
Last year, Japanese Rail Sim 3D Journey in Suburbs #1 came out on the eShop, a game that centered around the concept of being a real life train conductor in Japan. It wasn't very well-received here, but the title gave away the fact there would inevitably be at least one sequel. One would think that Sonic Powered Co. would've learned from the mistakes it made in Japanese Rail Sim 3D Journey in Suburbs #1, but unfortunately the snappily named Japanese Rail Sim 3D Journey in Suburbs #1 Vol. 2 has rectified none of the problems of its predecessor.
The premise sees players controlling a train as it rolls along a line in the Gifu prefecture of the Japanese countryside, while actual footage scrolls by on the upper screen. The problem with this stems not from the idea of it, but the way that it's actually played out. Simply put, the game fails to deliver - in a satisfactory way - what it promises, giving players little reason to invest much time in it.

For one thing, the player actually has very little input into what happens on screen. You can set or release the brake and there is a grand total of five speed settings, but beyond that all you can do is sit and wait. It proves a little troublesome at first to figure out how the train moves and when to brake or accelerate, yet once the player gets the feel for it the experience tanks and becomes mind numbingly dull. Perhaps it could be made more exciting if there were more variables to juggle, but simply adjusting a train's speed does not make for a terribly compelling experience.
This is worsened by the low quality and generally disappointing footage shown on the top screen. Perhaps the two-bit gameplay could be overlooked if the footage up top was something nice to look at or visually stimulating, but the actual result is less than ideal. The default view keeps the action relegated to a laughably small window in the middle of the screen, bordered by a half-baked image of the cabin's interior. Rooting around with some settings gets rid of the cabin view and blows up the footage to nearly the whole screen, but here it's revealed why the footage is defaulted to such a small view.

The image quality is quite poor and blurry, making it difficult to discern much detail in what you're looking at. Worse yet, there are issues with framerate and the image occasionally stutters or jumps. Considering that this is one of the main selling points of the game, one would think more attention would have been paid to capturing some good footage of Japan, but the final product seems lazy.
In terms of replayability, there's a surprising amount of library content to be unlocked. After pulling into each station you're graded based on how smoothly you drove, whether you stopped at the right point, whether you paid attention to speed limit and so on. Based on this grade you can receive short blurbs that discuss something about the architectural, geographical or historical aspects of the area. These are actually interesting, but they aren't quite worth sitting through the monotony of each stage to obtain.
Conclusion
All told, Japanese Rail Sim 3D Journey in Suburbs #1 Vol. 2 is a disappointing and uninteresting experience. While the idea behind it is solid enough, the execution is so poor that we couldn't recommend this to anyone. The trivia included is interesting enough, but it certainly does not compensate for the mindless gameplay and poor camera quality. Do yourself a favour and don't get on this train.
Comments 37
A trainwreck, then.
Consider my interest permanently derailed.
In Japan, "Journey to Suburbs" is just one game. They split it up here because I guess they figured it was a huge enough risk as it is to put out 25% of a game like this.
Anyway, I thought the other one (Journey to Kyoto), which Nintendolife also didn't like, was way better. But I'm like that, and these games are the literal definition of niche. Basically, these aren't bad games necessarily, but this review is fair. You already know whether or not you're going to take this journey.
I always wondered why the graphics in this looked so grainy and terrible. It looks like some of the demo videos from the original 3DS eShop games that started to appear. Plus these are $20 a piece, def too expensive. Stupid to not put them all together here and is even less reason to want them.
I enjoyed these when I played the demo. Perhaps if someone made a game like this with the train sim stuff but then mixed it with another genre to cover for the repetition and boringness?
I'll stick with Thomas the Tank Engine & Friends on the Super Nintendo, thank you very much. "START THOMAS."
I wonder if trainz simulator will ever appear on wii u
If they put it on sale for a quid like the first one i'll buy it.
I downloaded and played a demo on one of the games and the biggest issue for me was the very choppy framerate. It's impressive that the game was using the 3D for the FMV, but I guess the framerate was the trade off. I will say that it was kind of neat to be transported to another country (Japan) and see the sights through the train. There is a specific niche market they are targeting here and I'm guessing that for people who like trains, you could probably add 3-4 points to the score for them.
I guess I won't be Choo Choo choosing this.
The name alone is ALMOST enough of a reason to buy this game.
