Wii U Forum

Topic: The Wii U Scorecard: Rate the Games You've Played /10!

Showing 1 to 20 of 95

AuthorMessage
Avatar

PK_Wonder

1. Posted:

Basically, rate every Wii U game (retail, eShop, or Virtual Console) that you've played out of ten. With each new post, I add all of the scores and divide by the number of votes for each game, figuring out the median and create a rankings list. Please don't edit your posts. If you change a score or want to add a new game, just post again so I'm sure to find it. :) I would prefer that people actually experience or play the game before voting. Please don't rate a game based off of an experience with a demo. I have no easy way of proving this, so everyone is welcome to participate, but please don't make your score lower or higher than it otherwise would be just to change the averages. Give your honest rating on the day's title.

Rankings List (Retail):
1. Mass Effect 3: Special Edition - 93.33 (3)
2. Monster Hunter 3 Ultimate - 92.81 (8)
3. LEGO City Undercover - 91. 67 (6)
4. Batman: Arkham City - Armored Edition - 88.73 (15)
5. Ninja Gaiden 3: Razor's Edge - 87.50 (1)
6. Assassin's Creed III - 82.92 (6)
7. Need for Speed: Most Wanted U - 82.50 (4)
8. New Super Mario Bros. U - 81.90 (26)
9. Darksiders II - 80.83 (6)
10. Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed - 80.77 (13)
11. Nintendo Land - 80.22 (31)
12. ZombiU - 80.19 (18)
13. Tekken Tag Tournament 2: Wii U Edition - 80.17 (6)
14. FIFA Soccer 13 - 80.00 (1)
15. Warriors Orochi 3 Hyper - 77.50 (1)
16. Skylanders Giants - 72.50 (1)
17. Call of Duty: Black Ops II - 72.00 (7)
18. Scribblenauts Unlimited - 70.50 (9)
19. Your Shape: Fitness Evolved 2013 - 70.00 (1)
20. Just Dance 4 - 70.00 (1)
21. Tank! Tank! Tank! - 65.00 (2)
22. Rabbids Land - 60.00 (1)
23. Marvel Avengers: Battle for Earth - 45.00 (3)
24. 007 Legends - 45.00 (1)
25. Disney Epic Mickey 2: The Power of Two - 30.00 (3)
26. SiNG Party - 30.00 (1)

Rankings List (eShop Exclusives):
1. Bit.Trip Presents...Runner2: Future Legend of Rhythm Alien - 85.50 (5)
2. Mighty Switch Force! Hyper Drive Edition - 82.50 (6)
3. Trine 2: Director's Cut - 77.69 (13)
4. The Cave - 77.00 (5)
5. Zen Pinball 2 - 77.00 (5)
6. Nano Assault Neo - 74.69 (8)
7. Little Inferno - 74.62 (13)
8. Puddle - 73.75 (4)
9. Chasing Aurora - 52.50 (6)

Rankings List (Virtual Console):
1. Punch-Out!! - 77.80 (10)
2. F-Zero - 73.40 (15)
3. Balloon Fight - 67.88 (13)

Edited on by PK_Wonder

3DS Friend Code: 0602-7082-6398 (Paul)
nnid: PK_Wonder

New Leaf friends, please show the same courtesy I would for you - do not trample or steal my flowers, and I'll definitely be happy to share any fruit, just please ask first. I'm also a huge fan of online KI: Uprising, among other titles.

Nintendo Network ID: PK_Wonder

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Chrono_Cross

2. Posted:

Punch Out!! (6)
Chasing Aurora (6)
Nintendo Land (8.5)
ZombiU (6.5)
Assassin's Creed III (8.25)
Call of Duty: Black Ops II (8)
New Super Mario Bros. U (8.25)
Trine 2: Director's Cut (7)
Little Inferno (7)
Balloon Fight (5)
F-Zero (9)
Monster Hunter 3 Ultimate (8.5)

Hopefully Nintendo's E3 conference this year can serve the Wii U justice.

Edited on by Chrono_Cross

Just for you.
"I'm just a musical prostitute, my dear." - Freddie Mercury

AuthorMessage
Avatar

SCAR392

3. Posted:

Nintendo Land = 8.0
New Super Mario Bros. U = 8.5
ZombiU = 7.5
Call of Duty: Black Ops II = 7.0
Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed = 7.5
Tekken Tag Tournament 2: Wii U Edition = 8.5
Monster Hunter 3 Ultimate = 9.0
Lego City Undercover = 9.0
Nano Assault Neo = 7.5
Mighty Switch Force HD Edition = 7.0
Bit.Trip Runner 2 = 8.0
Balloon Fight = 6.0
Punch Out!! = 7.0
F-Zero = 7.0

I like all the games I have quite a bit. I do take into consideration the price somewhat, too.
ZombiU has been worthless to me as of yet, because I fell victim to a glitch that made me start completely over and I haven't touched it since, but it's a pretty good game.

