You’re not ready for this. No matter how many trailers you’ve watched or how much pre-release footage you’ve pored over, walking out into Hyrule Field for the first time in the Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake is a revelatory experience.
It’s easy to forget how impactful Hyrule Field really was in the N64 original. While the game itself is still held in remarkably high regard, its main hub world has arguably been supplanted by later entries, particularly Breath of the Wild's enormous, immersive open world. It’s pioneering, yes, but it’s also quite small and empty when viewed through a modern lens.

The remake, with its breathtaking visuals, modernised controls, and revamped soundtrack, makes it feel new again. Standing at the entrance to Kokiri Forest and panning the camera around to soak in all of the details, I had to take a beat to stop myself being overcome by the enormity of the moment.
Making everything feel new again is really at the heart of the Switch 2 remake. I want to be clear: this is basically the same game, but Nintendo has tweaked just enough to make it feel fresh. Whether it’s the slightly different chest location for the Kokiri Sword or the Cucco hiding spots in Kakariko Village, there will always be something — however small — to give you pause.
The biggest change is the visuals. Much like Star Fox, Ocarina of Time is a staggering upgrade over the original, offering an almost overwhelming amount of detail across the board. From the small trinkets on Link’s tunic (who, by the way, is definitively 'Link' here, with no renaming options) to the way shards of broken pots stay on the ground and move underfoot, every aspect has been overhauled to take advantage of Switch 2’s power.
Yet despite the almost hyperrealistic visuals, it retains the original's spirit. There was a lot of discourse about the presentation when the remake was first properly revealed, particularly around characters’ faces. Any doubts about the approach will fade away as soon as you start playing. Everything looks right; whether it’s Link’s design or Zora's Domain, this is Ocarina of Time through and through. If you’re one of the many fans who were hoping to see the Spaceworld 2000 and Wii U tech demos properly realised, this is it and more.
The visual upgrades extend to the dungeons, of course, and it's crazy how impactful they are on your enjoyment. Inside the Deku Tree feels like a living world with realistic bark walls and copious spider webs. Likewise, the shimmering reflections and ethereal soundtrack completely transform the Water Temple. Despite minimal changes to the gameplay and structure — minor alterations to puzzles ultimately have little impact — the dungeons are a joy to explore once again.

It’s not all perfect, though. Keeping such a stunning game running at 60fps on a handheld takes some jiggery-pokery, and Nintendo's solution has resulted in a few visual blemishes. Assets in the distance — mountains and trees — look overly smooth and there’s some shimmering going on when you pan the camera around. It’s nowhere near as severe as Xenoblade Chronicles X on Switch 2, but it’s definitely something you’ll notice occasionally, particularly during handheld play.
Overall resolution takes a notable hit undocked, too, to the point where even Link himself can look a little fuzzy at times. It definitely needs mentioning, although it wasn't significantly detrimental to my experience. Keeping the game running smoothly feels like the more important priority, and Nintendo has nailed that aspect.
The audio has also been completely revamped, as well. The soundtrack, while familiar, has been reworked with new orchestral renditions, and everything from the Kokiri Forest track to the final, epic battle sounds incredible. Key cutscenes also feature voice acting, and it's some of the best I've heard from a first-party Nintendo game in quite some time. Your fairy companion Navi, whose in-game interruptions have been drastically cut down, is delightfully cheerful.

Exploring Hyrule and taking in the new visuals is made all the more satisfying thanks to the new control scheme. I’ve mentioned panning the camera around a couple of times, but it’s worth stressing that full camera control is completely new - a strange thing to highlight in 2026, but the ability to properly absorb everything this world has to offer really enhances your relationship with it. You feel so much more involved, and it helps that locations like Hyrule Castle Town have been upgraded to take advantage: no more pre-rendered backgrounds, you can now soak in all of the glorious detail.
The other major addition is the ability to jump whenever you please. Again, how quaint! Yet leaping at the press of a button gives you so much more autonomy over Link’s movements, even if it doesn’t open new routes or opportunities during your quest. You still jump at the same moments to scale platforms and solve puzzles, but doing it yourself without having to run off a ledge to trigger it is both quicker and more satisfying.
Combat feels comfortingly familiar: you lock onto your enemy and slash at them with ‘Y’, altering the direction of your swing by tilting the left analogue stick. You can hop about, perform a backwards somersault, and execute a leaping attack with either ‘X’ (the default jump button) or ‘A’, while holding and releasing ‘Y’ triggers the spin attack. It’s basically the same – why fix what isn’t broken, right?
Yet every attack now lands with such ferocity — accompanied by a searing red flash and a deafening crash — that combat feels completely overhauled. Again, old is new. Indeed, it’s so effective that it even makes Tears of the Kingdom's clashes feel comparatively tame.
Making use of your various weapons and items is also much easier than before. By holding down ‘R’, you’ll bring up an item inventory that instantly looks familiar if you’ve played TOTK or Echoes of Wisdom. Displayed in a single line, you quickly scroll left and right for your weapon of choice, whether it be a Deku Stick, a Bombchu, or the Megaton Hammer. The selection is relatively limited compared to, say, Echoes of Wisdom, so I never felt the UI was unwieldy or overwhelming; I always found what I was looking for straight away.
Meanwhile, key items like the Ocarina, masks, and Iron Boots are mapped to the D-pad. The latter is especially useful in the Water Temple, which gained its reputation as a major sticking point partly due to the need to repeatedly access the main menu to equip and unequip the boots. Tapping down on the D-pad is a lot more intuitive and makes for a breezier experience.

You can also do this for the newly-designed Lenses of Truth, which function exactly as the original Lens of Truth but have been revamped as a pair of goggles instead of a magnifying glass. It makes so much more sense!
The game is littered with similar tweaks, many of which have a noticeable quality-of-life impact. Reloading now drops you in the exact location you last saved (instead of at your house as Young Link and the Temple of Time as Adult Link). Elsewhere, the new Echo Gem, a reward from the House of Skulltula quest that replaces the Stone/Shard of Agony, shines and vibrates as you approach any Gold Skulltulas.
As for the Ocarina, you can play tunes in a variety of ways, the most basic of which is by simply pressing specific inputs via the face and shoulder buttons. Holding down ‘ZL’ brings up a menu of songs you’ve learned so far - handy for a quick reminder at any given moment.

However, you can also use the Switch 2’s built-in mic to input tunes using your own voice. Simply hum the tune you want and it’ll mostly pick it up with no fuss. You have the option to practice tunes if you wish, and it makes for a cute, if gimmicky way to use the Ocarina.
I’ve not been able to test Hori’s Electric Ocarina (and who knows where Nintendo’s official instrument is at), but I whipped out my guitar to test a few songs, and lo and behold, it actually worked. It certainly won’t be my go-to method, and chances are I’ll just stick to the buttons, but it’s neat.
I've not been able to test the Zelda Notes features during the review period, but you might find it a worthwhile addition if you're keen to create and share Ocarina songs. If you have some Zelda-themed amiibo lying about, tapping one during gameplay yields a few bonus items (arrows, recovery hearts, bombs, etc.), but thankfully nothing that could be deemed essential. All welcome additions, though.

What hasn’t been added for the remake is the Master Quest, and this is a real bummer. Available via a special GameCube release and as an unlockable in the 3DS remake, Master Quest proved an excellent way for veterans to test their skills upon completing the game. Given how closely the Switch 2 remake sticks to the core structure of the original, veterans will breeze through with minimal issues. And if you do ever get stuck, the new Threads of Time feature, which essentially documents your progress, will help you get back on track.
I died just once during the entire journey because I just got caught off-guard by an Iron Knuckle in the Spirit Temple. You can increase the difficulty slightly by altering the UI to show either minimal information or no information at all, but it’s no replacement for the changes that Master Quest could have brought. I'm hopeful that it will be added via an update, but it’s a glaring omission.
The lack of multiple save files is also disappointing. Yes, you can just create additional profiles at a system level, but the game allows you just one manual save along with several autosaves. Sometimes you just want to experience the start of the game again without impacting your main save file, so this is a shame.

The one last major addition is The Hall of Fallen Foes, and this is a cool, albeit inconsequential bonus. Accessed by sleeping in a bed after a specific campaign moment, here you can gaze upon statues based on enemies you’ve slain. It’s a lovely way to properly appreciate their updated designs, and you’re also given the opportunity to replay boss fights or even take on multiple bosses in succession. The rewards for doing so are useless, but the act of optimising your battles and beating your time is fun enough on its own.
And so, even with all that knowledge, you're really not ready for this. The visuals, the gameplay, the audio – everything has been thoughtfully upgraded to such a degree that this will completely replace the original for many. While the lack of Master Quest means it falls short of being definitive, it's still a remarkable remake, and a must-buy for Switch 2.
Conclusion
Ocarina of Time on Switch 2 is a stellar reimagining of the original, one that completely revamps the experience with stunning visuals, modernised gameplay, and vastly improved audio. Despite some minor blemishes, this is comfortably the most visually stunning work Nintendo has ever put out, and it’s unquestionably the best way to play one of the most seminal games of all time.
That said, it is a very safe remake. Despite lots of minor changes throughout, it’s still essentially the same game you’ve likely already played, and so you might find it offers little challenge if you’re familiar with the N64 original or 3DS remake. This makes the lack of Master Quest — or really any kind of hard mode — particularly glaring, but I’m hopeful it’ll be added in the future.





Comments 340
Should have been a 10/10 and I will die on that hill
One manual save is very disappointing
Hey folks, if you have any (sensible) questions about OoT, I'll do my best to answer them.
It should be 9.5 out of 10
@hol_up 100% agreed
@nkarafo Decimal places are a myth here.
The overfamiliarity might not be too much of a problem for me. I only finished it once, back when it first came out.
I've played the first 1 - 3 hours another dozen times over the years but further than that I've probably forgotten quite a bit.
“Only one manual save file”
A regression from the original and even the Switch 2 versions of BOTW/TOTK which added a second save slot.
I feel like this game is not always about the challenge I guess most people have finished this multiple times but it’s the experience and to play through this amazing game with improved visuals and sound is enough for me, it’s an epic experience 10/10 every time
Can't wait! Cheers for the review.
96% on metacritic at the moment.
It's a remake what else did you expect ?
Great review, Ollie, and it's heartening to see that NL didn't buckle to the expectations of a 10. This may be the one to get me back into gaming.
The lack of Master Quest is worth the drop in point especially when the 3DS remake had it and more. Seems like a solid remake that other then better visuals adds nothing and takes away stuff. Should have remastered the 3DS remake in my opinion. Still i look forward to playing it later this week.
@Alcea 3 save slots and master quest obv
I'm so excited to play it again.
I only played the original when it was launched originally and have fond memories of it.
If it's the best way to play OOT, and NL has given the N64 and 3DS versions 10/10, why is this not getting 10/10?
I'm not hung up on a number or fanboying a different reviewing website, just logical it seems a bit off.
I get the lack of games saves is an oversight by developers, as well as the master mode which is in previous version (and BotW), but surely this being an upgraded version of two previous 10/10 rated versions would make this a 10/10 if we are reviewing the game based on its own merits (i.e. not comparing an old revamped title to a new one, a la BotW's Hyrule vs OOT's Hyrule).
I'm waiting to play this at midnight and maybe it's the nostalgia of 13 1/2 year old me playing it for the first time coming through, but not sure I fully agree with the negatives here, except potentially the visual point but won't know how bad it is until I play it myself, however, I am not a graphics geek and am quite happy with majority of games.
