With The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess HD around the corner you'll have seen that a glut of reviews have popped up, including ours, and now Eurogamer's Digital Foundry has produced an updated 'face-off' article comparing the new release with its GameCube and Wii predecessors.
Overall, the impression is a positive one, with the substantial resolution increase and improved visuals among the positives highlighted.
Visually it's a much sharper, richer looking game. No stone is left unturned in the overhauling of textures, and even character hair is remapped with a brand new asset - while shadow resolution is boosted too. Even the bloom effect is intensified for some cut-scenes, just like the Zelda: Wind Waker HD project on Wii U. Alas, geometry is left as-is from ten years ago, meaning we get the same rudimentary character designs and terrain dimensions, at times looking a little primitive for a 2016 release.
However on balance it's surprising how well the game holds up, and certain efforts are made to embellish the world - if only as a small gesture. For example, scenery is retouched in places like Ordon Village, and new trees are added to fill out its barren hillsides. Otherwise Nintendo's original location designs return as-is, and we've yet to spot other terrain tweaks in spots like Kakariko Village.
A negative highlighted is that in exceptional cases, one being the foggy area in Faron Woods, there are actual frame dips not seen on the GameCube and Wii. This is put down to the shift in resolution and the related strain on the hardware, whereas the older hardware was operating at a more manageable 480p. We suggested in our review (as a hunch) that the perceived lock of 30fps (which holds for the vast majority of the game) was down to the Wii U lacking the power to aim for 60fps, and this seems to affirm that belief.
In the end, though, Digital Foundry is happy with the remaster.
On the whole, Zelda: Twilight Princess HD does everything we had hoped for in this remaster, and though there will always be some lasting 'wants', the turnout is strong enough to make a return to this game all the more compelling.
Are you planning to pick this up on Wii U this week, and are you happy with its performance on a technical level? Let us know.
[source eurogamer.net]
Comments (29)
Watched the vid on DF youtube channel this morning. Overall the impression was positive and they were impressed how well the GC handled this.
Wasn't the Nintendolife review good enough?
I'm glad they enjoyed it though.
Nope, I'm not planning to buy the same game for the third time, for the third consecutive console. I'll pick the amiibo though, that's for sure.
Weird article? Publishing someone else's review? I only played the Wii version of TP in 2013 which was my first ever Zelda game I played, and loved it. It'll be bizarre to play it again in HD only 3 years later, but it is my favourite Zelda to date.
I played the original version and although affordability is not an issue for me, value for money is.
If this was a brand new Wii U Zelda game with the same short comings that TP has the review would not have been as positive.
I know that 'value for money' can be subjective, but this is not a new game and it has no additional content but has a new game price tag of £50.
Reviewers seem stuck between a rock and a hard place when it comes to Amiibo content. They are trying to justify to gamers who don't want Amiibos that they àre not missing anything, but they won't say the Amiibo content is not worth the price of the toy.
We have had enough old Zelda games to the extent now that the new one may not seem like a killer game for the NX when it gets released.
It will be interesting to see how the reviewer trys to justify a score of 9/10 for the new Zelda putting it on par with TP. They could be forced to give it a 10/10 because they have gone over the top with TP. Shame.
@zool £50?! You need to shop around mate!
Am I the only one who doesn't think the HD visuals look that much better than the old SD graphics?
I will buy the bundle, buy it digitally and buy an extra wolf Link amiibo! It's so worth it to me and the visual is HD enough compared to the Wii version. Now bring Skyward Sword Wii VC to the eShop Nintendo!
@RainbowGazelle I played the Wii (wide-screen) version on a 32" LCD on composite cables for the first time long ago and it didn't look that pretty (very jagged aliasing since it was Anamorphic wide screen and Bloom to the max, like watching with Vaseline-coated glasses). I'm afraid of how would it look now on a 50".
@Splatburst Same here! Glad I'm not the only impluse buyer in the comment thread.
Oh no, framerate drops! Though in the actual video, it's hard to notice the frames being dropped - you really have to look for it (even with the graph showing you when to look). I guess it helps that, for the most part, Link is standing still when the frames are dropped, so it's even harder to notice. I'll have to check that out for myself when I get the game and get access to that area of the forest. I love these comparison videos because they show just how much better the game looks with the new textures and increased resolution. Can't wait for Friday!
@zool hotukdeals.com/gaming/deals/new
There now I've saved you paying ridiculous prices.
@zool Why exactly would the score given to the new Zelda have anything at all to do with the score given to Twilight Princess? They might even have different reviewers.
It's not like the score matters one bit compared to the content of the review anyway.
@zool I agree, this game should be 30 max.
Especially after all the droughts we've been through >_<
Is it too late to preorder and get the special CD?
@zool What if the new one doesn't get released on Nx? Your problem is solved.
Day 1 physical copy for me
@Tamalesyatole Yeahhhh it was a jaggy mess. I really wish they would have waited for Wii U with skyward sword because that game could have been so gorgeous if it wasn't such a mess of low resolution and crap to try to cover that up. I think they did a fantastic job of retexturing twilight princess. They gave it a newer game feel while still maintaining the original game. But for $60USD I feel like they should be releasing a rebuilt game instead of a retexture.
Edit: fixed some mistakes. Damn phone.
Twilight Princess is my favorite Zelda game of all time, but....I'm not going to put down $50 for an HD port.
Not fixed 30 which is disappointing but will still be quality.
@Dakt I can't remember where, but it was under £30 this week somewhere, game only of course. It was a one day, or this week only deal
This review confirms what we've all seen in the videos. It's T minus 2 days for the US release...can't wait! I preordered it on Amazon weeks ago!
@RainbowGazelle It appears there are at least 2 of you. I'm not sure how it's happening. It's quite clear if one is looking at a 1080p video that isn't compressed too much with artifacts.
"A negative highlighted is that in exceptional cases, one being the foggy area in Faron Woods, there are actual frame dips not seen on the GameCube and Wii. "
That's actually highly disappointing. I hope they can come out with a patch to fix that. Re-releases really shouldn't be adding framerate drops.
(mind you, I'm not going to skip the game over this. but it is disappointing that they didn't do better)
Eh, it just drops from 30 to 29 FPS. And even then only in a few areas. Hardly a big deal if you ask me.
@GeminiSaint if that's it, then it's almost hardly worth mentioning.
@AyeHaley - I think it should be free, because I paid for it on Wii.
What do you think of that?
29FPS....OMG!!!!
You can't unsee it!
Everybody clutch your pearls and faint!
Too bad it's not a PS4 or XboxOne game...then it could dip frequently into single digits and no one would bat an eyelash.
Tap here to load 29 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...