I'll be honest, when I read this title, I thought this was going to be some bizarre way to justify the weird attempts to put a game's story outside of the actual game (see: FFXV, Quantum Break).
Honestly I'm indifferent at best to experiencing multiple specifically similar types of media at once most times, because I don't want things to feel redundant. And I do not have the capability to get into most serious reading either, especially after the past couple of years. I do feel like there are examples of when I've tried for something similar to this, but I genuinely can't remember them right now. For that matter, even I'd be very unlikely to get into a queer work while playing a queer game because most of the stuff I'm interested in, generally speaking, is not notably queer (much as I'd like to change that a bit someday). If I end up playing Ikenfell the same time I try that pirate show everyone went nuts for, that's entirely a coincidence, y'know?
The closest example I can think of for me is the GBA Astro Boy game. Since its secretly a love letter to Osamu Tezuka's work in general, I've planned on getting into his stuff next time I play it. It's something I've wanted to do, for a big project, for a long while.
Twin Peaks should be paired with Deadly Premonition all day long.
@CharlieGirl thanks for the rec on Saga - will check it out
@Enigk Hah, didn’t even twig that this has Life is Strange instead of Deadly Premonition! That’s basically Twin Peaks the game, in almost every possible way 😂
@KateGray I've said it once before, but I love your taglines. As soon as I read it on the main page, I clicked knowing you were the one to write the article. Your taglines are unique and a joy to read.
@Enigk When I saw Laura Palmer in the thumbnail, I thought that's where they were going to go. There's tons of allusions to Twin Peaks in that game.
Pokémon and Amoros Perros
@Rambler I can't recommend it enough! It's more in the realm of science fantasy than science fiction, so if that's your thing, you're in for a treat.
Had no idea what this read was going to be, it’s a nice idea.
Thought it’d be about listening to something on the side while playing.
Hah, I thought this was going to be about books and movie versions of the actual game (think Mario movie or an anime-show game). For the most part, I don't like those (is there even a Mario-based novel??) The idea of an unrelated book or movie for accompanying 'flavour' is clever though. While playing a game I often listen to seperate music and/or read a book interspersed between game segments; I've never done this very scientifically, but I bet you could plan some amazing combinations if you tried.
As for the above list, I have the opposite reaction to Hades. I've read the Iliad and other related myths just a little too much (many college classes) so all the innacuracies in the game trigger me a little. Possibly knowing something but being a bit less immersed in the subject would be the ideal.
Fun concept.
I can definitely relate to having a game inspire digging into other media. A while back I read Bram Stoker's Dracula because I saw it was considered an official part of the Castlevania timeline.
And I absolutely sifted through a ton of Greek (and even Roman) mythology after playing the amazing Hades.
I really tried getting into Saga. Just couldn't do it. Felt too pretentious and self-important. Incredible creativity without enough substance to have it cohesively hold together.
Haven reminded me of Saga from the very first screenshot I saw.
Twin Peaks is a harder pairing, not that it doesn't pair well with LIS but the fact is Twin Peaks influenced so many creators that there are about one thousand games that pair well with it, and probably dozens of them that wear their inspiration on their sleeve. Whether it's a character randomly quipping "damn fine coffee" or an entire game cribbing from the Lynch/Frost playbook like Deadly Premonition.
Skyrim goes well with Beowulf (read the Seamus Heaney version if you can).
Paradise Killer synchs nicely with Max Gladstone's "Craft Sequence". Not a one-to-one equivalent by any means, but you'll get what I mean once you start digging into the Craft books.
Kitaria Fables, Redwall. (Again, a lot of things go with Redwall as it was one of the formative "animal fantasy" series.)
Darkest Dungeon demands to be played while reading HP Lovecraft. But don't blame me if the narrators in Lovecraft's books all start to sound like DD's "Ancestor" in your head.
My recommendations:
-Dark Souls and the Books of the New Sun series by Gene Wolfe.
-Flower, Sun, and Rain paired with Dance, Dance, Dance by Haruki Murakami (although about 75% of Murakami's novels could pair well).
-Disco Elysium and The City & The City by China Mieville (not quite the same but pretty good).
Edit: The Island of Dr Moreau (novel) gave me major Bioshock vibes so I think they pair well too.
I really like this article, Saga is an awesome series.
Dexter and L.A Noire 🤷🏼
Wine sucks, I pair my dinners with hard liquor
You recommended The Song of Achilles last year and I picked it up right before a trip, nearly burst into tears on the first page and decided to hold off. Once I’ve read everything I can by Michael Moorcock and have time clear to feel even more awful than usual I’m going back to Song. I’ve read other versions of the Iliad and Odyssey and I’ve been into various mythologies since I was a kid, and I have the Iliad and the Odyssey translations by Fagles on standby.
I was deeply disappointed with the Witcher book series (yes I am aware that it came first) to the point where I don’t care about the game anymore even though that got me to pick up the books.
