Comments 19

Re: Nintendo Download: 12th September (North America)

Manski777

No Daemon X Machina for me, I'm saving my money for Zelda and Castle Crashers. Maybe I'll pick it up on Black Friday. Also Lego games are always great to have. This week I'll be working on Celeste DLC and gonna be buying me some Castle Crashers!

Re: Harvest Moon: Mad Dash Digs Up An October Release On Switch

Manski777

It's not even a harvest moon game... It's almost like they took overcooked and farm frenzy and smashed them together to make a broken combination of them. Graphics don't look that good, everything looks repetitive and overused, and I even see fps drops here and there... Will definitely not be picking this one up, that sheep keychain looks nice tho, hopefully it will help those who pre order the game to cope with the disappointment.

Re: Nintendo Files Lawsuit Against ROM Website Offering Nearly 300,000 Switch Downloads

Manski777

@Mr_Muscle Ah I see, if I were them, I would try to get it changed, but from a time perspective I would see why they wouldn't. I would say it's alright from a moral standpoint just because it isn't actually harming anything, while my argument for distributing ROMs still stands because it harms the income of the developers, whether directly or indirectly. And call me crazy, but if I was an owner of an arcade I honestly would just write a letter to get it changed, unless there's just some clause that allows for it now. Better safe then sorry y'know?

Re: Nintendo Files Lawsuit Against ROM Website Offering Nearly 300,000 Switch Downloads

Manski777

@Mr_Muscle

Well obviously some people make mistakes / have high morals for some things and not others, everybody is different. And honestly a law against video arcades? Do you guys have any video arcades in your town then? I mean I see where your going with this but my course of action would be to use your voice to speak up about it (but it probably doesn't affect you, like if you had a problem with it I mean haha)

Re: Nintendo Files Lawsuit Against ROM Website Offering Nearly 300,000 Switch Downloads

Manski777

@Mr_Muscle

If you are just arguing about backing up games you already own, that is actually completely within your legal rights to do so, and I definitely agree that it's okay. The line is crossed when you start distributing or downloading games for the sake of "preserving history" as others have stated.

Also I would say doing something "illegal" is defined as doing something against the law, whether or not anyone cares or catches you. And people with higher morals would obey the law rather then disobey it, but I'm not sure which viewpoint you were trying to convey there.

Psychopaths commit murder out of anguish, that doesn't mean that they should go off killing people. I was under the assumption he committed it in self-defense, but if he went off at a later time to get revenge I would say that's incorrect, but if you disagree I'd rather not argue about morals as I doubt I could change yours then (Sorry if I sound harsh there. I don't know how to word that without sounding harsh, but I don't mean to be).

Re: Nintendo Files Lawsuit Against ROM Website Offering Nearly 300,000 Switch Downloads

Manski777

@Mr_Muscle You know what I meant when I was using the term ROMs when referring to them in an illegal way. Yes, they distribution of ROMs is illegal, obviously not the ROMs themselves...

If I think murder is totally cool in certain situations, would you not think I was crazy? Express your opinion all you want, it's still illegal nonetheless unless something changes.

Self defense is completely different then murder, you are trying to protect yourself or something. There are clauses for murder that make it okay as long as it's in self-defense. The only clause that allows you to copy a ROM is you have to own the game and you may make a copy for yourself.

Yes, if literally nobody owns the right to the game, it would be legal to distribute the ROM as there would be nobody to stop you from doing so. But the fact is there aren't that many cases of this, and even fewer for games that people really care about. The argument is almost meaningless unless that's all your trying to prove, which in that case I would agree with you. In any other case though, it's illegal, and seeing as how there is an owner to the rights of the game in these cases, the proper solution would be to contact them about it. You might make the argument that if it's a bigger game developer or company, they wouldn't really care about your opinion, but in most cases, they will most likely re release the game if it hasn't been already for more monetization. As for smaller companies, they may or may not decide to listen to you, but that's their decision and you can't expect to save literally every game in existence.

Re: Nintendo Files Lawsuit Against ROM Website Offering Nearly 300,000 Switch Downloads

Manski777

I read the comments section here a lot, but I made a profile just so I can take part in this one haha.

Basically, what I've read is that some people say pirating is okay as long as it is preserving old games and there are some people saying that it is not okay at all. Here's the thing, ROMs are illegal, whether you are distributing or downloading them. You can try to justify it all you want, but at the end of the day, it's still illegal until you get laws changed. If there was a law against eating ice cream, you could say that's stupid and that the law wouldn't really help anyone, but it's still a law and we need to follow it. Another thing, say someone that lived near me dies and he had tons of really rare antiques and stuff, but no inheritance and it will probably just be sold to random people and not be able to be appreciated by the world. Does that give me the right to go steal it and give it to a museum? No, absolutely not. If he was still alive, I could ask him about it, but some things are just out of our control.

ROMs are illegal (of course unless you own the game and even then you are supposed to make it yourself), so instead of saying we have the right to do something illegal, why not use your rights of speech and protest about how we aren't allowed to do it, so something should be done about the rule. If you're so concerned with saving the history of a game, why not try to get this rule changed to allow for certain ROMs that fall under a legal clause.

Feel free to debate because honestly I would love to.