As 2014 comes to its end there's the inevitable tradition to enjoy — annual awards. As is becoming our norm we'll have staff awards, votes of which will be counted shortly, while also giving you the chance to contribute to the Reader Awards. If you gaze upon the eventual staff awards results and believe that they represent a travesty against mankind, you can — as a community — right those wrongs.
We're going to follow the same approach as last year, with a series of polls that'll allow you to easily vote for your winner in each category. You can vote below — results will be hidden until voting is closed — and have your say in the comfort and knowledge that a clever computer is gathering the data. There are a number of categories, and the great thing is that if your game of choice isn't in its respective list — though we've tried to cover the main bases — you can simply click "Other" and type in your choice; we will then manually add up any of these miscellaneous submissions and add them to the overall results.
Voting closes at 5pm UK / 6pm CET / noon Eastern / 9am Pacific on 23rd December, so get your votes in before then. You have all of the same categories as the staff, and a few important details are below:
- Bayonetta is included in the eShop category, simply due to the fact that it's available separately on the download store but only as part of a bundle in stores.
- There are inevitable release disparities of games available in one region but not worldwide — a notable current example is Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker. Unfortunately these games will likely struggle as a result, but that's a reality we must deal with.
- With such a discrepancy across regions and the sizeable number of high-quality new download games, we've left Virtual Console out this year.
- As before we have restricted this year to Wii U and 3DS; the Wii and DS eras are now long gone.
- The 'Overall Game of the Year' award includes all retail and download games for Wii U and 3DS.
- To emphasize a point above, the automated options in these polls represent what we feel are the most likely contenders. If your game isn't there then select Other and type in your entry — these votes will be given the same weight as automated choices.
Without further ado, let's get to the voting!
Voting has now closed, keep your eyes peeled for the results soon, and thanks for taking part.
Comments 191
Wii U retail: Tropical Freeze (hard choice between that and Smash, but I went for Donkey Kong).
Wii U eshop: Shovel Knight (Only played the 3DS version, but hey they're pretty much the same right? I didn't really play any of the others).
3DS retail: Smash no question about it.
3DS eshop: Hard choice between Xeodrifter and Shovel Knight, but I went with Shovel Knight for more length and content.
Overall: Tropical Freeze! The gameplay and soundtrack are polished beyond perfection!
Overall - Smash Bros Wii U, no doubt honey.
@Giygas_95 I voted exactly the same!
Hmmm definitely "no contest" on which game it will be.
Tropical Freeze was my biggest disappointment of the year, but I won't go into that...
I can't vote on overall or Wii U yet since I'm getting Captain Toad for Christmas, but so far it's likely to be Smash for me, which I didn't expect at all.
Wow, seeing the 3DS list really makes it hit home how much of a drop 2014 was compared to 2013 for that console. Bravely Default was easily my favourite on that list, but it actually came out here in the UK last year, so my vote went to Pokemon. I think it speaks volume that Fantasy Life and Sonic Boom are even a nomination. Bayonetta 2 for Wii U and Overall by a huge margin for me. Guacamelee and Shovel Knight for the two eShop awards.
Wii U retail: Mario Kart 8 (it was MK8 v. Smash for me, but the DLC Pack 1 really solidified MK8 for me)
Wii U eShop: Shovel Knight (Played it on Wii U, 3DS, and PC-all outstanding)
3DS Retail: Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire-really thought that they did a tremendous job with the remakes making them really stand out and feel fully fleshed, 1000000x better than X and Y (although those games were good). They're still my favourite Pokémon games of all time (even surpass R/B/Y even though those are the ones I grew up on)
3DS eShop: Shovel Knight
Overall: Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire (may be unpopular opinions, but I think truly deserved).
Not going to vote for any crappy developer's (Nicalis&Renegade Kid) game that hasn't been released in Europe. Really shame that Fatal Frame 5 can't be on that list. Thanks to Nintendo for that.
Would've voted for FF5, but since that wasn't possible, I took Bayonetta 2 instead.
bayonetta 2 point blank tho i would say super smash bros is a good second to it.
i think we all know what's going to win xD
Tropical Freeze and Shovel Knight are my top 2 games of the year, easily.
Smash and MK8 are both very good but just didn't have the same level of awesomesauce.
Didn't vote for Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Trilogy in the eShop release category, because it's now a new game. Lol'd at Watch Dogs.
@Jamester0722 Yeah, Smash is great, but Tropical Freeze just felt like magic!
For me the overall winner is Bayonetta 2 :3
@GuyWithTheGames Mario Kart 8? In my opinion, Mario Kart deserves to win! Although, Super Smash Bros. should be quite good choice as well!
For me Mario Kart 8 easily wins, as for 3DS I voted for Yoshi's New Island (was torn between that and Kirby Triple Deluxe). Sure I haven't played Alpha Sapphire (getting that for Christmas) but given how much of an overhyped game Smash (3DS and Wii U) became I'm not holding my breath.
