This past week brought us Mario Day, or 'Mar10 Day' as Nintendo of America promotes it. Goofy campaign it may be, but it's nevertheless an excuse to celebrate the mascot and his many, many games.
Having already extensively covered the series for its 30th Anniversary and having considered our favourites out of the plumber's platformers, we took the opportunity to ask you to pick your favourite Mario spin-offs. The rules were simple - Mario needed to play a leading part in the games (so no Luigi's Mansion) and we included both series and individual games.
Plenty of you took part in voting and the results are a mix of the inevitable and surprising. Without any more pre-amble let's get to the top 5.
In light of the presence (in this top five) of series that owe their existence to this SNES classic, it's pleasing to see it getting recognised by the Nintendo Life community. The final full Mario game on the 16-bit system and developed by the RPG masters at Squaresoft, this brought the cast of Nintendo's key franchise to life. The characters were portrayed brilliantly and with humour, and the key mechanics here would evolve into new franchises; when we talk about Mario RPGs, this is the title that laid the groundwork and remains a wonderful experience.
This writer's relieved to see this in the top 5, as AlphaDream's portable-only series was a key part of rekindling a personal love affair with Nintendo - kicking off with the outstanding Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga on Game Boy Advance, it then had two games apiece on DS and 3DS. It's a franchise that has thrived on quirky scenarios and timing-based battles, and though some have criticised the recent Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam for lacking a creative spark, it still arguably provides plenty of fun. It'll be interesting to see what AlphaDream does next with the series.
It was a mini-debate within NL Towers whether to include this game, as it's a game centred around classic 2D platforming from across generations of the main series. Of course, its nods to Mario Paint show what this one is really about - creativity. Released as the centrepiece of Nintendo's 30th Anniversary celebrations of the main series, this gives users the tools and sharing options to create levels that are well structured, anarchic, weird or whatever they want them to be. Regular updates only strengthen what is one of the Wii U's finest titles.
The Nintendo 64 original was apparently once planned to be branded as a direct sequel to Super Mario RPG, but with Intelligent Systems at the helm and in light of 'issues' with Square Enix, it established itself as a new franchise. Just as well, too, as its unique visual style and the scope it's given for creative gameplay has evidently proven popular with plenty of you in the Nintendo Life community. Each home console since the N64 has had an entry - with Paper Mario: Color Splash recently announced for Wii U - while it also arrived on 3DS with Sticker Star and crossed over with Mario & Luigi in Paper Jam. Evidently a key series for Nintendo, we look forward to seeing more of the Wii U title.
Unsurprisingly the runaway winner, ever since this series began on SNES it became a central franchise in both multiplayer and for solo players keen to master every track and bring seconds off their times. After a drastic evolution on the Nintendo 64 it's been a series that's both maintained traditions and revolutionised its approaches through the generations in terms of visuals, controls and mechanics. Though portable entries have proven hugely popular, it's in multiplayer through home consoles where it's perhaps at its strongest, and with the introduction of DLC taking things up a notch in Mario Kart 8 we have much to look forward to - we assume - in the next generation's entry.
So there you have it, your top five Mario spin-off games and franchises. Are you surprised at the absence of the likes of the Mario Party series, or do you think the list is right on the money? Debate it all in the comments.
Comments (52)
Shame that the last like, 3-5 entries in the Mario Party series have been pretty lackluster or I could easily see that show up here.
Mario Kart was a shuin to get first also I'm early so ima make a joke
Japan's Xbox One Sales
Also First(hopefully)
Paper Mario won't be high up on this list/on this list here in years to come since Nintendo loves the sticker star format.
Mario kart took 1st place does not surprise me at all I've had lots of fun with countless hours in the series with many fond memories for each of the games from the ds era onwards! Glad paper Mario took second even if sticker star was not a true game in the series (sadly color why isn't it colour in Europe? Splash seems to be following sticker stars footsteps I guess it may be miyamoto doing this but I won't point my finger yet!) My other game was the RPG series Bowser's inside story was truly a masterpiece and I loved every second of it!
@HyrulianOfHyrule Sad but very true they had such a chance after sticker star to listen to the fans but they've seemed to ignored us again!
Glad Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars made the list!!!! Even though it should be #1 ...or 2
Wario Kart won. That's the important thing to me.
So no Mario Vs Donkey Kong........
Not surprised at all!
I never played Mario RPG- LOTSS, I hope it comes to the VC as I would like to play it on the 3DS.
I do disagree with Mario Maker being on the list, IMO it's not really a spinoff. But either way still a great list.
Really no argument against Mario Kart being #1, in my opinion. Paper Mario could challenge it if Nintendo would go back to the series' roots and make a TRUE sequel to Thousand-Year Door.
Pretty good list. For me...
Mario Kart is still a good series, but not up there with Paper Mario, Super Mario Maker, or Super Mario RPG, in my opinion.
Mario & Luigi has been a hit-or-miss series for me. The only games I enjoyed from it were Superstar Saga, Dream Team, and Paper Jam.
