Back in 2018, the 3DS was still receiving a slow, but steady trickle of new releases despite the Switch stealing the spotlight with its runaway success. Though many put away the old handheld in favour of bigger and better things, there were still plenty of excellent titles released in this period, one of them being The Alliance Alive. A spiritual sequel (of sorts) to an earlier release called The Legend of Legacy, The Alliance Alive fixed many of the issues of its predecessor while also introducing a host of cool new features to make it one of the best RPGs available for the platform.
Unfortunately, it was also mostly ignored by the gaming community and flew under a lot of radars, so developer Cattle Call opted to upgrade it and bring The Alliance Alive HD Remastered to Switch. Though very little was added for this new release, The Alliance Alive HD Remastered is just as strong and RPG as it was last year, and certainly isn’t one to miss out on a second time.
The story – written by none other than Suikoden’s creator, Yoshitaka Murayama – sets the stage by opening with a cataclysmic event in which the Daemon race conquers the human world and divides it into five regions with a magical barrier called The Great Barrier. Fast forward a thousand years, and Daemons rule over the humans with an iron fist, while humanity has mostly forgotten about the other portions of the world they’ve been walled-off from. It’s a cool premise right from the off, and this is only strengthened by the strong characterization and the passive worldbuilding that’s always taking place.
The Alliance Alive HD Remastered doesn’t follow any single hero directly, as this is a story about the titular alliance coming together to overcome the Daemon regime, and this surprisingly works in the story’s favour. The equal focus on multiple characters allows for a more balanced worldview that shows all the nuances at play. For example, the opening act sees you taking control of two freedom fighters in search of a mythical ship that can traverse the great barrier, while the next act follows a studious girl born of Daemon nobility whose curiosity brings her into the human world.
The contrasting views on offer are interesting, to say the least, and this is only furthered as more characters are added into the mix with their own unique perspectives and stakes in the central conflict. If we were to name one flaw with the storytelling, however, it’s that the lack of voice acting is felt a little more strongly here, exposing the humble 3DS origins of the initial release. In that first release, the lack of voice acting was less noticeable due to the smaller form factor and simpler visuals, but when full-length cutscenes are playing out on the big screen in HD and you’re still reading what everyone is saying via subtitles, it feels odd, to say the least.
As with any RPG, you’re kept on a pretty tight leash in the opening hours, but the training wheels soon come off and reveal that there’s a surprisingly robust open world to be explored at your leisure. Biomes with varied terrains are commonplace here, introducing soft platforming elements and creatively-hidden caves filled with hidden treasures and optional bosses. We rather appreciated this level of more complex level design, as it often takes things a step beyond the standard RPG trope of walking slightly off the beaten path to a retrieve a treasure.
Battle follows standard turn-based rules, which fortunately feel anything but sluggish here. The developers included the options to both put the team on autopilot and to speed up the battle by up to four times, which all but eliminates any sense of grind from constant trash mob encounters. More importantly, though, each battle is wonderfully spiced up by the interesting tactics presented by the Formations system. On either side of the battlefield, there are three ‘lines’ that fighters can occupy, and where they stand in relation to one another will affect things like certain stats and the order in which everyone gets hit. Every character can be placed in one of three roles: Attack, Guard, or Support, and each of these will grant buffs to certain abilities and attacks, bolstered further by that character’s placement on the grid.
What we liked about this system is the surprising amount of flexibility that it offers, bringing to mind the Paradigm system of Final Fantasy XIII. You can set up several different formations in advance via the main menu, and these can be switched on the fly as the situation calls. If, say, an enemy turn results in one of your main DPS units nearly keeling over, you can switch to a different formation that sees them moved to the back for healing while a tank moves to the front to soak damage.
It’s the sort of battle system that practically begs you to toy around with it, and as you come to understand your team and the roles you want each character to fulfil, it becomes quite satisfying to set up formations that make your squad a virtually unstoppable force. We rather liked, too, how The Alliance Alive HD Remastered isn’t one to pull its punches with the difficulty. It’s easy enough to get through if you know what you’re doing, but this is definitely not the sort of game that you can skate through with minimal strategic planning.
Part of this comes down, too, to the rather odd progression system implemented here, dreamed up by SaGa’s Kyoji Koizumi. Much like that classic release, traditional tropes of levelling and progression in RPG’s are turned on their head here in favour of something that pushes the boundaries of what can be done with the format. For starters, almost everyone has access to the full list of eleven weapon types – which sort of act as soft classes – and mastery of each weapon type is slowly progressed via the acquisition of Arts, which act as special moves you can use with that weapon. The kicker is that there’s no discernible rhyme or reason to the pace at which you acquire new Arts, it’s an entirely random process that seems to be expedited somewhat by battling stronger enemies. This randomness extends to stat growth as well, where characters in your party will occasionally see an HP or SP bump at the end of a battle.