$¢@®³’²

AuthorMessage
Avatar

DefHalan

4. Posted:

ZombiU - 9
NintendoLand - 8.5
Batman Arkham City - 7.5
Mighty Switch Force HD - 8.5
Trine - 7
Chasing Aurora - 6.5
Little Inferno - 6
Nano Assault Neo - 7
Balloon Fight - 7.5
F-Zero - 8
Punch Out!!! - Haven't played enough

I have enjoyed most of my games. Slightly disappointed in Little Inferno just because I didn't feel like there was much re-play value. Chasing Aurora might go up once I can play multiplayer.

http://dudehugespeaks.tumblr.com/post/44243746261/nickels-dimes-and-quarters
http://www.penny-arcade.com/patv/episode/why-console-specs-dont-matter
http://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/200271/Video_Don_Daglow_on_nextgen_transition_traps_and_treasures.php

3DS Friend Code: 2621-2786-9784 | Nintendo Network ID: DefHalan

AuthorMessage
Avatar

MrGawain

5. Posted:

Arkham City: 10 (Genius in all areas, including use of gamepad)
Nintendoland: 8.5 (Brilliant with friends...but just OK on your own)
Darksiders 2: 8 (Great but glitchy and a little long)
NSMBU: 7.5 (Usual Mario quality but few surprises)
Tekken Tag 2: 7 (Reliant on multiplayer, solo game limited appeal)
AC3: 6 (Lost interest due to long prologue-almost as glitchy as Darksiders 2)

Smash Bros: who would win in a fight between Pikmin, Pacman, and Pokémon?

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Chomposaur

6. Posted:

Nintendo Land = 8
New Super Mario Bros. U = 8.5
ZombiU = 8.5
Call of Duty: Black Ops II = 6
Balloon Fight = 5
F-Zero = 7

Disclaimer: "All opinions are my own, please do not get offended by what i have to say"

Nintendo ID :JogurtTheYogurt FC :2294-4103-5306

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Jack_Package

7. Posted:

7/10

Jack_Package

AuthorMessage
Avatar

kkslider5552000

8. Posted:

8 (Nintendo Land)
5 (ZombiU, i'm sorry)
9 (Little Inferno)
7 (The Cave)

F-Zero VC I'm not too sure of (probably 6 because CONTROLS) but Balloon Fight is an automatic 11 obviously. I honestly wouldn't be surprised if someday I will have put at least as much time in Balloon Fight as I did my first playthrough of Xenoblade.

Edited on by kkslider5552000

3DS friend code: 2878 - 9709 - 5054
Nintendo Network ID: SliderGamer55

I have a Let's Play channel? How?!: https://www.youtube.com/user/SliderGamer55/videos

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Captain_Balko

9. Posted:

Nintendo Land: 7.8
New Super Mario Bros. U: 8.2
Scribblenauts Unlimited: 7.7
Zombi U: 8.5
Batman Arkham City: Armored Edition: 9.6
Balloon Fight: 6.5
F-Zero: 7.6
Punch Out!! Featuring Mr. Dream: 7.8

Captain_Balko

AuthorMessage
Avatar

PK_Wonder

10. Posted:

Towels wrote:

7/10

?

3DS Friend Code: 0602-7082-6398 (Paul)
nnid: PK_Wonder

New Leaf friends, please show the same courtesy I would for you - do not trample or steal my flowers, and I'll definitely be happy to share any fruit, just please ask first. I'm also a huge fan of online KI: Uprising, among other titles.

Nintendo Network ID: PK_Wonder

AuthorMessage
Avatar

SCAR392

11. Posted:

PK_Wonder wrote:

Towels wrote:

7/10

?

Maybe he just means overall.

