Melee has way better physics and mechanics, which is all it needs to make Brawl look like crap in comparison.

Yes, I've played Melee lately. It's a great game. I'm aware that it can become a button masher, but the same is true for most fighting games. But the person who actually knows what they're doing and has the skill can easily overcome a button masher. Thus creating balance between the casual and core players. Brawl is balanced more towards the casual.
lol. "noobs"? You realize that's just a word that nerds made up for people who play a way that they don't like, right? I don't play "competitively." I play for fun. The same reason I play any game. The items make the game more fun because of all the crazy stuff that happens. The matches seem so much more boring without the items, and in Brawl there's actually still a lot of chance without the items, between tripping and stage hazards. If there's an option to turn items off, there should be an option to turn stage hazards off, too. Or even different levels of intensity, depending on how chaotic the players want the match to be.

I love air-dodging in Melee. You should hear the things my friends say when they see me do it. The falling afterwards balanced out the fact that you could just become invincible to anything for a short period of time.

That's all I needed to say.

Because the gameplay is slowed down doesn't make the game "balanced more towards the casual" (that doesn't even make any sense. If it's "balanced" how does it go towards the casual? lol) And this doesn't explain anything on why Melee is a better core experience. What you just said applies to both games.

lol. "noobs"? You realize that's just a word that nerds made up for people who play a way that they don't like, right?

Lol we're all nerds here, dude. Welcome to the internet.

I don't play "competitively." I play for fun. The same reason I play any game. The items make the game more fun because of all the crazy stuff that happens. The matches seem so much more boring without the items, and in Brawl there's actually still a lot of chance without the items, between tripping and stage hazards. If there's an option to turn items off, there should be an option to turn stage hazards off, too. Or even different levels of intensity, depending on how chaotic the players want the match to be.

Wait what? You complain about luck and yet you like playing with items? Items are the only "casual" aspect of Brawl. Only with items on does the game become a casual luck-fest (Melee is the same way). If you don't like luck in your Smash games, turn the items off. And you playing for fun has nothing to do with why Melee is better suited to core gamers.

As for stage hazards, they are apart of every Smash Bros. game. You play the game long enough and you'll eventually learn how to avoid them in each stage. And tripping is an exaggerated issue in Brawl. Yeah its annoying, but when does it cause you to lose?

IAmNotWill wrote:

WaveBoy wrote:

As for Brawl being better than Melee...Well, i still feel that Melee's core gameplay has the slight upper hand in a couple departments mainly because of the multidirectional air dodging 'and' because you can stay up in the air a lot longer than sinking to the ground. Plus, Melee just feels a bit quicker where as Brawl is a little more floatier. I know that wave dashing has been abused but if they can somehow work around this and deliver the same air dodging that was seen in Melee I'd be in heaven.I still remember the day when i got brawl....And discovered that my precious air dodging was basically gimped & destroyed! You sink to the ground like a tank after performing it....And you can't air dodge/hover over peoples heads while on the ground like a ninja, nor can you control it in the air. I was so pee'd off that i didn't even wan't to play it. My friends didn't seem to care, but i had the grumpiest look on my face the entire time haha....

Seriously? You're like the only person I've seen that likes the air-dodging in Melee. The directional aspect of it was cool, but you could only perform it once and after that you would sink and couldn't do anything at all except float left-to-right as you fell until you hit the ground. In Brawl, you could dodge multiple times, and still use attacks in the air so you wouldn't be vulnerable as you fell.

I love air-dodging in Melee. You should hear the things my friends say when they see me do it. The falling afterwards balanced out the fact that you could just become invincible to anything for a short period of time.

You don't become invincible after you air dodge in Melee, or in any Smash Bros. game.

Mickeymac wrote:

Melee has way better physics and mechanics, which is all it needs to make Brawl look like crap in comparison.

That's all I needed to say.

The mechanics are the same in every Smash Bros. game....

If think Melee is a better game thats fine. But you have to give legitimite reasons on why you think its a better core experience.

Don't worry about it, man. Agree to disagree. And yes, I know we're all nerds here.

Thats cool. I just wanted to know why you feel Melee is better suited to core gamers.

The speed, the physics (e.g. gravity) and the hidden techniques.
Tripping wasn't extremely annoying or anything, but it just goes to show how it helps to level the playing field between casuals and core. The casual gamer will often do something like push a button not knowing what it does and stuck doing that making the player vulnerable for a short period of time (e.g. Jigglypuff's sleep, Snake's nikita, etc.). This way, even a skilled player will "slip up," even if for no fault of his own. Melee had no such thing as auto slip ups.
It's all the little things added up. Not any one big thing.

While I liked Melee for it's competitiveness, I preferred Brawl more because of it's CHAOS! Just was more fun to me.

...
WAIT A MINUTE! GET BACK ON TOPIC YOU HOOLIGANS!

Yeah, this sums it up. And he's also right about the fact that this discussion has gotten rather of topic. I thought this was about Namco helping in the development of the next Smash Bros, not an augment over Melee and Brawl!

