Originally released back in December of 2018, Ashen takes the extremely well-worn "Souls" formula and transfers it to an enchanting, beautifully stylised world where you assume the role of a nameless, faceless hero charged with restoring the heart of the Ashen, a great bird God whom, when resurrected, will spell the end of an age of darkness as it spreads its light across the land. This is a game that in no way attempts to hide the fact it borrows heavily from almost every aspect of FromSoftware's classic series – with the exact same stamina-based combat, bonfire-style save points, healing and retrieval of souls (here know as Scoria) upon death – and anyone with even a passing knowledge of how these games play will feel right at home here from the get-go.
However, where many Souls clones tend to laboriously concentrate on making their gameplay as devilishly difficult as possible Ashen – very wisely – settles for a more relaxed, bright and open approach, coming off as a uniquely laid-back offering in the genre that keeps those soothing rhythms and loops of gameplay we all know and love and adds a few neat little wrinkles of its own across its relatively short 25-30 hour playtime.
Where many Souls-likes tend to plunge the player into a lonely and brutal struggle through darkness, battling hard to parse overly-cryptic lore and obtuse systems of play as much as difficult enemies, Ashen strikes out in an entirely different direction tonally – here community is right at the centre of the story, team-work and togetherness the order of the day if its hero is to succeed. That sense of community can be seen right from the off as one of your player character's first actions is to found the settlement of Vagrant's Rest where, as the story unfolds, more and more NPC characters – refugees and warriors alike – will gather for shelter against the evil that lurks around every corner, bringing with them their own talents that help your hero on their quest to resurrect the Ashen.
Amongst the various NPCs who show up to this little oasis at the heart of Ashen's world is the blacksmith Bataran, who'll upgrade and hammer the damage out of the various axes, hatchets, clubs and cudgels you find as you journey through the world. There's Amara with her ability to create Talismans and relics which imbue you with various perks and boons to aid you in your fight and Vorsa, the mysterious hunter who fashions spears for you to strike your enemies from range – there are no bows or crossbows here.
As you take on missions and further the main plot of Ashen you'll constantly return to find Vagrant's Rest growing and evolving, from a tiny little settlement at the outset to a thriving place filled with the sounds of busy construction as it grows around you. You'll get to know the characters that inhabit this space, filling in their back-stories as you fulfil their quest lines – it feels like a much more human world than we're used to from this particular genre.
This central sense of community is solidified when you strike out into the world on the various missions and side-quests handed to you from the inhabitants of Vagrant's Rest as you'll always find yourself with a partner out in the field, a different NPC accompanying you depending on who you've accepted an errand from and it's here that one of Ashen's most unique design wrinkles comes into play as these NPC companions will randomly be replaced with other real-world players on the fly.
The game never alerts you to the switch and you'll only ever really know by those funny little human quirks that give away a real player from an AI stand-in. It's a fun system that works well for the most part, and it's also totally optional and can be switched off at any time should you prefer to play alone. However, we found ourselves enjoying the company and co-op play, apart from the odd occasion when we'd be paired up with someone more interested in charging ahead than relaxing and exploring the enchanting world that's been created here.
Indeed, developers A44 really have created a beautiful setting full of stunning vistas and a handful of truly excellent dungeons to blast through. Where Dark Souls sticks, for the most part, to twisting corridor-like levels with clever little shortcuts linking back and forth, Ashen is a much more open-world affair and, while there's no real clever interlinking of areas, there are plenty of puzzles within the landscape with some item or other always calling out from a difficult-to-reach place as you make your way across the gorgeous minimalist cel-shaded scenery. And it's always best to make the effort to reach these tricky items as they're almost always some sweet new axe, shield or new set of clothes to provide you with greater attack power or defence. That sense of pressing through new and exciting areas – inching forward and discovering new places and secrets that Dark Souls does so well – is present and correct here. It may not be on quite the same level technically but the magic is most certainly there, in both the addictive exploration and crunchy, methodical combat.
As we mentioned, the combat here is pretty much identical to FromSoftware's games – with the exception of back-stabbing and parrying having been removed from your repertoire of moves – and everything from how your character rolls, dodges and delivers light and heavy blows with their chosen weapon feels extremely similar, making the rhythm of combat instantly recognisable. Things can certainly be a bit scrappier from time to time; enemies tend to gang up on you in rather large groups occasionally, but this is mitigated by the fact you're almost always with your partner who can take a lot of the heat off you in battle when things get out of control. There isn't perhaps the same level of finesse in the placement of enemies here for sure but overall this is a hugely solid imitation of Souls combat.
The deep RPG aspects of your typical Souls-like have also been toned down here; levelling up happens automatically as you complete missions and it's only really in the upgrading of your weapons and the crafting and equipping of talismans and relics that you need to make any real choices. Again, this adds to that more relaxed vibe, giving you the central gameplay loops you desire without a lot of the hassle and pain, and it's all the better for it. From the unique character and world stylings to the relatively short running time, Ashen is a more easy-going game than you may expect that funnels you through its story and a handful of excellent boss encounters and dungeons without wasting your time or punishing you unduly. Make no mistake, though, this is still a tough game; not concentrating during battle will still see you come a cropper time and again, but it does away with so much of the gnashing of teeth we're used to with these types of games.
