When it was announced that Portal and Portal 2 would be making their way to the Nintendo Switch as part of the Portal: Companion Collection, fans collectively choked on their cakes. Two of the best puzzle games of all time on the go, you say? Yes, please! Naturally, when certain games get ported to Nintendo’s hybrid system, there’s an accompanying fear that they might not run quite so well on what is effectively a handheld device. Perhaps the frame rate takes a hit, or maybe the visuals aren’t up to scratch. Is this the case for the Portal pair? Thankfully, not at all. Let’s get into it.
The first Portal launched back in 2007 as part of a compilation known as The Orange Box. Despite some criticisms aimed at its short length and limited narrative, the general consensus was that it stood as one of the most original, unique games ever created, and that’s still the case to this very day. While the Switch has seen a number of games take inspiration from Valve’s classic, including Q.U.B.E 2, ChromaGun, and the criminally overlooked Superliminal, Portal is finally available to show the rest of the pack that it’s still the king of first-person puzzlers.
For the three of you who might not be in the know, Portal takes place within the Aperture Science test facility in which you need to progress through a series of chambers. These might simply require you to move from point A to point B, or you might need to trigger switches to open doorways, but the key factor is its use of the Aperture Science Handheld Portal Device, or simply the "portal gun". By using the gun to shoot out two coloured portals — one mapped to each trigger --you’re able to effectively teleport yourself from one end of a room to another by walking through one or the other.
Not only that, but the game eventually makes use of movement and momentum to allow the player to accomplish absurd feats of traversal. Essentially, by jumping down towards a portal lying below you, the effect of gravity allows you to build momentum and fling yourself out of the other portal in whatever direction it's pointing, propelling yourself over gaps and reaching areas that would otherwise be impossible to get to.
It might sound complex, but Portal’s pacing is absolutely masterful; the way it teaches you how to accomplish certain tasks without actually telling you anything is remarkable, and it makes you feel like a bonafide genius when you eventually work it out for yourself.
Valve could have left it at that and been done with it; we’d still be left with one of the best puzzle games ever created. But what elevates Portal even further is the incredible writing. Right from the start of the game, your character is accompanied by the voice of GLaDOS, an AI personality core who oversees the testing procedures within Aperture Science. Expertly voiced by Ellen McLain, GLaDOS’s constant berating of the protagonist is a source of endless humour and it’s no surprise that the gaming community holds the character in such high regard to this day.
The sequel, Portal 2, is pretty much more of the same, but it bulks the experience up considerably with new mechanics like the paint-like propulsion gel and laser guiding. The narrative is also a lot more satisfying, introducing Stephen Merchant as the charming (and ever so slightly creepy) robot Wheatley, and J. K. Simmons as Aperture's founder Cave Johnson, alongside the returning McLain.
The game takes place hundreds of years after the first with the testing facility in total disrepair, making the task of traversing around the rooms much more complex but also introducing some truly beautiful visuals in the process. Overall, having released as a standalone experience back in 2011, Portal 2 feels like a more complete package with a lot more weight behind its presentation.
Not only that, but Portal 2 also offers up a co-op mode that’s compatible with split-screen, local, and online multiplayer. Valve went the extra mile here, too, introducing two unique characters specifically for co-op play with a completely fresh narrative to boot. It’s not as involved as the main campaign, by any stretch, but if you’ve got a friend that you’re able to link up with, it’s well worth playing. If you’re playing via split-screen, the game also lets you choose whether to orient the screen vertically or horizontally, which is a nice little touch.
With that all said, how does the game actually run on Switch? In terms of resolution, you’re looking at full 1080p during docked mode and 720p in handheld mode. The great thing here though is you’re going to experience buttery smooth 60fps gameplay with both options, with only minor dips in the frame rate during particularly intensive moments, like when you create somewhat of an endless loop with your portals. Given the vintage of these games, you may expect them to function well on Switch, but as we've seen with other ports, solid performance is by no means guaranteed with decade-old titles. Nvidia Lightspeed Studios has done a fine job here.
The only downside on Switch is that you’re going to experience loading screens when moving between every test chamber. These don’t last particularly long, but they’re frequent enough to be noticeable. Another minor nitpick is that the game loses its connection to the internet if you put the Switch in sleep mode, bringing up an annoying error message between each chamber when you boot it back up; hopefully this gets patched at a later date.
