In a post on the Minecraft blog today, July 20th, 2022, Mojang staff drew a line in the sand when it comes to non-fungible tokens (NFTs) and the blockchain in their game, following feedback from players seeking clarification on the company's position on the controversial topic.
Multiple mod-makers, companies, and creators appear to have used Minecraft to make their own NFTs, making world files and skin packs to sell to players, using the game itself to earn players NFTs through activities done on a shared server, or using the Minecraft art itself in NFTs.
Mojang has no trouble with servers requiring secondary payment from players — as long as the person charging for access maintains the same level of pricing and mod access to all players — but they draw the line at NFTs for the following reasons:
"NFTs are not inclusive of all our community and create a scenario of the haves and the have-nots. The speculative pricing and investment mentality around NFTs takes the focus away from playing the game and encourages profiteering, which we think is inconsistent with the long-term joy and success of our players.
"We are also concerned that some third-party NFTs may not be reliable and may end up costing players who buy them. Some third-party NFT implementations are also entirely dependent on blockchain technology and may require an asset manager who might disappear without notice. There have also been instances where NFTs were sold at artificially or fraudulently inflated prices."
In short, Mojang is seeking to provide a "safe and inclusive experience" to its players, and has therefore stated that "blockchain technologies are not permitted... nor may they be utilized to create NFTs associated with any in-game content."
However, the door is not fully closed on the blockchain, as the closing paragraphs state that Mojang will be "paying close attention" to the technology to "determine whether it will allow for more secure experiences or other practical and inclusive applications in gaming." That's not likely to happen any time soon (or ever), as the company has "no plans" to integrate blockchain technology in the game.
You can read Mojang's full terms for Minecraft on their website.
Comments 37
Yes Mojang Please
I'm glad to hear it
Thanks, Mojang. NFTS suck.
Imagine someone paying thousands of dollars for an NFT of a grass block lol
But I wanted to "own" the ugliest low res textures ever!
this shouldn't have been a debate in the first place, but I'm glad this is their answer. Now if only every game developer held this stance...
Thank you! Finally someone saying no to NFTs without doing it beforehand, let’s go Mojang!
That's real good to hear. I'm not a Minecraft player but it's certainly nice to hear them say no to NFT bulldung.
Weird they say that, I thought that they loved mining.
Laugh track plays
Good. Destroy the whole blockchain.
They got the Point.
Now i have to buy Minecraft for that View of Things.
@SteamEngenius If only Inspector Gadget could actually own them brown bricks in Minecraft.
In regards to topic, do Mojang have the final say in this? Wouldn't Microsoft be able to veto their choice if MS went all in on NFTs?
Not that I think either side would go for it. More curious how much say MS has, considering it seems Todd Howard has to bow to MS with his buyout.
Good, NFT's are a cancer and should be wiped out.
This is refreshing to hear
They'll probably be using them in the back end. Users dont need to know whats happening under the hood.
@Ironcore I’m not sure you know what an NFT is.
@nimnio It’s the software equivalent of a customer asking a cashier if there’s any left ‘in the back’.
I wonder if this is exclusive to Minecraft or if it extends to Microsoft as a whole.
Right, sure... Greed will always follow
@Arkay hmmm, the gaming industry is breaking because of this quick rich scheme 🙄🙄
Good for them. I'm not into Minecraft, but I applaud the stance.
“There have also been instances where NFTs were sold at artificially or fraudulently inflated prices”
That’s every case of NFTs, it’s literally the point of them. It’s a pyramid scheme and those who buy in are expected to hype and inflate the ‘value’. That’s what the oft touted “communities” are.
NFT and crypto are zero sum systems. Someone can only earn money from them by someone else loosing it. It’s just another way to redistribute wealth and guess what? Like all the others it’s rigged in the favour of those who already have the money.
@Ironcore How is that even possible Lmao?
@Ogbert The Onion accurately predicted this:
Recession-Plagued Nation Demands New Bubble To Invest In
https://www.theonion.com/recession-plagued-nation-demands-new-bubble-to-invest-i-1819569940
I sometimes think NFT's are the most ridiculous bubble/Ponzi scheme ever. But I'm sure something even more foolish will replace them.
Based Mojang
Excellent. NFT's and crypto in general should all burn in hell. Only thing of 'value' they've ever contributed to society is more greed, exploitation and gambling addiction ...which we definitely don't need more of.
@XenoShaun Phil Spencer already said that he IS fully agains NFT's and the Metaverse, so while Satya Nadella gives him independence to manage the game division Xbox as a whole (Xbox Game Studios, Bethesda Softworks and in the future Activision-Blizzard) wont support NFT's, the CEO never said anything about NFT's but he sees a future in the metaverse, everything can change with time, but for now Xbox IS agains NFT's
In unrelated news NFTs are down over 90% from their highs
Those darn whippersnappers and their blockchain malarkey. I feel like my grandmother when I try to explain smartphones.
Well they are a subsidiary of Microsoft now. I'm pretty confident Microsoft won't be getting into NFTs anytime soon.
NFTs are a scam and if you invest in them well you're a sucker. Sorry but you are and if you're in favour of this trash then I'm afraid we can't be friends, like ever.
Good, because NFTs are about the worst thing that could be implemented in any videogame. I'm glad Mojang doesn't support this idea openly, even though I don't play any of their games
@Snatcher The London stock exchange uses a blockchain internally. Its not advertised because why does the end user need to know? It would be like what operating system does bt use in their head office, it would literally make no difference to the customer. NFTs have actual use case in places like hospitals, factories etc. Its not a picture of a monkey or whatever its just storage of information. Its like when companies started using email for eg.
@nessisonett Eek, I’d really hope I do as its part of my job lol shhh.
For anyone who buys NFT's
I'm currently selling London bridge, if you're interested.
Thank you Mojang.
Considering how much money NFTs make it's really interesting seeing very rich corporations like Nintendo and Microsoft not cash in on NFTs.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...