Many will no doubt feel uneasy operating under such an unpredictable progression path like this, as it basically makes the overall difficulty something that’s entirely at the mercy of random number generation. Rest assured, however, that the developers were keen to tune this system so it scales nicely with the current content you’re faced with overcoming. Stat gains and new Arts may be totally random, yet we never once felt like our characters were underpowered; the randomness is finely balanced against the challenge. We even grew to prefer this random nature over time, as it adds a certain level of excitement to each battle – even against common trash mobs – because there’s always a chance that one or more of your characters will receive a notable jump.
For those that still want a more traditional RPG experience, the developers have also included some elements that allow you to directly shape the role of each character in your party. Each battle will award Talents to its participants, and these functionally act as skill points you can use to purchase special boons for each character. These mostly take the shape of weapon specializations, such as decreasing the cost of Arts with a particular weapon type or boosting the rate at which you obtain new ones, while others can be used to do things like increasing post-battle drop rates.
Though Talents come in at a pretty brisk rate, it takes quite a few of them to buy a new skill for a character, so it’s key that a lot of thought goes into how you invest this all too limited resource. In addition to this Talent system introducing a soft experience system, Arts can also be leveled up individually according to what role they’re used in the most. Though the level jumps here are also random, we rather liked how this added in even more ‘concrete’ means of defining character roles, as it places emphasis on picking a role for a character and sticking with it.
Beyond the characters in your party, there’s a more generalized progression system implemented in the form of the Guilds. As the manifestation of the titular alliance, each of the five guilds specializes in a different role, such as weapon R&D or recon, and the services they offer will grant special benefits to your party both on and off the battlefield. What we liked about the guilds is how they act as a means of tying together virtually all the disparate elements of The Alliance Alive HD Remastered.
For example, exploration is factored in by how levelling up guilds is dependent upon you finding all the potential sites where a new location can be built, as well as talking to NPCs in towns and villages to staff the new locations. Putting the time in to develop your guilds will then directly lead to some huge benefits in battle, such as cover fire or revealing enemy weaknesses, depending on which guilds you’ve chosen to invest more time and resources into. Guilds are certainly a background mechanic in The Alliance Alive HD Remastered – you could feasibly go through most of the game without paying much attention to them – but we appreciate the additional depth that it adds to pretty much every gameplay element.
From a presentation perspective, The Alliance Alive HD Remastered doesn’t exactly impress, but it certainly satisfies. Each realm is given its own distinctive colour palette and visual style, while the dungeons and enemy designs can sometimes surprise with their visual flair. The handheld game origins are all too evident in the overall world design and the chunky character models, but the developers nonetheless did a fantastic job of redrawing assets in high definition. It looks and feels like the developers did more than the minimum required work for an up-res, although there’s only so much they could do with the base game. The Alliance Alive HD Remastered isn’t the prettiest game for the Switch, but it possesses a consistent enough watercolour-esque art direction that it charms in its own right.
This being an HD re-release, you’re probably wondering what else has been added to sweeten up the pot. The answer is: not a whole lot. Aside from the better detailed textures, fancier menus, and the redrawn character models, this is by and large the same game that you could pick up for your 3DS for around twenty bucks. Whether the upgrade is worth it or not is purely subjective. We would certainly vouch for this Switch edition being the definitive version of Alliance Alive, but those of you that are either financially conscious or have already played through it once on the 3DS may want to stop and think about how much you want to pay for the privilege of playing it on the big screen. Either way, this is a fantastic RPG no matter where you play it, and we’d highly encourage you give it a look one way or the other; just be mindful that this HD re-release is about as straightforward as it gets.
Conclusion
Nearly two years on from its initial release, The Alliance Alive HD Remastered proves to be a perfectly competent port of an already fantastic handheld game. A well-written story, a smartly interwoven and complex system of gameplay mechanics, and a distinctive visual style makes this a no-brainer for anybody looking for a consistently high-quality RPG experience on their Switch. It may feel a little simple, given its origins on the 3DS, but don’t make the mistake of passing up on The Alliance Alive HD Remastered, it’s well worth your time.
Comments 34
So many great RPG's on the Switch so little time.
Ordered my limited edition yesterday but your review has just made me realise I thought this was a re-release of Legend of Legacy all this time. Probably cos Allince Alive releases only a digital release in Europe (even though i imported the collectors edition from the US as a physical “back up” despite having sold my American 3DS).
Being a spiritual sequel I suspect I do not need to have played Legend of Legacy first?
In the mood for some Bravely Default style JRPGing so will start this up after finishing Torna: The Golden Country.
@Hylian-Likely lol love your name! And yeah with all these RPGs/jrpgs That are out or coming.... honestly I don’t think the human life span is long enough to complete my backlog at this point. 😂
Those are truly great RPG's @Hylian-Likely. I'm personally playing DQ11S right now. And the Misses got me Ni No Kuni & Collection of Mana for Christmas. Truly a great time to own a Switch.
There's so many great JRPG's right now, I am sure this is good but I'll have to pass because I have a lot of Dragon Quest to get into.
I hope one day Atlus ports SMT4&Apocalypse to the Switch. Or hell, any of the other SMT games the 3Ds received.
I wonder what it would be like if ports like this added in some sort of gibberish language you're not supposed to understand in time with the text? Then it's less this game never had voice acting than the game is a in foreign world and subtitled.