The biggest gameplay surprise, however, is that the Switch version offers full motion support for aiming. You can tinker with this to your heart’s content too, including the overall sensitivity, inverting the Y-axis, and even choosing which Joy-Con utilises the motion controls should you choose to play in docked mode. Other touches like button remapping and scaling text between screen modes make this version even more approachable.
Conclusion
It's hard to overstate our satisfaction with Portal: Companion Collection. Portal and Portal 2 felt incredibly fresh when they first released, and the years since have not diminished their immense impact. To now have two of the most unique and mind-bending puzzle games on a Nintendo console, and on-the-go if you choose, is a pure joy. If it weren't for the frequent load screens punctuating the experience, we'd have absolutely nothing to complain about here. The motion controls work like a dream, the games run at a near-rock-solid 60fps, and the writing remains as funny now as it did all those years ago. If you haven't played the Portal games before, this should be a no-brainer. If you have... well, just play them again.
Comments 115
ugh, should have waited for this instead of spending my money on Celeste... oh well, there's always next time.
Completed these so many times, yet I’ve already bought on Switch and playing again. Never gets boring.
"The only downside on Switch is that you’re going to experience loading screens when moving between every test chamber"
Honestly, this happens in every version of the game.
Crossing my fingers for a physical XD
I really want to play them now but I’m holding off just in case they have a physical release
Excellent value for money too
HUGE SUCCESS
Amazing games, and £13.49 for both is an absolute steal. I know they’re old hat and can be had elsewhere for far cheaper but for new ports you can’t say fairer than that
Just got those yesterday on Steam Deck for 3$ an absolute steal of a deal during steam summer sales. Glad to see more people will enjoy/discover those gems on Switch
@Z-Core Honestly, I don't think there was a wrong choice. Celeste and Portal, both great (although very different) games.
Portal 2 is without a doubt the best game I’ve ever played, not my favourite but definitely the best. To the people playing these for the first time, enjoy.
Glad these hold up! I'm generally not one for replaying old games I've already played (bar Windwaker, Mario Galaxy and some Ratchet & Clank games) but for Portal I think I can definitely make an exception!
It's hard to make a case for the switch version, as the Steam version is currently just 2,44€ and has mod support on top of that.
So when I get digital games I always wait for a 30-50% off sale. I have never bought a digital game that was not on sale. I bought this collection the second it came out, no waiting for a sale. And that’s after already owning the orange box and portal 2. Two of the finest games I’ve ever played in my years of gaming. Anyone on the fence, buy it.
@Z-Core $20 is the normal price. So, whenever it’s on sale, it could be lower when you’re ready.
@OcarinaHolder52 I saw play-asia had a listing for a physical collection that went rogue after the shadow drop.
Reached out to them and they confirmed they weren't able to make a deal to release a physical copy
Kinda bummed cause I have physical copies on PC/PS3/Xbox of bother Portals and really wanted to complete the set like that.
Does it include the 'Art Therapy' levels?
Chariots, Chariots!
The only thing missing is the custom stage builder, and the true highlight of the stage builder was the added Cave Johnson dialogue. If you haven't heard any of those bits, its well worth looking up the video on YouTube of all of Cave's dialogue in one 30 minute long video. Highly recommended.
Never understood the portal hype, but they are without a doubt good games worthy of a playthrough… just better to buy them at a vastly reduced price on pc, probably.
I'm holding out for Limited Run Games' inevitable collector's edition that will no doubt be shipped in a cardboard companion cube.
@sanderev
THANK YOU.
If that's the only thing holding the games back from a 10/10, I propose an edit. Even on a high end pc, these loads are all over the place, due to the older engines. these are ports of 10-year-old games, and you can understand the limitations here due to the engines also being old.
I will grab it when physical comes along, hopefully not Limited Run Games but someone else.
Loved both games on my PS3 (which is now extinct)
“ the game loses its connection to the internet if you put the Switch in sleep mode, bringing up an annoying error message”
Does this mean the game requires a constant internet connection?
Might actually pick these up someday even if I played them both to death and beyond on Xbox just for motion controls.
@sanderev Yeah I own both Portal games on a decent gaming PC and they have to load between chambers. This is in no way unique to Switch (nor does it seem to be any longer to load).
