The Nintendo Switch Parental Controls app is a neat idea, allowing parents to manage various aspects of their little 'un's playtime from their phone / tablet. Its functionality and the speed with which it updates the log is certainly handy, and in a pinch parents can even set the console to automatically switch off when a specified playtime has been met.
It's not perfect, though, as we've discovered. We have the parental controls app synchronised to our system (back from when we were testing it out) and just recently went on a road trip with the console. Based on our experience the app has a surprising loophole.
While away with the Switch we left it offline - Wi-Fi was never disabled, but we didn't actively connect it while on the move, either on the road or in a hotel. Having checked the parental app to see what it logged from that trip, it says we didn't play the system at all over the weekend, which is clearly wrong.
We'd assumed that the Switch would log playtime when offline and then synchronise with the app when connected, but having refreshed the console and app it's not picking up any of that weekend gaming. Though parents can use some controls on the console itself to limit activities, the advanced features of the app seem to lose their use once the system is off the grid.
It's a bit of an odd oversight, though it's not something that can't easily be resolved through updates to the app and system itself. Until then, kids can play all they want once they get the thing offline, so going somewhere unfamiliar with the console would do the trick, even without needing to turn off the overall Wi-Fi.
Sleepovers = Breath of the Wild marathon sessions, it seems...
Comments 46
Take that mom and dad!
This is a glorious oversight, I love it.
An online based feature that is subpar and exploitable on a Nintendo platform?!?!? NEVER!!!!
Just...LOL
Bowser Jr did not get his profile icon as a punishment
Classic Nintendo.
ruh ro.
RIP Activity log
So taking the system on the go means you´re activity will not be logged. An amazing oversight.
I don't have kids and I don't even want too so it's not my problem, but just out of curiosity, if you just set the timer so that the console turns off after it runs out it still works even if it is offline?
If so, parents that are concerned about time spent on games could still take advantage of this to have some control even though they cannot rely on the other finctions of the app
Patching in three... two...
Hahaha.... XD
That Bowser/Bowser Jr video is still cute.
I don't need an app to limit my playtime, my work does that job well enough :-/
Are you telling kids to take their Switch to unfamiliar places? Uh oh.
It tracks my activity when I'm offline or in Aeroplane Mode...
Haha! This would have spread around the playground like wildfire when I was a kid!
And once Nintendo patches this out, the kids will just invent a Switch case with a built-in Wi-Fi signal blocker so they can play unmonitored forever.
That video never gets old.
Phail...
Good!
''I used to fool my folks into being able to play more by turning my Switch offline. Good times...''
I can already hear today's kids saying stuff like this when they grow up. It'll be their variant of secretly continue playing a GameBoy under the covers past their bedtime! (Except.. they can still also do that with the Switch. ..without also needing dumb ways to actually see their screen.)
Won't this upset your friends over at family gamer? As well as any parent who follows the site? I'm surprised something like this was highlighted at all.
All you fascists are bound to lose.
@ThatNyteDaez It's probably a good idea to highlight it so Nintendo will fix it. I for one at least would like to be able to log data even while offline, like Wii, 3DS, and Wii U can.
@Paddle1 Honestly I set up the app just to log my playtime although Switch does do it to a limited extent. After 10 days of play it will give an estimate on your profile of how long you have played a game.
As a parent I love this app to monitor and control my kids playtime...However we all discovered this convenient loophole this past weekend while away. I hope they can patch this because it is very handy...For us parental "fuzz" types. Frankly this was a major selling point for my wife. The kids were doing all kinds of chores to earn time. Thanks Nintendo...Now just patch this loophole...Please?
Lol nintendo did this on purpose i just know lol.
To keep both the parents happy "as if" they are in control lol.
Good.
I haven't found this to be a problem at all - it updates once it's back on wifi. I haven't had it away from home longer than a day though, perhaps it only keeps data for 24hrs?
The major flaw I've found with it is that it doesn't have settings per user, only per console, so I can't track my kids' usage separately from my own. And if I set play-time restrictions they apply to me too!
Only Nintendo
Man this is an outrage!!! If Nintendo does not think in the children who will?
Without unlock code isn't possible to turn off the wifi...!
I'm a parent of 13 year kid, and when is outside with the switch is accompanied, so the point is to control the gaming time ate home...!
About the playtime don't synchronize, that i don't know, but i'm going to check.
@chardir yeah i notice that to, doesn't make sense. hehehehe
Today's Kids: What's a Offline?
Sounds good to me. That'll let today's kids grow up the right way instead of the PARENTAL way. I hope there is no way to patch it
I swear I've spent so much time hiding in places to play more, learning to bruteforce routers and poop it is unreal. Fortunately those times are behind me, and I'll be letting my own kids play until they drop when those times come. Gaming is good, and not just in moderation
Hihi, that's actually great news for kids!
The kid in me/my younger self would be so happy about this!
There's a possibility that it is a specific glitch related to this weekend only. A timezone related issue. I had several different service providers lose hours to the entire weekend of data that the only reason I can come up with is not being able to cope properly with the time change in whatever timezones their servers with my data reside in.
Did you check it after it went back online? It makes sense for the App not to monitor their progress while the system is offline. There really isn't a fix for that.
I've noticed it's not very good about keeping track of play activity even outside of parental controls when the system is offline. On my profile it says I've only played FAST RMX "for a few minutes," and I know I've played that game a LOT longer than that. (Especially online... so where is the counting getting missed?)
@TheLZdragon
Read the 2nd to last paragraph
@ThatNyteDaez
As a parent, (and I'm not) I think I'd like to be aware of any potential work-around to parental controls. You know what to look out for now, and it also brings Nintendo's attention to an oversight in their OS.
@Angelic_Lapras_King
As a representative of today's kids, I can personally confirm that this isn't true.
Though I can see that happening with Generation Alpha/Beta.
Easy make the settings parental passworded.
I agree with @undomiel, give it a bit more testing. I know I was unable to scan amiibos into BotW over the weekend because of Daylight Savings so it's possible other things on the system were affected too.
Oh that's why it didn't log my Zelda play time
I'm not a kid but this is glorious.
Ha
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...