This, yeah the slipping and floatiness is irritating...but I love Brawl more than Melee simply because of the chaos. Chaotic stages, more chaotic items like Smash Ball and Assist Trophy.

I'll help get back on topic! Since Namco Bandai is helping development I demand at least one Digimon be put in! Agumon, Guilmon, Wargreymon, Gargomon, or Gallantmon (that one's not gonna happen, TysonQ >:3). Anyone would do. Just so we can pit a Pokemon against a Digimon. It'd be my favorite Smash Bros.

I doubt we"ll see many Namco characters. If there's any at all it'll be Pac-Man only.

Well, then Digimon are pointless.

Sooo, wait is Bandai partnered with Namco or something? Just wondering, lol. And yeah, chances are it'll be just Pac-Man...I'm hoping Square will be involved somehow too.

You didn't know? Bandai and Namco merged into one company several years ago.

You successfully read my mind and got everyone back on topic.

All in day's work I guess

Well in video games I see Namco Bandai, lol...elsewhere I see just Bandai, and sometimes just Namco, and confused me. xD

How dare you say that about Gargomon and Wargreymon!? You clearly aren't aware of who are the best Digimon. u_u

i am thinking that panda and maybe roger from tekken might be a good fit

@Smash Brothers Melee V.S Smash Brothers Brawl
Anyone who says Melee is Better than Brawl, I respect your opinion and all but I must say that Melee was way too buggy and required just as much skill to play as Metaknight. The game was broken and had so many abusable exploits to the point where people focused on the exploits rather than play the game the way it was meant to be. They went as far as to make names for these exploits and dub them "Advanced Melee Techniques". I'm sure most of you know what I am talking about, for those of you who don't I suggest you go look it up on youtube. Melee has so many issues that Brawl has cleared up I don't see why anyone would stick to playing melee, unless for the simple fact that you just don't accept new things. I call that the Final Fantasy 7 Syndrome.
The Final Fantasy 7 Syndrome is common in old gamers and it hinders a gamer from moving on to better things. The Final Fantasy 7 Syndrome is a chronic illness where you believe that one game can not get any better no matter how many of that game the franchise pumps out. Take Final Fantasy 7 For instance. The game was a milestone of the franchise. The first Final Fantasy to use a 3d graphic engine. It had a great story and remarkable characters. It was released in 1997 for Playstation (15 years ago) To this day people believe that it is the best Final Fantasy ever created. Those people are sick. Many Final Fantasy games have surpassed FF7 but they refuse to grow up and move on. FF10 and 13 have done something that Final Fantasy 7 could never accomplish. FF7 is old and played out and needs to be buried in the desert with the E.T. Atari Games. Same goes for Melee. The game is merely a shadow in comparison to Brawl. Yes it has characters that we would love to return in the upcoming title, but that's about all it has going for it. I have met people that believe Super Smash Brothers 64 is the best of the 3. Melee has had it's time in the light, but is out-shined by Brawl, and thus will be the same fate as Brawl when Smash Brothers Universe is released for WiiU.

As for characters in the next "Smash" title

I believe these people should be added as playables

Characters to Add:
Matthew- (Golden Sun Dark Dawn)
Karis-(Golden Sun Dark Dawn
Agatio-(Golden Sun the Lost Age)
Karst-(Golden Sun the Lost Age)
Shadow The Hedgehog (Sonic Adventure 2)
Miles "Tails" Prower (Sonic the Hedgehog 2)
Knuckles The Echidna (Sonic the Hedgehog 3)
Skyward Sword "Link" (Replace Toon Link)
Poo (Earthbound)
Starman (Mother/Earthbound)
Lyn(Fire Emblem)
Roy(Fire Emblem)- (change his moveset a bit more to make him more diverse from Marth)
Mewtwo (Pokemon) He was the most unique non cloned character
Enhanced pokemon Trainer(When changing outfits the Trainer and Pokemon Starters should change also) I.E Trainer White with B&W starters
Lloyed(Tales of Symphonia)
Sheena(Tales of Symphonia)
Emil(Tales of Symphonia: Knights of Ratatosk)
Marta(Tales of Symphonia: Knights of Ratatosk)
Kos Mos(Xenosaga)
Pac Man
Clovis (Dragon Buster)
Red Barron/Blue Max(SkyKid)
Digman(Dig Dug)
Special Guest: Mega Man (He deserves it more than anyone else)

Characters to remove:
Snake
Toon Link
Olimar
Didikong
Wario
Metaknight
DeDeDe
Jigglypuff

Roster should be like 50 Characters Tops
I don't believe in Tekken Characters being in this game, They dont suit the atmosphere, that and they are actual fighting game genre characters
Everyone from Brawl should be in it except those on the list above. Ill shop up a character select screen layout.

^ I agree with your roster except for some of the characters to remove. Olimar is definitely going to stay! Jigglypuff is one of the original twelve, so I doubt that will happen (as much I don't like her/it). And everyone else should come back, except for Toon Link and Snake, those two can leave for all I care.

But I must commend you for wanting Roy back, because it seems your one of the only other people on here that wants the same. Of course like you said his moveset should be changed a least a little to make him different from Marth.