
A traditional adventure format seems an ill fit for something as freeform as Minecraft. The Markus 'Notch' Persson-created global phenomenon is an experience built on creativity with endless scope for experimentation, so constricting it within the boundaries of genre seems misguided. That said, the franchise has enough cultural pull that it drove audiences to brandish wild animals in movie theatres, so there is clear versatility in this IP.
Minecraft Dungeons spun off from the main game in 2020 as a Diablo-like dungeon crawler brimming with character-building potential and co-operative fun for all ages. It boasts the polygonal art style and iconography beloved by fans, presenting a simple yet satisfying loot-based RPG experience. The sequel expands on this formula further by moving from episodic progression to open-world exploration and adding more depth to the basic combat and traversal loop.

The story, for what it's worth, takes place in the continuity of the last game's conclusion. The heroes of the land defeated the Arch Illages, but soon the overworld is invaded by the Illager High Council, a trio of nefarious magic users wielding soul power. These villains have also learned to navigate a mysterious new dimension called The Sift. Your created adventurer starts out in the hub town of Brave Haven, venturing into the overworld and helping the locals. As they expand the world map and fend off waves of enemy mobs, they encounter the High Council numerous times and uncover the mystery of The Sift.
Hordes of enemies roam every corner of the world: zombies, skeletons, spiders, creepers, Endermen. The list goes on, and you're never far from a massive mob of them to churn through with your arsenal of weapons or spells. Endermen, in particular, are terrifying random encounters that net some juicy gear at the cost of your nerves.
As with the first game, customisation is still the most compelling part of this fight-and-explore loop. Loot spews from enemies and chests at a steady clip, and you're never far from a fun upgrade that buffs resistances or reduces cooldowns. All weapons and gear can be enchanted for extra utility, expanding the depth of build experimentation even further. Artefacts grant up to three different crowd control abilities in exchange for soul power, while Talismans are new for the sequel and offer additional stat buffs and resistances. Outside of magical boons, jumping adds an extra variation to your melee and ranged attacks.

All this combines for a satisfying level of customisation, but it's a shame there isn't much variety in how you actually use your builds. You won’t be too far from Bright Haven before being able to fill the screen with explosions and spells…but you're mostly using them against the same enemies in cookie-cutter locales.
The quest to defeat the Illager High Council is geared towards accessibility. It's a family game that offers a lighter take on the ARPG template, but that also makes it a tad bland. In swapping out linear levels for an open world, Mojang has stretched the appeal too thin. There's still a sense of discovery. Dungeons litter the Overworld, and portals into The Sift offer a new biome that's lovely to look at.
Yet none of this distracts from the fact that there isn't much going on in Minecraft Dungeons 2. Much like with Diablo and its ilk, the fun comes from wandering the land looking for the next source of shiny loot or overpowered enemy to tackle. The main story campaign is a breeze and clocks in at around 12-15 hours. There are tons of side quests and rifts to explore that will further expand your build capability with extra gear and talismans. The journey just isn't that compelling while it lasts.

Luckily, you can liven things up by playing with others. Minecraft is a franchise built on its open approach to community, and Minecraft Dungeons 2 offers a full suite of co-op options. Couch co-op is bolstered by "mixed co-op," which lets online players join your local adventure. The experience is seamless, and the game is much more entertaining when played alongside others.
Despite the smooth co-op experience, the game isn't without its technical flaws. Performance is spotty in both docked and undocked modes, with patches of slowdown in the Overworld and during large mob fights. Frame rate is significantly lower for cinematics, which is always a jarring transition.
It’s worth mentioning that when stable, this game sings on handheld, feeling completely natural to play on the go. None of the other Switch hardware capabilities are utilised: criminal, considering how well mouse controls would work for this kind of game.

