
Super Mario Bros. 3 is an undoubted classic, and one of the finest platformers of all time. At times bizarre, always great to play, it's a testament to what could be achieved on the 8-bit NES.
Naturally it's an enduring topic for gamers of all types, and some like to really dive into the meaning of the colourful and bonkers platformer. The following video (hat tip to Kotaku) was published this week by Cameron Kunzelman and tackles the theory of "The Plumber's Dream"; Kunzelman is a developer himself. It's not an entirely original idea, as we're pretty sure we've heard similar things before, but it sure gives the game a creepy spin.
We think the video is being earnest and serious, but how about this comment in reply to it? Is this serious over-analysis or a bit of fun?
But how could you even dive into the significance of the living mounds without touching on 1. (one) the sentient mushroom/owl hybrids [aka goombas] are more indigenous to the land than the portly, blue-mustachio'd plumber [aka Mario]; 2. (two) when Mario partakes of Nature's bounty in the shape of the Fall Leaf he takes upon animal-like characteristics of the tanuki while RETAINING aspects of his human self. This clearly shows that it is Mario who is the interloper of the profane order. As a human, and thereby a split relation of himself at present unto him-self at-hand, Mario violently pillages Nature's Bounty in an attempt to become one with the sorrow of immediacy, in short Mario becomes a refusal of refuse which refuses to be re-fused.
Our theory is that... ah, let's just play the game instead.
[source youtube.com, via kotaku.com]
Comments 46
It's a great game. Why is it that Nintendo games seem friendly on the surface, but get creepier than most mature series when you look way below the surface and apply some weird logic.
Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz..........
What a waste of time...
I want my 5 minutes back!!!
@Nintendo_Ninja I guess it's their form of easter eggs and maybe a method for them to appeal to all ages.
Another day, another nonsensical Mario theory....
dont like it.i like the idea of making this kind of weird videos about games but i dont think this is a good one.
I like to laugh at these videos but this one is trying really hard to sound smart and it kinda reminds me of the annoying philosophy students at uni.
Is this just another take on the whole theatre theory?
Friday fodder.
Are you people stupid?
Its an obvious parody of lore videos for the souls series, and feels more aimed at vaatividja's lore series.
Jeez anyone should be able to see that!
ok geordie but ... it still sucks
Super Mario Bros 3 is one of the greats for sure but the weird theories are getting old. I admit Game Theory had some funny ones like Peach suffering from Stockholm Syndrome but enough already.
Well that was a waste of 5 minutes. I much prefer the "Mario 3 is a stage play" theory over this babbling doofus.
@geordie I guess we're stupid then. No clue what that is.
@Awesoman seriously? I know this is a Nintendo site, but does anyone play any other games? Check out Vaatis videos and you will see what I mean.
People are taking the video seriously as a theory on Mario lol
AVGN theory that this game is satanic is not only more sound but 100 Billion X more entertaining
roflol.
This is a spoof of the Demon's Souls, Dark Souls etc lore videos. Especially considering that right now the Dark souls community is kind of choosing sides between Vaatividja original content/ plagiarism accusations.
Guess you have to be in the know.
@Monado_III That one made sense to me.
Well, I for one didn't think it was that bad. Certainly more interesting than all the cosplay stuff!
@Awesoman
"I much prefer the "Mario 3 is a stage play" theory over this babbling doofus."
it's supposed to be a parody. (-_- )
@geordie Finally someone with actual sense. Even if this was a non ironic theory, people still shouldn't complaining about it. It is all for fun, it not meant to be taken seriously or as fact.
Reminds me of those videos that try to make My Neighbor Totoro seem sad and disturbing.
Could anyone tell me which game is he playing at the end of the video? 4:59.
i can hear matpat's mario timeline theory grinding to shreds....
TatsTopVideos, have way creepier theories...
@DarthNocturnal But hey that's just a theory, a lame theory
The Hills Have Eyes because: Mario is a megalomaniacal warlord; Luigi is the embodiment of (green with) Envy, always trying to (green) 1-up Mario; Bowser and the Koopas are the real good guys trying to defend the true native inhabitants of the Mushroom Kingdom, the Goombas; the Toads are all parasitic mushroom zombies (think The Last of Us) who are hive mind controlled by "Princess Toadstool" (an alias for Peach), who was installed by Mario to hold power; the kings of each nation (dubbed "Worlds" by Mario to strip them of identity) transformed themselves into animals to try to avoid being manipulated into harming their people (and avoid the mushroom zombie plague, which targets humans); and every single brick you break is a living person, powerless to defend themselves, who is trying a last resort tactic offered by Bowser's mystics to survive and be transformed back to normal later after the onslaught (Mario is a sick man).
Mass surveillance from The Big Brothers (Mario Bros version of 1984) has come to the Mushroom Kingdom, and only Bowser's plucky army has a chance to end it. We've been had, friends... Don't be fooled by surface appearances. Look deeper, and the truth will reveal itself.
Yeah, the person just zoomed in on a blurred out shot of Japanese text. Had nothing to do with anything the video was saying from what I could make out. The text was actually about childhood stuff, like wanting to write manga in middle school (from what I can make out, the kanji is a bit too blurry for me).
Here's hoping you guys can get someone who speaks/reads Japanese on staff someday~
Just play the freakin game and enjoy it there is no deep meaning to this game.
It kinda sounds like they were trying to pair up Bloodborne with Mario. Plumber's Dream? Hunter's Dream? The bushes and clouds being the souls of fallen Plumbers and the souls of fallen hunters are prevalent as well in those games.
Haha, nice idea!
@Jayvir But Bloodborne didn't invent the "hunter's dream" concept/image.
@PlywoodStick
Wake up sheeple, the loomynarty is confurmed
cue x-files
What nonsense!
Well, at least it's not that Game Theory tripe It was actually watchable. Good effort
@geordie
par·o·dy /ˈperədē/
noun
1. an imitation of the style of a particular writer, artist, or genre with deliberate exaggeration for comic effect.
Nothing about it is comical. My above post wasn't an exaggeration; I nearly fell asleep trying to watch it.
I just like to imagine that not only was Super Mario Bros 2 a dream, but all the Mario games are Shroom induced dreams that Mario had.
Well, okay then. Slightly creepy.
By the way, why didn't you guys cover all the fame the Super Mario Bros. movie was getting on YouTube? There's an Honest Trailer and a CinemaSins video for it now.
@Mona-Reggie "Loomy Narty"... Watch that be an organization in a future Paper Mario entry...
@allav866
It's ok if you didn't get the joke. ( ~ .^)
par·o·dy /ˈperədē/
noun
If you know anything about the Vaatividya Dark Souls videos then the above description is perfect for this Mario video. It was hilarious (and not meant to be taken seriously).
Heard this before, aswell as th eother than everything is a lie, and just a theater set up.
I don't care honestly, the game is good.
What the hell
I'm sorry. I could not watch the video. Guy was trying too hard.
Creepy. I will never look at those mounds, and clouds with eyes, the same way again...
The author got his games confused. SMB3 was legit. SMB2 was all a dream, possibly as an excuse for why the game wierd and not playing like Mario (because it wasn't).
wtf, this is just Bloodborne but Replacing all of the lore with Mario stuff.
When the writers of Ancient Aliens and the narrator of the Shrek is Love Shrek is life videos get together.
I never cease to be disappointed by Youtube.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...