Rate the 3D Zelda games (Ocarina of TIme, Majora's Mask, Wind Waker, Twilight Princess, Skyward Sword) out of five.
Five because otherwise people will put really low scores for games they don't like, and it won't be fair. You can put .5's, and of course you can only vote once, although you can still discuss other people's ratings. If you haven't played a game then just put N/A. In 5 Days I will get the averages of each game, and we will find out what the favorite games are.
Ocarina of Time: 3.5
Majora's Mask: 5
Wind Waker: 4.4
Twilight Princess: 2.5 (It has the best ending though, as far as the feels go.)
Skyward Sword: 4.5
Ocarina of Time: 4
Majora's Mask: 4
Wind Waker: 5
Twilight Princess: 3 (I agree with @Spuratis on the fact that it has the best ending)
Skyward Sword: 4.5
Edit: Agree with skywake below me, Zelda games all have great quality and all deserve 5's. Even the DS ones, which are mediocre Zelda games, are still fantastic games. Just like to clarify that.
Ocarina of Time: 4.5
Majora's Mask: N/A (shameful I know)
Wind Waker: 5
Twilight Princess: 4
Skyward Sword: 4.5
.......... only because this is basically a "vote" thread. If this was just a "rate it out of 5" thread they'd basically all get 5s. All that said I'm of the mind that A Link Between Worlds might be the best Zelda game ever. Also Link's Awakening purely for the Ballad of the Wind Fish. A track which ranks above the best on the OoT soundtrack, matches Wind Waker's main theme and is about on-par with Midna's Lament.
Also the best scene in Zelda ever, from the everything but Majora's Mask that I've played, it the bit where you first meet Midna.
Ocarina of Time: 2.5 (I just feel it didn't stand the test of time at all, gets way over-hyped, and was just entirely empty.)
Majora's Mask: 5 (My favorite, and IMO, the most well-designed Zelda game out there. The Side Quests are actually enticing, the story is delightfully dark, and possibly the most interesting dungeons in any Zelda game I've played. Hint: That's almost all of them.)
Wind Waker: 4.5 (Great, until TEDIUM!!! Still one of the best Zelda games, ever.)
Twilight Princess 3.5 (Good gameplay, interesting items, and great ending, but content seemed more than just a tad disappointing, upon completion.)
Skyward Sword: 4 (Interesting controls and interesting story. Possibly the first truly great water-themed dungeon in Zelda, and I final boss I was legitimately afraid to fight, right away.)
The Legend of Zelda : Ocarina of Time - 2
The Legend of Zelda : Majora's Mask - N/A
The Legend of Zelda : The Wind Waker - 5
The Legend of Zelda : Twilight Princess - 3
The Legend of Zelda : Skyward Sword 4
Too bad a lot of friends I know didn't like Majora's Mask because you only do all these things in three days and its reset all the things you done. Also sometime they don't like it because they are stuck in clock tower town and don't know how to transform into human again.
I feel like I'm giving Twilight Princess a higher score since it was actually the first Zelda game I ever beat (got the game in 2006, when I was 9 years old. Didn't finish games often back then). When playing the game recently, my nostalgia's kinda died since now I'm noticing all the flaws with the game, but I still find it quite enjoyable. And yeah, I agree with TP having the best ending, closely rivaled with Wind Waker's ending.
Ocarina of Time: 5/5 Majora's Mask: I haven't played this since it came out and I forget large portions of it. Been holding out for the inevitable 3DS remake, so can't rate this one at the moment. Wind Waker: 5/5 Twilight Princess: 4/5 Skyward Sword: 5/5
So I like Zelda games, it seems.
So Anakin kneels before Monster Mash and pledges his loyalty to the graveyard smash.
Forums
Topic: Rating the 3D Zelda Games
Posts 1 to 20 of 78
This topic has been archived, no further posts can be added.