The Paper Mario series will always be my favorite I think. Even though I did not enjoy Sticker Star the first time I played it, I'm willing to give it another try if I can catch it on sale (I only buy digital now). I even hated Animal Crossing: New Leaf at first but now I'm in love and play it dayly.
Anyway, I very much enjoy the first three games in the Paper Mario series and after giving Sticker Star another chance I'm sure I'll love it also. I didn't hate everything about it, just the fact that teammates were taken out and replaced with stickers. The music was awesome and the writing, what little it had, was as great as always. I'm even looking forward to the new Paper Mario game that will be releasing on Wii U. Now I know the series is changing and we probably won't have another game like the first two.
A lot of RPG fans here. They are great games though. I do with Party was in here somewhere though
I would be interested in trying a Mario rpg, as I never have played one. Any recommendations? Preferably ones on 3ds.......
@Ashthearcher Mario and Luigi: Bowser's Inside story was the first RPG I ever got into, and still my favorite. I would definitely recommend it. If you like that, every Mario and Luigi I've played is great, and Super Mario RPG is awesome too (though it's a little hard to get a copy of).
Sorry about the 10+ comments there. It wasn't posting so, despite my knowledge of how the internet works (I have my own website), I was still stupid and kept pushing the button until it worked, resulting in it being posted waaaaay too many times.
Truth be told I only voted Paper Mario for the first two.
Looks like a fair Top 5, I'm surprised and happy that Mario Maker made the list. A shame that Mario vs. Donkey Kong didn't make it; wasn't expecting it too but DK '94 and the first M vs. DK were fantastic puzzle platformers. Hopefully, one day Nintendo gives that formula another go.
I also love the Paper Mario games (all of them!) and the Mario & Luigi games but the Paper Mario fanbase's reactions to recent events is sad and off-putting. At least the Mario & Luigi games are still on full force, I kinda prefer those anyway!
No MARIO PARTY?! That's a shame!!!
I personally LOVE party 9 and 10!
Kart fully deserves 1st place.
I only voted for Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars. I'm glad it made it into the top 5.
Aw no love for Mario Party or Golf.
@Zelda_Rocks Thanks for the help! Might pick up super Mario rpg on vc. I will have to check out bowser's inside story as well. I know it's getting a lot of hate, but color splash intrigues me as well.
@DreamyViridi That amiibo game is coming out soon.
@Ashthearcher - Oh I know, (Does that game have an EU release date? I don't think it appeared in our Nintendo Direct.) that game is continuing with the Mini-toys mechanic though. I meant another Mario vs. Donkey Kong that was like the GBA games, as puzzle platformers with Mario himself
@DreamyViridi Ah. Alright. And sorry, don't know about EU or even U.S. I Didn't pay that much attention to that part of the direct.
Probably a pretty fair list but Dr.Mario is a sadly missing. It's IMO the only puzzle game i consider to be on the same level as Tetris. If you count the original Peggle on DS too then that's pretty close for me also. It's just so awesome. Dr.Mario is the Rodney Dangerfield of Mario IMO.
Surprised at Mario RPG made the list. 1 game beat out all the other series. But I'm not sure what I expected.
Mario Party has a lot of hits and misses; it doesn't surprise me that it's not on this list.
I didn't vote, but I agree with this list. Of course, that doesn't necessarily mean my opinion counts.
These results coincide with my personal opinion near perfectly though I would have switched Paper Mario around with the Mario and Luigi series myself. The results are pretty much what I expected them to be.
@DoctorOverbuild Hopefully in the distant hopefully fingers crossed 🖖
@HyrulianOfHyrule We can only hope but I've had hope for 5 years and it didn't work out
@HyrulianOfHyrule Who drew your profile pic?
I've enjoyed the paper mario series, so I hope Nintendo makes it great again
Where's Mario Teaches Typing?
@boyika using by Google-fu, I found this http://captainosaka.deviantart.com/art/The-Legend-of-ZELDA-169582665
Not really. Mario Party 7 is the 'last' entry in the series. It seems Super Paper Mario would be the last one too, if they stick to the Sticker Star format.
What exactly was surprising about the list?
@Wallkick03
NO not trump's make america great again
I love the Mario Golf games. The 3DS one is really amazing!
Mario Tennis could be up there if they'd just bothered to add some extra single player and online modes.Instead we got Ultra Smash,the Streetfighter V of tennis games.Strikers and Golf too have so much potential to be more than they are.The core game is there,they just need more content and the same effort put into them as Kart and Smash receive.They could be massive games for Nintendo if they wanted them to be!
Eh, the RPGs are on top for me.
@HyrulianOfHyrule Do you have the artist's link (sorry, I have a tendency to do that. If you don't know it's fine)?
Great list there!
Not enough love for Mario and Luigi, in my opinion.
Mine was Paper Mario but Nintendo took a dump on it and is continuing to do so.... so I am going to go with.. yeah, mario kart.
I would have voted for Mario Kart, but i feel i don't enjoy them as much anymore.
@Zelda_Rocks
You should not be negative toward yourself. No one is perfect and all you did to the best of your ability was your very best.
@Kalmaro Oh cool. Thanks!
@boyika no prob
@Kalmaro
Tap here to load 52 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...