If you've played Animal Crossing: New Horizons, you won't need us to explain just how common - and infuriating - the pesky sea bass can feel. It's everywhere, standing between you and the more rare and desirable alternatives at every corner, and each time you catch one, you're greeted with the line, "I caught a sea bass! No, wait - it's at least a C+!"
Having to read that one line over and over again has driven players mad; popular YouTube channel Girlfriend Reviews actually went as far as creating a Billie Eilish parody called 'Bass Guy' to demonstrate just how often you can stumble across them.
As it happens, the joke's author himself admits that even he's tired of seeing it. In a thread posted to Twitter, Nintendo's Rob Heiret has told us how the joke was put together, explaining that the team knew players would be forced to see it again and again and how that thought affected its creation. Here's what he had to say:
"If you've played the game, you're tired of the sea bass joke. I get it. *I'M* tired of the sea bass joke, and I wrote it. But here's a secret about the sea bass joke: It was originally "I caught a sea bass! Well...maybe a C- bass...)
And when we were workshopping the fish jokes, someone pointed out that, as a joke people were going to see many, many times, generally along with disappointment they didn't catch something better, maybe it would be better to spin it positive. Make it a C+ instead.
From a comedy-mechanics perspective, it's the same joke, relying on the homophones "sea" and "C" to change how you perceive the description of the animal (and, let's be honest, it would work better as a verbal joke than it does in print, but that fish has sailed).
Anyway, my point is, we were doing our very best, down to details you might not have considered, to make this the most positive, comforting, funny game we could. And I know the dev team was doing the same."
So, next time you find yourself getting annoyed at the "it's at least a C+!" joke, spare a thought for the poor localisation team who had to come up with something, knowing that whatever they wrote would start to grate eventually no matter how good it was.
For what it's worth, we think the fish and bug puns are pretty great!
[source twitter.com]
Comments 58
Idk, the original idea feels a lot like it understands the pain. The new one feels like it's mocking me.
Would be nice if there was some variation. The Squid gets three references to Splatoon, but the others only get one. Hey ho, hardly an important thing ^_^
EDIT: 2 x Splatoon references, 1 x Mario reference
Shouldn't make fish jokes just for the halibut.
Couldn't really care less about the joke either way. Spawn rate for sea bass is way too high for any joke to work. Problem is the spawn rate not the joke.
It works because the joke augments the groan of catching a sea bass. It's perfect.
I thought the squid was a reference to Mario?
guy should be ashamed of that joke even if it was for a good fish. it's just SO bad. I hope other languages don't have to deal with such cringe
Just doesn't work very well IMO whichever way they spin it, because my first thought is that the + is meant to replace the 'bass', so I'm scratching my head wondering how 'bass' and 'plus' are meant to be associated.
Maybe they can still add in a few more Bass jokes in the next update, and the let the game randomize them, to surprise people. ^^
@Manah
Very true. Forced positivity can be dangerous to the general sense of connection. Like when when someone tells you you ought to smile more.
There's a time and a plaice for fish based puns.
@sikthvash @TryToBeHopeful "I had an inkling I might" references Splatoon, and "do they not actually bloop" references Mario. I think the last one was "off the hook" or something and Im not sure where that is from. I agree though, having 3 different comments for each catch... or at least the more common catches... would have made the jokes a little less redundant.
Why not have the little blurb appear the first time you catch that particular thing for the day, and then that's it until the following day.
That'd be so much better.
Why would you admit that you wrote that!? Dangerous idea...
Well why does it have to come up every time? The repetition is a bit ridiculous in the game. It's just bad design on the developer's part.
I mean, he's doing puns for a Japanese game localization. Such people deserve early retirement with lifetime bonuses, discounts and probably mass salutations on the streets. And I'm only being half humorous here at most.
@Murbs @Franklin These are fintastic. Maybe we should scale back the fish puns though? Or make them ofishall? I betta stop... I just cod not resist the opportunaty...
@LavaTwilight Yeh, Off the Hook is from Splatoon 2 - it's the group formed by Pearl & Marina. For some reason my pre-caffeinated brain thought there was another Splatoon reference, but as you say it's to do with Blooper from Mario ^_^
@gcunit Eaxctly what I thought!
Hey, don't you know? It's all about the "Bass".
it took me a bit too long to get the joke, maybe they could replace it with another dry joke every now and then, I'm sure someone could come up with another one
They definitely should have gone with a joke that played off of there abundance like haven’t I seen you before?
I am not sure how much Nintendo is using the repeated "showcasing" of your character for every item you get as a purposeful speed bump so we don't play our way through the material too fast for their taste/DLC schedule.
Best one from family fortunes. Question . . . Name a way to cook fish? . . . . . . Answer . . . . . . . Cod! X x x x
It's weird this is the thing you focus on from that twitter thread for an article and not the fact that the localizer is talking about how the small moments that happen in Animal Crossing is there to provide comfort and that he was humbled that the game has become important to so many people. That some people would even celebrate birthdays with friends, or make a place for their mother's grave in their town to visit, because they couldn't visit the real grave on Mother's Day because of quarantine.
But hey no yeah go with the sea bass part.
