Update: Unpacking Master has also now been removed from the Google Play store, meaning it's no longer available there or on iOS, great news for Witch Beam and good work everyone who got in there and lodged a complaint!
Indie developer Witch Beam's Unpacking was one of the surprise gaming hits of 2021, at once a relaxing zen-like puzzler, creative and delightfully tactile play space and thoughtful musing on the unstoppable passage of time. We gave it a fabulous 9 out of 10 in our glowing review, saying that it "deftly applies established game design ideas from completely different genres."
Now, however, Witch Beam has taken to social media via the game's official Twitter account to warn fans of an "ad-riddled" knock-off of Unpacking which has shot up the charts on both the iOS App Store and Google Play store. To the untrained eye, the rip-off — which is very cheekily titled "Unpacking Master" — looks pretty much identical to Witch Beam's game in screenshots provided by the dev, albeit without the stylised pixels of the original.
Witch Beam goes on to say that they have obviously seen plenty of imitators already, but that this one is particularly bad as it's gained a ton of traction and been aggressively advertised on both TikTok and Instagram. It then goes on to highlight similarities with side-by-side comparison showing art from each game:
It's obviously a very hurtful situation for the indie team, as they themselves say;
"It's demoralising for a small team like ours to see content we spent literally years planning, refining and handcrafting be hastily reproduced in an opportunistic ad-riddled app a mere 3 months after our launch."
Thankfully, as of this morning, and no doubt thanks to the complaints of fans of the game who alerted Witch Beam to the situation in the first place, Unpacking Master has been removed from the Apple's iOS App Store, where it had been sat at #1 in the free games chart. However, the clone is currently still riding high in the Google Play free games chart at #3 with over one million downloads as things currently stand.
Let's hope that this one gets pulled from Google Play as quickly as possible. In fact, maybe we should all get on there and alert the store to the fact it's a blatant copy.
What do you make of these free to play clones and the speed at which they pop up on mobile stores? What should be done to stop them from hurting and blatantly profiting from indie devs like this? Let us know in the comments.
Comments 14
Absolutely disgusting. How this could get onto the App Store in the first place is beyond me, but the fact that someone would rip off any game to such a like-for-like degree is appalling to say the least.
mobile "game" devs have no sense of shame or decency. ripping off an indie game is completely rancid.
Given the quality control or lack thereof that allows asset flip garbage or games laden with bugs (or in basement’s case- no ending) ending up on the eShop, it’s no surprise stuff like this ends up on other- more widely used- storefronts.
I wonder if the suits pushing things to the store for Apple or Google even play games?
I have this on my wishlist on switch since Christmas, as i have a kid who's big on giving gifts and the whole Christmas season hit him real big, this is the push i needed to finally buy this game and since this friday its pay day, i decide to gift him the game for no reason (hes just a cool 6 year old kid) 🙂
Disgusting action, glad it got taken down.
I thought "fair use" was okay though? Lmao
I got an ad for this one time. I wish ads on mobile games had report buttons
I play a handful of mobile games, mostly officially licensed character themed ones. I remember playing and getting an ad for a Galaga rip-off, using Galaga's sound effects and jingle. Ironic part, this was within the official Bandai Namco Pac-Man app.
Glad this got resolved, I'm always stumbling across fake games on mobile storefronts. As I mention I play a few officially licensed character games, this happens frequently with popular and well known characters.
@twicesmt I don’t understand fair use very much but I’m pretty sure it doesn’t protect near perfect copies of the original made for profit.
I have this wishlisted and was waiting for a sale, but I'll grab Unpacking at the weekend to support the developers.
I honestly had new clue about this game, I actually had played the rip off and it's ad every 10 minutes of play through. Thanks for reporting, ill get the actual game soon now.
Dear whoever made this,
I hate you.
Kind regards,
Mikmoomamimocki
@twicesmt funny how people advocate so hard for fair use when it's a reverse engineered Nintendo port, but never go to bat for a knockoff of an indie game also running on all original code. Game is obviously a ripoff and they're profiting off unassuming people just like the Wordle apps, but it's all or nothing. You ban the right to make indie knockoffs you'd also lose your Nintendo knockoffs.
One of the knock-offs has been repeatedly popping up on some of the games I gave on mobile. I have Unpacking on my wishlist for both Steam and Switch, and I'm not even giving the knock-off developers a store page view. The more quickly they're forgotten, the better
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...