$¢@®³’²

AuthorMessage
Avatar

astroshamu

12. Posted:

ZombiU 9/10
New super Mario bros U 8/10
Sonic racing 8/10
Trine 2 7/10
Little inferno 8/10 (didn't think I could spend 10 hours just burning things, I was proven wrong)
Chasing aurora 6/10
Puddle 7/10
Batman arkham city 8/10
Scribblenauts unlimited 8/10
Epic Mickey 2, 5/10
Nintendoland 8/10
The cave 7.5/10
F-zero 7/10
Balloon trip 7/10

Games I haven't finished but how much I'm enjoying them so far
Need for speed most wanted U 8/10
Lego city undercover 9/10
Monster hunter 3 ultimate 9/10
Bit trip runner 2, 8.5/10

Edited on by astroshamu

astroshamu

3DS Friend Code: 5198-2415-2393 | Nintendo Network ID: Astroshamu

AuthorMessage
Avatar

SunnyShores

13. Posted:

alright.

Zombi U - 8.5
New Super Mario Bros U - 8
Assassins Creed three - 9.5
Mass Effect three - 10
Nintendo Land - 10
Epic Mickey two - zero. just terrible.
Darksiders two - 8
Black ops two - 7
lego city undercover - 10
scribblenauts unlimited - 6
nano assault hd - 7
trine two - 8
bit trip runner - 10
mighty switch force - 8
the cave - 8
puddle - 7
little inferno - 8
batman arkham city - 10
wii street u, not a game but deserves a 10

hollow within

Nintendo Network ID: SunnyShores | Twitter: Z0MB1E_CHR1ST

AuthorMessage
Avatar

iphys

14. Posted:

Nintendo Land 6.0
Nano Assault Neo 8.5
Little Inferno 7.5
Puddle 8.0
Zen Pinball 2 9.0
Balloon Fight 6.5
F-Zero 5.5
Punch-Out!! 9.0

http://backloggery.com/iphys

3DS Friend Code: 1504-5686-7557 | Nintendo Network ID: iphys_eh

AuthorMessage
Avatar

MAB

15. Posted:

Untitled
Fairly sure alot of these review score threads have been brutally locked down and banished into nothingness... 100/10 ;)

MAB

AuthorMessage
Avatar

PK_Wonder

16. Posted:

Updated! Adding my score of 9.0 for Punch-Out!!

I'll try and update as frequently as possible. Remember; if you play a new game and want to add a score, or beat a game or have a new perspective on a game and want to change your score, please post again! I'm keeping track of any scores from previous posts in a separate calculation document, ready to just add the new scores and update the median! So tell me if I have to specifically change a score :)

Keep 'em coming, especially for those games with only one or two ratings! The more scores, the better representation!

3DS Friend Code: 0602-7082-6398 (Paul)
nnid: PK_Wonder

New Leaf friends, please show the same courtesy I would for you - do not trample or steal my flowers, and I'll definitely be happy to share any fruit, just please ask first. I'm also a huge fan of online KI: Uprising, among other titles.

Nintendo Network ID: PK_Wonder

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Jack_Package

17. Posted:

PK_Wonder wrote:

Towels wrote:

7/10

?

Its a running joke on One Life Left. Every review is scored 7/10

http://www.onelifeleft.com/

Jack_Package

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Banker-Style

18. Posted:

ZombiU 8/10
Darksiders 2 7/10
Tekken Tag 2 8/10
Assassin's Creed 9/10
NSMBU 8/10
Mass Effect 3 8/10
Sonic and AAll Stars Racing Transformed 8/10
Batman Arkham City 9/10
Nintendo Land 8/10

Nintendo Network ID: Da-Banker
3DS XL FC:3265-6271-5244
In 3000 years time,people will remember the name,Da-Banker,for being such a [Censored]

Nintendo Network ID: Da-Banker

AuthorMessage
Avatar

JaivfromONM

19. Posted:

Nintendo Land 8.5
New Super Mario Bros U 8.5
ZombiU 9
Trine 2 8
Chasing Aurora 1
Monster Hunter 3
Rayman Legends 9
Batman Arkham City 7

Edited on by JaivfromONM

Subscribe to me on YouTube and add me on the Nintendo Network
JaivfromONM

3DS Friend Code: 3394-3560-6744 | Nintendo Network ID: JaivfromONM | Twitter: JaiCaputsnik

AuthorMessage
Avatar

GoombaJMR

20. Posted:

Nintendo Land: 81
NSMBU: 75
Trine 2: 85
Sonic All Stars Transformed: 75

Unfortunately my WII U Library has been a bit empty.
Ill try posting a 3DS scorecard, cause this is pretty cool

3DS Friend Code 0860-3671-7874 - Notify me somehow if you do add me!
Sign this Paper Mario TTYD 3DS Petition!
http://www.change.org/en-GB/petitions/nintendo-and-intelligent-systems-remake-of-paper-mario-the-thousand-year-door-on-the-3ds?

Twitter: GoombaJMR