@Giygas_95 Playing Tropical Freeze reminded me why I love video games. The game play is super tight, graphics are great, and the atmosphere is just pure fun!
Bayonetta 2 was a close 2nd for me, but since I haven't finished it yet (played through Bayonetta 1 first) I felt that DK deserved the vote!
Honestly, it should be titled "game you had the most fun with this year" because game of the year has implications that any game follower/player/enthusiast can't ignore, sales, reviews, visuals, Fun factor, hours of play, etc... So it shouldn't be about who you think will win, or who should win, but how much FUN you had playing these games. So I know the game I had the most fun playing will not win (Hyrule Warriors)(especially co-op), but my second most fun game Mario Kart 8 has a far better chance, but smash has a stronger following and a bigger voice, so my guess is Smash.
Fantasy Life and Bayonetta 2 FTW! Oh, and Smash U.
These lists looks great, hard to regret be a Nintendo gamer with so many good games around OwO
The only "let down" for me was the eShop on Wii U, I know some of those games are "super-awesome" in theory, but fact is that none of them are even in my wishlist ^_^; (Please don't kill me Shovel Knight's fans >.>;;; ).
A bit surprised to see the Sonic Boom games as options, but I guess it's just fair to give them a chance despite the critical fail.
Anyway can't wait to see the results, so many potential winner in those lists
For me...
Wii U Retail: Hyrule Warriors
Wii U eShop: Guacamelee: Super Turbo Championship Edition
3DS Retail: Kirby: Triple Deluxe
3DS eShop: Shovel Knight
Overall: Kirby: Triple Deluxe
Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze is definitely my game of the year.
Voted Smash as a retail game for both 3DS and Wii U and Shovel Knight and Phoenix Wright Trilogy as eShop GOTYs. Had fun with Scram Kitty but Shovel Knight was just a tad better and I voted Shovel Knight before I took a look at 3DS eShop section which also has Shovel Knight. If I could vote again I'd vote Scram Kitty for Wii U eShop and Shovel Knight for 3DS.
It was tough decision. I love Super Smash Bros. and Donkey Kong: Tropical Freeze but I going for Shovel Knight for Overall Game of the Year. I am still torn for Wii U Retail Game of the Year...I think I'll just leave that poll alone for now and perhaps my mind be will made up if I do come back to the poll...if not, oh well.
Wii U Retail and Overall: Smash Wii U (easy)
3DS: Tomodachi Life (yeah, I liked that better than Smash 3DS)
I don't really play eShop games so I didn't vote for those.
BAYONETTA 2
and
Child of light
Retail U: Mario Kart 8
eshop: Shovel Knight
Retail 3ds: Smash
eshop: Retro City Rampage
Overall: Bayonetta 2
Many great WiiU games this year. 2015 looks equally if not more promising!
@GuyWithTheGames I don't know which game is going to win What game are you referring to?
this just isn't fair, too many games to pick just one. wii u is def system of the year
Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze.
Smash Brothers for Wii U.
well I cast my votes
@Liquid_ice I voted for smash but good point. i actually can't pick between bayonetta 2 and smash so i'm voting for smash on some sites and bayonetta on others
Got to be Shovel Knight for me,a rare game that despite all the hype has actually exceeded my expectations.My only negative with it is the realisation that I've nearly finished it.Bring on the sequel!
Why is Sonic Boom Rise of Lyric a choice for Wii U retail GOTY? That game is probably the worst game on the Wii U.
Child of Light was one of the best games I have ever played. Should've been listed in the overall GOY poll
Nintendo is really going to shine next year.
Vote:
Mario Kart 8, (then TF and the slightly disappointing Smash U)
Guacamelee! STCE (Loved it)
Tomadachi Life (Simply enjoyed it the best, I haven't played Pokemon yet)
Overall: Mario Kart 8
Fantasy Life.
I've gone for Smash Wii U overall, though it was tough to decide between that and MK 8 for me. I think Tropical Freeze would be up there too but I've not played that yet!
Mario Kart 8 is my man, unfortunately I know it will lose out to Smash, but hey it could still grab second.
Ugh, Armillo, definently my biggest disappointment this year.
It's so hard to choose this year! MK8 and SSBWU are definitely tied. But damn does Shovel Knight just take all my wins this year.
Overall GOTY was Smash for me.
3ds was Fantasy Life, I absolutely LOVED it.
Shovel Knight for 3ds eshop(The 3d effect was great on this version)
I went for Smash though Tropical Freeze is also amazing.
For 3Ds eShop it was between Shovel Knight or Shantae. I enjoy more Shantae overall.
@FritzFrapp
That game is outstanding. Couldn't vote for it nearly fast enough.
The 3DS eShop was great this year.
Long time reader, first time poster.
Wii U: Hyrule Warriors
Wii U eShop: Shovel Knight (didn't really play much as far as downloads go on Wii U, so I picked this due to the fun I had on the 3DS version)
3DS: Pokemon ORAS, though this was a tough decision; Smash, Persona Q and Theatrhythm were also all fantastic.
