Welcome all to Box Art Brawl, the weekly series where we scrutinise regional box art variants from around the globe and vote on the best.
Last week we examined the European, North American and Japanese covers of Super Turrican. At the time of writing, the easy winner is Japan with 66% of the vote. However, both Europe and North America appear tied with exactly 17% each. Having plugged into the mainframe here at Nintendo Life Towers to get a look at the numbers on the back end, we can confirm that... North America takes second place by the slimmest margin possible: one single vote! Congratulations to North America, and commiserations to lowly Europe. So close to being 'first loser'!
This week we're looking at a Konami series that has graced us with its presence round these parts twice before: first in Box Art Brawl #2, and again in Brawl #19. Super C was a port of the arcade Super Contra and added a few new levels to the original. It's available to play these days on the NES Classic Mini or as part of Konami's Contra Anniversary Collection on Switch, so if you missed out on the second entry in this run 'n' gun series, it's easy enough to catch up.
Ready? Let's lock and load...
Europe
As with the first game in the series, video game violence censorship meant that Contra's human protagonists, Bill and Lance, were jettisoned in favour of robots in Europe. Probotector II: Return of the Evil Forces is a rare cart these days, and finding a box with the glorious art above in good condition will set you back a pretty penny.
RD008 (the blue robot) and RC011 (the red one) look pretty great. They're shiny, they've got big guns and they're pulling a killer front-cover pose for y'all. Throw in a sweet B-movie subtitle and there's a lot to like about this cover.
Japan
The Famicom version sees Billy and Lance blasting baddies on a grid that's cracking beneath them. A drooling enemy occupies the top of the image while tanks, choppers and perfectly spherical, reflective bullets fly out of an odd portal in the background. And there's an island with palm trees thrown in there for good measure.
Individually, the elements are exactly want you want on a ball-busting '80s-inspired action game, but the image lacks focus. It really needs a close up of some rippling biceps or an explosion to draw the eye. As it is, it's a bit all over the place.
North America
The North American version uses the same key art as the Japanese variant, but pulls in closer and gives you a better look at what's going on. It's still a little haphazard, but with a logo that recalls the original and the silvery-grey border providing continuity with Konami's other NES output, we prefer this to the Japanese version, even though it it still lacks focus.
Better than the killer European robots, though? Now that's a tough call.
Humans or robots? That's your choice this week. Click your favourite cover and hit the 'Vote' button to let us know below:
And so ends the Contra series' third entry in the Brawl of the Box Arts. We'll see you next week for another round.
Comments 44
NA all the way. Japan looks very pretty too.
I go for Europe. Gives me a transformer vibe x x x
I like the three of them but my vote goes to EU version since that's the one I grew up with.
Japan or NA for me. That art is beautiful. I picked Japan because there's more of the art visible, but it is very close.
The European one is baffling, but I guess if you grew up with it I can see the appeal. To me, it's just a close up of some off-market Autobots, against a generic backdrop. Even the font of the text is boring, to say nothing of the subtitle. Return of the Evil Forces doesn't quite hook me in.
This was an easy one for me. Love the Eighties Miami Vice meets Predator feel of the Japanese and US covers, but the EU robots just look cool. That box art hasnโt dated at all - you could get away with that now.
I always vote USA because I'm a good American.
Couldnt even tell the Europe one was a Contra game. I picked North America, probably the image chosen but it has better colors than the Japan one.
@TheDanslator Yeah I think Id have to agree with you 100% on that one.
Japanese box art for me.
Always loved the JP/US artwork, remember it being used for ads in magazines and it just really tells a cool story that gets you interested. NA art work just shades it for me.
I love robots. I own many of them. Probotector just doesnโt do anything for me and I much prefer the ridiculously over the top 80s Commando type heroโs.
Robots are cool...but not when they should be rambos
I love robots, but I couldn't vote for EU knowing that it's not really what the game is supposed to be, even though it's cool.
Really tough call between Japan & US. Either is a winner, but I went US because of the more vivid art, but that could just be a scan quality difference.
The Japanese and American ones destroy that awful EU one. The EU one is just a lame generic robot picture (about as lame as subbing in robots was to begin with). I'd guess this was some lackluster generic mech game going by this. I assume the votes it's getting are far from the people who grew up with it and thus associate the generic robots as being Contra.
The other 2 actually show things from Contra. And between the other two, the Japanese one has the art filling more of the box, but the American one wins due to much better colours.
NA all the way!
Japanese has a small edge over NA for me. Europe is just what the hell am I looking at? "Return of the Evil Forces"? Why not just go all the way into the Blandness Zone and call it "Robot Video Game 2"?
I love and hate the title of the Europe one. It's such a stupid name.
Europe this time, even if some assets are swapped out. Those robot poses are decent, plus the art isn't nearly as unfocused as the other two.
Brownie points to that snarling alien on the other two covers, however.
I voted Probotector last time, this time I actually prefer the crazy 80s background and slightly better detail on the protagonists of North America's cover.
Japan and NA look to cartoony, I think Europeโs is awesome!
@Cotillion Agree about the cover, but I prefer the Sprite swap, even without nostalgia I'm sure I would. Robots r coolz man!
Back in the day I wished we could play the soldiers in Germany, nowadays I think the name "Probotector" and the robots are simply awesome. The EU Artwork is among the best in the NES library.