Hope anyone who is picking this up loves the remake and if its your first time I expect you will be spoiled with this as your core OOT memory.
Ngl not getting a 10 is a touch surprising, but nonetheless I am so excited for this
Got probably another 8-15 hours in the Witcher 3 before I can jump in.
Glad it played out well.
I was thinking to myself, what’s the chances NintendoLife give this an 8 😆 thank you for the review, I’ve never played it and I’m excited for it to drop in to my postbox.
all i read in your review is 10, yet you gave a 9
I think 9/10 is a very accurate score, I look forward to playing it tomorrow on my brand new Zelda edition Switch 2
Having not played the game for over 20+ years, I’ll be fine without Master Quest. For now…
For me, Zelda OOT is essentially the same game I've never played. I did check it briefly during the NSO trial and could not accept the ugly graphics and clunky controls. I'm thankful Nintendo chose to remake it, just like Star Fox. I ordered my copy today and will pick it up tomorrow.
I kinda thought it would get a 9 because it is the same game, same world size, and no Master Quest. Still an amazing Zelda game though!
Unsubscribed.
Thanks for the review! Seems like it passes with flying (enhanced) colors. I'm stoked to play it myself. I really hope we get updates, just because I would love to experience even more with this game. A Master Quest, at least. They did that for BotW, so who knows.
I kinda expected the manual save. They kept the basic code for, as they say, for nostalgic reasons. I don't know whoe they are trying to convince. It is easy to include something like a jump in there, but having an auto-save feature or a streaming system to enable gameplay without load screens would have been actually work. It is a potty, as they obviously were willing to put work into the graphics.
Pretty much certain that Master Quest will be added as DLC.
I see why it isn’t a 10. With such a massive remake, you should bring something substantially new also for the veterans.
I’ve never played the Master Quest and was looking forward to it with this release, or some Hard Mode which lets the game feel more like a Soulsborne, with reduced health and limited save points.
Now, I will probably buy a used copy on eBay in 2027.
Edit: Okay, this game is just too tempting, and Amazon discounted it a bit, so…
Great review! Thanks.
96 on metacritic! I am so relieved Nintendo did not mess this up!
I don’t normally quibble over 10s as half the time I don’t agree with reviewers anyway; but this reads like a 10. I never beat Master Quest (didn’t like the changes) so I don’t see how its lack of inclusion detracts from a remake of the original game and not MQ. If ones first version was the GCN version that makes more sense though. (A remake is not gonna alter the genre but will make itself the best place to experience the game. Which it sounds like this has done. A reimagining would make sweeping changes such as FF7R does.)
A remake is like a retranslation of a text (or director’s cut); you will go back to the original source if you have access and not existing translations (which is probably more accurate in this case since Nintendo tightened up the script.). Nintendo is using the N64 game as the source of comparison. It is confusing that this review isn’t doing the same.
Ah well sounds like it is a faithful remake to bring the original game to modern audiences (spaceworld can stop haunting us as a what if). Which is why I say this sounds like a 10 and thus this review is confusing.
I 100% concord with reviews opinion, the lack of 3 save slots and master quest is a complete detriment and gives a sour taste in my mouth when this should be a celebration of a Classic from my childhood, at the end of the day is a $80 game that should have been feature complete (like the $40 3DS one 🫠).
@hol_up I agree, if you’re going to remake the GOAT you really need to pull more out of the bag than a visual upgrade and some QOL improvements.
If Nintendo weren’t going to go all out to make a 10/10 game then it hardly seems worth it.
Master Quest will no doubt come as DLC in time. Hopefully as free DLC though. If it eventually gets paid DLC though, I wonder what it would be.
I won't be reading the review, only the summary, but still super hyped for this. It's getting universal acclaim across the board.
It is very likelly that Nintendo will release a Master quest in the future. They often release something new after some time...
It should have been 11 apples out of 10 oranges
Wait, did they mark Breath of the Wild down for only having one save slot?
No Master Quest is like downgrading a Sony game for not having New Game+ at launch
What are we doing here haha
EDIT: Also, why is your comment system so awful now, if I go to my account to check my comments it doesn't even have a link to the comment anymore, just edit and delete options. Actually downgraded your system. Hilarious
Don't forget the day 1 patch which adds 4 save game files and solves the distant images looking too smooth, plus makes you a cup of tea in the morning.
96 on meta highest rated game this year.
Thank you Nintendo, I shall be playing tomorrow.
Excellent review, and pretty much sums up what I expected.
Those expecting 10/10 - it’s a tad unrealistic. This sort of scoring (IMO) is usually reserved for something that is either near perfection or reserved for titles that push the boundaries of game design further. This is a safe remake of a game that came out in 1998, so realistically it was never going to touch something like the modern era Zelda’s of Breath or Tears.
Really glad it still holds up though ultimately 🙂 (also gutted for no Master Quest, come on Nintendo, even the 3DS remaster managed to include this!)
I hope they add master quest later on, and expand on it ! It would be sweet
The game is going to be a blast, I'm so excited !!
@Olliemar28 Is there anything new to the fishing? From the trailers it looks like they may possibly have added some stuff. I remember i spent hours just fishing in the game
Sadly I'm not a target audience for it. I like Zelda series, but not OoT, and this new wrapper won't change it for me.
9/10 it's plain bad review.
Simple to explain, first you basically knock a entire point because of one thing "master quest", meaning that for you master quest alone worth on tenth of the game? let's see you being this rigid with other games...
Second, this is a remake of an original game, not a remake of a remake, if the 3DS didn't had the master quest you wouldn't know about it, they can even add it later as an updated because it's not something from original...
Now everytime i see a review from nintendo life, is something is missing for anything specific a save file, a quest, a detail, im expecting a point know off right away, so they mantain their consistency.
@hol_up Of course you've played it for a few dozen hours before forming such an educated opinion
@PushMyGran86 Not really no, but it's still a great time.
@Olliemar28 Is there any option to turn OFF completely Navi's LISTENS ?
Getting it anyway, but ffs one manual save?
@Eggs Your logic is sound. And I'm not sure the lack of a save file and a Master Quest should really be expected. I think being not a wholly original game, we are looking more for parity with previous versions and what this then does to stand out from those. So, maybe this is why it's a slightly lowered score. Visuals alone (with some other improvements) might not be enough to overtake those demerits. But, as ever, a review is subjective.
Master Quest isn't that big an omission. The MQ dungeons aren't better than the original layouts.
Sure it's a different challenge - but not a better one imo.
Plus multiple save files across profiles isn't really an issue either
@Tibob No, but I honestly barely noticed it. Tolerance may vary though, of course.
Nothing really to add except that this is not just a love letter to fans of the original, there is a whole generation who have never played this and wouldn't get past the graphics or speed of the original. There is also the fact that this is a test for other games to be created or reimagined in the future using the engine and assets. As a gamer in their late 50's, this is how my mind imagined the game looked as I played it in the 90's...and loved it. The same game that is better on the 3DS but limited to that tiny screen. I'm gonna love it.
It's 96 on metacritic
The 9/10 is completely fair for a graphical and quality of life upgrade. It recognizes it's still a good game but there is a tiny part of many of us that wanted something more.
Glad to see all these super rational opinions on this website, as always. People get so hung up on what other people think about games, why don't you just play the game yourself and talk about what you personally thought? It's fine to discuss differences in those opinions but people who think reviewers are "right" or "wrong" about their personal impressions seriously need to get a grip
Hope some DLC is on the way (Master Quest) and other fun bits. As it stands now- I’m still happy this was made and can’t wait to play it this week.
So... I can live with a 9/10
I did want to say, as a Veteran of the N64 and 3DS, I don't replay Ocarina of Time for the challenge of the game. I replay the game, because it's Ocarina of Time! The original game is an absolute masterpiece. Truthfully, I only 100% the Master Quest just to say that I did it. I always replay the original.
As for 1 Save File, who cares? Switch and Switch 2 can hold multiple gaming profiles. I am definitely going to reference this review, the next time I see a 10/10 Nintendo game on this site (if you guys even do that anymore).
@Olliemar28 Thanks for the review. I can’t stand the US voice acting, can you select the Japanese audio?
I don't understand why the limit of a single save file? Creating a new profile just to start a new run without losing the existing save file is not convenient at all.
@AmplifyMJ Wow kinda surprised you haven’t played this yet. You opening it right away or wrapping it up for the holidays? I’m still undecided. I had preordered it on Amazon and it was due tomorrow but we’re traveling tomorrow for 5 days so I canceled it and preordered it again and it’s currently due to arrive the day after we get back. So at that point I’ll have to decide. Not sure when I’ll play it but if that cover looks good I may want it out on the amiibo shelf. 😁
@Olliemar28 Probably a stupid question but I owned a PS Vita for a day, and ACNH on Switch so I have to ask - can you clarify if the 1 save slot is per account or console? I have only 1 Switch 2 and 3 people looking to play this but if we all have to share 1 save file I’m canceling my pre-order again. 😩
And just to clarify on my end yes we each have our own accounts going back to the Wii U and PS3. (Changing those kid accounts to adult accounts is never easy 😝)
Thanks for the review, even more excited than I already was after reading this (while I expected it the lack of Master Quest is the only bummer in comparison with the 3DS version as much as I don't particularly care for it personally) - can't wait for my copy to arrive hopefully tomorrow to start playing it myself!
Modern critics are the worst.
@VenomUK You can indeed.
Waiting for the "cut content" DLC announcement a week later that adds Master Quest and multiple save files.
@rjejr Per account, you'll be fine.
96 on Metacritic and a bit surprised it's again Nintendolife bringing the score down. That said still an excellent review and a good read.
@hol_up The fact that they still use FSR 1.0 is a crime at this point.
They would have an excuse if this was a Switch 1 and 2 combo release, but when its a dedicated Switch 2 release, it should have been updated to DLSS... or at the very minimum updated to the latest FSR version.
So that alone is worth nipping a score point. As Nintendo shouldn't get a simple pass here, since they are not some 3rd party dev. This is a first party in-house release, so they had full access to the Switch 2 hardware from the start.
PS. I am still looking forward to the game and have it pre-ordered. But the above should be mentioned and is allowed to criticize Nintendo for.
Really liked the review.
@uncleMike It has a 96 on Metacritic currently, so Nintendo Life's review score is actually a below-average score for the game.
As always, you underscore all big games in general, so even this not getting 10/10 by you is not surprising. You should fix that really, since it makes your reviews kind of irrelevant compared to the rest out there. The game has a 96% metacritic score.
@Olliemar28 Thanks for the review!
How do the puzzles hold up to modern standards? I’m afraid they might feel overly simple, since we’ve come a long way since then?
@hol_up agreed, this is written for people who've played the game and not general audiences.
No, Master Quest? I guess it will come as an update later. Updates these days are great ways to promote games a second time and bring them back to peoples minds.
@Falk_Sturmfels technically that would be promoting the game a fourth time. It’s funny how much stick PlayStation gets for remakes when every platform is at it
Com'on let the good times roll 🥰 can’t wait for my copy.
Glad it is over and done and we can move on to truly revolutionary new Zelda games and leave the past where it belongs in the past. Lets be done with these one to one remakes now. For good.
Surprised for the 9/10 if honest. Purely for the fact that this game will finally, after so many years, be accessible on the big screen (3ds improved version just handheld) with awesome graphics so people who have not played the original due to graphics will finally get to experience it. Or even people who have played it for that matter but were stuck on the small 3ds screen or had to persevere with out of date graphics in recent years, controls etc.