3DS eShop: Shovel Knight
GOTY: Pokemon ORAS
@Giygas_95 My votes were almost the same as yours, only I picked Hyrule Warriors for Wii U Retail (DKC:TF overall). HW surprised me a lot. I played the heck out of that game constantly since September. I will probably get back to it on the next set of DLC, but am trying to use my Holiday time off from work to catch up on my backlog.
Smash Wii U is great too, but I am kind of burned out on it after having to go through All Star mode with each toon all over again after having done it on the 3DS one already. I was annoyed that I had to unlock all the classic trophies again since I have them on the 3DS already. Same exact trophy, but I have to do a classic mode again that is twice as long as the 3DS one...
3DS retail was a no brainer, PLVSAA.
Mario kart 8 easy
Mario Kart 8 by far.
3DS has had a pretty bad year. I'm still playing all of 2013 3DS games.
As usual, the most popular games are the most recent (Smash Bros. Wii U & Pokemon). I haven't gotten around to playing those, so I couldn't vote.
So Bravely Default and Layton 6 came out only in America this year, so they're on the list. Rune Factory 4 came out in Europe this year, but it's nowhere to be seen. Same goes for SMT 4. I'm seeing some obvious bias towards America here (surprise, surprise).
I voted mk8 for Wii u retail and overall, should really have given something to donkey Kong tropical freeze but it's the multiplayer options of Mario kart that wins it for me! E shop was a tough one as I've liked allot lately, steamworld dig was simply amazing, just a shame it was so short, still my favourite though
ahem
Why is Theatrhythm Final Fantasy: Curtain Call missing from the 3DS Retail game of the year category yet Sonic Boom made it in?
Also, where's Nintendo Pocket Football Club?
I haven't even played 2 of these yet. The vote should be a week after CHRISTmas.
Great list of Wii U games this year!
@Peach64 I know what you mean about the 3DS. Kirby, Yoshi, and Smash were all great... but it pales in comparison to Luigi's Mansion, Animal Crossing, DKCR, Mario & Luigi, Pokémon X&Y, and of course: A Link Between Worlds... all in one year!
I said this in another article but "Persona Q: Shadow of the Labyrinth" is my Game of the Year. I think it will be remembered as one of the greatest Nintendo 3DS titles of all time.
"Super Smash Bros. for Nintendo Wii U" will be a classic as well. I can't think of another game that had so much hype (nearly 4 years of it) and lived up to it.
I have to go with Mario Kart 8. It never gets boring playing online with other players. Besides the frustration with Smash U's lack of DPad support, it gets boring after an hour. With Mario Kart 8, I could go 3 hours straight. DKTF and Bayo1&2 comes second.
For eShop, Shovel Knight all the way. I don't know about the 3DS eShop games though.
I LOLed when I saw watch_dogs and Sonic as "Best Retail Games."
I'm certain it will be between MK8 and Smash.
@Kolzig Yeah, a painful reminder of Fatal Frame 4 (would've been Project Zero 4 over here...) Well, Nintendo made me mod my Wii for that game, and now I use it to play fan-translated roms of some of my favourite games ever: Sweet Home (NES) and Mother 3 (GBA) for example.
On topic: Bayonetta 2 is my GOTY, no doubt. I've been waiting for it eagerly eversince the very first announcement and teaser, and it wasn't a disappointment!
Wii U: Super Smash Bros. for Wii U
3DS: Pokemon Alpha Sapphire
Wii U/3DS eShop: Shovel Knight
Game of the Year: Pokemon Alpha Sapphire
It's been a great year.
Wii U retail: Sonic Boom. I don't get all the hate, I really love that game.
3DS retail and overall game of the year IMO: SSB3DS. I prefer it to the Wii U version.
Needless to say, none of the games I played this year were very good.
I would have Voted for Pier Solar as "WiiU eshop game of the Year", but it's not there. Instead I just voted for the equally awesome Shovel knight ^^
Wii U retail: Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze
Wii U éShop: Bayonetta (1)
3DS retail: Super Smash Bros. for 3DS
3DS éShop: Xeodrifter
Overall: Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze
It was tough picking between Pokemon, Professor Layton, and Smash Bros... also, I really need to play Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze. I'm going to track that game down on ebay soon.
As of 23rd December, I still wouldn't have played Smash Wii U and Bayonetta, so I chose Mario Kart 8 for Best Wii U Retail. I didn't vote in any of the eShop categories, because I haven't played most of them(Oh, how I'm missing so much). In the 3DS retail category, I voted for Smash 3DS in favor of ORAS, because I kinda know that I'll enjoy Smash more(I haven't played ORAS yet... ).
Wii U retail: Smash U
Wii U eshop: Shovel Knight
3DS retail: Fantasy Life
3DS eshop: Shovel Knight
Overall: Smash U
Smash will probably win out of popularity, but I really think it should go to Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze.
