There has been a surprising amount of pool-based games released onto the Nintendo eShop as of late, hasn’t there? We have the simply named Pool, which looks to be giving Tennis a run for its money in the award for most generic title of 2018, as well as Premium Pool Arena that looks to add a fair amount of customisation into the mix. Next up we have Pool Billiard, a game that unfortunately is sure to sink to the depths of the digital store in no time at all. And with good reason, because this is an incredibly barebones experience that you’ll grow bored of very, very quickly.
Upon booting up the game, you’re not exactly going to be spoiled for choice when it comes to choosing what to play first. You can pick between either the traditional Eight-ball Pool or the more competitive focused Nine-ball Pool, and then it’s on to the match. You can compete against the AI, your friend using the two Joy-Cons, or in a three-round tournament. There are six different opponents to play against, all of varying skill, but that’s where any sort of diversity begins and ends.
There just isn’t anywhere near enough content here to back up the asking price. You’ll very quickly tire of playing against the computer, and the tournament mode doesn’t fare much better. It advertises itself as a competition that will take you to billiard halls all over the world, but in practise it is anything but. It’s all well and good calling it the Tokyo Cup or the Hong Kong Cup, but at least put in a bit of effort to make it seem like you’re actually there. Every single environment looks exactly the same, and thus you’re actually just playing the same game of Pool over and over again in one dreary room.
There’s not even any online functionality either, meaning you’re limited to playing against what the title itself serves up, or a friend you can somehow convince to play a match with you. There are high scores attached to each style of game, but with no multiplayer, you’re only competing against yourself.
The literal games of pool you’ll play yourself are fine. Guide lines can aid you when taking shots, while you’ll get a slow-motion replay of every ball you pot. The amount of power you put into each shot is governed by the R button, and then you can release it by pressing A. If the way we’re talking about all this sounds monotonous, it’s because that’s exactly what Pool Billiard is. The experience is completely by the numbers with so little to be excited about, and so what should be an entertaining experience quickly becomes a borefest. The tournament mode could maybe stretch your play time to around two hours, but you won’t have much fun doing it.
The tiniest of silver linings comes in the form of the game’s motion controls using the Joy-Con controllers. Pulling back the controller with your arm and letting go helps to resemble a real life cue, and it works well in motion. Obviously, it can’t replicate the act of lying on the table and taking aim with that cue, but it gets the power down. This is a neat little feature that deserves to be expanded upon in a much better game.
Conclusion
Pool Billiard has to be one of the dullest experiences we’ve come across on Nintendo Switch so far. It functions in that it offers multiple games of pool to play, but it has nothing to serve up outside of that. This could have been somewhat alleviated by online functionality, but with no multiplayer in sight outside of a local match, you’re going to very quickly tire of playing against the AI. We strongly recommend waiting for a better pool experience to take on the go.
Comments 26
Without me.
At least it has an equally dull name to match.
They should have called it Dulliards.
Uhuuhuhuhuhuhhuhuhhuh!!!
Day one buy! Review has convinced me I need this
The developer’s name sounds oh so suitable.
My thoughts are here.
https://socoder.net/?GotoPost=65688
I’m now waiting on that third Switch-Pool to show up.
The pool game in Wii Play had better graphics.
I already got a better version of this game, it's down on my basement next to my very own vending machine.
Let's port Cue Club 2 and call it a day.
Well, tbh the first was good too.
The 3 games of Pool announced and released over 3 weeks aren't good at all. None of them have online multiplayer. There's an opportunity for someone to put out a competent game of Pool. Everyone loves Pool.
These pool games are poor, they are on the b list of mobile games on phones...that’s how bad they are.
whos up for a mean game of pocket pool?
The pool table at my aunt's is better than this. The best part? It's played in 3D!
Which (if any) of the pool games are made by the folk who made the chess game (that is rather good!)
@GrailUK Ripstone published Pure Chess on the Wii U. It was developed by Voofoo Studios. Ripstone also published Chess Ultra on the Switch. They made Pure Pool.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bfS1I71g4vI
It's a decent game by all accounts and crucially it has online multiplayer amongst other modes. It's €10 on Steam and €5 on PS4 at the minute. I'm sure Ripstone will be looking into releasing it on Switch.
I didn't think it was that bad, but the CPUs do get annoying as the tournament mode goes on.
I still am going to point to Pool Paradise on GameCube. Launched for $20 brand new (of course it had to be physical), had a variety of environmental themes, unlockable cues etc and chillax music. No reason at all to be this lazy, boring and bland.
@SLIGEACH_EIRE Thank you for that mate. So many Pool games I couldn't keep up. But I would gladly support Ripstone.
@RETRO_J That's why a demo is worth a thousand words.
Trying the game before buying is better than any reviews.
This game would have been solid. On the NES.
I wish reviewers could just stick to facts and leave out opinions.
I’ll play Billiards on Super Monkey Ball instead.
The version of this they had on the wii (can’t remember its title) had online... why not here?
@RETRO_J I must agree that this review seems rushed and the reviewer apparently didn't actually play it in certain ways (maybe he's a "gamer" who just doesn't want to bother with games that don't involve blowing stuff up).
It starts off with a lie about there being only 9-Ball and 8-Ball available. There's no mention of the game of Rotation, nor the one-player "Basic Game" and how it works. Also, the description of the motion control is incorrect, so apparently the reviewer never actually used it. Unfortunately, you don't actually pull back; you just shove your arm forward in lieu of a button press. The shot power is still determined by the R button. That was quite disappointing, and I sometimes find myself thrusting my arm forward hard to make a powerful shot, forgetting that power is determined only by how long I hold down the R button before moving my arm.
(And the HD rumble is practically nonexistent. Every 10 balls or so that sink, you get a little vibration. It does not "feel like you're holding the cue" as advertised.)
However, the fact that you can put spin on the cue ball, and the fact that players can handicap themselves with shorter guide lines, are essential points that should be mentioned in a game review. It makes it easier for players of mixed skill to have a competitive game. The three available view modes also are absolutely necessary to mention in a sports game review.
Despite the disappointing aspects I mentioned, I find the game quite enjoyable and would recommend it given the low price point.
I love pool but don’t have room for a pool table, so instead I bought this. I like how you can play with the buttons when your on the go or just don’t want to move;/ but if I’m in the mood for a realistic pool game, I lay my switch flat on my dining table, and I lean on the table just like you would for real pool it really feels close to pool without have a real pool table. If I was rating it I would rate 7-8 out of 10.
@Hylian_Ticipated I loved Pool Paradise. I put many an hour into that game. Might have to go dig it out soon. Unless I can find a decent one on Switch to go with for now
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...