For wine I suggest damn fine cab called Ed by Edmundo from Argentina. Sounds like madness but this is $10 wine that tastes in the $50-60 range. With that said, I’ll usually just take a few stouts myself.
@Losermagnet Your book recommendations are certainly on point! I am more inclined than ever to buy Disco Elysium now, as the City and the City is an absolute masterpiece.
I've found marijuana goes much better with games than booze.
Shouldn’t the sub-header here be ‘Well, not JUST like wine. You can't drink a game’, as opposed to ‘book’, since the game is the substitute for the wine here?
Heaven’s Vault and Arrival is a solid pairing. One step further: Inkle released a couple of books further expanding the world of Heaven’s Vault.
@JasmineDragon Disco Elysium is pretty fantastic. One of those games that I couldnt stop myself from playing. In a general way the story resembles TC&TC, but the protagonist of DE being sort of a burned-out failure gives it a dash of The Big Lebowski.
"But here's something I do know about: Video games."
Your thesis underminds this statement. If you can't do it with just that medium, then you're doing it wrong. Part of the reason many have trouble digesting Halo, is because its dispersed across media that no one has the time or the interest in investing time in. If you want to make books, then just make books. This doesn't just apply to games, every bit of media has this problem. It creates a disjointed experience. Which is why the cross media intiatives tend to fall apart almost as soon as they start. Look at the wasteland of such products.
I get what you're saying to some small degree. Often is the case like with gears of war which was far better after reading its collection of books, shows something very broken about gears of war as a game. It means the game is incomplete. The game is not finished. That the game did a very poor job of conveying its story and world to the player. What the hell is the point of having a medium that lets you show, speak to, and allow the player to interact with a world, if it requires a 400+ page light novel to explain all the things the game could do in 10, 20, 50, 100, 200 or even 1000 hours.
I don't want to invest in a book series I'll never read. I don'tt want to watch square enix's stupid movie that is meant to substitue the first 20 hours of the damned game. I'm looking at you Final Fantasy XV, literally ruined the start of that game with the BS they pulled.
So no. Look at the waste land of crap product. This isn't an enhancer, its a means of exploiting for more cash there George Lucas.
@SteamEngenius I usually comment to disagree with you, but on this we are 100%.
Mind you, sometimes it's why not both?
@Losermagnet Definitely something I could get into. I just have to clear out some current games first.
It sounds like you would enjoy the Watch series, have you read those?
@NotSoCryptic Wow, somebody did not read the article at all. This isn’t about expanded media across books and comics. This is about playing games and reading books/comics with similar themes. So like playing AC Odyssey and then being inspired to read up on Greek myth.
@NotSoCryptic did you just read the opening para or what because all of these are media that evoke or are alluded to by the game being mentioned, not directly connected to them in any way like all of your examples
@JasmineDragon this is the first I've heard of that series. What're they like?
Saga is amazing. I'm thinking of starting over, as I recently read the latest issue, and I've been out of the loop for a few years. Never heard of Second Quest until now, and it looks awesome.
I love LiS and all, but very disappointed your didn't pair Twin Peaks and Deadly Premonition. Aside from the dead beauty queen and Northwest US setting, LiS doesn't match up all that well. Whereas virtually every aspect of Deadly Premonition is Twin Peaks based/inspired/ripped-off.
Also, Alan Wake pairs perfectly with like half of Stephen King's oeuvre, particularly The Dark Half or Secret Window, Secret Garden (which are basically just alternate takes on the same premise and were both inspired by King's being "outed" as Richard Bachman).
Now that's a really interesting article!! I really liked it
@JasmineDragon Is that the Watch series written by Lukyanenko? They’re some of my favourite books even if he’s an utter tool. There’s probably more than one series with that name though so ignore me if I’m inserting my niche fantasy novels into your conversation 😂
Re: The Iliad, ancient Greek epic poetry was meant to be read aloud and sung/performed orally with accompanying music, so it makes sense that the author finds it better as something to be listened to, as opposed to something to be read (like a book).
@nessisonett That's the one!
@Losermagnet Russian urban fantasy / slipstream with a dark streak. Witches and angels and vampires through a filter of Russian folktales and science fiction. I think it's a very safe recommendation for a Mieville fan.
Subnautica pairs pretty well with Star Trek: The Next Generation, or really any Star Trek in general. I tend to write the text for my memory capsule from the perspective of one of the characters. To be honest, it’s always Data every time.
Being a Christian, my knowledge of the Bible helped add a bit more enjoyment to the already highly-entertaining romp that is Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (whose absence on the Switch I'm still salty with), with obvious series staple biblical nods and references to the bosses such as Legion (then Granfaloon, my all-time favorite Castlevania boss) and Beelzebub.
I also frequented the Greek mythology pages of Wikipedia when I was playing the old God of War games on PS2 and PSP.