I replayed it the other day, and man, this is one of those games that reminds me why I play video games in the first place.
@RadoGoji Nice to have you here!
I don't think it's fair that Bayonetta 1, Ace Attorney Trilogy, and ORAS are in the running since they're ports/remakes of games that didn't come out this year. But it's whatever.
Tropical Freeze for Wii U and overall Game of the Year for me. I doubt it will win either, but it's the most fun I've had on a Nintendo console this year.
Anyways, looking forward to seeing the results!!
Best Wii U Retail:
Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze. I still don't think it tops Diddy's Kong Quest, but it's an awesome game nonetheless. Best 2D platformer I've played since the SNES era. Smash and Mario Kart 8 are runners-up.
Best 3DS Retail:
Fantasy Life. Ridiculously addictive with some pretty neat ideas. A close runner up would have to be Bravely Default, which, at 102 hours, is the most-played game in my entire 3DS library.
Best Wii U / 3DS Digital:
Shovel Knight. Old school trappings with modern design sensibilities. Great graphics, music, and overall atmosphere. Guacamelee is a close runner-up on Wii U.
Game of the Year:
Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze
overall game of the year - Mario kart 8
Went with MK8 for Wii U and Bravely Default, even considering how flawed it is, for 3DS. That would probably change once I play Persona Q, but I haven't had the chance to dig into it yet.
I've already given my opinion on Smash plenty enough.
Wii U physical-Mario Kart 8
Wii U eshop-Scram Kitty
3DS physical-kirby Triple Deluxe
3DS eshop- Steel Diver Sub Wars
Overall- Mario Kart 8
Reading through posts here, I'm delightfully surprised to see Tropical Freeze get so much praise. I though I'd be sort of an outcast here in my love for that game.
It makes me sad that GotY awards seem to just gloss over 2D platformers these days.
@Kirby_Fan_DL3
Sonic Boom?
@Spoony_Tech I agree. Not everyone can get games on release day.
Wii U retail: Smash Bros
Wii U eShop: Shovel Knight (Haven't played it yet, but it looks great)
3DS retail: Smash Bros
3DS eShop: Kirby Fighters Deluxe (Same as Shovel Knight)
Overall: Smash Bros Wii U
Tropical Freeze deserves everything. Loved it! Shovel Knight on Wii U eShop and Shantae on 3DS eShop, Bravely Default as best 3DS game, and overall DKC TF the best of the year.
Sonic Boom Wii U, duh.
@NandN3ds Yeah. I know I'm among the minority, but I loved that game, especially the multiplayer.
3DS retail - Professor Layton vs Phoenix Wright. Anybody? I thoroughly enjoyed it.
oh well, HARD decision..., but I wish good luck to many games, they deserve this award; for me, this are my candidates, XD
-Super Smash Bros Wii U/3DS
-Pokemon Omega Ruby / Alpha Sapphire
-Mario Kart 8
-Bayonetta 1 y 2
-Captain Toad
-Shantae
-and more (including NES Remix, Watch Dogs and Gunvolt), XD
man, really hard to pick, but had to choose Tropical freeze for GOTY. Just flaw less game. was an early release so it's being forgotten in the mario kart, smash and bayo hype.
however, in terms of hours played, Hyrule warriors is the run away winner for me.
It's Mario Kart 8 all the way. Saved and transformed the Wii U.
I love Bayonetta 1 and Bayonetta 2. Both worthy as well, but when I think about how MK8 has boasted my Wii U gaming to a (hopefully) daily occurrence, it's no contest.
Shovel Knight is by far my game of the year. I think it's the best game ever made in its genre.
DK is still shrinkwrapped since I lived abroad for most of the year and still working throuh the backcatalog of the WiiU. Really looking forward to that.
I'm tempted to vote for Bayonetta 2 for Wii U Retail and Overall even though I haven't played it. You know, just to give credit where credit is due.
I'll compromise by not voting in either of those categories. Sitting out solves everything.
Wii U Retail - Captain Toad
Wii U eShop - Shovel Knight
3DS Retail - Smash Bros.
3DS eShop - Azure Striker Gunvolt
Overall - Captain Toad
Shovel Knight is GOTY and it isn't even close.
Mario Kart 8 for me!
Wii U Retail - Mario Kart 8 (haven't played Smash or Toad yet)
Wii U eShop - Shovel Knight (and that's saying a lot because Guacamelee and Child of Light were awesome)
3DS Retail - Bravely Default...by default
3DS eShop - Azure Striker Gunvolt
Overall - Mario Kart 8
Dude...where's Rusty's Real Deal Baseball at? Well, I suppose it wasn't an EU release.
had to role a di to decide between Bravely Default, Smash Bros for Wii U, Shovel Knight, Bayonetta 2, Pokémon ORAS, Smash bros for 3ds.
Shovel Knight won the roles so good job shovel knight
No Bravely default in the best overall games but we have Mario Golf and Tomodachi life...
