Forums

Topic: Game of the Year: 2026

Posts 101 to 117 of 117

kkslider5552000

VoidofLight wrote:

I'll just check the trailers after the show, since I'm only interested in watching it for the Persona 6 reveal. I also think there needs to be a talk about how largely Xenophobic TGA is, and how Japanese-made games hardly get taken seriously unless they're from grandfathered franchises or end up being "western" in spirit like Kojima's games or the Souls games.

Guarantee it would've been much, MUCH worse 15 years ago. (even ignoring how much worse the Spike Game Awards somehow were)

Still mad Xenoblade 2 got snubbed for music in its year tho. Glad 3 at least got GOTY nomination in its year but I genuinely think 2 is an all time soundtrack more than 3 is an all time game. (high praise)

[Edited by kkslider5552000]

Non-binary, demiguy, making LPs, still alive

Megaman Legends 2 Let's Play!:
LeT's PlAy MEGAMAN LEGENDS 2 < Link to LP

Matt_Barber

VoidofLight wrote:

MixedTape has no original compositions, and GTA6 is barely going to have any songs originally composed for the game.

Mixtape has an entire original soundtrack in addition to the licensed music:

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/15Tz8zP3DV5FRR8HQ88Mem

I know less about GTA6's soundtrack, as does anyone who isn't subject to an embargo, but there was an album featuring 34 original tracks announced so, at the very least, it too will have a substantial original component.

I think you can rest assured that nobody will win that award purely from licensing existing tracks.

Matt_Barber

darkfenrir

Control Resonant got decent amount of nominations, so I'm pretty happy with it (And hopefully it will win a few).

I also voted Cairn for best indie because despite not finishing it since I only played the demo on Switch 2, that was amazing.

darkfenrir

VoidofLight

@Matt_Barber I guess, but I still feel like it sucks that Fortune's Weave wasn't nominated given it blows at least MixedTape out of the water in it's entirety. Stuff like the Pale Raven's Landing, Cycle of the Sun, or Wings of the Sunbearer are some of the best songs I've heard in a RPG to date.

"It is fate. Many have tried, yet none have ever managed to escape it's flow."

Matt_Barber

@VoidofLight I won't knock FW's soundtrack, but it seems a far more serious oversight that it's not even been nominated for the best Strategy game.

I guess I'll be deleting my build spreadsheets and concentrating my efforts on the deeper gameplay of Slay The Spire 2.

Matt_Barber

kkslider5552000

I say this as a New Horizons defender...it being nominated in its year for GOTY but not Pokopia feels like insanity. That obviously makes no sense. 2020 was a weird time, it wasn't THAT weird, I dare say.

I just feel like the people who judge these don't actually think about them very hard. Like the Xenoblade 2 music snub only happens if the judges are like "Well Spiderman and Red Dead and God of War had good music, and I loved those games so I have to vote for it in every remotely positive category I can". And as someone who has spent lots of my time complaining about Xenoblade 2's faults, it is genuinely unfair for it to not be nominated for that specific quality. I feel like I put more time into voting for GVG's little weekly music contest thing, spending my time listening to music I am unfamiliar with, than these judges put into these nominations.

[Edited by kkslider5552000]

Non-binary, demiguy, making LPs, still alive

Megaman Legends 2 Let's Play!:
LeT's PlAy MEGAMAN LEGENDS 2 < Link to LP

Grumblevolcano

@Matt_Barber I think a game can only be nominated for 1 genre award so because it got nominated for Best RPG, it can't be nominated for Best Sim/Strategy. Either category works for Fire Emblem considering it's a Strategy RPG, similar thing happened with Triangle Strategy in 2022.

If the setup wasn't present you'd probably see GTA6 winning Best Action, Best Action/Adventure, Best RPG, Best Sim/Strategy and Best Sports/Racing regarding the genre categories.

[Edited by Grumblevolcano]

Grumblevolcano

Matt_Barber

@Grumblevolcano Sure, there are RPG elements in Fortune's Weave, but you could say the same for both Fates and Three Houses, both of which went into the Strategy category. It still feels very odd to me that it's suddenly jumped genres like that.

Matt_Barber

MontyCircus

"The Foregone Conclusion Awards!"

The last decade of The Game Awards GOTY winners all have one thing in common:

  • They were rated on MetaCritic at least an "89" from critics on at least one platform
  • They received at least 50 reviews on at least one platform

Qualify:

  • The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (but I don't think remakes should, and probably lots of jurors will agree)
  • Resident Evil Requiem

Do not qualify:

  • 007 First Light (not a high enough score)
  • Control Resonant (not a high enough score)
  • Phantom Blade Zero (not a high enough score)

We'll find out today:

  • Grand Theft Auto VI

The vast majority of jurors that decide the awards are game journalists. MetaCritic is a good representation of the consensus of their evaluation of games, so I find this metric a useful tool for the "who's it gonna be?" purpose.