I got a $20 eShop card and bought Toodee and Topdee the day before this shadow dropped. Wish I wouldn't have in retrospect LOL. I'm glad these are great ports!
(Toodee and Topdee is a great game though, so no regrets there, haha)
@MH4 Yeah, Toodee and Topdee is brilliant. I bought it day one and it was such a blast.
@gaga64 I don't think it needs a permanent connection, basically I think it wants to connect to the internet to record your achievements (it seems to pop up whenever I unlock an achievement, which is usually after finishing a room).
Edit: Yeah I just turned on airplane mode and it carried on playing, so a connection isn't required.
Never played Portal, but I know everyone is always raving about the games. I'll probably pick this up at some point to try for myself--$20 isn't too big of an ask. But I already have way too many games to play with more coming out soon, and money's getting kinda tight. I honestly don't know if this game will be for me--I'm not really a fan of puzzle games OR first-person shooters, with a few notable exceptions. But it's one of those games like Minecraft or Undertale where I feel like I owe it to myself to try it at least once and see what the hubbub is all about.
I'll consider a physical release.
I don't really know what this game is about and never cared to look further into it. I didn't much pay attention to Superliminal either, but the description of the game sounded promising when Super Rare issued a physical release, and I bought it on impulse without viewing so much as a trailer, and I thoroughly enjoyed it. I figured it would have been more fun to experience than it would have been to watch, so I am glad I trusted my instincts. In fact, Superliminal is one of relatively few games that I've completed on Switch (considering my embarrassingly obese backlog), and if this is anything like that, then I will probably enjoy this too. I miss a good puzzler.
I have noticed the hype this game gets, but for me it just looks bland and not interesting in the slightest. I guess now it's coming to something I can play it on I will have to have a proper look into it.
@sketchturner Got it on sale and was able to play through the first world with a friend yesterday, and the level design is super inventive! Plus the silly story is delightful. Absolutely glad I got it.
A must buy if you haven't played them, that's all I have to say.
Putting the Portal games on the Switch isn't about "why"... it's about "why not"!!
Oh wow 😨.
What does a non Nintendo game have to do to get a 10/10 on this site? We’re taking about two of the finest games ever made, in one collection, that run just as well as they do on any other platform for just £13.50!!
C’mon guys you need to reconsider!
These games are fantastic, and none of the loading screens have ever been intrusive in my experience. A perfect score would be justified seeing you consider the games otherwise flawless
Anyone know if GlaDOS's slightly awkward "adopted" "joke" from Portal 2 was cut out?
@BulkSlash ok cool, thanks
@Z-Core Oh no! It’d appears you’ve ended up with one of the best platformers of the last decade instead of one of the best puzzlers. A woeful state of affairs indeed.
I've never played Portal so I'm very tempted, but I wish they sold the two games separately; since I'm not sure if I'll like them enough to play both games I'll probably wait for a sale.
Portal 1&2 are two of the best games ever made. Instabuy and such a great fit for the Nintendo Switch.
Almost a sin to not give them a 10/10.
@FishyS If you end up disliking Portal it's time to start questioning everything about your taste
I never played, sure ill grab, but I can wait for a physycal..
Just think, Portal released with Half-Life 2 and its episodes on the Orange Box. Again, we're talking about Half-Life 2 here, videogame royalty. No one knew what Portal even was. It was supposed to be a curiosity, a side dish.
And yet it's Portal everyone now remembers from the Orange Box. That should give you a clue regarding its quality. Its opening rooms have become a go-to game design example, like Super Mario's 1-1 and Doom's E1M1.
Many games have imitated it. Some are even great, like The Talos Principle. But they're never quite Portal.
@chipia it’s easy to make a case if you want to play the game portably or on a tv and a switch is the only console you have that can run it.
Now give us the Half-Life games Valve.
@Z-Core uhh no, Celeste is pure perfection!
@Z-Core
Celeste is a great game. Makes you tear your hair out but still great!
I'm having such a great time playing these again and the both look and play wonderfully on Switch. I hope they sell really well and we get Half-Life 2 on Switch and then maybe, finally, a new game in those series.
Is anyone else experiencing a weird error in between levels or when getting achievements on Portal 2? I get a 'unable to connect to the internet' pop-up error when it tries to load the next level or when I get an achievement. Which is weird because I know I'm connected to the internet because I get friend notifications and can go on the eShop.
