Edible Magikarp

Welcome to "Would You Rather", where we ask you to choose from two (or more) equally awesome/horrible things, and find out if you're in the majority or the minority. Of course, you can always argue your case in the comments.

Bienvenue, hungry diners, and welcome to the Nintendo Life restaurant Chez Ninté, where we'll be serving up a 14-course meal made of the rarest meats you'll ever find on a menu.

Today, we're asking the age-old question: which Pokémon would you eat?

For Starters

Starters

Fun fact: the Starter Pokémon are actually called "Appetiser Pokémon" in the US. Since we're setting out a full meal for you, we might as well start at the start: which one of the three iconic starter Pokémon do you think would be the most delicious?

Charmander is probably a little spicy, and would be quite nice as a curry. Squirtle can be a lovely turtle soup. Bulbasaur is a handy all-in-one caesar salad, as long as you add your own croutons.

Subscribe to Nintendo Life on YouTube809k
Watch on YouTube
Which Pokémon would you rather eat?

The Classics

Partners

Not all Pokérestaurants are fancy. Some are just diners in the middle of nowhere, serving up battered Magikarp and chips to the masses. If there were two common, classic Pokémon to have for lunch, it would probably be the series mascots: Pikachu, and Eevee.

Now, we think Pikachu could make for an interesting dish: being a rodent, Ash's longtime companion would probably taste a bit gamey, like rabbit. Eevee, on the other hand, is a creature of indeterminate species, somewhere in-between dog, cat, and fox. We can't say that we know what any of those taste like to eat as a meat dish, but we did accidentally lick a dog once and it tasted like fur.

Which one would you rather Pika-chow down on?

Which Pokémon would you rather eat?

The Steak And Eggs

Steak N Eggs

There are quite a few Pokémon that are already basically analogous to foods we regularly eat here in the real world, and we can't spend all day listing them or we'd never be able to take the weekend off.

However, everyone loves a classic steak-and-egg breakfast, right? Unfortunately, this is "would you rather", so you'll have to pick just one: a juicy Miltank mignon, or scrambled Exeggcute? Bear in mind that both are sentient, but Exeggcute is multiple sentient beings as one - although whether that's a bonus or a horrifying thought is up to you.

Which Pokémon would you rather eat?

The Queen's Forbidden Pantry

Queen

Culinary delights across the world have often involved some ethically dicey dishes, like the Ortolan Bunting, which is drowned in Armagnac, roasted, and then eaten whole, as the diner covers their head with a cloth in order to not be seen by God. We don't doubt that there are some corners of Kanto with similarly illegal traditions, but since the Pokémon games have never really covered food crimes, we have to imagine our own.

And what could be more illegal than eating animals protected by the Queen herself? The swan is an obvious one, but we can't imagine the Queen would be too happy about some random Pokémon trainer chopping up a corgi, either. Which one of the Queen's pets do you think would taste the best?

Which Pokémon would you rather eat?

Ready Meals

Spaghett

Sometimes you don't want to fuss around with chopping vegetables and deboning fish - you just want to pop into Tesco and grab something tasty that someone else made. Good news: the Pokédex has you covered.

Tangela is basically a pre-sauced spaghetti dish, and all you need to do with Unown is grab a bunch of them and boom, you've basically got a bowl of alphabet pasta. Sure, you might have to deal with the fact that both have eyeballs, but doesn't that just add to the flavour?

Which Pokémon would you rather eat?

Round

Round

What is this category? Round animals. What does that have to do with food? Well, in the real world, we don't really have round, edible animals. They're mostly sort of horse-shaped. There's something vaguely exciting about the prospect of eating a big round steak cut from a spherical creature - or perhaps having one roasted whole, like a pig.

Never mind that both Jigglypuff and Rowlet are very cute. You've come this far, and eaten five other cute animals. They could have been someone's pet.

Which Pokémon would you rather eat?

Eating Children

Baby

You've crossed the line now, and you're definitely going to Hell, so here's a question: if you had to eat a baby, which baby would you eat?

Not a real baby, mind you. That's very murdery and a bad crime. A Pokémon baby, though, that's fair game, because they are just pixels on a screen, and this is all a thought exercise, and please don't send the police after us. So, we ask you: Happiny, or Togepi? Please bear in mind that their parents may or may not come after you, if that's a factor.

Which Pokémon would you rather eat?

Is It Vegan?

Salad

We're not really sure how veganism works in a world where the plants have faces, but if you can stomach it, there are some quite nice veggies in the Pokémon world.

Oddish is basically a radish. A radish you can be friends with, yes, but a radish nonetheless. And Bellsprout? Beansprout. You might prefer a stuffed Weepinbell pepper, but this is the salad section, so you'll have to deal with eating the boring Pokémon, sorry.

Which Pokémon would you rather eat?

Legendary Cuisine

Dogs

We could have had any of the legendaries face off in this section - Regice has always looked a lot like a tasty ice lolly to us, and we reckon Type:Null would taste a bit like everything at once - but considering how infuriating it was to try to catch the Legendary Dogs in Pokémon Gold and Silver, we want to eat them mostly as revenge.

But which one of the trio is the most delicious? We bet Entei tastes like spaghetti and meatballs, Raikou tastes like a katsu curry, and Suicune tastes like jelly.

Which Pokémon would you rather eat?

The Challenge

Challenge

You bet that the Pokémon world has those "can you eat this" challenges, just like the real world - except, instead of a really big pizza or a very spicy burger, it's "a Pokémon bigger than your house".

Wailord is a whole lotta fish to eat, but we'd also love to know what Alolan Exeggcutor neck tastes like. Plus, you'd get to brag that you ate a tree.

Which Pokémon would you rather eat?

Basically Cannibalism

Sexy

We've already spoken a bit about crimes against humanity (eating babies, scoffing the Queen's pets) but how about the biggest crime of all: eating humanity itself? Sure, technically these two aren't actually human, but they're human enough to make it a bit weird.

There's also the extra angle that both these Pokémon are a little too uncomfortably, er, sexy. We're not saying we think that, but we are saying the designers definitely did.

Which Pokémon would you rather eat?

Eat God

Eat God

There isn't really a religion in Pokémon, but both of these Pokémon - one natural, one man-made - are basically gods. And wouldn't you love to eat God?

We swear, this article began as "which Pokémon would be tastiest" and now it's just descending into "WOULDST THOU LIKE TO EAT GOD", but if a god-animal existed in the real world, we'd ask if it went well with gravy.

Which Pokémon would you rather eat?

The Dessert

Dessert

You've just killed and eaten a bunch of pets, but your hunger is not satisfied. Luckily for you, you monster, there are several Pokémon that are basically already made of pudding, which means that you can't really be blamed for finding them delicious. If a real-world animal evolved to look like a lemon meringue pie, then it's not doing a very good job of surviving, is it?

If you can manage to fit just a little more Pokéfood down your gullet, perhaps you'd enjoy a whipped cream Alcremie (which comes in multiple flavours) or an ice cream Vanillite (upgrade to a Vanillish for just £2)?

Which Pokémon would you rather eat?

Coffee Before You Go?

Liquids

This is one of those fancy restaurants where they offer you a little espresso or a mint tea with dessert, even though it's 11pm and you need to go to sleep as soon as you get home.

Although a lovely Ditto milkshake would probably taste quite nice (just tell Ditto to turn into a strawberry before you pop it in the blender) we're going with two obvious liquids right here to round off a lovely meal: a nice glass of Milcery, or a cuppa Polteageist?

Which Pokémon would you rather drink?

Thanks for joining us for this morality-testing meal. Please explain yourselves in the comments below.