This is easily a 10/10 as a new generation will finally get to experience it fully and even older players will get to relive the experience in such amazing detail.
9/10 is actually below average given the reviews out now. Anyway, so looking forward to it!!!
Told you guys. Folks will likely give it a 9 cause of nitpicky reasons.
But I will say. Not having Master Quest is a bummer
I don’t understand how they could omit Master Quest, which is essential for any experienced player who wants at least some challenge since this game is quite easy! Really disappointed! I am not happy because I hated when Nintendo hides content behind Amiibo, like extra difficulty in samus Returns. Not Cool, Nintendo!
The Master Quest's absence isn't a big deal IMO, and I think they just mixed these two together when it comes to enemy placement (Dynalfos' are now appearing in the Spirit Temple by default, instead of being exclusive to the Master Quest).
@HubbaHunt yes major bummer indeed but Hopefully when you play under different Nintendo profiles on your switch it creates differently save files. Because I want to experience this game with my kids but don't want to wait for them either
This game wasn't all that difficult to begin with, so it's very disappointing to read that they nerfed the difficulty without giving a Hero mode. Still looking forward to it, but Nintendo needs to go back to having their games be a little more challenging.
@IronMan30 'this is written for people who've played the game and not general audiences.'
Yeah that was a real problem to me cause I never played the original so I don't care about the nostalgia aspect..this review reads like an existing fanboy quibbling over things any normal person trying it for the first time would never even for a second think about! Most games I play have one save slot. What even is Master Quest and why should I care? Makes no sense..stop living in the past people..
I’ve never tried Master Quest so it’s not a big impact to me. What’s honestly disappointing, all things considered, and please consider as a nitpick, constructive criticism, not one that truly bothers me, is the lack of DLSS. You have the tech Nintendo. This is the ONE game you retool your pipeline for.
My other minor criticism is the review itself. It’s rather short and doesn’t share a whole lot of detail for those who will be playing this game for the first time. From my lens, or lenses to be on point , it reads very well, but for a new player to OoT, I think the review could go a bit further to identify why OoT is still such a momentous game in 2026.
Still excited as HECK and very happy they chose to lock in 60fps over image quality. Besides, the image fidelity (art, assets, vfx) make this game look absolutely STUNNING! I cannot wait to hear the music on my system too!
My body is ready.
Midnight launch at EB Games tonight.
LETS GOOOOOOOOO!!!
You just know Master Quest will come later as either DLC or just a free update. Probably deliberately holding it back so they can give it an extra boost of marketing in the next Direct or just as a Nintendo Today post.
Reads like an old-school 97-98% review to me. Couldn't give it 100% because of a few minor points (that might get addressed in the near future anyway).
I Guess they left master quest out because they plan on adding it on later on, maybe for a small fee ? It wasent there originally.
The visuals Cant be pulled on imo. Its on switch 2, it looks amazing.
Only 1 save slot is wierd and is a minus, but not a whole point.
This should had been a 10/10 imho, specially when u compare it to other 10/10.
But im ready! This will be awesome 😃
96 on Metacritic with >80 reviews is insane.
A 9 sounds quite generous given the price and size of the game.
Looking forward to make up my own opinion soon.
Quite a few hung up on the fact it got a 9 and not a 10.
It can be a thin wedge between the two. Whether its a 9 or 10 is a moot point on what is reviewing as a fantastic game regardless.
Can't wait!!!!
Can't wait to play this for the first time, never played the previous versions
My one and only wish when the switch 2 was announced was that I was hoping for a OOT remake and now here we are 😁.
I think I’m one of the fortunate ones that the last time I played and completed OOT was on its original release. Can’t wait for this tomorrow (although I can’t play until Friday, I promised my daughter, we would be playing it together ❤️).
Enjoy everyone
Removed - unconstructive
I've never played the original so I'm definitely looking forward to this. My only experiences with Zelda has been all of the Switch releases, and I love BotW and TotK so im hopeful this will be just as good, if not better, judging by the high regard the original is held in.
“Stunning visuals across the board”
Also…
“Distant visuals look overly smooth with some shimmering”
🤣
Nevertheless, I can’t wait for this tomorrow!
I'm rather disappointed by the increase in games from Nintendo that only have 1 save file. I can understand it for some games like Pokemon (multiple save files would mess up the competitive scene) and Fortune's Weave (the way the paths converge) but OoT is not one of those.
I can understand the arguments of those that complain why the score is not 10/10, but I can also see the rationale behind not giving this game a perfect score. It's simply that expectations go up over time, especially for remakes. Also don't forget the huge price tag, for which it is fair to expect some bonuses.
This is 💯 a nostalgia play for me so the few cons there are listed are not going to be an issue for me at all. I’m excited to ‘visit’ it again, especially with the mindful tweaks that have been made.
@olliemar28 my only question would be how do you feel, this feels compared to the new Zelda games now with its upgraded visuals and quality of life upgrades. Is there more of an overlap that you maybe remember or do they feel of very different gaming eras?
Pretty lame to dock a point for something that was never going to be in the initial release.
Get over the Metroid Prime 4 review, be happy about video games again, and give it whatever score you genuinely feel it deserves. Ocarina of Time is something special. It's an event, not just a game in itself. It's something bigger than that.
@Excalibur_120 nope its because the points are stupid its a faithful remake you had no masters quest on the orginal., some shimmering ? Caus eim sure that clearly took him out of the experience it comes out of just looking for reason not to rate the game fully , I have seen them forgive worst
Master Quest better show up as a free update. Says I, who have every opportunity in the past to play the Master Quest version but couldn't be bother to.
@Olliemar28 you review gripes are stupid there was no masters quest in the orginal , shimmering you complained about ? Really cause im sure that took you out of the experience and 1 save file ? 🤣🤣🤣 I wish people would actually review games for what they are
@oleface What a measured and well-written comment, thank you.
@CairiB It feels like a nice blend of the original Ocarina of Time and Nintendo's more recent 3D Zelda games. It very much represents the 'classic' Zelda experience that's kind of been lost with BotW and TotK, and I hope it informs Nintendo's approach with the next mainline game.
@8bit-Man They're still fun and hold up really well. Nintendo has made some minor alterations to help players parse the puzzles a bit better, but it's nothing major.
Nicely written and totally fair. I saw the comment count and knew it must be a less than 10 and people would be all bunged up about it. I'd give it that 9 alone for being an extremely safe remake, with distracting over the top flourishes especially in combat. You fight an awful lot in this game, it doesn't need to feel like an explosion every sword strike. The score is pretty but a bit overcooked in spots, though that's also typical of the modern day. Subtlety is a premium, everything has to be glammed up. It's like an overcorrection for the excessive drabness.
There's no hero mode either. A remake should have at least a hook or two to get the original players a little excited. But they did a cool job of importing some continuity from recent titles and of course they couldn't stray much from the source on a title this beloved, where gamers lose their mind over a 9/10.
That's likely for the best — could you imagine the Vesuvius-level response from folks online if they'd gone full FFVII: Remake with it?
The comments about the score from people who've not even touched the game yet didn't disappoint. Excellent work, everybody.
@0_Cassiel_0 It does feel at times this site is overly harsh on the big games and I do wonder sometimes if it's because they're afraid to look like biased fanboys or something. :-/ I don't remember seeing a game having one save file listed as a negative before and Nintendo's done that loads of times.
Ooof, yeah, I think the 9 out of 10 is warranted without the inclusion of Master Quest and multiple save slots... I wonder what the thought process behind that was? Why does Nintendo have to... be Nintendo sometimes? lol
I'm going to replay this game annually. I'd like to keep my original playthrough of it saved though... Guess I'll have to make another profile.
As always, I appreciate the review Ollie!
I am sad that they didn't include Master Quest.
Resident Evil 2 remake really spoiled me cause I get disappointed every time new remakes are announced.
I don’t want a variation of an experience I already had; I want a brand new one based on the original.
Yes I am going to enjoy greatly this switch 2 version of OOT but it’s still going to be the same experience I had on GameCube and 3ds.
Eh, plug in the N64 cart and there's no master quest. It's absence is unfortunate (considering their own precedent on the last OoT "remake") but not a mark against it. As a previous commenter stated, I don't play OoT for the challenge, I play because it's OoT. Very excited!
@Excalibur_120
Disagree with the Price argument.
They have put alot of time and money into this, so the pricetag is more than fair. Even when master quest is added later on, and maybe will cost 10$, its still 100% fair priced.
And if this isnt a 10/10 remake, what is a «good» remake ?
Their plan was to take this old game into 2026 and not add alot of new things that messes up the formula. I have to play it myself tomorrow, but from what I have seen, it looks like they have done a «perfect» job with this and also not communicated anything that could lead to false hopes.
As expected, this guy always reviews 1 point lower for games that would typically be expected to score higher on a Nintendo-focused site.
@Olliemar28 aw fab! This is pretty much exactly what I was hoping you would say in terms of their forward planning. It does feel like they are testing the waters so let’s see what happens in the future.
Excuse all my beautiful errors in that first comment. 🙃🤣
@Broosh this was my first intro to it. I didn’t know that it was even a thing!
Only one manual save file? Per profile, of course. So who cares...
Roll on my Friday off. I cant flippin wait. Already told the wife not to expect any house work to be done when she gets home from work 🤣
@Suketoudara Ollie is still feeling guilty over the Metroid Prime 4 review.
@Suketoudara but they end up looking out of touch. Not like Edge magazine with its ridiculous super low scores dor decades, but still. Also one save file, when you can have multiple accounts on the same console is not even a negative thing. Sounds just like "too much water"
I thought that I was going to be pissed at them safe walling me from playing Master Quest on first play through, not the whole thing missing entirely! 😓 Maaaaybe I can see them adding it later as DLC, but who knows at this point… I wanted to play it right now (also for this masterpiece I like everything to be on the physical cart as is, day 1. Very disappointing and I feel it’s warranted to dock a point (never mind the one save or little gfx blemishes that do not impact me); for people who have already beaten the game at least, considering the whole thing is pretty much 1:1 with the 1998 original and the 3DS remake too… I’m not one to replay games over and over, I find lack of challenge boring and considering I beat the normal game on 3DS again, Master Quest was the way for me to experience again one of my fave games ever and still find it challenging and fresh besides the graphics and little changes. Bummer. For first time players (or ones who don’t mind replaying games they’ve beaten many times), it’s all good tho, enjoy!
@Markatron84 it's simple really, it's all in context, because when you have so many 10/10 or 5/5 or 100/100 reviews from critics with 96% on metacritic overall right now- some of which mind you are not even focused on Nintendo - and you see a 9/10 from a nintendo focused site due to not having a mode some would say not essential and which could be added as a DLC later on and the one save file.. then well I understand why people might be sceptical?
Oh god I’m skimming the comments section… I shouldn’t be surprised considering what goes on in here at any Digital Foundry article or Edge review of Nintendo games, but man the CRINGE. Booohooo you gave it a 9 out of 10, criminal, it’s a TEN! How dare you report facts! What a freakin embarrassment, fanboys are so passé.