They're cool games for people into trains and this tourism/edutainment sort of stuff. I wish the eshop had more titles like the superb Louvre multimedia.
@The__Goomba And there's a picture of a train!
@World What's the difference between these ones and the first game that came out?
ALL ABO... oh
This is a real shame - as I really wanted this to be brilliant! :/
@NinChocolate Literally nothing except stations. #2, #3, #4 are part of the original Suburbs release in Japan too, so they share the same interface, path to unlocking things, and difficulty levels. I think there's a demo of #1 on the eShop, which will tell you if any of the other ones are for you!
(Journey to Kyoto, the other train game that came out between Suburbs #1 and #2-#4 is a completely different game, though. Even the controls are different!)
Yes, avoiding this one...it's from the wrong side of the tracks..
@World I liked Journey to Kyoto. What is the difference with the controls?
Europe has not Journey to Suburbs.
@FarsanBaloo I haven't played Suburbs in a while, but the "max speed" control in Kyoto is the same as the normal speed control in Suburbs? There's also a coast option in Suburbs, which I don't think is in Kyoto (from what I can tell). They're minor differences, but they threw me off the first time I played Kyoto!
(I didn't realize Europe didn't get Suburbs! Kyoto is overall a much better game, so you're not missing out unless you're a huge fan of train driving games and always want more!)
I'm proud of the lameness of your puns, fellow NLers.
I want a trainwreck sim where the more damage done and casualties to property and passengers and cargo earns more points. Im not kidding this would be awesome!!!
@AlexSora89
...well, you engineered it..
@SH007ME These train puns are really running out of steam...
@MitchVogel
Ha ha, yep, I think it's the end of the line for this one..
@SH007ME
@MitchVogel
This comment section is off the rails... DAMMIT
@AlexSora89
..uh huh, this game took a real kick in the Caboose..
I'm sorry I would rate these games a 6. The graphics could be better like the Kyoto release. But the driving is delightful and gets very hard when you go up in difficulty. I expected bad reviews since nintendolife has never rated them very well. If you look at players ratings on the Eshop they get a 4 and a half star rating. They are not perfect except for the Kyoto version which is beautiful and smooth. But they are fun if you ever wanted to drive a train. I wish they had released the cartridge here I would have bought that. I'm still short Volume 3 and 4 but plan to get those soon
@Priceless_Spork kinda like Gomez from the old Adams family used to crash his trains and blow them up? Hilarious
@Hey-Cha-La yeah I like them myself and would rate the volumes a 6. The Kyoto release I would rate a 9. It's extremely smooth and looks great. My issue with the Kyoto version is that the train stations are not very far apart. I think Volume 2 has 2 stations that are 3 kilometers apart. A really nice cruise on the train
@SH007ME I think it'd be a real shame to get railroaded into playing it.
Much of the nuances during play come from the lay of the track. There is more to it than just release the brake and set a speed. Sure you need to like the train sim theme but if you do this is a nice game/sim to have.
My main gripe with this 'review' is this. This game does not simulate being a conductor. Even compensating for American English it does nor make sense. Wikipedia defines conductor as follows:
A conductor (American and Canadian English) or guard (Commonwealth English) is a train crew member responsible for operational and safety duties that do not involve actual operation of the train.
@MitchVogel Congratulations for merely repeating the same pun comment #16 had already done before.
@MitchVogel
I know, you poor reviewers, it's probably hard not to blow your stack on a game like this..
@Windy
Oh, thanks for letting me know! I will definitely check out the Kyoto chapter.
What is up with these super-long names? We had that PoPoLoCrois: A Fable of Gardening Fairytale Adventure Story and now this.
I mean, how many volumes until we get to #2? Sheesh.
@Boshar I agree with you. But Nintendolife has been nototious for giving these sims poor ratings while other websites have rated them 3 points higher. Even the Kyoto version which is beautiful got a poor rating here. Well not poor but a 6 if I remember correctly. 6 isnt a bd rating but after playing Kyoto it is to me. Also dont forget Nintendolife rated Race for the Line , a racing game I consider to be the worst ever made a 6. Reviewing games is not a perfect situation. We all have different tastes. However I dont see 10 percent of people giving race to line more than a 4. The rest would be lower
@Hey-Cha-La there is a demo for Kyoto. I would suggest downloading the original volume 1 demo then download the kyoto demo I think you will agree as far as cleaning up the game its like night and day. Haha kyoto has a night and daytime option
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...