We can’t help but feel sorry for Poi: Explorer Edition. As a 3D platformer, releasing in the same week as Super Mario Odyssey on Switch must be incredibly disheartening; the latter has been receiving praise left, right, and centre – and will likely be slotted firmly into many players’ consoles as we speak – leaving little room for any attention to be given to the former. Our time with Poi has been a real treat, though, so - whilst you may have another platforming great on the mind at the moment - you may want to give this one a whirl too.
Comparisons have been made between Poi and various Mario titles – especially Super Mario 64. This writer would argue that it has a stronger Super Mario Sunshine vibe, however; one of the earlier worlds even consists of windmills and ropes to walk along! There are two main reasons for why these comparisons are regularly made – firstly, the platforming gameplay (which we’ll get to later) and, secondly, the structure and core format of the game itself. Seeing the game’s layout gave us a little boost of warm, nostalgic feelings that were very welcome indeed.
Your task is to collect Explorer Medallions – there are over 100 of them in total – and these are scattered around various ‘worlds’ and can also be obtained by completing challenges. You can jump into these worlds from a hub-like area and, when you do, you’ll be asked to select a chapter. Each chapter directs you towards a Medallion but, should you stumble across a Medallion from a later chapter first, you can grab that one instead. On top of this each world contains coins, fossils, locations, and gears to find – all of which can result in more Medallions - and there are lots of minigames and challenges to complete that will net you even more.
The gameplay itself works exactly as you might expect; the basic idea is to run around in 3D worlds, jumping across platforms (double jumps and wall jumps included) or on top of enemies to defeat them, collecting everything you can get your hands on. At first, the jumping felt incredibly ‘floaty’ to us – almost too imprecise for any solid platforming gameplay – but after some time had passed we really managed to get to grips with things and it eventually allows for some very fast, exciting movement. There are times where you might feel your character get away from you a little - causing the odd flash of annoyance – but, for the most part, everything begins to fit into place. You can also roll into enemies to temporarily stun them and other mechanics are eventually introduced such as hanging on to mesh-like gates and flying with the help of a parasail.
For the first few hours you are bombarded with new things to see and do – your hub area is a flying ship and, as you collect more and more Medallions, numerous other characters start to appear in the sky around you. These offer slightly different experiences should you want a break from the main game’s chapters; some are minigames, some are challenges, and some will keep track of your collectables and offer Medallions for your hard work. What starts as a very open, sparse hub-world quickly becomes incredibly populated with various little areas to visit and, largely thanks to this fact, the game really does feel like an adventure.
As you spend more time with the game you’ll realise that whilst it feels like it’s overflowing with content – and in some areas it truly is – several things are often repeated, which is a slight shame. For example, there are a couple of chapters that are exactly the same in each world (collect 100 coins, and collect seven keys) and, whilst these are fun at first, you’ll eventually get tired of completing the same tasks. As a complete counter argument to this, though, some of the game’s chapters are certainly good fun and are unique to each area. Boss fights stand out as highlights and Medallions that are obtained by pure platforming fun are always a blast to collect.
The ‘Explorer Edition’ of the game is exclusive to Nintendo Switch and adds a few, pleasing, little touches. There is an unlockable soundtrack and a selection of art pieces from the game for you to look through at your own leisure – the accompanying artwork (which can also be seen on loading screens) features some really pretty pieces and is well worth a look through. There are also costumes and hats for you to wear which are new to this version and, pleasingly, the game has been adapted to work with the Switch’s unique features as both Joy-Con motion control (which is completely optional) and HD Rumble are supported.
Conclusion
Whilst it could never compete with the likes of Super Mario Odyssey, Poi: Explorer Edition is a great platforming adventure in its own right. Anyone who enjoys a good ‘collect-a-thon’ will be in Heaven with this game – the Medallions are great fun to work towards and finding every single extra collectable will take some considerable time and effort. If you enjoy games of this genre, and have the means to do so, we’d definitely recommend giving Poi a go and help it to be noticed in what must be one of the cruellest release windows ever. It deserves to be played.
Comments 50
If "bad timing" is ever examined in textbooks Poi's release date will be the first example cited.
Played this on Steam. Quite liked it but most people, including myself, already got Odyssey to scratch the 3D platformer itch. Plus, I‘d rather give Yooka-Laylee a second chance than double-dipping on Poi.