Removed - trolling/baiting
Removed - unconstructive feedback
@Username_1 so because they focus on Nintendo then they should be over positive on how they feel about a 1st party game and inflate the score? Why, to appease the fanboys? They lauded the game as GREAT and scored it a NINE, not a FIVE, get over yourselves. A reviewer should give a pass to something they (correctly so, I might add) feel should be reported on because fanboys cry over Metacritic average, 😂 For many people who have already beaten the game, the lack of Master Quest might be very impactful because it means you play on autopilot with zero challenge. They wrote that they only died ONCE during the entire 25 hours+, don’t you see how it can be disappointing and impact how you feel about a game? Especially since it was something that had been “fixed” since Wind Waker’s preorder bonus giving out Master Quest! And then on 3DS. If you feel it doesn’t make a difference for you and others, it’s simple: don’t take it into account! For the reviewer, and others, it did. End of story. There is nothing out of touch about scoring a NINE and some
Others a TEN, heck even and EIGHT would be perfectly fine because these are PERSONAL opinions.
@repsahj yeah noticed that too. he tries too hard not to be seen as a nintendo fanboy. look at me I dare to give a 9 as a Nintendo Life writer.
Seeing as how I didn't like Master Quest, this will be a 10/10 for me. ☺️
@Olliemar28 I enjoyed the review, thanksBeing a latecomer to Nintendo, I've never actually played OOT (I have played a few of the other Zelda games but bounced off them) so have no skin in the game regarding the score. So as a complete newbie with no context to what came before, is this a must play?
I’m thoroughly convinced NintendoLife is IGN for Nintendo.
96 on Metacritic… once again this site giving one of the poorest reviews.
Might be time to close shop, eh?
Also - Pokemon ZA soundtrack is now on Nintendo Music!! (Day 7 of NintendoLife not reporting this)
The distant visuals not looking the best is a tiny bit worrying. If there's one thing I can count on with 1st party games that I can't with 3rd parties, it's for the games to look nice and sharp in docked and handheld. But i doubt it'll be as bad as a 3rd party game
Also I couldve sworn someone who had the game early on twitter, confirmed the game had multiple saves. Thats confusing
@Uquntz Oh yes, I'd say so. If you've bounced off other Zelda games, I can't say whether or not you'll enjoy this one, but it's certainly worth a shot.
@Olliemar28 Hey! are japanese voices an option out are we stuck with English?
No Master Quest? Well, that is disappointing, to say the least. I bet they're going to sell it to us as DLC later...
But overall the review doesn't surprise me. It would have been something if they botched the remake, which they clearly did not. I'm still going to have a ton of fun playing it. But really hoping for Master Quest later!
Master Quest is totally going to be DLC. I can feel it.
I think people put far too much emotional investment into a score number. Ultimately it's a very broad and arbitrary indication of quality, especially when there are so many hundreds of games with completely different facets of what marks their quality, and everyone has their own basis of what denotes a rating.
@Uquntz Absolutely! You’ve never played it, it’s one of the GOATs.
@rjejr Never had an N64! My cousin did / does and he is with overwhelming majority in considering it a masterpiece. I haven’t decided what I’m doing yet! My son is very keen to play so might let him work away while I continue with Resident Evil 4 REmake. Interested to hear what you do yourself!
@H_Hazuki They are an option, yeah.
@Alcea Agreed. Can’t say I love when a review is done on a remake/remaster (especially if such a beloved game) and the complaint is “played it to safe”. How is that an effective measurable metric of the experience/quality of the game?
It’s still Ocarina of Time, was always going to be. What was the reviewer expecting? Ganondorf invading the forest and wiping out all Kokiri? Sheesh.
In the Wind Waker preorder bonus disc that contained original Ocarina and the first version of master quest you had six save files (3 files in each version). Then six files again in the 3DS version for the same reason. Now only 1 file and no master quest
My 1st save file would always be my 100% completion run which I'd keep forever. 2nd file would be for 3 heart runs where I'd never collect any heart pieces/containers and as few items as possible (no lense of truth, one bottle, only green tunic etc.). My 3rd file would then be used for all future replays of the game where I'd complete as much, or as little as I wanted.
Having to create two more profiles on my Switch 2 to do that sucks and it's a shame my play data hours won't be tracked beyond my first play through since I'll be using my 2nd and 3rd profile for future replays.
@Olliemar28 I just wanna say I'm sorry for any comments bashing you over giving your opinion. Appreciate you!
(That said, am I the only one here who thought Master Quest just... wasn't very good? I mean yeah it was harder but I personally really didn't like the remixed dungeons. They felt very amateurish to me.)
Many games with perfect scores still have plenty of minor problems. However, this should not detract from their perfect scores. A game being perfect shouldn't just mean it's flawless and free of errors.
@MamaSymphonia I'm really not familiar. I got the original remix with my pre-order for Wind Waker back in the day, so I do think I tried it a little. But if I remember correctly, I found it very challenging and walked away from it.
@LXP8 Just wait for the Nintendo Switch 3 Edition. You'll get another save file. 😉
No game has a right to a 10. not having 3 save slots and Master Quest on purchase is more than fair for a drop in a point.
Huge respect to @Olliemar28 for the integrity. The fanatics' POV doesn't really matter anyway. Even nintendo knows this wasnt supposed to be the big zelda pricing it at 59. Its a present to old time fans and it delivers
@hanzel
"all i read in your review is 10, yet you gave a 9"
are we reading the same review?
✌️
I really am torn by this game. On the one hand, I'm excited to experience the game again in such a breathtaking way. On the other hand, I'm worried it won't live up to the hype simply because I know the original game inside out so there won't be much in the way of surprises. The lack of Master Quest does bum me out too as I enjoyed the extra challenge. Some of the smaller changes will probably niggle at me too lol (not being able to rename Link, no additional save slots and no file select screen!)
Just want to point out that I feel pretty confident that we would have possibly the same level of vitriole (maybe from the other side of the argument?) if this score had been a 10/10. It feels like every time this site or IGN releases a perfect score, they are criticized for being corporate shills, Nintendoters, lazy reviewers, etc. So, let's please be respectful and kind, take a couple breaths, and try to have some perspective. I know it can be frustrating to feel like your favorite/beloved [blank] isn't getting the appreciation or glory or credibility you feel it deserves - I was hoping for a 10 here, too! - but it doesn't have to take anything away from the enjoyment of it. I guarantee you are not alone with your love and passion for these media. But let's also try to understand that we - the people writing these reviews, included - are all individuals with subjective points-of-view. Everyone else's opinions are just as valid as your own. Share away, but can't we keep it reasonable and tolerant? Please. Hope everyone that wants to gets to enjoy their time with this game! Looking forward to playing it myself, tomorrow! 🕊🌈
Was the 9/10 a typo???? How is this not a 10/10???????
Getting the series' fundamentals wrong (I mean, every Zelda game up to and including Ocarina had 3 save files and renaming) is extremely damning with a remaster, I think 9/10 is generous no matter how shiny they made this game.
The notion of breezing through Ocarina again only in "generic 3rd person action game" form sounds so boring I can hardly stand it. We are enjoying our current playthrough of the original, though 🤗
If the entire point of this remaster is to recreate the magic of my childhood playthrough, and offer the same for a new generation that never played the original, then not letting the player name Link is a narrow but deep failure on both fronts.
@RedYoshi999 I hear you on those concerns. It's been a while since I last played, but I still was hoping for more surprises. All the same, I think I'll probably get absorbed in it and be very pleased. I would also welcome small additions with post-release updates, just to continue the fun. It could happen.
How dare you score this 0.6 points lower than the average! heresy! burn the wizard!
@Olliemar28
"Cons: (...)
I have not noticed this in any videos or photos from the game so far.
How bad does it look?
Can you add a photo example of this in the review?
Preferably with a comparision between docked and undocked mode.
I personally feel like it should have been a 10/10. This remake is titled The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. I see no Definitive Edition or Deluxe Edition.
I know that GC and 3DS included Master Quest, but the original did not. I realize there isn't 3 save files, but you can create multiple profiles, which technically gives you more than 3.
If this is the best way to play the original, then that seems like mission accomplished, but that is just my opinion.
@matt_e
9/10 is "mission accomplished" by any reasonable measure.
@Sonicka https://www.nintendolife.com/reviews/nintendo-switch-2/mewgenics
@-wc- 9/10 - simply the best way to play a 10/10 game. 🤔
@matt_e
they specifically said it wasn't definitive in the headline.
"non-definitive way to play 10/10 game that arguably never needed a remake to begin with" sounds like a 9 at most, to me, frankly ✌️
What about the frame rates and performance?
@Saad_Moonwalker
"It’s not all perfect, though. Keeping such a stunning game running at 60fps on a handheld takes some jiggery-pokery, and Nintendo's solution has resulted in a few visual blemishes. Assets in the distance — mountains and trees — look overly smooth and there’s some shimmering going on when you pan the camera around. It’s nowhere near as severe as Xenoblade Chronicles X on Switch 2, but it’s definitely something you’ll notice occasionally, particularly during handheld play.
Overall resolution takes a notable hit undocked, too, to the point where even Link himself can look a little fuzzy at times. It definitely needs mentioning, although it wasn't significantly detrimental to my experience. Keeping the game running smoothly feels like the more important priority, and Nintendo has nailed that aspect."
@Olliemar28 its very simple question did one save file or shimmering break your experience? Did it make you lose interest in the game in any form or fashion ? Did the difficulty level hurt your experience?
About what I expected, though I admit I'm surprised the Master Quest isn't at least unlockable like in Ocarina of Time 3D. I think that's worth the slight score drop. Lacking multiple save slots is remedied by using different profiles. This is far from the first Switch family game to do this.
Unfortunately for me, this release has become very bittersweet. I won't receive the game until Monday ($10 physical pre-order discount through Amazon), but at this point it doesn't matter. Kind of hard to play a game when I had my Zelda Switch 2 console pulled out from under me last minute and don't know when I'll be able to secure one.
Hopefully, Master Quest and additional save files get patched in later down the line like how split screen was added back to the Star Fox remake in September. It's not the end of the world for me if they don't add it, though. I'm still excited to play when I pick it up later down the line.
Also, calm down people. 9/10 is a very fair review score.
@-wc- Why in the world are you stalking the comments and replying to anyone who dares criticize NL for giving it a 9? Surely you have better, more productive things to do? We get that you hate the game(and modern Nintendo and AAA gaming in general), you've made your point, respectfully please calm down and let others enjoy things man
Interesting that the definitive way to play a perfect game that was improved in every key capacity only scored a 9. Also, it is not quite the definitive remake because it doesn't include Master Quest, which was something never in the original and not easily obtainable. I can accept that! Looking at Star Fox and its extra content, notably Challenge Mode, it would be a shell of a game for veterans without that.
I'm fairly certain Nintendo will deliver Master Quest eventually. Right now they want you playing Zelda Ocarina as it should be played. That's especially so for new players, so it's a shame we didn't get a second opinion in the review from that perspective. We're not all Ocarina addicts. Even myself, who only played it once all those years ago, much of it will be very fresh.
....What about the King Zora cutscene, though?
@HubbaHunt Hopefully that will be changed with a future patch and possible Master Quest being added in the future also.
@-wc- You don't intend to buy this remake for a console you don't own, and have no intentions of owning in the future, because it doesn't have a Master Quest version included. I'm sure you could purchase the Master Quest version for your GameCube or play an emulated version on your Steamdeck if you were really that bothered about playing it.
@-wc- So as I understand, it took some visual hits but as for the the frame rates it's 60fps so it's perfectly smooth?
Anyway, this is a fair review and a 9/10 is a very, very positive score. The next main entry will likely be a 10/10 as Nintendo is known for taking everybody by surprise with something really fresh.