I just want to know 1 thing, is it (Portal 2) cross platform?
@Henchdog dang it! I’ll just get the digital version then. Thank you so much for letting me know, now I can buy it now without worrying XD
So, no physical release? I was looking forward to playing this with my girlfriend... oh well, I do have The Orange Box. I've never played the games, but have heard good things about them for years. Just something that's been in the back log for a long time that I haven't got around to...
@dil_power I read an article, which I agree with, that stated the switch might suffer some losses to the steamdeck. Like you and the article alluded to, the steamdeck will get third party games sooner and cheaper. I know a lot of people won't shell out $400+ for another gaming handheld, but those that do, will use the switch primarily for exclusives, and won't be asking "will this come to the switch?".
The fact that Valve is only charging $20 for two solidly-made ports of two of the best games I've ever played just feels unreal (load times are a bit of a bummer but I played the PS3 versions of these games initially so nothing new to me).
Hoping these ports do well enough that Valve considers porting more of their back catalog to the Switch; the Half-Life games on Switch would be a dream. Left 4 Dead would also be great so long as they're able to optimize the Switch's...shaky, to put it nicely, online.
I know these are significantly cheaper on Steam during some sales, but I'd also like these portable....Hmm.....
Man I remember when the first Portal originally came out, it went absolutely viral throughout my uni dorm. Good times, man
Anybody know if there's still going too be a physical release for this game?
I checked sites like Play-Asia, and apparently the page for buying a physical copy was removed.
Hell yes.. 10/10 for me. Absolutely epic series with brilliant dialog and puzzles. If a physical version releases then I'll buy it too.
@OwenOtter So... Why not Half-Life 1+2 on Switch?
@russell-marlow Here's hoping!
I probably may get this once it goes for sale, though I already got it on Steam getting this for on the go play seems like a better deal. Yes I know about the Steam Deck, why Gabe hasn't deliver mine yet is anyone's guess.
I would get this, if I didn’t already buy these on steam for like 70 cents each. Like honestly these games are dirt cheap there
So basically a 10/10 for this port since the load issue isn’t even unique to Switch. I’ll get sometime later
@PhhhCough yup totally agree. I don’t know how small of a demographics owners of Switch/Steam Decks are but for sure I see little value in buying third parties on Switch… and I was not impressed by the latest Direct…
Ha, I think I think I'm going to get these games when I get paid hehehe. Amazing review, but I wonder if HD Rumble is used.
I've played and completed both Portal games, but never actually owned either — time to finally rectify that
These ports are almost flawless. My only criticism is that the captions in the first game are very small in handheld play. Portal 2's captions are much better.
As for loading screens between levels, those have always been there, even on the original PC versions.
It's soooooo good as it always has been. Great price as well. I would have happily just paid that for Portal 2.
Come on valve, Half Life 2 next please.
60fps, definitely worth the double-dip in that case.
Awesome games indeed! It was a long time ago, but I remember having enjoyed them a lot. Hapoy yo see them back!
@Maxz i mean, I beat the game in one 6-hour sitting (I was exhausted afterwards), and yes it was AMAZING, but if I knew I had that much time on my hands, I kinda wish i spent that time on something that i REALLY wanted to play instead of something I only sort of wanted to play.
I'm surprised, didn't expect this to be 1080p60.
I'll have to try Portal out for the first time.
I have these on Steam, being new to pc gaming, I only have Steam Deck. Nonetheless, I have a physical Switch collection and will absolutely be adding this to it, even if it's via Limited Run.
@gaga64 I was wondering the same thing ... as in why do you have to be connected to the Internet for this game.
Great to hear the framerate is near rock-solid 60fps. With the Switch being, well, the Switch: I'll admit I was a bit skeptical!
The loading screens were always the issue no matter what platform you played these games on, even the PC albeit not taking as long. Still, that has never taken the experience away from me every time I play these games and are well worth a play. I will admit that the PC versions are the best way to play these (not talking about performance), as they have more to offer, especially with the community test chambers in Portal 2, but this is still a great way to experience the games once again, like I'm doing on the Switch. Well worth a purchase.
@Z-Core lol I did the exact same thing last week and feel the exact same way haha
Been so many years since I played these games. Loved all the goofy characters in Portal 2.