At least i can vote in the other option.
Wii U retail: Mario Kart 8
Wii U eshop: Shovel Knight
3DS retail: Fantasy Life
3DS eshop: Shantae and the Pirate's Curse
Overall: Fantasy Life
Looking at the Wii U lists shows what a great year of software that console had. So many great games to choose from that picking a favorite is a problem that I love to have.
Sonic boom obviously
It was pretty hard to choose some of the options since I haven't bought too much games compared to last year so it was hard to pick some as I haven't played a majority of the other games in each choice.
Wii U Retail: Mario Kart 8
Wii U eShop: NES Remix 2 (sorry, don't own most of the favorites)
3DS Retail: N/A as I don't own one
3DS eShop: N/A as I don't own one
Overall: Mario Kart 8
For me this has been a year of Deus Ex, Arkham Origins, Assassin's Creed III, and Xenoblade Chronicles, but Mario Kart 8 is a game that I keep going back to during idle times.
Wii u: Tropical Freeze
Wii U eshop: Stick it to the man
3DS: Triple deluxe
3DS eshop: Shovel knight
Overall: Tropical Freeze
Shout out to Hyrule Warriors which was the biggest surprise of the year, awesome game
I voted for tropical freeze.
Smash bros for 3ds.
Shovel knight for wii u and 3ds eshop.
Tropical freeze will take game of the year.
Great year for the Wii U! I couldn't choose between Mario Kart 8, Super Smash Bros or Bayonetta 2. Also as a Metroid fan i loved Steamworld dig and Guacamelee. Too many great games to choose from.
Obviously:
Wii U: Super Smash Bros. for Wii U
Wii U eShop: Shovel Knight
3DS: Super Smash Bros. for Nintendo 3DS
3DS eShop: Shovel Knight (but I voted for Retro City Rampage)
Overall: Super Smash Bros. for Wii U
I love Tropical Freeze (one of my favorite all time games) but if I'm honest and look at time spent in the games I have to lean towards Mario Kart 8 (both are still amazing games). I loved Shovel Knight for the 3DS as well. So many great games this year, looking forward to next year!
Smash is great and all, but Tropical Freeze and Triple Deluxe are my favorites. I feel like people kind of gloss over them and focus on Mario, Mario Kart and Smash.
I think the DLC for Mario Kart 8 put it over the top for me. Those new tracks are so inventive and fun. Smash was great and is still a great game with a group of people, and I'm pleased to see Tropical Freeze get so much support!
ALL the love for Bayo 2!
For 3ds retail, I chose Pokemon ORAS, with SSB4 coming in close behind. After all, Pokemon Ruby Sapphire and Emerald are my all time favourite games (I completed Emerald 6 times), but I love me some Smash (I have over 130 hours clocked onto it, even though it released close to an exam period for me )
Wii U Retail: Sonic Boom
Wii U eShop: Zelda: A Link to the Website
3DS Retail: Galaga
3DS eShop: Watch Dogs
Overall game of the Year: Ninja Gaiden 9:The Revenge of the 47 Sakurai
Seriously? You didn't even nominate Rusty's Real Deal Baseball?
@Shadowkiller97 @Peach64
I was honestly surprised as well. I forgot the dearth of games that came out this year for the 3DS. I mean, I guess I can't complain, as I already had to cut some of this years out for budget related reasons, and I still want to pick up some titles I missed, but I really hope that 2015 will try to pick up some of the slack of this year.
Anyway, Wii U wise, it was really hard, because while I have a Wii U, I haven't been able to pick up a single title for it. I just went with which I've enjoyed seeing in a Let's Play the most.
And then for the 3DS, it was a choice between Pokemon and Smash. It was a tough decision [made harder by the fact I haven't picked up ORAS, and that I avoided most of the spoilers other than the Corocoro scans/official reveals and the review here, and the unfortunate Pokejungle review, that actually gave me a pretty big spoiler, despite being like 4 words] but I went out with my hopes, and said ORAS.
By the way, next year looks amazing! I am especially looking foward to Zelda U, Splatoon and Majoura's mask 3d. I might give Xenoblade X or Xenoblade chronicles for the New 3ds a go.
Why is Sonic Boom even a choice for game of the year?
DKC TF as it holds my favorite game of all time
Bayonetta 2 by far. It's a shame that a lot of people won't vote for it simply because they won't play it. It really is the best action game of all time.
@Giygas_95 I chose Donkey Kong Tropical Freeze as well yo
I haven't played any of these games... is it weird that I read nintendolife?
Go go Mario Kart 8!!!
"Wii U Retail Game of the Year"
"Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric"
I picked Bayo 2 for the WiiU game of the year. For 3DS, it is Tomodachi Life. That game is also my overall game of the year. It completely got me by surprise and I have been playing it for 5 minutes per day since launch. The amount of actual content may be slim and repetitive, but the scenarios that you and your friends end up in are hilarious. Whenever a friend comes over to my place they ask how their Look-a-like is doing. It is a charming experience, and I love it.
