With the great news about Mega Man Legacy Collection 1 and 2 coming to Switch being announced recently, we've got another slice of Blue Bomber-related news - this time going all the way back to the first NES game.
In the world of games, a lot of minuscule things get dug up, discovered and passed around. Rumours, urban legends and gossip go hand in hand with games. Does a game have a secret code? Was a game radically changed before release for various reasons? Did a game have a secret, uncredited programmer? They are often fun to discover and talk about; sometimes they are easily proved or debunked. Others just kind of hang around without ever being fully solved.
One such example that has been around for a long time is the alleged similarities in the stage theme from Elec Man from Mega Man and the song "Faithfully" by the rock band Journey. Both songs start off with four distinctive notes that are very memorable, and while the songs don’t sound the same all the way through to the end, there have been many discussions about the similarities over the years.
Elec Man is not the only song which has been compared to Faithfully. An obscure R.E.M. song called “All The Right Friends” was included on a soundtrack some years back, and again, they share a lot of same characteristics. Super Mario Bros. and Sonic The Hedgehog 3 have triggered their own discussions regarding musical influences over the years, as well.
So, What about Journey and Elec Man? Was it an homage or not? I reached out to Mega Man composer Manami Matsumae - AKA Chanchakorin - and in the video below, she gave me a very direct answer. To see what she said and compare all three songs, check it out.
If you are a fan of Manami Matsumae’s work - which includes recent titles like Shovel Knight and Mighty No. 9 - you might want to check out her debut album. "Three Movements" was released on 17th of December last year, the 30th anniversary of the release of the first Mega Man game.
If you liked this video be sure to check out GTV for more things retro, Nintendo and Japan.
Comments 33
Lot's of music unintentionally sounds like other stuff. I always remember the Suikoden 2 dancing music when I listen to the middle 8 of Nuno Bettencourt's 'Happiness'.
Those references might date me a bit.
Haha lots of waffle but yeah they are totally the same. More of a homage rather than soothing they need to go to court over I'd say
An obscure*
O is a vowel, so you use "an" not "a".
I am just gonna leave this here...
For the more time constrained among you, skip to 1:26.
You are welcome.
Back in 1983, none other than Prince called up the Journey people to ask for their blessing for a song he was working on. He was afraid that Purple Rain sounded a bit too much like Faithfully!
The quote is at 5:23 if you don't want to watch a 6-minute video just to know if the composer was a Journey fan.
I can't stand Elec Man's theme. Perhaps it's because as a child I would always sing these words to the theme: simply having.... Simply having... Simply having a wonnnnn-wonderful Christmas time....
Yeah, I know it's strange. Yet every time the theme starts to play those words go through my head haha. Interesting comparison though and the two tunes do sound similar.
Mega Man in real life looks terrible.
Top Journey songs:
Faithfully
Only the Young
Ask the Lonely
This article is such a troll, takes forever to get to the headline and then makes you sit through a video. YouTube level clickbait right here. 😂
Which resulted in the conception of more children? Faithfully or Elec Man's theme?
The beginning of Elec Man song is also somewhat similar with this song ( The Beginning of Piano part) :
Winner Takes It All by E-ROTIC
there is already so much music composed all around the world that is basically impossible to compose an unique melody...if you think that you composed an unique melody, there is already someone who has composed it before you.
Here are the quotes so you don't have to watch the video:
(Regarding Elec Man and Journey),
"I have heard this from many people, but when I was composing music at that time, I didn't know any songs by Journey. Even if I did, I wouldn't do such a daring thing (as to copy a song) because it would come out in public."
"Some people have said it's plagiarism and it hurts slightly. But the songs are very similar, and I don't think there's anything I can really do about it now."
If Journey felt plagiarism badly enough, they would sue. I like both the Nes/GB versions of the theme. Also cool that, on a slightly unrelated note, Elec-Man was in Smash.
I think it's using the same cadence of chords just in different keys and the rhythm is similar but I rarely ever believe plagiarism in music especially based on her past work. Also writing a song isn't the same as writing a term paper especially for composers and changing a few words to plagiarize either if you did hear a song you like and you we're going to plagiarize it there's so many more ways to mask it so people couldn't easy identify it.
Speaking of plagiarism, your logo is a plagiarized version of the ABC logo.
YouTube isn't a replacement for journalism
Why did you keep hiding the main point of articles in videos? I'm not going to watch a video to get a bit of info that could easily be given in two sentences. You only do it for the ad revenue. Getting tempted to stop watching any of your videos.
@GumbyX84 read purinpuffs comment. It gives you the quote from rge vid so you dont have to watch it.
I didn't know she worked on shovel knight? It explains why the music is so good.
There are plenty of little parts that sound like other songs. I swear I hear parts of Yesterday in Twoson. Of course New Age Retro Hippy is Johnny B. Goode. That's What I Say from Runaway Five.
Then there's Louie Louie in California Games.
@PurinPuff
Thank you Purin Puffin.
@ALinkttPresent I used to work there and so its a nod to that. You are the first person to notice that, or at least tell me
@GumbyX84 Thank you for telling me. I will make sure articles have the same text as a video in the future.
I wonder if Neon Tiger's stage from Mega Man X3 was inspired by My Michelle by Guns N Roses.
There are but only so many notes lol coincidence.
Double dipping aren't you guys? (Site ads + YouTube revenue)
Shovel Knight's soundtrack was by Jake Kaufman. Only two tracks were by Matsumae.
Not just Journey. Go check out "Hold Your Head Up High" by Stan Bush. The melody is identical.
Did Green Jelly get in trouble for using "The Mob Rules" as a boss theme in "Spider-Man & Venom: Maximum Carnage"?
I heard that Black Sabbath gave Tecmo trouble for "Iron Man" being in the arcade version of "Ninja Gaiden".
Interesting.
elecman's theme was one of the least interesting and boring melodies of MM1. Cut man's theme is hands down the most iconic, with fire man and ice man's themes being very memorable.
Bomb man's theme was just the worst, as was his power!
I started a blog about similarities between video game music and pop culture themes. There will probably more than one Megaman entry on it:
https://www.destructoid.com/blogs/PhilsPhindings/
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...