Bargain! Absolute bargain, didn't play it enough as part of the Orange Box on PS3 ad now its in my hands..Bliss!
"Another minor nitpick is that the game loses its connection to the internet if you put the Switch in sleep mode, bringing up an annoying error message between each chamber when you boot it back up; hopefully this gets patched at a later date."
I've been getting this whenever I play Slay The Spire and turn my Switch on from Sleep Mode. It's a minor inconvenience, but pretty irritating
If only the custom levels could be playable on this version....ah well. TwT
If I hadn’t already bought these two games and played them on the Steam Deck (with motion controls, too), I would’ve definitely purchased the Switch version. I have told my brother about this collection, and he might buy it at some point. It’s good to see that it runs well on Switch.
When and I hope physical becomes a thing, I will triple dip!
Also I love the 2nd opinion!
@Z-Core I imagine those six hours don’t include the include the B sides or C sides or the free Chapter 9 DLC. Like some of the earlier Pokémon games, the post-game is pretty much sizeable as the main story. It took me over 50 hours to beat every level (maybe because I stuck at games), and there’s even now I can’t say I’ve 100% completed it.
But this is sort of missing the point. Obviously, no one can/should tell you want to can/should enjoy, or what you should play more off. I just wanted to point there’s definitely more than six hours’ worth of game in there.
Still, it sounds like you’ve had your fill. I home you get some time to play some Portal soon!
PC version takes just as long to load as switch, regardless of setup. Still both a 10/10 in my book, Portal 2 is a S-Tier game.
The only downside is that Steam is running the Summer Sale right now but it doesn't include Portal on Switch
Always saw the hype about this but didn't have any other platforms to play it. It was a day one purchase as soon as it landed on Switch and it's awesome. Bit on the short side as apparently I've nearly finished 1 but with all the bonus material and still Portal 2 to plough through, I can't grumble at the bargain price. Load times are just something people have to deal with, they happen in EVERY game
@Great_Gonzalez I think random matchmaking for the co-op could have made it a 10/10 and maybe a map maker with level sharing, still a 9 is really good. (edit: you know what I ignored the price, I guess for just $20 maybe it should be a 10/10)
@FishyS They both run at 60 FPS in both docked and handheald.
@chipia It's not really hard. If you don't have a Steam Deck but do have a Switch and want to play this portable then this version allows that. It's still cheap and a great game.
Portal and Portal 2 are near-perfect gems. It's rare that gameplay and writing are both excellent and mesh so well. Really tempted to pick this up despite having played both multiple times in the past when I had a gaming PC.
@sanderev happened on the Xbox 360 and PS3, continues to happen in the PC version (they're just sped up because SSD go brrrr).
Edit: I finally get to listen to Wheatley on the go!! Yes!
@Aiodensghost indeed Switch loading the game is similar to a Steam Deck doing the same thing (I tested that), a PC with a faster SSD and RAM might load faster. A PC with (only) an old spinning HDD (which I had when I originally played these games) will load slower.
I do hope Valve will gets good sales from these games, so they will also port Half-Life 2 to the Switch.
@OcarinaHolder52 I'm pretty sure PlayAsia is putting out a physical version.
The reviewer mentioned some games that took inspirations from Portal...and none of them were The Talos Principle???
If you've never played it - do it!!
Still my GOAT game.
As someone who has missed over the past decade of PC (and most console) gaming due a physical pain disability, it's always a joy to see one of my old favorites come to the console that I both could afford and can toss and turn with me in bed. Gods I hope I can save up to afford a Steam Deck next. Gaming is pretty much my only escape from a body filled with angry bees ***** acidic honey, and I so so SO badly want to escape into some of the worlds PC gaming has had in the last decade.
Always appreciate your body working correctly, people. Always. 😔
If THIS game can't get a 10, then nothing deserves to. We're talking about 2 of the most critically acclaimed video games of all time. OF ALL TIME.
I've played these games at least 3 times. In fact the Christmas before last I sat down and played Portal 2 again from start to finish with my brother watching and helping.
This is the easiest day 1 I've ever seen in my life. The games look INSANELY good on the OLED screen, the HD rumble, the gyro aiming, the native res at 60fps...