In terms of this Switch port, graphically we struggled to see any difference between this and the original PC release of the game. It runs at 720p/1080p in handheld and docked modes respectively and the only issue we noticed during our playthrough was some minor stuttering and fluctuating from that 30fps target – which seemed more pronounced in docked mode – when entering new areas. It's by no means a deal-breaker, and we didn't notice any frame-rate drops during large enemy encounters or boss battles. Initial loading times can also be a bit of a pain but this is something that's an issue in all other versions of the game. Overall this is a very impressive turnout on Switch for a hugely enjoyable Souls clone – one the better entries in the genre – and it's perhaps a testament to the clever minimalist art-style that this one runs so well on Nintendo's hardware.
Conclusion
Ashen doesn't try to hide the fact that it's a Souls clone through and through. However, where many before it unwisely try to out-do FromSoftware in terms of difficulty or obtuse systems and lore, A44 has taken its game in a more refreshing, community-focused direction. This is a slightly more relaxed take on a Souls-like; it gets you into its action and gameplay rhythms quickly, isn't interested in punishing you particularly unduly and doesn't outstay its welcome. Its story and setting are enchanting and the sense of togetherness and companionship that it creates as its plot unfolds sets it apart in a genre much better known for relentless loneliness and isolation.
Comments 24
Great Review! I have been waiting for more information on this one... I really want to play this one at some point, however my backlog feels like a souls-like every time I look at it. I will hold off for a nice sale as I have no doubt this game will click with me.
Bought it with Xmas credit. I love it, and have been playing excessively for the past 5 days.
My biggest criticism is it runs like a dog in docked mode. The frame rate, regardless of where you are or what you're doing just goes out the window. Handheld it runs fine. Hopefully a patch will smooth some of the kinks out.
@AhabSpampurse I only found it stuttered noticably when arriving in new areas in docked mode, handheld far smoother. Here's hoping for a patch to smooth it out.
It's definitely my game of the year; tbh I haven't had this much fun and awe since BotW! I've longed for NL to review this so more people can find out about it and enjoy it!
EDIT: Only played handheld since I gave my day one to the kids and bought a Lite. Since I am a mother of three I never get the TV anyway...
@RebeccaEdv That's high praise! May have to look into this game as I loved Dark Souls.
Nice review. I picked this up awhile back when it launched on PC and really enjoyed my time with it. They really nailed the feeling I got when I first played Dark Souls. The mood, atmosphere, lore and visuals are wonderful. One issue I had was the lack of variety in loot. Most of the hidden items were just upgrade materials, and after awhile you didn't need them so going out of your way to find a secret item was rarely worth it. Also, the final boss of the main game and DLC was very bad.
Missed this on gamepass but looks interesting. I may pick this up now
Just be aware that this has a tendency to crash. Played it about 3-4 hours and really enjoying it, however it’s crashed about that many times also, on e when I was saving at a ritual stone. Luckily it didn’t trash my save. From what I’ve seen I think it has to do with the online component so maybe best playing offline
@PJOReilly it might just be me. My Switch is a day 1 launch model that's been used excessively. I don't want you to think I'm being dramatic but I could send you footage to show you what I mean; it runs pretty ropey for me all the time. As I said, it's not much of a deal breaker. I commute loads and the majority of playing has been in handheld anyways.
I've been curious about the Souls genre but couldn't get into Bloodborne due to difficulty, is this a good option for a person like me who couldn't get gud?
Cool, I'll add this to the list...I still need to finish sekiro, as I love these types of games. Got sucked in by DQXI and haven't turned on my poor xbone in some time.
Oh what a lovely surprise. This one slipped under my radar when it originally released, looks like a proper good time.
Wishlisted!
@zoneoftruth I would definitely say so. I'm generally not very good at games and really enjoyed it! I still had a lot of trial and error but found that it was always fair. Whenever I died it was because of me rushing or something like that. Once or twice I could maybe blame the baby!
@zoneoftruth I was the same, struggled with bloodborne but really wanted to like it. Ashen is great though, I would recommend it I am five or six hours in and the exploration is excellent and feel like I am always making progress, even playing for short bursts- give it a shot!!
@zoneoftruth Yes, I would try this. It's much easier than Bloodborne and you have an AI companion with you to help out.
@nimnio Yes it's possible, but it's kind of complicated and doesn't always work well. If you're getting it to play the entire game with a friend, I would pass. If you're both getting it to play a bit here and there together, then sure.
I’m not sure why but this game reminds me heavily of The book:Eragon....
This looks like a really solid game, it's just not a game that I feel a particular desire to have, but I guess I can thank the excellent 3'rd person action games we have had.
Played this on Xbox. Good "Darksouls-like" game. It's very approachable & I'd say the normal difficulty is just right for any player. Also it's fun.
@RebeccaEdv since your a Mother of three you should get the T.V. whenever you want! But being a father of two I know the reality of the situation. That is why the switch is my main console.
It’s weird, I’d probably play this on other consoles but it would be odd for me to play this on Switch. That’s probably partly due to me not owning a Pro controller and I’m definitely not going anywhere near a Souls-like with joy-cons.
I’m on the fence with this one
I've only recently started on Dark Souls so this will have to wait its turn. Is it eshop-only?
I love dark souls, but this doesn't do much for me... feels like an unfinished game that is still waiting a finishing touch. I know they went for this simple graphics.. i played it and went back to dark souls
Tap here to load 24 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...