Bug-wise, I had a couple of issues with invisible (and invincible) enemies spawning during ambushes, which required a hard reset to fix. Meanwhile, enemy AI is often a mess, glitching into terrain and freezing. Several elite enemy ambushes were a breeze thanks to my attackers getting stuck on a wall, allowing me to use them for target practice.
Mojang is famously transparent about squashing bugs, with a public defect tracker for all to see and use, so these problems will likely be ironed out over time. For early adopters, though, the experience is noticeably uneven.
Conclusion
Minecraft Dungeons 2 adds some mechanical changes alongside a new open-world format, making for a distinctly different sequel. It's a simple, bare-bones ARPG with a strong co-op experience that's currently let down by some technical hitches.
Those jumping in at launch will likely be the established fanbase of either the franchise or the popular first Dungeons entry. Anyone else after a deep or challenging ARPG is unlikely to be won over.





Comments 20
I'm interested on this game as I still play the prequel at times nowadays. Xenoblade X is eating all my free time so decided to wait before buying it, and it seems like the right choice if it's a buggy mess. Time to wait for a fix!
Thanks for the review, overall still interested in checking this out at some point, but I'll definitely wait - even more so considering the bugs, but also since I haven't played the original Minecraft Dungeons and so I'll most likely play that first (and there will be also Minecraft itself for me to finally try after the release of the Switch 2 version)!
I might check this once it has enough DLC and updates to be a more engaging experience.
I played the original Dungeons via Game Trial a while back and enjoyed it (I almost beat it but the trial ended when I hit the last level). I won’t get Dungeons 2 any time soon but I am intrigued by The Sift.
I tired the first one but it just felt like baby's first Diablo and after playing it for a few hours I just was wondering why I wasn't playing Diablo.
I've really got to play the first one more considering I have it.
I feel like this review is completely wrong in the scoring. As for bugs all games have them and for the loop, I mean the first game had the same thing. Co-op is better than the last game as well.
If anything this is an 8/10 not a 6.
"Thou will not publish reviews on Sundays"
(It's one of the Ten Commandments, I believe)
Not something I'd play on my own, but it could be a fun co-op romp. I'll keep the game on my radar as I mildly enjoyed the first game
Sounds better than that new Star Wars racing game. It doesn't have co-op at all.
Bought for my 8 & 5 yr old boys whom are enjoying on their Switch 2. No complaints thus far 👾🙏😇
Never liked Minecraft. Despite knowing this spinoff is not even remotely similar I avoided the first one. Ended up playing the arcade game on a whim and found I enjoyed it. Don’t know about the console games, but the arcade one felt more like Gauntlet than Diablo. Made me actually interested in this. Sadly it sounds like this one is a fair bit inferior to the first game. Would like to see the first one get the Switch 2 treatment
Not sure where you got your information, but Hatsune Miku created Minecraft.
Hopefully they do the right thing and stop the spinoffs right here, they've been trying to force the fun on this for a long time. Not everything Minecraft will be a success.
They haven't done anything with the main critiques of the first game.
It's still very simplistic, so it still becomes boring and repetitive again quickly.
Still boring loot with too much of the same over and over again. Too little variation.
The fights themselves are also very boring and repetitive. Its just ambush after ambush after ambush after ambush, with the same annoying witch throwing these explosive walls around you.
All in all, just another low effort spin-off game from Mojang. Maybe they should just stick to the main Minecraft game. They are clearly just a one trick pony.
@JJtheTexan I heard about this meme, but never fully understood it. Did the creator of Minecraft say something bad about the trans community? (That’s what I got from a quick google… maybe you can clear it up.)
It seems that the sequel turned out exactly as I feared. There doesn't seem to that much of a huge difference between this game and the previous game so I can't see why I would play it. New biomes and slight mechanic changes aren't enough to convince me to buy the second game. I would rather wait on a deep sale. My kids would sure like the game.
@molkom basically Notch said some unkind things about trans folks and it became a running gag in response to say Minecraft was created by the virtual idol / SEGA game character Hatsune Miku. There are a lot of trans people and allies in the Minecraft community, so it was a sort of low-key way to clap back at Notch, I guess.
I'm not a Minecraft player but I always thought that was a clever and funny response.
@JJtheTexan Thanks!
And shh, I’m not a Minecraft player either ;3
I enjoyed the first, the key-card is immediately off putting though. Maybe in a year when it's been fully optimised and on sale.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...