Its so good on Switch. I literally bought a Vita 10 yrs ago hoping to get Portal on handheld. I ordered a Steamdeck but Switch OLED has a better screen, way longer battery life, smaller and lighter, easily docks and has tabletop with detachable controllers. I was prepared to play on Steamdeck if I had no better option, but now I do.
I think I'm one of the 3 or 4 people on Earth that didn't think Half Life was that good...so never got around to trying Portal either. Definitely going to try it, but hoping there's a physical edition announced soon.
@wonderclassic nope, and frankly I'm glad they didn't.
Man this is soooooo good, but seriously, these games are available for like $1 on Steam. Given how much cheaper so many games are on Steam, the Steam Deck is very tempting sometimes. If the Steam Deck worked for Half Life: Alyx and VR gaming in general, I'd be all over it.
Definitely holding out for a physical edition. This is the one game that I would like to own on cartridge.
@Daz1380 Agreed. Bought it right away and happily played it on the subway. What an absolute treat.
I am ready to order the companion cube collector's edition from Limited Run Games. Where is it??
I always found these games highly overrated. Create portals in a set of rooms that all look the same. Playtime a few hours.
I have no idea why some people say these games are one of the GOATs.
Half Life 2 on the other hand was genuinely better than most shooters.
@JaxonH
Where did you get the info that Portal games are the most critically acclaimed games of all time?
According to review aggregators metacritic and OpenCritic that honor goes to Ocarina of Time and Mario Odyssey respectively.
@Cia
I said 2 OF THE MOST critically acclaimed of all time.
So tired of ppl picking arguments for no reason. I'm just gonna block you.
@JaxonH
Still didn't get it. I don't find any evidence that these games would be 2 of the most critically acclaimed of all time.
Also, my response was not negative. Not sure why you wanna block me.
@Cia I personally think the appeal is the puzzle solving, story, and humor, along with the mechanics. You can boil any game down to its basic concepts and call it stupid. "Half Life 2 is just another sci-fi alien game."
The playtime could be viewed as a good thing or a bad thing. Sure, with long games you get more bang for your buck, but that doesn't necessarily make the overall experience better. I'd rather play a game that's short and amazing than I long game that way overstays its welcome.
Another good thing, while not completely related to the switch version, is that it was made so long ago. Sure, that means the graphics are outdated, but for Portal 2 specifically I think the graphics work just fine, and these games can practically run on a PotatOS. For those without beefy high-end PCs, this game can almost certainly run on their device.
These games are some of the most critically acclaimed. Just not THE most critically acclaimed.
I do agree that blocking is a pretty confusing overreaction. Not sure why blocking is warranted here.
DISCLAIMER: I'm not saying your opinion is invalid, just explaining the value others get out of the game.
@ColeTD
Portal collection has 95 in metacritic while xenoblade 3 stands at 89. There's no way Portal is better than Monolith's magnum opus.
love to see valve port more like CS , l4d , Half life 2
@Cia I mean... There is way. Others can have different opinions. I personally liked Portal 2 much better than the Xenoblade series.
Also, you chose not to respond to any of my points, instead just saying there's no way it's better than Xenoblade. My main point is that just because you don't like it doesn't mean others don't find value in what you dislike. There are tradeoffs, and people have differing opinions.
Also, what point are you even trying to make? First you say you have no evidence that it is critically acclaimed, but then you complain about how it is overrated. Is it overrated, or is it bad and not critically acclaimed?
Again, I respect your opinion that it isn't a good game, but you are ignoring our actual arguments whilst contradicting yourself.
One thing, I feel, that helps with the Switch ports performing so well is that Nvidia's previously ported Portal 1 & 2 to Tegra hardware in the Shield TV versions.
Just discovered this now!!! I’m getting my hands on it even though I’d actually been doing a few other downloads at the time. I haven’t played it in forever, but like the review said, the ability to play it handheld is such a huge draw.
@nukatha yes, it does include the DLC. In fact that was the first thing I did when I got it because it was the only thing my cousin & I had not completed together on the previous platform.
P.S. My cousin lives in Egypt right now and there was almost no sign of lag whatsoever and it hasn't crashed once yet!
@gaga64 this does not happen with portal 1 or if you turn on maintain internet connection in sleep mode this will not happen in portal 2
@coolsteel_K good to know, thanks
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...