@Malanta7
I respect your opinion of the game, what I don't respect is you making his opinion less than yours just because you don't agree with him.
There's nothing wrong with a person who doesn't like certain game genre to review one, a reviewer is supposed to give you 2 things: a technical side and his/her opinion, and he did both. If you liked what he said about the game then this game is for you, don't take his opinion into account. That's the point of a review.
No, I see no fault in someone that only drives motorbikes to review a car as long as review it as what it is a car, wether I agree with his opinion or not.
And yes, I would take your opinion as valid because it's what you truly felt about the game, the only reason I would not count it it's if you lied.
A review is more than just the score, if people get what the game is and you review it as it is, in this case a point and click game, even if your opinion is different from mine, then it's a good review.
I'm an open minded person, I respect all opinions as long as they're true to what the reviewer felt and they're respectful.
@Malanta7
Just because you think point and click games are meant to be slow and relaxed, doesn't mean they have to be for everyone or that everyone has to like that, this is his review and he's entitled to his opinion. If you're telling me people can't dislike things for what they're supposed to be, then you're wrong here.
Regarding the IGN review, I'm one of the few who was on the reviewer side, not because I agree with her, I don't, but because it was her opinion, if she didn't liked that there was an big emphasis on swimming, she had all the right to point it out as a flaw for her.
If you can't accept that a review is just another person's opinion and can't accept such opinion because it's different from yours, then there's something wrong with you. People who can't respect other persons opinion can't fit well into all of society, they only fit with those of the same mindset.
@Malanta7 I agree that the comparisons were unnecessary since they're not even the same type of game, but you can't say it ruins the whole review nor that people getting angry for the score and different opinion and saying he shouldn't be trusted it's ok.
To all the people getting angry for the review or score and are saying you don't trust the reviewer from now on, grow the [removed] up. It's his opinion, apparently it's not common sense that a review is just the opinion of the person reviewing the game. There will be times you will not agree with someone, doesn't mean you can't trust them, they're not lying to you. Just because your opinion are different doesn't the site is biased, your opinions are not worth more than his, the majority of opinions are no better than the minority.
@Razer
Nobody is saying that women with prosthetic limbs on the front lines is historically accurate, but you denying the prosthetic arms when you actually had no idea or the fact that you think you need super powers to outrun a tank when it's completely possible, shoes how little you actually know about WW2 facts.
Second, it's a video game, it is meant to entertain, period. You want historical accuracy? Go watch a documentary. Video games are meant to entertain and DICE is doing just that. If you can't understand that and think to be historically accurate is more important than to be fun, then video games are not for you.
@Rhaoulos Just because you don't like it doesn't mean nobody else does. You're on the minority group there. Don't call the developers lazy for doing an art style you don't like. If you're tired of them because you think they're overused, then hyper realistic graphics are even more.
@Razer Even if this game is not historically accurate, you not wanting to play it just because of it is moronic. If you don't play games to have fun, what do you even play them? For a person who wants his opinion about historically accurate games to be respected, you sure crap a lot over other unrealistic fps franchises. You want your opinion to be respected? Then respect others and you haven't earned that.
People could easily outrun tanks, they were not fast. They didn't because they can't abandon the territory.
Bio engineered woman? You mean the prosthetic arm from the 1940's? Yeah, if that is bio engineered, then people with current prosthetic arms are robots. For a person who wants their games to be accurate you don't know a lot about history yourself.
Comments 58
Re: Broken Sword 5: The Serpent's Curse - An Old-School Point-And-Click Adventure In Every Sense
@Octane
I don't remember ever writing an offensive word but if I did, I'm sorry.
Re: Broken Sword 5: The Serpent's Curse - An Old-School Point-And-Click Adventure In Every Sense
@Malanta7
I respect your opinion of the game, what I don't respect is you making his opinion less than yours just because you don't agree with him.