Yet another indie game with an over inflated digital price to cater to those who want a physical version. Everytime there is a physical release for indie games this happens,this is a $14.99 title. If this is the route the indies wish to take then they won't be getting any sales from me and I hope other digital buyers do the same. It is a new trend that needs to be nipped in the bud and the only way it'll happen is if it hits their profits. Only then will something be done about it.
Maybe I'll check it out in the future. Certainly a case of unfortunate timing.
@OorWullie It's nice for those of us who prefer physical copies though. What we need is for Nintendo to change their pricing policy on the matter.
Wishlisted it!
Whoever comes up with these release dates for games?The planning is terrible.
Like nearly everyone who has a switch I bought Mario day one but am very interested in this one and although my backlog is ridiculous I may pick this up in the next few days to support them.
@BenAV It is and I don't mean to sound like I've got anything against those who want a physical version but it's not fair for digital buyers to be forced to pay double the price. Before the Switch came along, games like this were digital only, now all of a sudden loads of indies are coming with physical releases, pushing the price up considerably .I can't blame the indies, they're seeing the demand from Switch owners for physical releases as a way to charge more for their game. If Nintendo change their pricing policy then I doubt we'll see so many physical indie games.
It’s a great game and deserves attention. I just don’t understand what they were smoking releasing days from Mario Odyssey. Should have been at least a month before or after...oh well, 6 hours playing Mario last night but regardless I’m still gonna grab Poi. Retail copy of course! 😉
I bought this and plan to play it before Odyssey. I know I'm in a minority, but it looks charming. Sure, compared to Mario, its going to be buried due to being released way too close, but I personally will enjoy both of these titles.
@OorWullie
I agree with that. That's why I opted to get the physical version. If the digital was 15 like on other platforms I would have bought it at that price point, but considering I get discounts on physical games I decided that was the best option for this game for me.
I do think its a bad trend, and I hope it changes somewhere soon down the line. Even with bonus content it doesn't warrant a 15 dollar increase.
@OorWullie I’m glad we’re seeing a lot of indie games going retail. At least we all have a choice and mine is retail always first. It Also gives the Switch a better retail presence in the stores. As far as pricing goes I totally agree with you but I’ve scored very cheap games both ways so it depends...and Nintendo (I doubt) would never put a price restriction on what another company wants to charge for its games. If they tried that I’m sure they’d all run for the hills! Lol
Added to the Wishlist for after Odyssey.... And LA Noire, and DOOM... Then Poi! Maybe...
Will buy eventually. Hopefully I can find the retail version.
Not bad.
I have pre-ordered Poi : Explorer Edition since last week.
Hopefully it will come as soon as possible.
@justin233
Hello.
You can find the retail version from playasia.com too.
https://www.play-asia.com/poi-explorer-edition/13/70bjvt
This whole situation makes me so sad. This game is so charming and enjoyable but it'll never get the acknowledgement or sales it deserves. My copy arrived Thursday night and I got to play a few hours before Odyssey arrived and I was impressed. But now it'll sit unattended for a few weeks while I 100% Mario Odyssey.
I love games like this and the fact that there's a physical edition means I'll probably have to pick it up at some point.
digital prices definitely do leave something to be desired.
i'm so used to steam's deep discounts the the console prices are just insane imo. every one of them; not just nintendo.
i guess it just is what it is. i do hope N starts discounting stuff more. i own 1 physical game (botw) and the rest are digital. i hate swapping carts even though it's kinda charming in 2017.
odysee will be the next cart i buy (used and at a discount).
This game looks like it could be made on Roblox. NO SALE! 🔨
Wasn't planning to get this, but after reading this review I just ordered from BestBuy for the physical version. Came to $23.99 with 6% back via CC and 4% back via double reward points. So effectively $21.59
Not bad
Lovely game. I doesn't stand a candle when compared with Odyssey but a good game in it's own right. Bought it digital, if only to reward the developers for not making another pixelated 2D platformer.
If it had arrived a month before, this could have sold a lot of copies, but now it will probably be lost in the crowd and the aftermath of Odyssey. Still, hoping they make money off the game...
Glad to hear it's still great though. I'll get this after finishing Odyssey.