MontyCircus

VoidofLight

@Matt_Barber I genuinely just think it's a case where the people making the categories and nominations never actually played the games they're nominating. That's probably why Fortune's Weave is put as JRPG, because to the people who make these choices and don't actually care about the game it looks anime, so therefore it's a RPG and not a strategy game.

@kkslider5552000 The choices are pretty much made on what carries hype and can drive the most headlines. If you look back at most years, all the games that get nominated for things like GotY tend to be games that have a lot of "hype" generated around them. Stuff like Elden Ring, Expedition 33, The Last of Us and the Last of Us Part 2. Things that are so big that even a casual gaming audience that never pays attention to these "award shows" (TGA isn't really an awards show as much as it is an inflated commercial) could get behind.

This is why you could tell that even before they announced the nominees that GTA6 was going to be nominated for nearly every category.. or how you can tell at the moment that it'll win pretty much every category it gets nominated for even though no one's played it outside of journalists. Animal Crossing New Horizons being nominated for GotY was a fluke because of how big Animal Crossing was during the pandemic. The game outsold many games that came out in the series, let alone many games that came out that year.

All of this is a bid for the event to stay relevant by clinging to big name releases. They also have a massive bias towards Western games, or games that are spiritually western.

"It is fate. Many have tried, yet none have ever managed to escape it's flow."

gcunit

MontyCircus wrote:

We'll find out today:

  • Grand Theft Auto VI

The vast majority of jurors that decide the awards are game journalists. MetaCritic is a good representation of the consensus of their evaluation of games, so I find this metric a useful tool for the "who's it gonna be?" purpose.

I feel like the industry is leaning so hard on GTA VI, and social integrity of in such a state of decline, that it just won't be allowed to review anything other than record-breaking.

I was tired of the GTA formula playing IV, which has prevented me playing Red Dead Redemption and GTA V at any length (so far) so, I don't know how much Rockstar has innovated the gameplay since GTA IV, but that's what I hope they've focused on.

You guys had me at blood and semen.

What better way to celebrate than firing something out of the pipe?

Nothing is true. Everything is permitted.

My Nintendo: gcunit

ParrakerriRush

Yeah, seeing the reviews, this puts the final nail in the coffin that GTA 6 is going to win. With all the hype and buildup, it seems inevitable. Not gonna put up with watching a 4-5 show about games I'm not going to play...

Back to waiting for Kirby...

[Edited by ParrakerriRush]

Odyssey 2 when?

Grumblevolcano

@Matt_Barber @VoidofLight I was thinking maybe they were struggling to find RPG candidates but not for Sim/Strategy so they put Fire Emblem in RPG to get RPG up to the usual 5 candidates.

Grumblevolcano

darkfenrir

While I get that it's annoying GTA 6 got so many nominations and stuff even before release, I wish people just focuses on that they don't like that instead of going... "GTA 6 is not released yet!!!", because it has been played by reviewers?

(Legit just went and read a review and it makes the game sounds super neat, which I might grab when it goes on PC and on discount, etcetc)

darkfenrir

squiddu-real

i just find it funny when people get crazy mad over these awards still, like surely most of us have thought at least once it's mostly just advertising bs

really, it's more a thing of... well i got not much better to do on a thursday night so why not, sometimes the game announcements have fun stuff (contrary to people who say it's all ue5 slop, most of it is but i think that blinds people to more interesting stuff)

(she/her)
girl who draws with a robot sona.

–nso classics spreadsheet–
–music app history–
^ (these are clickable!!) ^

take a stop at station WFMU online!

Switch Friend Code: SW-7976-4656-5576

UpsideDownRowlet

Don't worry, we'll all suddenly remember that we haven't cared about The Game Awards for years once our respective picks for the awards don't win everything.

Anyway, I doubt I'll be watching this year. Unlike last year, I won't have a free Thursday to give to the awards, as final exams are coming a bit later than previously.

"I will reference Deltarune at every opportunity"
Currently Playing: Cult of the Lamb, Pokémon HeartGold
Switch 2 Username: Owlex | (he/him)

Haruki_NLI

I think the problem is GTA fatigue, which is wild, because it's been hyped, blown up, awarded...and it's out tomorrow. We knew it was releasing, we knew it'll win awards, there's nothing really to discuss. There's no discourse, just like when Clair Obscur was everywhere. Foregone conclusion from the moment that game released.

Haruki_NLI

Please login or sign up to reply to this topic