Wii U Forum

Topic: Why has ZombiU got mixed reviews?

Showing 1 to 20 of 196

AuthorMessage
xBASSxMONSTAx

xBASSxMONSTAx

1. Posted:

Gamespot 4.5 out of 10
Game Informer 5/10
IGN 6.3 out of 10
Gamesmaster 97%
Eurogamer 9/10

I honestly don't know what to think anymore. :(

Can anyone explain why this game has got so much mixed reviews overall? Could it be that some reviewers have been payed to give it high scores?

Edited on by xBASSxMONSTAx

xBASSxMONSTAx

AuthorMessage
Tasuki

Tasuki

2. Posted:

Different people have different opinions.

Push Square Moderator and all around retro gamer.

My Backlog

Nintendo Network ID: Tasuki311

AuthorMessage
WesCash

WesCash

3. Posted:

Tasuki wrote:

Different people have different opinions.

Still, there should always be some objectivity to reviews.
I can understand a 7 versus an 8 or even a 7 vs a 9.
But a 45% compared to 97%?
Not sure what to make of that.

Edited on by WesCash

WesCash

AuthorMessage
Bass_X0

Bass_X0

4. Posted:

I don't like most sports games but to be a reviewer, I should at least be able to recognise a good sports game even if I don't personally like it due to my individual tastes.

Edgey, Gumshoe, Godot, Sissel, Larry, then Mia, Franziska, Maggie, Kay and Lynne.

I'm throwing my money at the screen but nothing happens!

AuthorMessage
xBASSxMONSTAx

xBASSxMONSTAx

5. Posted:

WesCash wrote:

Tasuki wrote:

Different people have different opinions.

Still, there should always be some objectivity to reviews.
I can understand a 7 versus an 8 or even a 7 vs a 9.
But a 45% compared to 97%?
Not sure what to make of that.

I can't makes heads or tails of that either. I mean that's a big difference. Too big for my liking.

Edited on by xBASSxMONSTAx

xBASSxMONSTAx

AuthorMessage
Xilef

Xilef

6. Posted:

Conspirasy. They are trying to make us confused.

..honestly don't know. Different people though the ideas was executed good or bad?

Sten

AuthorMessage
Happy_Mask

Happy_Mask

7. Posted:

Tasuki wrote:

Different people have different opinions.

[16:08] LordJumpMad Hides his gut with a griddle
[16:08] Reala: what ljm does for cash is ljm's business
[16:08] LordJumpMad: Gotta look good my my next game u_u

AuthorMessage
WaveBoy

WaveBoy

8. Posted:

I'll take IGN & Game Spots reviews over the others. :p
So..uh....How about that Rabbids Land?lol

Currently Playing: 3D Shinobi III: Return of the Ninja Master!
We shall swim to Bubble Island, or you will suffer the wrath of my Trident Laser!
80s FANATIC & King of NES Tekkidome!

AuthorMessage
Ness_Villager

Ness_Villager

9. Posted:

I'd go with Eurogamer and Gamesmaster's scores.

Puni Power
3DS FC- 2380-2910-9753
Formerly NintyKing or NintenKingiiU.
"Does that make me Crazy?"

AuthorMessage
JohnPhilipSousa

JohnPhilipSousa

10. Posted:

I'd say that some people are afraid of new concepts.

JohnPhilipSousa

Nintendo Network ID: JohnPhilipSousa

AuthorMessage
WesCash

WesCash

11. Posted:

Bass_X0 wrote:

I don't like most sports games but to be a reviewer, I should at least be able to recognise a good sports game even if I don't personally like it due to my individual tastes.

Exactly. I personally don't like fighting games (Street Fighter/MK/Tekken/etc.) but I played the new Mortal Kombat with some friends the other day and it is definitely a great game. I hate it and don't ever want to play it again, but I'd give it a 8.5 or 9 out of 10 easily.

WesCash

AuthorMessage
LordJumpMad

LordJumpMad

12. Posted:

ZombiU is just RedSteel with zombies, and RedSteel wasn't a bad game, but it wasn't good nether, and it also got mix reviews.
The Wii U doesn't have much excludes titles for its console, and having 3rd parties games like Assassin Creed, and Batman, which are already out on other consoles for a while now doesn't help the Wii U.
Having poor excludes games doesn't give people good reason to even get a Wii U if they can get better games on other consoles.