@King_MFW
"replying to anyone who dares criticize NL for giving it a 9?"
I didn't reply to you, did I? 🤔
It's a bit rich that someone who is on here lamenting a 9/10 with hysterical punctuation is telling me to calm down so they can enjoy themselves. ✌️
@Slowdive
" The next main entry will likely be a 10/10 as Nintendo is known for taking everybody by surprise with something really fresh."
from your mouth to God's ears! 🤗
I can't wait.. this is a great encouraging review. 10's for a remake is a very hard ask.. It's also a personal opinion. Reviewed by people who are veterans of the original game - A remake needs to not just look and sound good, but maybe offer something entirely new - but that was not the goal here. The goal was to make the best version of Ocarina of Time and I think this will be it. n64 version was just ground breaking. It's an unfair comparison. As for 3DS version - there is a master quest and it was 2011. Things change.
The challenge: Zelda games have always given you a choice. If you accept the heart containers and spend time exploring and getting all the pieces of heart, your travels will be a lot easier. Some players want to be as powerful as can be. Others want more of a challenge - getting only the heart containers from bosses..or maybe not picking them up at all. That is your movable challenge bar.
It's going to be a good end of my week..
@Saad_Moonwalker
"So as I understand, it took some visual hits but as for the the frame rates it's 60fps so it's perfectly smooth?"
that is my read on it, too 👍
Master Quest can/will probably be added later.
I find multiple save files within a profile to be annoying.
@Slowdive it's already 10/10 everywhere else.. just not here
@matt_e yeap, I’ve heard nothing but good things about Mewgenics. Not my sort of genre however.
Does Navi still say "hey listen?" or does she actually speak now? I know I was never bothered by her original dialogue personally, in fact I actually found it really endearing.
The fact that you have to be named "Link" is interesting. I believe Nintendo realizes they have to move away from the whole "the player and the game world need a LINK" pun thing it had going for it. For a movie franchise to work he has to actually be a distinct character. (with a voice.) But imo they already undermined this stance with their timeline logic. (the Hero of Time lost? uhh no I didn't!)
(there's zero chance master quest will be added, but a hard mode from the start shouldn't be too much to ask)
Cool, maybe one day
@-wc- Why expect features that would be in a deluxe or definitive edition and not in the original and dock the score as a result?
We can agree to disagree. It is my opinion and yours differs and that's fine.
I'm a fan of the game. I played it day one, when it was originally released, and again on day one when it was released again on the 3DS. I don't own a Switch 2 yet so I will not be playing this one on day 1.
Having said all that, I think that Master Quest should have been fully unlocked and available on day 1. Many of the fans of this game have multiple full play-throughs and having this available on day 1 would have been nice for those gamers. Nintendo often make their games basically play themselves for younger gamers, why not throw an olive branch to the gamers that have been playing their games 30-40 years?
....and having one save state for this game, and on this system; unacceptable.
.........but the game is incredible and this version looks amazing! I'm jealous of everyone playing this tomorrow. If you are a younger gamer and never played this, or missed it for whatever reason, you owe it to yourself to play one of the greatest games ever created. Enjoy!!!!!
Never have i seen a bunch of people whining and complaining about a score not getting a perfect score when the game got a 9 score. Such babies sorry to say.
All the comments from people who haven't played the game saying it's a 10........ <insert clown emoji>
Fewer save slots, the lack of a Master Quest, occasional visual issues, and decisions that are likely tied to making the inclusion of voice acting more convenient (being unable to rename Link; Final Fantasy X made it work fine with the protagonist, which is VERY dialogue heavy, so basically any game with voice acting has no excuse, really), are perfectly valid complaints.
I'm still very much looking forward to playing the game this weekend! Planning to make a whole event of it, meeting up with my sister out of town and cosplaying as Link for the lulz and everything (close enough to Halloween that it's basically being treated as a Halloween party). Been gathering materials for the outfit over the past month; got the whole shebang, sword, shield, tunic, rupees and fairy figurines, all manner of straps and belts, the works.
for me this game is a solid 10 cant wait to pick it up tomorrow along with stellar blade.
@KevinP Majority of us played the original plus this remake is 100 times better with all the improvements not just to the visuals and graphics but also the layouts and boss fights have improved along with the soundtrack as well.
I already had the game pre ordered long ago and looking forward to revisiting this game.
I'll probably wait a bit to play it though since I'm still going through Fortune's Weave but OoT is next on my to playlist.
I am so excited to receive and play it tomorrow! Even though the game seems to be fully modernised in terms of controls, the purist in me wonders if it would also be fully compatible with the N64 pad as well (more of a curiosity than a dealbreaker)
So it's Mario RPG all over again. Simplified and easy
@Username_1 The actual simple answer is: no one here can say "this game should have gotten X/10 instead of 9/10", because they haven't played it.
I'll never understand in a million years why people come to a review of a game and moan about whatever score the outlet slapped onto it. Reviews are opinions. If Ollie Reynolds deems the game to be a 9/10, then he deems it to be a 9/10. What exactly is the point of anyone saying "I don't like the score you have given this unreleased game which I haven't even played yet" because they think it's too high or too low?
It's completely ridiculous. Just play the game when it comes out, and if you don't like this review or the score, then write your own review and give it your own score, so people can come and tell you that you're wrong as well.
Make a remake and you will reevaluate the original out of it's prominence. That's how it always goes. If they were smart they would resell the original as well separately and sales would increase for that as well.
Nothing makes for nostalgia more than a bunch of young people telling you this is better.
@RiasGremory How do you know this is 100 times better if you haven't played it? That's my entire point. You could be completely correct, but Nintendo Life has played it. And they gave it a 9. People who haven't played it, insist it's a 10. It makes zero sense.
I will enjoy the heck out of this game.
No Master Quest is a true disappointment, though.
So many new Zelda players are coming from BotW and TotK and are gonna be shocked when the credits roll after 30-40 hours.
@King_MFW
oh dear, it seems that I've run afoul of the Nintendo vigilante tone police.
Please quote my words that insult another user if you'd like to be taken seriously, thanks. ✌️
(EDIT - or, delete your preceding comment as a tacit admission that you are absolutely full of it, that works too 👍)
It seems that you can't handle opinions that differ from your own, but that is all I've shared, here. I hope you enjoy the remaster when you play it, even though someone gave it a 9 out of ten.
Can't wait for it tomorrow!!
@Markatron84 missing the point. The fact is the game has been given a perfect score from the vast majority of critics. This review is the minority marking it down for the reasons stated. It's fine. It's an opinion of this site - not a popular one it looks like but of course respected. Hence people are wondering why? Some of the reasons stated for marking it down in context with everyone else are perceived as slightly harsh? That's another opinion... All good!
Looking forward to the game. Thanks
If you have never played the original and have no nostalgic feelings in that regard. Is this then still a fantastic game when comparing it to modern games coming out? I mean, a lot have happened since the original came out. Can somebody give it an an unbiased comment as if it was a new gaming launching today?
@matt_e
I think it's a fair expectation that the new release be "definitive," and certainly the discourse has largely revolved around will it or wont it be THE definitive way to play Oot, so framing it this way in the review makes sense to me.
incidentally, how is the score "docked?" surely it's understood that a 10/10 game in 1998 does not automatically score a 10 in 2026 by default?
how many times has it been reiterated by this website that the score is not the result of a pros minus cons equation? or that it is subjective?
I encourage differing opinions and I like to understand where people are coming from, hence my questions. I hope the game ends up being a 10/10 for you, when you play it! 🥳👍
@Suketoudara
And how many of those games were remaking a game with three save files? The con here is for the removal of something from a previous release, which a remake shall be accounted for. A 9 is a fantastic score, I don't see the problem at all.
As for Master Quest, I think people are severely underestimating the appeal, it is not just a harder version of the same game like changing two lizalfos for two Stalfos, it is a very clever remixing of the dungeons, (even the mini dungeons), and that without modifying anything about the structures themselves, in practice almost duplicating the ammount of content in the game. I hope it comes back as free DLC.
@oleface
So a broken experience and a game that loses someone interest is a 9/10? What is an 8 then, a blank screen?
Had shipping confirmation wahoooo!
@AmplifyMJ I honestly don't know. At this point I'm not even sure who's going to play it actually. My 2 kids and I watched my wife play Echoes of Wisdom so might go that route again, but maybe they'll each want to play it. My oldest started it on 3DS but quit b/c they got bored.
We'll figure it out in the car for 20 hours the next 5 days. If they ever give it back to me at the dealership where I currently wait on pricing to see what I get done. Currently suggesting new spark plugs and "engine cleaning". But no prices yet. I should go ask.
A lot of people seem to forget that a 9/10 is still an extremely good score. Read the review people!
Having only one save file is quite interesting considering every mainline Legend of Zelda game so far had at least 2-3 save slots. My guess is that since Nintendo knew the Switch 2 is already been jailbreak (probably should had never publicly acknowledge that even if a jailbreak is found and could be done, a smart hacker would wait until the Switch 2 generation is over before he open his big fat mouth about it cause now future Nintendo Switch 2 games will be made to have some sort anti-exploit feature or DRM in them for the rest of the gen), they may had reduced down on the save file thing to just one so to prevent hacking players from finding exploits. Having only one save slot now up the risk of those who wants to find exploit in the game cause now doing it risk them of harming their save progress while at the same time added a kind of urgency to newer player since that's the only save point they had and must know when to save before tackling such a dungeon or boss battle.
As for the Master Quest, not having it is understandable since this was meant to be as vanilla as the original could get, the 3DS version getting it was merely a bonus since not many people bought the 3DS. Still in this time and era of gaming it wouldn't surprise me if Nintendo would added it later as free or pay DLC depending on how they made those contents. Overall the 9/10 score totally justified what Nintendo did with the game. People had to remember that Nintendo doesn't market this remake for to the Master Quest, they market it as a remake of the vanilla version that'll come with better graphics, smoother performance, and modern qol features so no Master Quest post game contents is not that big of a deal.
Same score as Metroid Prime 4. Better stay away from this one
No Master Quest is a bummer, but I'm still so excited to play Ocarina of Time in 4K. It's time to return to the Zelda game that started it all for me.
9/10 - too much water dungeon
@Username_1 I'm not missing the point, simply because there isn't one
Everyone's reviews and scores are subjective. People need to stop putting so much stock into them.
It's. Stupid.
“I’ve not been able to test Hori’s Electric Ocarina (and who knows where Nintendo’s official instrument is at)”
Wait is Nintendo’s ocarina different from Hori’s? I see Nintendo is selling Hori’s on their website and thought that was the officially licensed ocarina.
Guys stop fighting, I also think it's a 9, specially if it takes a considerable hit on it's visuals on handheld...
Ouch, who hit me?! I'm gonna catch yo-
Ouch! again? Stop it! I just think that as good as Ocarina is, a 9, an almost perfect score is vali-
Ouch, arghhhh! Hey, why are you tying me up?! No guys, I'm not a wizard! No, I didn't kill your crops, you don't even have them!
RIP,

PS: Should've been an 8.8…
@Joeynator3000 It's sexier than ever
Great review and you’ve highlighted some things that other reviewers have glossed over, like performance in handheld mode.
I give this review 10/10.
@nitte That entirely depends on how highly you value those "modern games coming out." I think a lot of them suffer from a lot of problems that older games don't, because the technological, economic, and cultural constraints have changed. Conversely, I also think older games suffer from plenty of problems that new games don't, so it evens out.