@Tsurii897 I'm right there with you. As much as I love Smash and MK8, Hyrule Warriors has been played more than any game I've ever owned, including actual Zelda titles. GOTY imo.
Good Lord there was some top notch games released this year!
It's too hard to choose the GotY for Wii U retail and overall!
I've enjoyed Mario Kart 8 immensely, but Smash is just too awesome. I haven't sunk my teeth into Bayonetta or Donkey Kong too much yet so hard to say about those. The rest have no chance.
Shovel Knight was my definite choise for eShop win on both platforms. It took my heart by storm! Smash for 3DS got my vote for 3DS retail, so maybe I'll give the Wii U one to Mario Kart 8 ?
MARIO KART 8 💙💙💙 all the way omg it's a double rainbow road!
SMAAAAAASH!!
Followed by Hyrule Warriors, Mario Kart 8, and Bayonetta 1&2.
From the indies I loved Guacamelee, Shovel Knight, Squids Odyssey, Stick It to The Man, Scram Kitty, and many others.... but my award.... goes to... Stealth Inc. 2.
how come these votes NEVER have a catagory for virtual console games?
Ohh is so hard to choose between Donkey Kong tropical freeze and Bayonetta 2!I love them both very dearly.
Wow that was difficult, between Tropical Freeze, MK8, and SSB4 It was a coin toss. I could make a case for all 3 games.
Time Spent: MK8 hands down. Although TF has solid replay value and I'm sure SSB4 will surpass all games here in the following months.
Content Amount: SSB forsure. But does quantity equal quality? With all the dlc and how solid the tracks have been thus far, I'd of given this category to MK8 if they'd of just pulled through with fixing that horrendous battle mode..
Music: Anyone whose played the game would agree TF holds crown. But the amount of classic tracks in SSB4 has always been absurd, and those top notch remixes..
All 3 games are aesthetically gorgeous. Although personally I think MK8 took the biggest leap.
Fun Factor: I haven't had as much fun with a single player experience as I've had with TF in a long time. The bar for MK8 is notched up once you get online, but man does the frustration level soar... I just can't deny there's something really special with SSB4. I can spend hours soloing the game, the online competition is endless, but the second you get a group of your buddies over for an old fashion night of smashing it really tops it all 10/10
In the end I gave it up to SSB4. Still it only goes to show the quality of games Nintendo has released this year! And I'm already looking forward to the next!!
I voted Smash, Shovel Knight, Smash, Shovel Knight, Smash.
I don't personally own Shovel Knight, but I hear so many good things about it everywhere that I feel it deserves to win. As for Smash, it was certainly a toss-up, but with all of the big-name, heavy-hitters that came out across all platforms this year, I think Smash Bros. is the only one that didn't disappoint the majority of those that bought it.
Retail U: Donkey Kong Tropical Freeze
Eshop U: Child of Light
Retail DS: Kirby Triple Deluxe
Eshop DS: Shantae and the pirate's curse
Overall: Donkey Kong Tropical Freeze
@Giygas_95 So glad I'm not the only one who thinks tropical freeze was goty. So underrated
Wii U (retail): DKC Tropical Freeze
Wii U (eShop): Armillo
3DS (retail): Mario Golf World Tour
3DS (eShop): Shovel Knight
GotY: Bayonetta 2
Gosh it's so hard choosing between DKC Tropical Freeze and Bayonetta 2. They are both so deserving! Smash and Mario Kart are also worthy, but they're not bringing anything new that we haven't seen before. Great games, but they obviously didn't wow me like Tropical Freeze and Bayonetta 2 did.
Really feelin' the love for Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze. If that was your pick, you have impeccable taste.
I am trying hard to like Smash Brothers. Afterall I payed 60 on that game. Ign gave it like a perfect score. After playing it, diappointment... unless you really like the roster and characters in that game...
The 3DS was underwhelming this year, the only game I've purchased for it being Tomodachi Life. Guess I'll have to vote for that then.
@argus Yes. Why do you?
My vote has gone to MK8. It's gorgeous; terrific fun just in single-player, and certainly where my time has gone most.
I bought Bayonetta 1&2 Day -1, and have no doubt they're awesome but I have hardly got started on Bayo1 yet, so couldn't go for retail/overall, but did give Bayo1 my eshop vote. Getting Smash tomorrow but god knows when I'll get to play it.
My favorite indie has been Bit-trip Runner 2, but I think that's older than this year.
This thread is another reminder that I need to find time& money for Shovel Knight, Hyrule Warriors and DK:TF too
Well done Wii U! 2014 has been a great year.
Wii u retail: A hard choice, but I chose Bayonetta 2 over Super Smash. Because Bayonetta 2 is something different for once.
Wii u download: Child of light is great, but I chose Guacamelee.
3DS retail: No doubt, Kirby of course. Man, that was a good Kirby. Full of surprises and making great use of the 3D effect.