I'll have to check this game out at some point! Thanks for the review.
Maybe if it goes on sale...
Looking forward to this. But £30 - not sure on that. May have to wait for a sale. I don't like doing that but I think this price point is a bit off. £19.99 and I'll be all over it.
Wanted to buy it as my Mario Odyssey copy didn't arrive, but
a) I can't find it on the German eShop and
b) 30€ is just too much. I would have paid 15€ because I'm craving for a fun platformer. The funny thing is I'm not sure I need this game anymore after Mario Odyssey has arrived.
Better then I expected. For those who can't afford odyssey at the moment.
Is there any content difference to the PS4 version (apart from soundtrack, art and costumes) I love a 3D platformer and this seems to have passed me by. With the price difference ill go for the PS4 release though...
This is really good, nice addition to my collection.
I'm not convinced by this review. I'd like a demo to get a better feel for how the characters handle and the overall vibe.
How does this compare to FreezeMe? I didn’t really like that one and this looks to be almost exactly the same as that game.
@gcunit I'm not surprised; it's been obvious for quite some time that NintendoLife reviews are overgenerous and the scores inflated.
@Steel76 It reminds me of Super Mario 3D Land, down to the color palette.
@JHDK true. I'll still buy it but not now since Odyssey.
Good to know I'll have options. Sometimes one or two games isn't enough to scratch that collect-a-thon itch.
When you put this game side by side with A Hat in Time, this game looks less interesting now as a indie 3D platformer game. Ehh maybe I'll still get it sometime down the road.
@OorWullie Nintendo's pricing policies have nothing to with it being $30. Nintendo has always allowed budget retail pricing. It's Alliance Digital Media's fault for thinking they could sell a game like this for $30 instead of the much more reasonable $20 for which the other indie retail games are asking
However, I shouldn't have needed to visit Nintendo's official website to find out the price. Hey Nintendo Life, why isn't the price listed on the Game Overview page or the side info panel? For that matter, why don't you ever list the game ratings?
So how does the camera work? That important detail should always be mentioned in a review for any 3D platformer.
It's hete already? I backed this way back when it was announced and still planned for Wii U. Sadly, that never happened, and as I don't own a gaming PC I thought I'd never get to play it. Until it was announced for Switch! But I had no idea it would be this soon, awesome! Although whoever planned the release date for this game must be been smoking something pretty strong... :'D
@Wazeddie22 Fellow Lunar fan shares my sentiments, I see! If I get this game, it sure as hell won’t be for a while yet, long after I finish Odyssey.
@daveh30 "Then Poi!"
This made me chuckle,because poi means then in italian.
@BulbasaurusRex - The camera handles comparably to that of later PS4 games. Rigid, but manageable.
Just had the game for Switch for a few days before Odyssey. And really, the game is charming in its own right.
@Paraka OK, but HOW does the camera work? Is it automatic with manual adjustments, fixed angles, completely manual (ugh!), or what?
EDIT: Having seen gameplay videos on Youtube, there is an automatic camera with manual adjustments, or you can play with a fully manual camera. I don't know why anyone would want to turn off the automatic camera, but the option is there. Anyway, now I can safely add the game my future Switch Wishlist (but only worth it during a big sale)...
I ended up ordering a physical copy after I saw it was available.... Its gonna stay sealed on the shelf for a while though. Got tons more Mario to play, then Doom, and LA Noire, and RE... Might get to Poi on my Christmas vacation, depending on the Zelda DLC release date. Definitely a different story than the Wii U's first yearn
Gonna pass, this looks boring.
I received the physical copy (NA) shipped from Best Buy on the 26th. Did they break release date? I'm confused, LOL.
@OorWullie,
I totally agree! By the way: A download on a Nintendo device should NEVER cost more then versions on other systems (Steam, PS4)!!
@justin233 Still eventually, or did you buy it? 😄
Played it on Xbox. Great little game. Took about 9 hours and a half to 100%. Jumping and controlling the character are great. Dashing needs work but it works. Every few levels, there is something that appears or happens so there are side quests and challenges to do with some secrets to find.
Levels are fine. Need some more details with some improved graphics here and there. Levels could be bigger too.
Controls are fine and you can zoom in and out, zoom to shoulder view, reset camera, run by holding the roll button, etc.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...