Anyway, yes, Ocarina of Time is a masterpiece, not despite its age but because of it and because of all the things it does that modern games don't. That's why you play classics, to experience a different way of doing things. You already have modern games if you want modern games.
That's why I play everything. It's the only way.
Yep sounds like what I expected. I guess a bit miffed about the lack of challenge but hopefully they add MQ at some point in the future (probably right around the time they find those ocarinas to flog).
Enjoy the game everyone.
One manual save, no auto save? Just more Nintendo BS. No Matter Quest. I’ve never had the chance to experience that. This would have been a great way to do so. Very disappointed about that. Lack of challenge also hurts. Seems like an 8/10 to me.
lol it has less content than the 3ds or even the GameCube remake (no master quest), only one save file, and you can’t even rename your guy.
@Aquinas not until they remake/remaster Zelda The Wind Waker!!
Wii U was an improvement but we need it on Switch 2 to have it forever and without all that bloom.
@Koda1000 There's autosave, several of them actually. But yes we want more save files! Dragon's Dogma 2 had only one and it was a horrible one without multiple autosaves so it was a struggle, until their update this year that added 3 save files and other saves. So, maybe Nintendo will change their mind with an update.
Why would they release any extra game modes when that can come a few months later as, hopefully, free DLC, to extend game lifetime.
What Nintendo REALLY needs to do with their games is get together with Randomizer Modders and add them to their games. This would add infinite replay ability for those who like them.
OOT N64 Randomizers are insane, Metroid Primes as well
Want more save files, just make a new account
I'll confess I never played more than a few minutes of the original game, and I haven't read through Ollie's review (yet) for wanting to avoid anything spoiler-y. I just want this Ocarina remake to be as fresh and surprising as possible when I finally play it.
That said, it sounds like another high-quality glow-up of a huge N64 hit, and I'm looking forward to it! I'll be in line at my local midnight release tonight, just to nerd out with the other video game fans there. (And maybe to look, in vain, for the official Ocarina flute that Nintendo announced.)
Reading the part about handheld performance, fuzzy Link, overly smooth distant scenery is disappointing. I’ve been playing through Xenoblade Chronicles X DE (the original Switch edition) in handheld, as I play all games in handheld, and I am mystified that a new Zelda has less populated and detailed distant scenery that XBX a WiiU game.
If we look at all the other 10/10s on NL there is only one where the reviewer couldn't think of anything wrong. Tetris Effect Connected. Therefore, it doesn't need to be perfect to be a 10/10
Ideally the game arrives at my doorstep tomorrow and I get a chance to play in the evening. First time preordering from Nintendo and I’ve been pleasantly surprised that they try to ensure that the game arrives on release date.
Now, can I complete my 3DS run beforehand? Currently on the Spirit Temple and then I imagine it would be onward to Ganondorf.
i think the overall metacritic score is a little to high based mostly on a combination of nostalgia and pretty graphics..
I kind of figured this wasn't going to have any major difficulty spikes for veterans, and I'm not too bothered by the lack of Master Quest, since I just see that as a glorified ROM hack.
Once I get my hands on this game though, I'm going to make this challenging for myself by doing a three-heart run. Won't be my first time doing so, since I've done this on N64 and 3DS, and I've almost completed the game without dying at all in my most recent run, if not for the the Stalfos in Ganon's Tower.
@Kensui You do know of course that the Master Quest of Ocarina first appeared in 2003, eight years before the 3DS, right? When the N64 version of Ocarina was made playable on the Gamecube?
If you think the MS debuted on the 3DS remaster, you need to get your facts straight. The Master Quest was always meant to be a part of the original experience. It only didn't make the game because the N64 disk drive was a sales bust.
I believe that many Nintendo games are massively overrated including Breath of the Wild, so I enjoy reviews that are more objective when approaching Nintendo's games. I played Breath of the Wild on Wii U and Switch for hundreds of hours on each, and still think the critical reviews are way fairer than the ridiculously hyperbolic praise that it and its sequel received.
That said, Ocarina of Time is one of Nintendo's best games ever, so the 10s are deserved. It's really a masterpiece that I have completed many times on different platforms 100%. Being a remake of a 1998 game, though, if the reviewer expected something more, 9/10 is also deserved. I'm sure that I'm going to love it, but also miss something extra for us, long-time fans. Something like an extra dungeon before getting the Light Medallion would have been welcomed.
I’ll refrain from buying it for a couple of years until my doughter is a couple of years older so she can olay it by herself. She isn’t native english speaker and only six years old right now so I think it will be a bit hard for her still. But to be able to give her this experience in a couple of years will be great
This reads, plays, looks and feels a 10/10.
It is a shame for a site of this size and with such a long-standing reputation to seek attention through this ridiculous and indefensible score review.
you did not just say this game is hyperrealistic lol
a highly detailed and stylized art style =/= hyperrealistic. in fact, it's not realistic at all. it very much feels like the original was brough into life with a modern feel but the same style
@Olliemar28 surely it’s now the definitive way to play OOT? I would have said 3D was the de facto way to play the game on release and for me personally it was my go to version to play (having played the original at launch…God I’m old) and this will definitely now surpass that as the best way to play OOT and the preferred version i.e. the definitive version. If it isn’t, then is it the N64 original, 3DS or VC?
i think nintendo life review is probably one of the most sensible ones they are not drinking the koolaid. i am surprised no one has mentioned the remake as goty material..
Literally bought an NS2 about 5hrs ago for this game. Damn thing won't connect to my wifi, but recognises everybody else ugh.
I use s25 and s26 hotspots for everything but this damn machine isn't detecting them. Got an IT mate coming in a few minutes. Not happy. Only bought it for OoT 😞
I don't know, I feel like a faithful remake that improves on the original and doesn't take a step back should at LEAST receive the same score one would give the original.
And since OoT is widely recognized as a 10/10.....
@Olliemar28 hi Ollie. Thank you for the review. I wondered if you felt the negatives were worthy of a whole point deduction? Obviously that is the way the review scores work so I understand that. But did you feel swayed between 9 & 10, or definitely a 9. Would you have gone in between if you the option?
I hope you don’t mind me asking such a fussy question.
TL;DR the remake is being reviewed here, not the original game.
Everyone saying this "obviously should have been a 10/10" is kind of missing the point of the review. Most of this game's audience is going to be people familiar with the original and probably even accept that one as a "10/10" masterpiece. The review is for the REMAKE, not the original. In a hypothetical world where Nintendo released the same exact game with literally no changes (graphical or gameplay related) at $60/$70, would the reviewers be obligated to give the remake a 10/10? I would say no, and probably even rate it negatively given the lack of effort put into the remake.
Based on the review, the 9/10 makes complete sense. There's a masterpiece underlying game, and a lot of effort HAS been put in to make the game smoother and more visually appealing without sacrificing the original's style. BUT, it doesn't have the hero mode included in previous versions of the game and adds very little of significance to the folks who have played the game multiple times. That diminishes its value as a remake, especially at the price they're selling it at.
When money gets better for me, I definitely want to get a Switch 2 and this. It's disappointing that there's no Master Quest, but everything else about this remake seems fantastic.
Taking a whole point off just because the game doesn't have a second quest 🙄 Meanwhile most other publications shower it with 10:s. I mean the original OOT didn't have master quest either and no one was complaining. It's like playing Witcher 3 through and lowering the score because the game didn't have another full length adventure after the ending. Nonsensical.
I haven’t played Ocarina of Time since the 3DS remake.
I got an early copy and the game feels pretty new but familiar.
It’s good.
No buts
Fun
@Olliemar28
"Cons: (...)
Distant visuals look overly smooth with some shimmering"
I think this was done on purpose:
"Ask the Developer Vol. 24: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time — Part 2"
"the overworld"
"Shida: Getting the visual balance right was especially challenging in large areas like Hyrule Field. We wanted the scenery to feel vast and beautiful, but we also had to avoid giving players the impression that they could go anywhere they could see, even beyond the mountains. So we gave the areas that could actually be explored a high level of detail, used slightly less visual information in inaccessible areas so that they would be seen as distant scenery (...)"
Look, I can sort of understand that there's no Master quest, but not even a hero mode? Really?
Hero mode / master quest or any kind of hard mode have been a staple of almost ALL of the 3d Zelda remakes in the past. It is expected to be there. And Ocarina is easily the most played game of a the entire series so it is the one that needed it the most. Some hero mode completely transform the game. Skyward Sword for example should never be played in normal mode, the hero mode makes the game much better and it even makes some of its mechanics make a lot more sense.
Fingers crossed for at least a proper hero mode to be added in a future update. In fact it really makes very little sense that they did not see it as being absolutely necessary.
I completely understand the review score based solely on that point.
@Misima Because the newer one fixes a lot of problems.
@Koda1000 I agree. It concerns me that so early in the Switch 2 lifespan we're already seeing such a marquee release by Nintendo struggle with these things. I hoped the Switch 2 would better handle some of these small details for at least the first few years of its life.
@-wc- Which God though? And are their ears pointy?
@Kensui Persona 3 Reload also lost point because it didn't include content that was present in an earlier remake. Just like the Master Sword here. And the people who wrote in the (Persona 3 Reload) comments agreed. Why should it be different in this case?
@Cia besides the fact that the scoring system is based on more than a sum of any one factor and not just the listed bullets at the end, the perfect 10’s other sites were definitely handed out far too easily from nostalgia.
This is an excellent and very faithful remake, and OOT was a remarkable game for its time. However, it doesn’t push the bar as an experience like it did 28 years ago, and there are much better Zelda-likes out that that iterated on this formula long after the game came and went.
9 is therefore pretty darn generous of NintendoLife if you ask me. Especially when you consider that this is the second time Nintendo have re-released this title.
@AussieMcBucket
1) Impossible to know or say.
2) Yes, obviously.
Oof that first con is a big one for me
@Markatron84 are people allowed to question this subjective review against the vast majority of other subjective reviews which however happen to concur it's a 10/10 game?
Over generalising and saying it's stupid to bother with reviews anyway because they're all subjective etc.. ok.. so why be triggered when people ask if the lack of multiple save files and an additional mode which could be added later are worth the point deduction?
Intrigued however, if this is not the definitive version as stated in the title to.. Currently.. play the game, which one is it? The 3ds on a small screen or the one that came out 28 years ago?
Thanks
Phew, so you’ve decided that the omission of Master Quest keeps this from being perfect. That’s very arbitrary.
Nintendo Life gave 100 to the 3DS version ...
Removed - trolling/baiting
I really would rather have multiple save slots per game. I don’t like the new system. I have ended up with content split across multiple accounts before and it is enough of an an annoyance that I choose the messing around with disabling the cloud save updating and then having a quick play through over it even though that is annoying and I suspect I will mess that up at some point.
I have played the Master Quest more than anything (Even though I had the USA N64 version of the original I probably didn’t play it as much as the emulated Master Quest (I think I only played through Wind Waker twice)).
I do hope the Master Quest they are saving for DLC with significant differences.
Amazon have at least shipped it to me now. (Said Tuesday until about 6 hrs ago).
(Hopefully they don’t have to tie up the main Zelda team if they do MM).
This is why reviews are a joke. This should be a 10. You said it's the best way to play the game, and both prior versions have a 10.