3DS download: Sorry guys, I haven't played anything significant this year. If I played Shantae, I may have voted for that one.
Best overall: I would have almost chosen Kirby, but I just decided to go for Bayonetta 2.
Wii U GOTY: DKC Tropical Freeze
Wii U eshop: Shovel Knight
3DS GOTY: SSB 3DS
3DS eshop: Shovel Knight
Overall GOTY: DKC Tropical Freeze
regardless of how you see it…this has been a great year for gamers
Smash Wii U, Bayonetta, Smash 3DS, Shovel Knight, Smash Wii U.
I adore Hyrule Warriors ^_^
Could game of the year awards wait until the year's over? I need more than 3 weeks to determine if Super Smash Bros. for Wii U is GOTY worthy.
Smash 4 Wii U, SI2, Fantasy Life, And Ace Attorney. I was torn between putting SI2 as "other" in overall, but Fantasy Life was amazing! 275 hours and counting!
@SKTTR
I KNOW RIGHT!!! Stealth Inc. 2: Game of Clones is AMAZING! I love how it doesn't baby you. It gives you a gadget, tells you which button to use, and bam. IT'S GLORIOUS!
Sadly, it will be overlooked. 😫😭😞
The lack of Curtain Call over some of the other choices is incredibly unsettling.
I think Rune Factory 4 is turning into one of my fav 3DS games of all time, and it was just localized recently.
Bayonetta 2 is my Wii U and overall game of the year by a large margin. I loved every second of it. Smash is also great, but Bayonetta 2 is the reason I bought my Wii U.
Bayonetta 2 wins all.
Really tough decision between Smash Bros Wii U and Bayonetta 2 for GOTY. I went for Smash only because I've played more of it so far. It literally was a coin flip, ask me 5 minutes later and I'd probably choose Bayonetta 2. I gave it Wii U Retail GOTY to make up for the slight.
Should this not have been done early in the New Year to give people a chance to play more of the games.? I'll be playing more games over the Christmas period as I'm sure many other people will be too.
MK8 was out of the running straight away because of the atrocious Battle Mode. Otherwise it would have been a tough decision between 3 games.
@Billfredbobob Yeah, plus to me at least, going with Smash Wii U is just too obvious. I did the same thing last year with Super Mario 3D World and voted for Runner 2 instead because I sort of root for the underdog. I've never gotten such a huge rush out of any game like I have Runner 2.
Voted for Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze in both ballots it's in. I absolutely LOVE Smash Wii U, but gee, Tropical Freeze does not get enough love. Stellar gameplay, amazing environments and visuals and creative level design (running quickly through a burning savannah using juice-filled fruits to clear the path, put out burning trees and vines, and save the wildlife? got it. railing through a raging lumber mill with the wooden ride you travel on being cut and molded into different objects that affect gameplay as you go? sure. a whole world that, as you only realize later, is an entire fruit based world with each level representing a part in the factory process all in the end to just make POPSICLES? this game is amazingly creative and charming) the most catchy and yet atmospheric soundtrack I've heard in ages (gotta love that David Wise!), and so much more. Smash U is amazing in a lot of ways; AMAZING soundtrack as well, fantastic visuals, good characters that are fun to play, etc. But since a lot of it's fun comes from multiplayer experience, I'm leanin' more torwards the game that gives me the best, most memorable experience that I don't need another person to "feel" all the way. DKC:TF is amazing, and I really wish more people would play it.
Tropical Freeze. Donkey Kong has a special place in my heart.
How about a category for Japanese imports? Fatal Frame V gets my vote
The only Wii U eshop game I have actually played is Pure Chess, so I voted for that. Probably the best chess game I have ever played, looks amazing and has a great system, great AI, with good amount of difficulty levels and great learning tools.
Bayonetta 2 is the GOTY for me.
Tropical Freeze is the ultimate winner in my book. That game is amazing.
Captain Toad is relased next year...
All time favorite for 2014 is Tomodachi Life, I hope a sequel is in the works.
Pleasantly surprised to see the love for DK in the comment section. This game really helped me get through dark times in both spring and summer. Beautiful visuals, great music, superb control and level design, and all the characters are so funny, they make me feel like a 7-year old again.
Mariokart 8 for Wii U because what, 7 (?) months later I'm still playing it regularly. It really has captivated me longest. Plus, even my PS4/Xbox1 playing mates can't get over how gorgeous it is. 2nd is DKC: Tropical Freeze. It may have overtaken DKC2 as the best in series, it really is brilliant. People seemed to forget it pretty quickly but I think it's an underrated, supurb gem. 3rd would likely go to Bayenetta 2 but I haven't played it yet. It looks stunning and huge! Instead I'd give it to Smash - What a year it's been for Wii U if I'd consider leaving Smash off a top 3 list!
3DS has had a pretty average year. Looking at that list of games really puts it into perspective. Bravely Default gets the vote. Shovel Knight by miles as far as Eshop goes. Miles!