I don't really mind the puns. And I wouldn't even be opposed to seeing a randomized "collection" of puns whenever I catch a fish. Currently it's a bit repetitive. Even though I really like most of them.
I'm more worried that the poor man felt the need to explain the joke.
Yeah the jokes can get monotonous, I caught the mermaid today and it says:
wow! no wonder the sea is so clean!
I haven't gone fishing for a specific fish in a while (working on my village) but that joke gets old fast.
I’ve never understood this with computer games - they put all this work into a game, it’s music and art and then can’t be bothered to put a few more lines of text in to avoid text repetition. Animal crossing is terrible for it, but it’s a common problem in gaming in general.
I could write say, at least three pun-style responses for all the fish within a days work easy. Why can’t Nintendo?
Can you imagine that workshop to agree all the fish puns? Would have been absolutely painful. I totally agree though - it would be nice to have some variation, even if the jokes are terrible!
@Carck i get that yes, but THAT joke specifically is just so bad
The jokes are so lame, that they're good.
i prefer the Black Bass. The most metal of all the fish🤘。
My favorite joke so far is with catching frogs.
New horizons was my first a.c. game and during the first day, I caught a few Carp and didn't notice until after catching a few that the joke says "if i catch one more they can carpool." Well not realizing all the sayings were jokes, i went around trying to catch Carp. After catching a dozen more or so, I kept waiting for that Carpool to arrive to no avail.
I guess the moral of the story is the joke was on me the whole time.
@Tandy255 haha mine too. Poor Cousteau...
@Xiovanni I suppose he's 'gill-ty' as charged.
@Torakaka
No treble.
I know it's all random luck but I've had visitors to my island tell me that my island sucks for fishing! I had two people fishing with me yesterday for over an hour on my rainy island with tons of bait and the rarest fish we caught was the red snapper. But we did catch tons of Sea Bass and Olive Flounder!
It's not even better than a sardine...
maybe Nintendo will give an update so now we will have a C- sea bass instead of a C+...lol or better yet, Nintendo should make an update for the sea bass will change every few catching so that we won't want to through them back..
list of new "punishing" puns for the sea bass:
1) I caught a sea bass! Well...maybe a C- bass...
2) oh look, See, Sea Bass
3) oh Look I caught a D of a Sea Bass
4) I caught a D Bass! I miss the Sea...
5) not another C+ bass...
fortunately, i have not seen a Sea Bass in over a week; maybe longer. saw some red snappers, koi, alive flounders, and some zebra turkey-fish,, but no sea bass...
however, i did see a black bass or. unfortunately, it looked like a sea bass. at least it was nice to see a new pun while searching the sea.
@Torakaka Oh, you're in treble now.
That's an eerily similar title to the article of Kotaku Autralia..
@sikthvash
Unlike other fishes, squid has three lines. Two referring to Splatoon and one to Mario.
...Also for this sea bass line... I assume it refers to school grade (or such) ? We use numbers... not all makes sense
This statement really reflects everything that's wrong with everything that the modern world does with just about everything. And a terrible reflection on what passes as English graduates these days, which seems to be the makeup of Treehouse at present.
This explanation describing "workshopping the fish jokes" and "comedy-mechanics." Comedy is comedy. It either is or it isn't. You don't "workshop it", you don't engineer "comedy-mechanics" based on textbook theories. You either know comedy or you don't. If you you have to do either of the above, you've already failed at the goal before you got to it.
"If you have to ask what jazz is, you will never know."
-Louis Armstrong
I'm sure Rob is more than competent. Stop "workshopping" and engineering "mechanics." You're not designing a gameplay loop, you're writing dialogue. Go with your gut. If you have a clue what you're doing, you'll be right every time. If you're not, the editorial process should catch it.
I still remember the pun from the GameCube version:
“I caught a sea bass.
See? Bass!
(Why do I keep saying things like that?)”
Predicting the future, eh?
I think the joke is at least a C+!
This comment section. There are plenty of people who can make a pun, but you don't hear folk carp on about it.
I'm tired of it, and I don't even have ACNH!
@SoManyHaveDied The Dutch ones are pretty good... or... at least they tried. They give me chuckles. Sea is pronounced say in Dutch, so they made it "Hoozay, a bass." Not too annoying.
All the repetitive text is tiresome. And jokes work once; twice if they’re hilarious. Three times is reserved for the best joke in the world, which everyone knows is: Why do baby ducks walk softly? Because they can’t walk hardly...
C- would have been more fitting. There's not much of a positive spin to catching yet another sea bass.
I... don't read anything in the game for the most part. Especially not the fish puns after the first time.
Come to think of it, I set down a sea bass and now I can’t find it. I wonder where that fish has gone? I did love it so! I loved it like a son...
I LOVE the puns in this game. New Leaf's were fine but I found myself DYING over the Bluegill and the Darner Dragonfly. Good work, Localisation team!
I still think about the original "I caught a sea bass! See? Bass! (Why do I keep saying things like that?)"
I'm surprised there was nothing about dropping the bass. "I caught a Sea Bass! This is one Bass I can't drop!" Or something like that.
seabass the guy form dumb and dumber who got a salt shaker thrown at him
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...