@Olliemar28 this will be the first time for me to play OOT since i never had N64 so i cant judge the review as i never played the game but the good looks to be awesome for me
The obsessive worship of this game is so friggin weird to me. I grew up with it, I played it, I thoroughly enjoyed it. It mostly deserved its praise. But are we really melting down because a remake got a 9/10 instead of a 10/10? Nintendo actively chose NOT to include a substantial addition that all prior rereleases included. It simply can't be considered the definitive way to play it for that reason alone, nevermind the other issues mentioned. It's a fair score, but if they chose to give it a 10 I wouldn't complain because it really, really doesn't matter.
A 9/10 from NL will have absolutely no bearing on the legacy of the original game, your personal enjoyment of this version, its sales, or really anything else at all. If you are sincerely upset by a 9/10, please go outside and get some fresh air every now and then. You'll be ok. This game will be ok. Everything will be ok.
@Username_1 it being stupid to bother with reviews because they're subjective isn't what I'm saying at all.
It is stupid, however, for someone to bother with reviews if all that person is going to do is question the reviewer's opinion just because it doesn't perfectly align with:
1. The general consensus on the game.
2. The preconceived idea that person holds regarding the quality of the game or the score it should have received in a review, especially when that person hasn't even played the game and has no basis to build an informed opinion on.
The only thing triggering me personally is idiocy.
Thanks.
@Ichiban Thank you! Somebody with common sense.
See. I'm not unreasonable Ollie. I'm not mad you didn't give the Ocarina of Time remake a 10. You made some decent points and observations and I understood every one of them.
Knowing me, I'll probably give it a 10, but that's my view. Lol I do have a question. Was the game as good as you expected? Did the small changes to the puzzles keep it fresh? It seems like that would help a little.
@Olliemar28 Is there an option to mute the voice acting?
@Markatron84 from the exchange throughout, you will see (I hope) I have not offended you in the slightest. It does reflect on you though how easily you throw adjectives around. Wishing you well!
Had little doubt it would be an all time great(again), but good to see nonetheless. My copy should arrive tomorrow if Walmart handles their bidness properly
4 more hours to wait. Ugh.
upon release it was a 9. today it is an 8 at best. amazing how judgement chanages when you aren't clouded by nostalgia and irrational thought. a link to the past is far superior to ocarina of time in the gameplay department and i imagine windwaker beats it as well — looking forward to playing it soon.
@Porco I find OOT to be superior to LTTP in every way, especially gameplay.
@Username_1 perfect points.
@-wc- Hey man, I just wanted to apologize about earlier. I have always believed in making the world a better, more positive, and kinder place, and unfortunately I didn't live up to my own expectations earlier. To tell you the truth I deleted the 2nd comment because I felt bad(I unfortunately forgot that you were going to be emailed about it anyway). It's unfortunate as this may have been your first impression of me, and if that's the case, just know that once again how I spoke to you earlier was not the typical standard I hold myself to. I saw someone expressing some valid negative opinions about the remake for one of my favorite games of all time, and unfortunately lashed out. Hope you can forgive me, and if not, I saw that you're playing the original OoT, hope you enjoy the rest of that👍
And to everyone else, sorry about the long wall of text, just had to clear my conscience haha. Have a good night(or morning), and if you're gonna play it, enjoy the game tomorrow!
@michellelynn0976 It won't make you feel how you did when you were young.
Master Quest will probably be a DLC, free or paid, in a few months
@Misima It don't need to. It's incredible. Get over it.
84 critic reviews on MetaCritic, and the lowest score is 8/10.
@16bitGeneration It could the best way to play a game that may not still be a 10 by modern standards if it was reviewed today.
@Alcea
Maybe something that shook up the formula a bit?
The RE2 remake is a really good example of a ground-up remake that has the same beats and story of the original but adds so much more.
This sounds like the recent Starfox game, which amounts to a very pretty but very safe remaster.
I honestly can’t believe
1) People are getting upset about a game that they haven’t played yet
2) People are getting upset about the score at the end of a review being 9 rather than 10.
Seriously?
@FineLerv the best way to play a 10/10 game would be a 10/10 game.
@electrolite77 I'm already a few hours in. It's great.
I don’t understand why people expect a game that got 10/10 almost 30 years ago to get 10/10 now. Is Space Invaders still a 10/10 for you? Probably not?
Games are reviewed through the lens of their current time so getting 9/10 is still pretty incredible when the mechanics are 30 years old.
Tbh personally I preferred link to the past before it, Wind Waker after it and now breath of the wild and tears have far surpassed it for me. It’s a good Zelda game but nowhere near my favourite. I even personally prefer Links Awakening on Gameboy!
Anyway having said that I’ve still bought the console, case and game and it should arriving today ha ha!
I can’t believe you only gave it a 9 because they didn’t make MORE changes. That’s just ridiculous. This game was perfect and literally the only improvement possible was graphical and QOL, which is all they changed, that docks a point?
If they’d made sweeping changes it would be heresy and I’m just shocked that if it was a ten then it’s only a nine now. I love this site but this review is a travesty. Nothing but glowing praise for tasteful, thoughtful remastering followed by complaining they didn't what, didn’t give link a gun or something? What a criminal review.
@NintendoGuy4U It's a bit dated now though isn't it? I'm waiting on Amazon to deliver mine today, but even at the time it was probably a 9/10 from me.
Like a lot of people, surprised this didn't walk away with a perfect score but when other versions of the game exist that technically do 'more' gameplay-wise I do think there's a valid argument to be made. Just weird it's one that's getting made on the pro-Nintendo website of all places.
Most games or remakes do not come with an added-hard difficulty ‘master quest’ - so knocking this down a peg for that is unusual. Same goes for the single manual save, which is identical to Breath of the Wild.
Is this a criticism levelled only at remakes or is this specific to Ocarina of Time for some reason? Reading all the other reviews, these omissions don’t seem to be problematic.
The original OoT is a Too 10 of all time for me, playing it on release, but not coming back to it that often. I know it is on NSO, but I wish so much Nintendo had just given us the original, Master Quest, and Majora’s Mask on one cart. Even if it was just a 1 year limited thing like Mario 3D collection for his 35th anniversary. The landscapes look good, but the figures look worse than the original somehow. They haven’t extended enough either… like, just add a few more dungeons to the Deku Tree, add 7 or 8 streets to the market and more things and quests to do, it could have been so easy. Instead we got 2026 visuals with 1998 gameplay and level design… I can’t imagine what a 12 year old picking this up for the first time after 100 hours in BotW or TotK is going to think. They’ll finish it in a weekend and be like “wtf?” There’ll be a lot of disappointed kids this Christmas (and I bet a lot of 40 years old in a few months saying “hmmm, it’s not as good as I initially thought now that release hype wore off”). Let’s hope the whole thing is just an internal demo for whatever comes next.
There has been worse 10/10 scored games here so don’t take NL reviews as gospel. NL depending on the reviewer usually has some weird nitpicks to instant dock points.
Docking a point because of no Master Mode is a choice though. If that was the standard to dock points then lot of the current 10/10 would have docked points.
Case in Point: Tears of Kingdom doesn’t have a Master Mode that made the game more difficult that BotW the predecessor game had and set the standard for that style of Zelda. Should Tears current 10/10 be revoked because Tears was an easy game? Hell the game performance was considered atrocious on the S1 (worse then BoTW), but still got a 10/10. So it’s really a game of darts on reviewer whim.
People that keep bringing up the 3DS version as a reason for demerits is blatantly ignoring the objective exclusive benefits that the S2 OoT provides and overall outweighs them. I would gladly take one save file if it meant I get the S2 benefits/features/QoL.
🙄 This God damn obsession with metacritic. Regardless of if Nintendo Life have offered a lower score then the rest of the industry, it doesn't matter!
No disrespect to Nintendo Life or anyone else in the industry, but their opinions are on par with every other opinion that exists, they're aren't any more or less important.
Opinions would even differ depending on what staff member is doing the reviewing.
If people stop and think for a second, they might realise that things aren't too dissimilar, Between a 9 or a 10 means that you agree with helluva lot more then you disagree with.
Having played the game, this is a 10/10 for me. It is an experience, not a game. The tightrope balance of keeping the feeling (cinematic and scope) while still amazing (as in to make someone amazed) the player is being well kept. There are areas of the game that make me viscerally uncomfortable (or elated) even though I know they are there.
This game is what nostalgia truly means. Not some ruined or derided longing for better days, but the ability to have core memories and associations strummed by an evocative experience. This game does this as I find myself giggling or shuddering or laughing or trying not to tear up. At the same time it is FUN. I miss pure adventure games in a world of open world procedurals (BOTW and TOTK managed to avoid this feeling), get gud death runs, and epic rpgs where I need a spreadsheet to keep track of choices made so I get the ending I want. I just want to wander, and perhaps find some new connection.
I’m reminded of why I was so adamant that zelda games were adventure games and not RPGs as a kid (I still feel this way), I don't need to learn combos but attack patterns are engaging enough that I am not playing a QTE, I can wander and discover and while there is a sense of danger, I don’t have to inch my way through, terrified that something is gonna spawn, stab my character and take away my progress. I can smile and be curious about the varied NPCs and make up little thought about their inner lives without having the game having to keep a realistic schedule. Also, oddly enough and I hate to say this, no romance. Just two kids chosen by destiny to stop a big bad in a world of magic. (I know there are shippers in every fandom. I don’t see it, so leave me alone).
The presentation is beautiful, and it feels like the story telling quirks of all the zelda games were neatly layered on to make the characters feel more vibrant, while leading with OoT’s narrative style.
It’s odd. As much as I loved OoT as a kid/adult, I didn’t think it a masterpiece…and felt it was a little bit of a sacred cow, even as I have replayed it many times. Yet this new version with its thrilling music, intuitive UI, engaging but constantly moving narrative style and beautiful but whimsical graphics I now get what people meant by this being a masterpiece instead of a very good game. If BOTW was LoZ (first game) fully realized, then this S2 OoT is OoT fully realized. It feels like a memory, it feels like a reunion, it feels like a link to the future.
Thank you Nintendo.
Never played it so I'm fine with the "negatives". Whenever I pickup a Switch 2 (most likely when there is a 1000 € OLED Model, lol), I'll make sure to get this!
<3
It's here!! With the special pre-order texture foil packaging, yes!! Super exciting!!
"Oh no, it's so bad that I can't make a second user account for a second save file". Really, it's that simple and takes like 20 seconds...It's a sad day when Metacritic rates this game higher than Nintendo Life. Isn't it this site, itself, that gave both predecessors 10's...? Ocarina of Time: Master Quest was a separate title that wasn't released in Japan until February 17, 2003- does that mean the original Ocarina of Time, released in Japan on November 21, 1998, only deserves a 9/10, too, for not being Master Mode, too? So sorry the developers didn't accommodate to your exact whim for a 40th anniversary series tribute- they'll never make that mistake again 😳 Let's hope The Legend of Zelda movie has Master Mode, too, or it gets docked.
Also, what happens, then, when this game is, in fact, updated with these oh-so-convenient in-game save slots and Master Mode? Is it fitting that the "world's most popular source of Ninetendo news and reviews" (besides, of course, Famitsu) will update its score accordingly? Doubtful, but please surprise us.
To the rest of us: just play the game for what it is. This goes for any game- Steam, Sony, Xbox, Nintendo, or any other platform of choice. We are our own best source of how "definitive" a game is to each of us, not a review. "Comparison is the thief of joy."
Overrated game, not even in my top half of Zelda games. Glad the Hype Train has pulled into the station, now we just need GTA6 to arrive....Hey, did you guys know that the new Castlevania game is one of the best games ever made? And it's all original? And it trys so many new things and totally succeeds? And has maybe the best voice acting of all time? Oh, Noone cares? Okay!