@DarkolitPL learn to read!
Wii U retail: Bayonetta 2
Wii U eshop: Shovel Knight
3DS Retail: Persona Q
3DS eshop: Ace Attorney Trilogy
Overall: Bayonetta 2
:3
Wii U: Tropical Freeze, Child of Light; 3DS: Fantasy Life and Shovel Knight.
@ThomasBW84 Talking about release disparities, don't forget that some of those 3ds retail games arrived in EU only via eShop!
Mario Kart 8 by a mile. 3DS has been a pretty full year for me. Still playing Pullblox and Fallblox.
It's unfair to have an overall category with both 3ds and wii u, handheld games are always less impressive because the hardware is limited and developers find bigger success in the console market (the Wii U's early lethargy aside).
Fantasy life!
Thought I was one of a few voting DKC TF, but from the comments it seems it stand a chance and that it will be close between Smash, Bayo2, DKC TF and MK8. A great year for the Wii U especially! And next year could be better!! (I see Captain toad is nominated now, but I hope it will be on the list for next year for us Europeans to decide as well)
It's all about Tomodachi Life!
"Shantea 3" hasn't actually been released in Europe let, so you added that but not "Captain Toad"?
To be honest, Smash and Shovel Knight were the only games I felt truly satisfied with, so I just voted for those and gave Smash U my overall GoTY. Every other game I would consider had some flaw that impacted my enjoyment or just didn't feel as polished and fun. The only other title like those two would maybe be Tropical Freeze. To be fair, I haven't played Bayo2, though.
@audiobrainiac Yeah, it's hard for the other choices to put up a "fight."
It's hard to make a choice. I voted for Bayonetta 2 but there are a few great games in the list I haven't bought yet.
Had to vote for Tropical Freeze. That game was perfection.
Man, the Wii U had a great year! Smash Bros, Tropical Freeze, MK8, and HW are all fantastic games! I've only played a little bit of Captain Toad but it's great too.
@JaxonH - Armillo is really that good? @sinalefa Said you would talk me into it. Guess I wont even bother asking since its on sale for $4.
And I'm surprised you voted for anything over DK. B2 must be good. I voted for HW, even though those types of games have been around forever it was still different enough and really good. Of course I haven played B2 yet.
Since I haven't played ORAS or Smash on the 3DS, I gave my retail vote to Conception II (good game :3)
Wii U...MK8 for that and Bayonetta for the digital
Overall, I gave it to MK8...
@Giygas_95 I didn't vote for DKC:TF but I thought that game rocked. The truth of the matter is that there are multiple "game of the year" titles on Nintendo systems this year.....but you have to choose only one. I voted for Mario Kart 8. It's by far the best in the series. It's one of the best looking games on the Wii U. Tons of tracks and characters. You can choose traditional controls or motion controls. The game just rocks! But I could have easily voted for Donkey Kong, Smash, or Bayonetta 2.
I'm very happy to see all the support for DKC:TF! That's an awesome game.
I was torn but i went DKCTF
Bayonetta all the way!
Bayonetta 2. It's a love letter to gaming.
DK and Smash are my two-way GOTY.
gogo mario kart take it home.
@ThomasBW84, I just wanna know why were the games put in that order on those lists
@Sherman Totally random
Since I couldn't decide for 3ds eshop, I wrote in Battletoads because why not?
Sad not many people are mentioning Bayonetta 2... just an absolute blast to play. Smash is just Smash in HD, can't really say much has been improved over melee other than graphics and characters/stages... or at least I could tell anyways. Still is a blast to play, and after a hundred hours i'm still not bored.
MK8 is by far the most remarkable sequel, it really added new gameplay ideas that work extremely well. And now Link in a go-kart, jumping on an Excite Bike track... its like nostalgia-crack to us older gamers (30's)
@2Sang I feel ya... I loved that series as a kid.
Arrrghhhhhh, couldn't decide between Child of Light, Guacamelee or Pullblox World for Wii U eshop game... So close...
Really, REALLY happy to see so many people voting for DKC: Tropical Freeze.
Bravely Default gets my vote. For 3DS AND overall!
@FritzFrapp me too!
Despite all the greats that came out this year, my vote belongs to Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze. It was like the pinnacle of the franchise. I've not played a platformer so well designed, so challenging, and so fun, in ages. I hope that it gets the GOTY recognition it deserves, especially in the wake that is the Smash and Mario Kart titans.
Wii U Retail: Super Smash Bros. for Wii U (runner-up: Mario Kart 8)
Wii U eShop: Shovel Knight (runner-up: Guacamelee STCE)
3DS Retail: Professor Layton Vs. Phoenix Wright (runner-up: Super Smash Bros. for 3DS)
3DS eShop: Azure Striker Gunvolt (runner-up: Kirby Fighters Deluxe)
GOTY Overall: Super Smash Bros. for Wii U
@RainbowGazelle That's what "Other" is for.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...