Topic: Unpopular Gaming Opinions

i mean that's true, but if you grew up with snes and still have one, it was worse than being a wii u owner with a switch

i did not, so i largely agree though, but lets be honest, by that logic, a computer or a psp was better than any older nintendo system, roms lolololololololol

Somewhat gaming but more generally tech related -

I don't really like mechanical keyboards. Those that I have used feel clunky and the keys have too much resistance. Plus I'm not keen on the noise. I'd much rather use my laptop keyboard any day.

Another comes to mind -

I think the Gamecube controller is overrated. I absolutely adored it at the time (and it arguably holds up as the best controller of the generation), it feels great to hold, and for some games (e.g. Smash) the unconventional face button layout just seems perfect. However, the D-pad and C-stick are poor, and I find the analogue stick to be too stiff. Most controllers since (ignoring Wii and Wii U) have improved on shoulder buttons also.

In fact, I think the only redeeming factor of the Gamecube controller in the modern day is the unique face button layout.

@RedderRugfish I get what you're saying about the GBA/SNES, but they are also a decade apart. The SNES was Nintendos first foray into a lot of the things that SNES could do, so of course a decade later they would have gotten better at it and added improvements to the sequels and remakes of the SNES games that the GBA got.
I don't disagree with the opinion, I don't think it's quite a fair comparison, though, given the time span between them.

@RedderRugfish speaking of both Gamecube and GBA...

It's a real shame that the GBA player was only on Gamecube. The Gamecube controller is very ill-suited towards GBA games.

I once played most of Donkey Kong Country on Wii VC with a Gamecube controller before I had a Classic controller. That was a mistake.

Harvest Moon is more fun than Rune Factory.

@RedderRugfish
"so if there's a sequel that fixes these issues then I might be willing to try it."

Try Harvest Moon Tree of Tranquility Wii.
You can play as either Boy or Girl.
If you are boy, you are looking for wife and if you are girl, you are looking for husband.
You still need to give gifts to them but to get engaged with them, you must do their favors. You must join in lunch date, do their request and accept their love confession. After that there will be an event about Blue feather (an item to propose eligible bachelors / bachelorettes) and after you get that item, you can propose your lover.

Old Harvest Moon didn't have specific events to get engaged more with your lover. Just keep giving them gifts until they are eligible enough to get married. But starting from Harvest Moon Tree of Tranquility, you must do their quest to able to marry them.

Btw, i played as a Girl on Tree of Tranquility and married with Owen because i'm looking for Handsome Husbando, not interested with Waifus.

I like the platforming mechanics in Super Paper Mario more than I like them in the full 2D Mario Platformers. Mario's movement just feels so much more natural like it does in the 3D Mario games.

Splatoon is not unplayable without motion controls. I used a wired Yoshi controller to play one day because my Joy-Cons needed charging. Didn't do too bad with joystick aiming and won a few games. Maybe it helps as I've played other shooter games on Switch and Wii U with joysticks, so I'm use to it.

@Grisinblue they have released 4 new IPs since the release of the Switch. Although one could debate their quality. 1-2-Switch, Snipperclips, Arms and Labo are all new Nintendo IPs.

They also have third party studios making exclusive new IPs like Astral Chain and Mario + Rabbids Kingdom Battle.

They've also had several new IPs over the years since the 3DS and Wii U were released:
Boxboy
Code Name: Steam
Pushmo
Dillon's Rolling Western
Ever Oasis
Tank Troopers
Nintendo Land
Splatoon
Star Fox Guard

Again, not saying all those IPs are brilliant, and most of them didn't take off. Splatoon being the exception. So they are doing original IPs, and almost the quantity you want.

Not arguing against you. I'd also like more original IPs from Nintendo.

...eh.

Like on one hand, I do think Nintendo is kinda mostly stuck on its popular IPs right now. They know what sells, they know what people want, and at best they'll sneak an Arms in there if a team is available not working on their popular thing. At some point I would like to see them focus a bit more on something new and exciting. I always adored how during the Dreamcast era Sega basically said "**** it" and put out as many bold, creative games as possible.

But that was also clearly dumb, since the Dreamcast killed Sega's role as a first party gaming company (granted, it was the final nails in the coffin built by Sega's terrible Saturn decisions...). And when most of what people want is from their pre-existing franchises, its hard to justify making more games like...um...Arms. And I think it's really unfair to undersell the creativity and effort put into a lot of these sequels.

BOTW fundamentally broke 20 years of the Zelda formula and went against a number of normal gaming conventions, especially in the open world genre it was going for. It was almost like if Team Ico was given the task to make Skyrim at points, it's pretty out there for such a major title. Super Mario Odyssey is absolutely filled with creative ideas with the countless "captures" you can do, that almost inherently has more variety than the other 3D Mario games. Super Smash Bros. Ultimate was intentionally made to be a best of Smash Bros rather than a wholly new game, and still included a completely new style of story mode and spirit gameplay to go along with it. That's even ignoring the time they gave Mario to Ubisoft and we somehow got "Rabbids crossover strategy game". Like if they really wanted to make something uncreative, they could, and would likely get away with it. I mean, some of the best selling Switch games are just ports of Wii U games.

So...basically...you want new IPs that appeal to you, but any other new IPs don’t count. Got it!

Couldn't agree more. I think of something like The World Ends With You, and it just doesn't need a sequel. By all means take those gameplay ideas or the aesthetic and go somewhere else with it, but don't try to continue a story that is already beautifully complete.

This is one of the beauties of series like Final Fantasy. Not every game is a winner, but each numbered entry does a pretty good job of being distinct from the previous one.

Yoshi's Island, while clearly a platformer that had a lot of care put into it, is a sloggy collectathon.

[Begin slight rant]
I also don't think the Pokemon removal and animation controversies for Pokemon Sword/Shield are anything to get too up in arms about, particularly since we don't have all the details for how Pokemon Home will work just yet. I'm tired of seeing the complaints about those various facets and, honestly, the complaints in the article comments here and elsewhere online have made me not even want to discuss the game with fellow fans. I've actively been avoiding topics of discussion and have just been following the news on my own for the most part.
[/End slight rant]

You should see Crafted World! It's a really fun game for the most part but the number of collectibles is ridiculous.

Yeah I agree, some of the complaints are somewhat justified but the amount of negativity towards it is way over the top.

Bloodstained Ritual of the Night (whatever is the version of the game) is not a great game.
It's a poor parody of the greatest Castlevanias.
If the same game was made by someone else than Iga, this game will be considered as mediocre as it is.

@Dogorilla I agree that some of the complaints regarding Sword and Shield are justified, but I still think it's another classic case of the internet making a mountain out of a molehill.

I think my main problem with Yoshi's Island was that I should've played the game in smaller chunks. Some of the levels seemed a little too long for my liking. I think I was just expecting something sort of (but not totally) along the lines of Super Mario World, which I love to death. The game was also overhyped to me.

I love Yoshi's Island, but I actually understand that. I had similar problems with Tropical Freeze and more fittingly Wooly World. And even in Yoshi's Island its one of the only parts of the game I would actively consider a negative at points (though only if you try to 100% later levels).

It helped that I played it when it came out on GBA, and I barely knew it even existed before the remake came outl, so I had the complete opposite reaction.

Speaking of Yoshi, I liked Yoshi’s New Island. Sure, it was easy, but it’s like a Kirby game.