Edited on by LordJumpMad

For you, the day LordJumpMad graced your threads, was the most important day of your life. But for me, it was Tuesday.
University of ⓂⒶⒹness
LordJumpMad's Theme

Twitter:

AuthorMessage
steamhare

steamhare

13. Posted:

From IGN and gamespot's reviews, I get the feeling that the melee combat isn't very good and the reviewers refused to use any other weapons, or something. They complain a lot about the cricket bat.

Am I missing something, maybe?

Edited on by steamhare

steamhare

AuthorMessage
Ness_Villager

Ness_Villager

14. Posted:

steamhare wrote:

From IGN and gamespot's reviews, I get the feeling that the melee combat isn't very good and the reviewers refused to use any other weapons, or something. They complain a lot about the cricket bat.

Am I missing something, maybe?

No.

Puni Power
3DS FC- 2380-2910-9753
Formerly NintyKing or NintenKingiiU.
"Does that make me Crazy?"

AuthorMessage
moomoo

moomoo

15. Posted:

steamhare wrote:

From IGN and gamespot's reviews, I get the feeling that the melee combat isn't very good and the reviewers refused to use any other weapons, or something. They complain a lot about the cricket bat.

Am I missing something, maybe?

It's more that because the nature of the game requires you to use it a lot for saving ammo (since you don't want to use ammo often) it's not good to have shoddy melee combat. The reviewers just didn't seem to have fun with the title. I don't think they're inherently wrong about it. Neither are the people that adored it. This looks to be one of those love it/hate it games.

Best thread ever
Feel free to add me on Miiverse or PSN.
Miiverse is Moomoo14, PSN is Moomoo1405390

Nintendo Network ID: Moomoo14

AuthorMessage
GameLord08

GameLord08

16. Posted:

The blunt truth is that it appeals to a rather niche set of gamers, and not many have learned how to efficiently progress in the game, as its outcome depends pretty much solely on the skill and strategy of the player themself, not in-game. Zombi U is a very adventurous concept, as true survival horror has somewhat become an alienated genre in the industry; as a result, it doesn't necessarily bode well with everybody's palate. Destructoid's review did a good job of addressing this, despite giving it an 8/10.

Simply put, Zombi U is like marmite; you either love it or hate it. It's a game that's incredibly subject to a variety of subjective opinions, hence the very mixed reviews floating around. As a word of advice, judge for yourself whether or not you'll enjoy this game - reviews for Zombi U are all over the spectrum.

Edited on by GameLord08

GameLord08

AuthorMessage
Parkway160

Parkway160

17. Posted:

Reviews are only opinions there good to have, but they should not determine whether or not your going to buy something.

Parkway160

AuthorMessage
Haywired

Haywired

18. Posted:

Yeah, it does sound a bit like Red Steel all over again. Maybe that's Ubisoft's plan, to release an exclusive "hardcore" launch title with a Nintendo console, that therefore gets far more hype and attention than it ever would have got normally, and then turns out to be a bit mediocre...

My Nintendo Collection

Nintendo Network ID: Haywired

AuthorMessage
fortius54

fortius54

19. Posted:

GameLord08 wrote:

The blunt truth is that it appeals to a rather niche set of gamers, and not many have learned how to efficiently progress in the game, as its outcome depends pretty much solely on the skill and strategy of the player themself, not in-game. Zombi U is a very adventurous concept, as true survival horror has somewhat become an alienated genre in the industry; as a result, it doesn't necessarily bode well with everybody's palate. Destructoid's review did a good job of addressing this, despite giving it an 8/10.

Simply put, Zombi U is like marmalade; you either love it or hate it. It's a game that's incredibly subject to a variety of subjective opinions, hence the very mixed reviews floating around. As a word of advice, judge for yourself whether or not you'll enjoy this game - reviews for Zombi U are all over the spectrum.

I have to agree with you on this. It is a niche, and it is a pretty ambitious launch game. However, you are not going to get a break from these websites for a Nintendo game, especially an exclusive. I heard an IGN guy on the preview talk about how all of the Zombi U problems had been fixed. I really don't even know why I bother to read their reviews.

fortius54

AuthorMessage
TysonOfTime

TysonOfTime

20. Posted:

WaveBoy wrote:

I'll take IGN & Game Spots reviews over the others. :p
So..uh....How about that Rabbids Land?lol

This made my day.
Thank you.

You don't die until you're dead!

Nintendo Network ID: TysonOfTime