A great pairing would be Xenogears (though that one's not on Nintendo Switch) and Neon Genesis Evangelion.
I would also pair up Metal Gear and Escape from New York.
This is a fun setup for recommendations! :v
One mixture I -can- recommend if you want to feel absolutely terrified is
Killer 7 + House of Leaves
They don't really overlap thematically, but they share parts of their character portrayal, and both stories are experienced through layers of retelling or distorted viewpoints, making it hard for the audience to gauge if we're told the truth, or some character's version of it.
@NotSoCryptic
I fully agree!
However, this article is not about adding other media to a game franchise at all.
It's about ingesting thematically related works from different mediums at the same time.
@Pod
House of leaves is amazing.
There is a Jacques Derrida book called Glas that is equally typographically mad, but costs a fortune.
The last section of Dhalgren by Samuel Delaney starts splitting up and repeating chunks of itself so that by the end of the book it's actually the start but from an opposite view point.
Among Us and The Thing
Removed - offensive remarks
@Enigk Logged in to say the exact same thing!
@Desrever A Saga game feels like the kind of thing that would 100% exist if Telltale hadn't gone through such a rough patch.
A book and wine is a different type of combi though, although it certainly can enhance the reading experience, this combi, like the hades one might be more tlike the combination of drinking and having a good meal before: a solid basis
@SteamEngenius That suggestions gets the thumbs up from me.
It fact like this article says there are certain games that work better with this, as I sometimes struggle with hanging that long thing out the same of my mouth. And in particular when I do it playing splatoon I seem to get smoke in my eye and it starts running which is not really good for seeing.
Glad to see some people like this article but for me when I was kid computer games were not really a thing, so I read lots of books. But when computer games became something I completely gave up reading books because they were not as good as games for me.
Such a great article, thanks Kate! I’m inspired to play some great games and read some great books. And since I have “won” the Covid lottery this week, looks like I’ve got time to do just that. Though maybe not a functioning brain.
Lovely article @KateGray combination of two of my favourite hobbies, lots of great books here to recommend. Many of these games are better the more you know on the subject matter. Hades in particular was a joy the more you knew about the various gods and demi-gods.
Tip on the wine: when they give you a sample, you’re actually just meant to be checking if the wine is corked (i.e. spoiled) and not if you like it. Just smell the wine in the glass (or the cork if at home) if it smells like wine you’re all good if it smells acidic or vinegary then send it back! No need to taste it. At least you’ll look like you know what you are doing!
@Jackpaza0508 I'd rather watch Sonic SatAM
When I was reading Game of Thrones last year it really made me want to play through thd Banner Saga again. A fantastic epic of a game, really enjoyed the pairing.
@Tenma220 I know! I have a degree in Ancient Greek and Latin! That's why I said it
Interesting article! I find myself getting into moods like this, wanting more of a particular vibe. Borderlands and Mad Max. Dead Space and Alien, Pokémon and....curry.
@the_shpydar I thought about it! But in the end, I wanted to pick some less-obvious pairings, rather than the one-to-one inspirations.
I considered adding things like The Witcher + The Last Wish, or literally any fantasy game + Game of Thrones, but it felt a bit like saying "wine goes well with food". Everyone knows that 😅
@Agent_P Adventures was just the first one that came to mind
@KateGray
Gotcha, makes sense.
And when i think about it, Nathan Prescott works as like an alternate universe version of early 1st-season Bobby Briggs, if Bobby Briggs was horribly evil, and not just a dumb misguided jock jerk.
@nessisonett Your first sentence was mine verbatim when I saw the Saga image.
I've said it before, but I'll say it again: Card Shark and Barry Lyndon. Then to get the trifecta of game, movie, and book, afterwards read Pascal's Pensées where he pretty much turns observations about the emptiness of the gambling culture around him into proto-existentialism.
@KateGray That first paragraph is magic. Besides my mother insisting me she's not a wine snob (she kind of is), I have a wonderful memory of going on a date to a fancy restaurant where the tables were a little too close together, and after the guy next to us told his date, "I feel that by the third glass you start to get palate fatigue", we spent the rest of the meal struggling to contain our giggles. Some wines might be better than others, but for the most part wine is wine and what does it matter once you're drunk??
Anyway... there are a number of games that I played in the same time period as listening to an album or watching a certain movie or reading a book, and some of them really did work together and are forever connected in my brain, which I think is pretty cool.
@Rambler
Oo, nice, thank you for the recommendations!
Life Is Strange fans should also check out I Am Not Okay With This and Undone on Netflix and Prime Video respectfully.
Also everyone please read Saga.
@CharlieGirl don't know if you've heard, but they're supposed to be resuming saga soon
@hsfmd since 2012, the series has always had a few months of break between story arcs (and one hiatus that was over a year long).
Tap here to load 69 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...