Seen a comment from someone here (can't find the comment) saying this is an experience not a video game. Couldn't have said it better. Played a bit just now and WOW, absolutely magical!
@GASEOUS It's only $70, not $80... Unless you're in Canada or something. Either way it's a normal Switch 2 game price.
The negative aspects don't really bother me, this is a dream fully come true for me, ever since I saw what these characters could look like on the GameCube in Super Smash Bros. Melee, but then was dashed when Wind Waker took a hard left turn with the series. I already have a second profile on my Switch for an extra save slot if I want to start over or just mess around, trying different things. I like it that way so the second save doesn't add to my total hours played on my main profile.
@Max_the_German Soulsborne games didn't invent difficulty lol.
@uncleMike Lots of people evidently care about the lack of multiple saves on one profile. Makes no sense just like it made no sense in BOTW.
@Aquinas Pretty much every game I've played this year allows multiple save files on one profile...Nioh 3, Wo Long, Phantom Blade, Crimson Desert...Nintendo is the only developer doing this type of save system. I don't know if it's because of some Nintendo game tradition from 40 years ago but if it is, they haven't moved on lol.
It's crazy to give THE 10/10 game of all time 9/10 !!!
@Username_1 Howdy, that was mine. I’ve edited my comment a few times so that may be why you could not find it.
@Ryu_Niiyama thank you! Made me look for your comment again and very glad I did since you've added so much more. What a great comment/ review!
"You're not ready for this" is so lame. Bro, come on. Most of have played this game already.
If you have good cans, play this game in headphones. (or a good av system in general) Sound direction is thrilling and complex.
@Ryu_Niiyama You're so right to call this out. Still trying to digest/ fully comprehend what's going on myself, its too much to fully appreciate! On a Sonos surround sound system and it sounds phenomenal! Not sure if surround is fully supported, but for sure it's been immersive.
There is only one thing on Earth that can compare to this and it is when Zoolander dropped magnum on the planet. (Insert gif in your brain of Zoolander spinning and droppin magnum)
10/10
https://youtu.be/Ao31lQuYPjE?is=BBlvv6Z64L_wfOv2
It's about time Nintendolife starts using decimals.
This remake might not be a 10/10 in your opinion. But a 9...? No way. This game deserves at least a 9.5/10.
Come on, Nintendolife, give this game your first ever 9.5/10!!
@michellelynn0976 unless you're buying it for me, I don't want it. Sorry.
I'm here just to say the game Is awesome. I feel like a kid again. Thanks Nintendo 🥹
I've not played the original game so I'm not affected by nostalgia.
I still have to say that this is an absolutely 10/10 game. Young Link is also really adorable!
If we have the Master Quest later, then I hope it will be in a free update. Like it woulld be quite awkward to have this as a paid DLC.
@Misima Too bad, your loss.
Once again Nintendolife bringing down the metacritic score hehe
Some people on this website are insufferable. One save slot and no master quest are very valid points. Id give it a 9 too
I'm right after getting the Goron's Ruby, and the original is my favourite game of all time- with that context, so far- this remake is an 8/10 at best.
The design philosophy is way off- the game just flat out tells you what to do all the time, and what rewards you get for everything- where's the sense of surprise and adventure?
Only one equippable ""C-button"" item is an absolute travesty- especially as they waste a second button on opening the item quick-menu- why not let that button be a second equippable item slot?? Having to open this menu every single time you want to do something slightly different is mind-numbing, immersion-breaking, and prevents you from experimenting. I genuinely don't know what they were thinking with this change- the Switch 2 has MORE button inputs available than the N64, not less!
The combat is better than the original, so far (beyond just effects- there'a a lot more to it than that which should have been brought up in the review)- aside from the fact that the game just raises the shield for you by default- again- this is such a handholding, safe remake which is absolutely petrified of players not knowing what to do or experimenting for even a nanosecond.
I really, really want to love this remake, but I just... don't. It systematically removes so much of the sense of adventure and discovery by just telling you things, compared to the original. It's like this version of the game is permanently locked in to a "beginner" mode which you can't change.
While playing, I keep flipping between "this is cool" and "why did they do this?" It feels like this remake fundamentally misunderstands the subtlety and subtext and spirit of the original in all the gameplay changes, and all the overly safe, sanitised, sanding-over of everything.
I really, really want to love this remake, because I adore the underlying game more than you could possibly imagine, so this does not come from a place of cynicism or pettiness- I really, really, really want to love this game, but every few moments I play it it does something worse than the original... alongside occasionally doing something better. The whole thing has me tied up in knots.
I just want new Zelda games from now on. Let the past be what it is, love it for what it is, and let's find fantastic new experiences to enjoy alongside it instead of trying to replace it.
Google Search / OoT Trick:
My friend Mike just told me about this.
(verified it works as of 7 Nov 2026 in both U.S. and Australian)
1. Do a Google search for 'Legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time'.
2. In the bottom right of the search results page, you'll see a Master Sword above a stone insert.
3. Click on it and the Sword will go into stone insert, and you'll hear Link shout from one of his sword attacks (presumably spin sword attack).
4. A Tri-Force will appear on-screen
5. The results page will now display in 1990s era search result theme.
6. If you click on the Sword again, it will release and page will go back to original theme.
Thanks Mike M (my oldest and dearest friend)
and Thanks Google for being awesome.
P
@King_MFW
Hey, no apology necessary! You seem like a thoughtful person, and a passionate Nintendo fan, to me! I understand feeling acutely grumpy about your favorite games, believe me 😅
Thanks for coming back, it was a thoughtful message, and mighty big of you ✊ I won't forget this and I'm happy to have made another Nintenfriend 🌞
With respect to the review and I appreciate its from the reviews perspective. This should be a 10 in my opinion. This is perfection just as the original was. It reinvents the wheel, purely being based on it predecessor alone (which subsequently laid the foundations for 3D gaming in general). I love this game. Its a masterpiece for all time!!
@DonierGunad
"This should be a 10 in my opinion. This is perfection just as the original was. It reinvents the wheel,"
FYI: "reinvents the wheel" means an unnecessary iteration that falls short of the original, or at best is a waste of time.
in any case I hope you enjoy the game! sounds like you already are 🥳👍
@MegaJ
literally everything you mentioned is what I already know in my bones is how I will feel about this game when I play it. I really appreciate your perspective 👍
well, besides the control regressions, particularly the "only one c item" part... really didn't see that coming! 😅 what were they thinking?
At death mountain. So far it has far exceeded my expectations. This game is so beautiful beyond belief. The sound is incredible. Literally there's detail everywhere. I will replay this numerous times. Easy 10/10 for me so far. Can't wait to play the rest, although taking my time and exploring as much as I can because I don't want it to end!
@16bitGeneration "the best way to play a 10/10 game would be a 10/10 game"
Yes. And if the original is still a 10/10 to you, then for you this remake would be a 10/10.
Reviewing remakes is tricky. That's why I believe there should be a score for new players to the game and Veterans. Because if I have never played the game before and see it's a 9 (while very high) I might think oh ok it's not perfect. A score should tell me for the 1st time playing how good it is and not aimed at a veteran who has played it 50 times. With remakes maybe do a separate score for Veterans and a score for people new to the game so they know that the game itself is actually 10/10 but for people replaying it telling them hey it's a 9/10 remake
Nintendolife being the one pushing the metascore down is not what I had on my bingo card! A 9/10 because of the two reasons stated would only be justifiable if this was a simple upscale remaster with better textures and some improvements. You have reviewed a full on remake adding so many things like totally new (and top-of-the-art) visual presentation and art design, orchestrated music, voice acting, expanded dialogues and cut scenes, modernized controls and more. Giving this a 9 just feels sour and deliberate to stir controversy. Can’t take you seriously.
Nice review and nice score. I think a 9 is very reasonable for a old game with just a new lick of paint. In fact I am very surprised it still got a average of 96% on Metacritic.
@rjejr just waded through this whole comment section and you never updated us on the spark plugs! Did you get the car back and did you decide how your family was going to play the game?
Your Echoes of Wisdom story is like how my brother and Implayed Majora’s Mask Christmas 2000, I started it but really wasn’t feeling it so ended up watching him play, had the strategy guide on my lap for when we went for all the masks and it’s one of my favourite gaming memories.
9/10 <facepalm>
I'm 15 hours in, and my opinion is that this is absolutely the definitive experience for this game. There's no way I'd ever recommend any of the other versions to someone unfamiliar the game. I don't see any reason to go back to them myself either. It's perfection, 10/10 for sure
7/10
It feels like the game just hands out e.g. Epona and the Hookshot... I remember that to be a bit tricky? Half way through the game and have not needed any potions or fairys.
They should at lease allow you to carry the same amount of bugs as you can carry beans.
They made it WAAAAAAAAY too easy, and gutted all of the cool little details and secrets. It looks gorgeous, but feels flat compared to the original. The game treats you like an idiot, telling you everything and making all the puzzles overly obvious, to the point where they're no longer puzzles.
It really upsets me what they did to the gameplay, considering how stellar the presentation is.
Don't care that there isn't master quest included, unlike these hipsters just screaming master quests for online for likes, it's the oot game I like. You wannabe gamers are never happy. What you gonna cry about next? No majora's mask included
This game is awesome. Beautifull remade and smoothed out in the annoying parts. Went back to 3DS version to find it a lot more frustrating. F.e. in Saria's Forest, you know you have to use the hookshot to get up there. In 3DS you hook to the tree, in S2 version that tree is removed and you hook to the symbol on the temple. Consequent and recognisable.
Buttersmooth. If you want more challenge take the master quest from Gamecube or 3DS. Or just wait for it on S2.
From a first time experience perspective, this should be 10/10. If you compare it to other version 9.5/10 is justified, but why would you compare it. Probably you played it many many times, and still not give it the 10/10...
So, having played through this game, I'm finally going to drop my two cents:
This is a 10/10 game. They do not get any better than this. Any minor, perceived flaws are too easily outshined by the mere superbness of everything in this game.
This game made me feel like I was 17 years old again. I could not put it down. There is not a game in the universe that has felt more "definitive" than this one, for me - I've been playing video games for forty years.
Anyway, thanks for the review. I think 9 is a fair score, but in reality, it's a 10.
@charliecarrot
I have not enjoyed a video game so immensely, since perhaps Super Mario Maker on Wii U, which I'm pretty sure was at least ten years ago. It's just absolutely fantastic, and I do mean this with a straight face - Any score less than 10/10 is inaccurate, and borderline insulting the sheer majesty of this game.
Just finished this morning. What's done is done and my comment isn't going to change the score. All I can say is that this is a list of NintendoLife's 10/10 games:
https://www.nintendolife.com/games/browse?score=10&sort=date&page=2
There is not one single game on this list released this decade that can meaningfully be said to be 1 full point better than this game, and I agree with many of those titles being rated as outstanding. For me, this is certainly the definitive way to play, but that's subjective. It just cannot be that Quake and Quake 2, Tetris Effect Connected, and Bayonetta 3 (given its performance), and even Metroid Prime Remastered all outclass Ocarina of Time (2026). There is no flaw in this remake that is such a demerit on this game as to outsize any and all flaws in any of the other 10/10 games. Respectfully.
@Kensui cry much?
@FaroreAbhorsen respectfully, no one cares.
This entire comments section is a bunch of adults crying over a video game getting a 9/10 score. I knew Nintendo fanboys were pathetic, but this is just sad.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...