Unlike many here (it seems), I still have a 3DS and I still love it. Will probably pick up that version at a lower price point and be fine with the choice.
I remember trying both on 3DS.
While they apparently share some roots, the first game (Legend of Legacy) wasn't much fun to play.
The second game was much better on the 3DS so I guess it's much better on the Switch, too.
Is this game really much better than Legend of Legacy? Because that game was not very good and Nintendo Life was a lot more generous in their review than other places.
Seeing as they didn't add much new content with this, I'll just end up waiting until a drought to pick it up. Its definitely one of my favorite 3DS games though, and I highly recommend it to those on the fence
@FX102A That's right, you can play them in either order
Loved it on 3DS (not a 9/10 😅)
A bit generic and basic. But not stressful turn based RPG for on the GO. I could be tired after work and still not get a moment where I said "I am tired to deal with this".
I can see the art working well on Switch (cites must look great in HD). No Voice Acting, but text was super big and easy on the eyes even after 9hrs in front of the computer at work (looking at you Fire Emblem) and Story keeps you going.
Music is super "meh" (It did not even have extra battle music on 3DS). I got it for $25 and came with an ArtBook. At $49, it is same price as Dragon Quest 11. I would play that first (now that is a 9/10)
I loved this game so much on the 3ds. I am glad that it has come to the Switch to hopefully find an even bigger audience. I have the 3ds Limited Edition and still pop in the soundtrack occasionally.
I definitely recommend this one.
@CurryPowderKeg79 and not enough money for it all... ugh rip
Where they feet at?
If this just didn't have the chibi art style i'd probably be interested, generally just can't get into that art style. I got Bravely Default, but had issues getting into it because of the character art styles.
@Guitar_bard @CurryPowderKeg79 can I g hopefully it's also a physical release
@Hylian-Likely If you're going to go through Fire Emblem: Three Houses be ready to play marathon the video game. I spent 70+ hours on one house alone, lol.
definitely interested in this, but I can wait for a price drop
I really like the sound of the game from the review. Like the fact there's lots of exploration and the optional guilds sounds cool. Think I'd prefer to pay on the big screen so will go for the Switch version. Feel the need to play Dragon Quest XI first though which will take up lots of time so will be quite a while before I get to Alliance Alive.
Am wondering if Nintendo will start porting first party 3DS games to Switch towards the end of the consoles life cycle.
It is physical here in the U.S @Joe-b because i saw it on Best Buys website.
@construx I completely agree with you there. Still got a 3ds and use it very much along with my switch
@CurryPowderKeg79 Thanks!
Should have packaged in Legend of Legacy, but... it’s fine. I still bought it.
I want Stella Glow now! Or a Stella Glow sequel. Where are all the smaller, mid tier JRPGs 3DS used to get? Atlus hasn’t published squat in 3 full years. Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE Encore will hopefully usher in the next 3 years with better support (still have Persona 5 Scramble and Shin Megami Tensei V from them but let’s see more mid tier support).
The screenshots provided actually look kinda cool.... the kinda cool that makes me wish I kept my preorder. No doubt I want the game, that was never a question. I’ll be getting this, I think, eventually. But first, I pledged I’d actually finally play through Ni No Kuni.... and then The Witcher....
I've been eyeing on this on the 3DS for a while, but because I'm "done" with my 3DS I'll be looking to buying the Switch version.
Great game on the 3ds, the graphics (and gaming) are above average IMO. The battle graphics were a nice touch, the vehicles looked great, the character chibis and just the way they handled a few things most of us take for granted, make this game stand out for me. as one of the better overlooked RPG's on the 3ds.
Glad this one is here on Switch but for $50 I'll wait for a price drop. 3DS version is only $26 so for any one who doesn't care about the game being slightly pretty just stick to that version.
The switch is definitely turning out to be my dream RPG machine. So many games to play 😃
@JaxonH : Stella Glow was one of my favorite 3DS games!
I wouldn't play it again on the Switch because there are so many excellent games and I don't have infinite time but I would surely buy a sequel!
I have to admit, the FF3-esque chibi models kind of turned me off initially, but! After hearing about all the gameplay depth and seeing the in-game screenshots, I've come around and now am very interested!
Switch really is becoming the best JRPG console, getting remasters and ports from a wide variety of consoles all on one system.
I have the 3DS version, and honestly, I thought it was merely OK. It's probably my least favorite RPG on the system, but to be fair, I did a pretty good job of choosing RPG's, so it's got tough competition. But now it's on Switch, and it looks pretty bad by Switch standards. The graphics are very bland looking. Sure, they gave them clean, HD lines, but the detail is no greater than what you got in the 3DS version and the backgrounds look like trash. And the review even admits they didn't really do anything new in this version as far as game play. I hate to be so negative, but I don't see how a lazy port of an average 3DS game gets a 9/10.
Correction, this was a Wii U game, it has to be since the Switch only gets Wii U ports, not 3DS ones, because no one played Wii U games due to less than 1 million people owning one, unlike the 100 million selling 3DS. Please fix your error, thank you.
Tap here to load 34 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...