Topic: VC vs Remake

Do you absolutely want the original game on the VC, or can you get by with a remake?

I can usually get by with a remake, provided they're faithful enough. However, true classics like Super Mario Bros. cannot be successfully remade. The only thing they really needed to add to Super Mario Bros. 3, for example, was a save feature.

Though Super Mario Bros. 3 was successfully remade with save feature included aaaages ago on the SNES. What are you saying?

what are you talking about? the Mario Bros. games were successfully remade via Super Mario All-Stars, not to mention the Super Mario Advance series.

umm...... who cares

there still fun and Great Games, (remake or not)

I HIGHLY prefer having the original on the Virtual Console to the remakes. Yes I'm picky that way.

Now video game remakes aren't all that bad, at least not as bad as movie remakes, but video game remakes are mostly pointless unless you can dramatically shape the game enough to where it is worth buying.

Depends on what game it is.

This, but if it's a good game then I'll buy both. For comparisons.

Yeah, I can play Super Mario World on 4 different systems.

Super Mario Advance 4 added too much. Remove the voices, e-Reader thing, and larger inventory window, and you have what I want.

I'd like a remake of the original LOZ that includes a map of Hyrule.

All depends on how much you change the game from the original.

What you're looking for has been available for more than 15 years...It's called Super Mario All Stars. It's actually good I'd check it out