None of them stand out but I choose NA because it represents the look of the game the best of the 3.
Hey, what's with the robuts?
How is NA not winning by far?!?! Who the hell votes for a cover that doesnโt represent the game at all?!?!?!
Box Art Brawls Current Total:
Europe: 14
Japan: 17
North America: 13
It is insane to me that the European art is currently beating both alternatives. Goes to show the power of nostalgia!
Went with N.A. I like how 80's it is. The image appears sharper and more defined.
Europe wins it again!
I like and dislike elements of all of them(US and Japan being almost the same). I have no nostalgia for any of these. I do like humanoid robots, and I like them on the Probotector 2 cover. The background is a bit boring and the sub title is too generic both in what it says and the font used. The "Probotector" part of the title should be much larger. I think the NA cover is better than the Japanese cover. NA has messy composition. There's no strong focal point. It seems like they just patched together elements and placed them randomly. It's not a bad piece of art, but not a great cover due to the composition. The "Super C" title is prominent and stylish as it should be. I almost voted Europe, but I think NA is a bit better overall, mostly because of the title logo.
The robots are cool, but have literally NOTHING to do with the game. Went NA for this one. I (just barely) prefer the color palette over Japanโs.
Don't really care if they're not in the game, EU box art is quality. The American and Japan boxarts are a bit forgettable.
@Cotillion We don't associate it as being Contra, because it isn't. It's Probotector. Such a ridiculous comment.
How can the robots have nothing to do with the game? There are robots in the Probotector games, whether you like it or not.
@Franklin Thanks for the tally
For years I wondered why Iโd never heard of Contra. So many people mentioned it and praised it as a classic but I was clueless.
Now I know itโs because Contra is Probotector, a game me and my brother spent hours on and loved. Fortunately I didnโt miss out.
Kinda shocked that the European version is winning at the time of this comment. Clearly inferior to the others to me. I attribute this this site's UK readership voting out of nostalgia and the similarity of the Japanese and NA versions causing a vote split. Even if you like the mech aesthetic, those designs are very underwhelming. Also, on a side note, "Return of the Evil Forces" is one of the dumbest subtitles I've ever heard. It's like self-parody.
While I think the EU cover is the best, I just can't vote for a Contra cover that doesn't even feature the actual human characters that are supposed to be on it. NA all the way here.
Difficult because you are actually looking at 2 completely different themes on the 'same game'. However I'm going to look at it purely as Contra so JPN for me.
@Dragonslacker1 Thats exactly why my parents bought me Probotector for my christmas present when I first got my NES.
"The robots are cool, but have literally NOTHING to do with the game."
Eh? But the two robots are in the Probotector game.
"However, the North American cover looks like an improvement of the Japanese one. The colors are touched up, thereโs a cool new visual effect, and the guys look like theyโre jumping out at you. I absolutely love it! It was a tough choice, but I voted for NA."
The huge borders to the left and right of the image make it the worse of the three to me.
"Difficult because you are actually looking at 2 completely different themes on the 'same game'. However I'm going to look at it purely as Contra so JPN for me."
But its not purely Contra. Its also Probotector as well.
"Europe is just what the hell am I looking at? "Return of the Evil Forces"? Why not just go all the way into the Blandness Zone and call it "Robot Video Game 2"?"
You must not be seeing the same image I am. Are you sure you're not looking at Mega Drive Probotector? Because that cover is Blandness Zone.
Here is the artist who made the NA/JP cover art of this game:
Knowing nothing about the game Iโve gotta vote Europe! Thatโs the one in the shop I would pick up to look at at least. Even with the terrible tagline!
I voted Japan, I like that the image is wider, but NA looks great too. Europe looks good, but I feel the image doesn't represent what this game is very well, JP and NA do a much better job of representing the actual game.
I think that in general terms - based on the results of these polls, a lot of people here among the NL readership are doing a pretty solid job of avoiding a strong "familiarity bias" - meaning, I don't think a lot of people are just arbitrarily preferring what's familiar just because it's familiar, or what's novel just because it's novel, but letting simple tastes weigh more than that, and chosing a mix of the two. I know that in my own case as an American, I'm probably not that far removed from voting NA, EU, and JP about equally. Actually, if anything, it's JP I'm voting for the most. Based on the polls, it seems like there's a lot of people like me here, who are not being "region ruled".
However, in this case, I do think familiarity / novelty biases will be stronger, as, is your frame of reference playing these games playing as vaguely Stallone / Schwarzenegger-esque humans in Contra, or playing as sorta generic robot soldiers in Probotector (which I must admit sounds a bit too much like "Probiotic" for me). ๐
Here, I think we will all be a bit more likely to either run towards or away from the familiar because of how striking the difference is. In my case, I am a bit averse to the robots, preferring the humans, although, I didn't go full familiarity, as I favored the more opened up artwork and style of the logo on the JP version.
Also, if my theory here holds any water at all, it makes loads of sense that the presumably predominantly EU readership of this UK site would predominantly favor Probiotic....er, I mean Probotector! ๐๐
In any case, they're all three decent box arts, so it's kinda hard to go too far amiss here. Anyway, I do really enjoy these contests. Please keep them up!
Cheers!
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...