There's nothing wrong with a person who doesn't like certain game genre to review one, a reviewer is supposed to give you 2 things: a technical side and his/her opinion, and he did both. If you liked what he said about the game then this game is for you, don't take his opinion into account. That's the point of a review.
No, I see no fault in someone that only drives motorbikes to review a car as long as review it as what it is a car, wether I agree with his opinion or not.
And yes, I would take your opinion as valid because it's what you truly felt about the game, the only reason I would not count it it's if you lied.
A review is more than just the score, if people get what the game is and you review it as it is, in this case a point and click game, even if your opinion is different from mine, then it's a good review.
I'm an open minded person, I respect all opinions as long as they're true to what the reviewer felt and they're respectful.
Re: Broken Sword 5: The Serpent's Curse - An Old-School Point-And-Click Adventure In Every Sense
@Malanta7
Just because you think point and click games are meant to be slow and relaxed, doesn't mean they have to be for everyone or that everyone has to like that, this is his review and he's entitled to his opinion. If you're telling me people can't dislike things for what they're supposed to be, then you're wrong here.
Regarding the IGN review, I'm one of the few who was on the reviewer side, not because I agree with her, I don't, but because it was her opinion, if she didn't liked that there was an big emphasis on swimming, she had all the right to point it out as a flaw for her.
If you can't accept that a review is just another person's opinion and can't accept such opinion because it's different from yours, then there's something wrong with you. People who can't respect other persons opinion can't fit well into all of society, they only fit with those of the same mindset.
Re: Broken Sword 5: The Serpent's Curse - An Old-School Point-And-Click Adventure In Every Sense
@Malanta7
I agree that the comparisons were unnecessary since they're not even the same type of game, but you can't say it ruins the whole review nor that people getting angry for the score and different opinion and saying he shouldn't be trusted it's ok.
Re: Broken Sword 5: The Serpent's Curse - An Old-School Point-And-Click Adventure In Every Sense
To all the people getting angry for the review or score and are saying you don't trust the reviewer from now on, grow the [removed] up. It's his opinion, apparently it's not common sense that a review is just the opinion of the person reviewing the game. There will be times you will not agree with someone, doesn't mean you can't trust them, they're not lying to you. Just because your opinion are different doesn't the site is biased, your opinions are not worth more than his, the majority of opinions are no better than the minority.
Re: EGX 2018 Game Listing Reveals That Oddworld: Stranger's Wrath Is Headed To Switch
@Razer
Nobody is saying that women with prosthetic limbs on the front lines is historically accurate, but you denying the prosthetic arms when you actually had no idea or the fact that you think you need super powers to outrun a tank when it's completely possible, shoes how little you actually know about WW2 facts.
Second, it's a video game, it is meant to entertain, period. You want historical accuracy? Go watch a documentary. Video games are meant to entertain and DICE is doing just that. If you can't understand that and think to be historically accurate is more important than to be fun, then video games are not for you.
Re: The Darkside Detective: Season 2 Will Bring Another Dose Of Comedy Adventure To Switch
@Rhaoulos
Just because you don't like it doesn't mean nobody else does. You're on the minority group there. Don't call the developers lazy for doing an art style you don't like. If you're tired of them because you think they're overused, then hyper realistic graphics are even more.
Re: EGX 2018 Game Listing Reveals That Oddworld: Stranger's Wrath Is Headed To Switch
@Razer
Even if this game is not historically accurate, you not wanting to play it just because of it is moronic. If you don't play games to have fun, what do you even play them?
For a person who wants his opinion about historically accurate games to be respected, you sure crap a lot over other unrealistic fps franchises. You want your opinion to be respected? Then respect others and you haven't earned that.
People could easily outrun tanks, they were not fast. They didn't because they can't abandon the territory.
Bio engineered woman? You mean the prosthetic arm from the 1940's? Yeah, if that is bio engineered, then people with current prosthetic arms are robots. For a person who wants their games to be accurate you don't know a lot about history yourself.