Retro Forum

Topic: Game vs. Game

Showing 1,781 to 1,800 of 2,068

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Suicune

1,781. Posted:

SMB3. In NSMBU it is super easy to get lives and the acorn is too readily available.

3DS name: Arminillo
3DS FC: 1118-0310-8459

"The Rich Boy wakes Up, But is Handsome."
-DeviousSnorlax

Nintendo Network ID: Arminillo

AuthorMessage
Avatar

WanderFan91

1,782. Posted:

Not exactly a fair vote since I only played one of them, but I'll stick with Super Mario Bros. 3
EDIT: Well I think it's highly apparent which game is going to win this time!

Edited on by WanderFan91

AKA StarBoy91
Ah, irony
Wanderloggery | StarBlog
Massive retro gamer with a heart <3
Big Wander Over Yonder fan
Also a fan of Gravity and all things 16-bit
23 and proud =)
To each their own

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Klimbatize

1,783. Posted:

Mario 3, though NSMB Wii U is very good.

  A person without a sense of humor is like a wagon without springs. It's jolted by every pebble on the road.

www.Retrodrome.net
Top 64 Nintendo 64 games of all time
 
 

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Chuie

1,784. Posted:

Mario 3 ftw

3DS FC:1332-8177-3517 currently playing:Tales of xillia (2nd playthrough) BIG TALES OF FAN! BIG SONIC FAN! lloyd x sheena yuri x judith
PSN ID:Bioshock1313
youtube:ChuieTheUmbreon my new channel
i was mieu-fire

AuthorMessage
Avatar

KingDunsparce

1,785. Posted:

Super Mario Bros. 3 :)

"I'm the man who's gonna burn your house down! With the lemons! I'm gonna get my engineers to invent a combustible lemon that burns your house down!" ―Cave Johnson
Join the Chit-Chat Crew! :P
Behold: My Sparceloggery
Needs more Dunsparce. Much better

3DS Friend Code: 2938-6384-0441 | Nintendo Network ID: Pikminsi

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Bulbousaur

1,786. Posted:

Both games are great, but Mario 3 all the way.

Bulbousaur

3DS Friend Code: 5112-3450-2144 | Nintendo Network ID: Bulbousaur

AuthorMessage
Avatar

misswliu81

1,787. Posted:

super mario bros 3. new super mario bros U is excellent still

misswliu81

AuthorMessage
Avatar

WesCash

1,788. Posted:

Is this question for real? Super Mario Bros. 3 is always the correct answer.

WesCash

3DS Friend Code: 2019-9710-8219

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Joshers744

1,789. Posted:

This is tough. They are from different time periods so it's hard for me to compare. I mean, obviously U has more to it, and what can be some fun mutliplayer (not to mention it's a lot prettier)...but if you can consider the quality of games then, and how good 3 was for it's time, compared to how good U is for it's time....I may just go ahead with 3...that's tough though

Nintendo ID : Whopper744
XBL : Jataylor744

My 3DS friend code is : 4639-9014-2585Online games i have right now : MK7, Mario Tennis O, Kid Icarus: Uprising, Sonic Generations, Luigi's Mansion Dark Moon, Animal Crossing : New Leaf

-John 3:16

3DS Friend Code: 4639-9014-2585 | Nintendo Network ID: Whopper744

AuthorMessage
Avatar

DestinyMan

1,790. Posted:

I vote for Super Mario Bros. 3. It's tough to compare two Mario games from two very different time periods, and techincally NSMBU should be better because its more advanced, but SMB3 is a true classic and it does so many traditional 2D Mario elements right. It's also one of my favorite Mario games, so that helps. NSMBU is still good on its own, but SMB3 is so fun even today with its pick-up-and-play gameplay and nifty levels and power-ups.

Most wanted Smash Bros. newcomers
1. King K. Rool
2. Mii
3. Takamaru
4. Kat & Ana
Little Mac was on the list, but he's been confirmed.
Miiverse
https://miiverse.nintendo.net/users/DestinyMan

Nintendo Network ID: DestinyMan

AuthorMessage
Avatar

CrazyOtto

1,791. Posted:

I vote SMB3, but NSMBU is an amazing multiplayer and it's a great party game.

Rest in Peace ShiftyLook
I help keep these threads updated: New 3DS VC games in Japan, Missing 3DS VC and Wii U VC between regions, and Full of list first party Game Boy, Game Boy Color, and Game Gear games missing from the 3DS VC.

3DS Friend Code: 4511-0465-7453 | Nintendo Network ID: MrSRArter

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Maskeraid

1,792. Posted:

Super Mario Bros 3, it was the first Mario to do DLC.

My Maskloggery
[16:08] LordJumpMad Hides his gut with a griddle
[16:08] Reala: what ljm does for cash is ljm's business
[16:08] LordJumpMad: Gotta look good my my next game u_u

"He say oogly? What means that, oogly?"
"Grr... He means your face would frighten small children! Now be quiet!"

3DS Friend Code: 2921-9222-4787 | Nintendo Network ID: Happy_Masked_Man

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Geonjaha

1,793. Posted:

Super Mario Bros. 3
I'm insulted that this is even in question.

I make Pixel Art on occasion.

3DS Friend Code: 2277-6645-7215

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Emaan

1,794. Posted:

Geonjaha wrote:

I'm insulted that this is even in question.

I don't think many here (looking at the votes) expected New Super Mario Bros. U to actually come out on top. I just thought it would be interesting to challenge nostalgia. You know, when we hold certain classic games at such high standards that we don't fully appreciate the new things.

I think it speaks volumes that we actually had a few people who liked the new game better.

Both games are excellent in their own regard. So they're both winners. This is all for fun and interesting discussion, so you probably shouldn't feel insulted. :O

Updating the games and 'announcing' the winner when I get home~ :p

I believe in make believe~
[20:48] Emaan dances the pikpik emaan;
[20:48] Sensei_PikPik does the pikpik emaan
The Emaaloggery
✰ I'm not really here that often anymore ✰

3DS Friend Code: 0559-6948-0467 | Nintendo Network ID: Emaann

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Geonjaha

1,795. Posted:

Emaan wrote:

Geonjaha wrote:

I'm insulted that this is even in question.

I don't think many here (looking at the votes) expected New Super Mario Bros. U to actually come out on top. I just thought it would be interesting to challenge nostalgia. You know, when we hold certain classic games at such high standards that we don't fully appreciate the new things.

I think it speaks volumes that we actually had a few people who liked the new game better.

Both games are excellent in their own regard. So they're both winners. This is all for fun and interesting discussion, so you probably shouldn't feel insulted. :O

Updating the games and 'announcing' the winner when I get home~ :p

Haha, I was joking - It would be pretty stupid to actually feel insulted just because someone likes different games.

With that said, I don't have any nostalgia for the first title. I played it for the first time a long while after it first came out. The fact of the matter is that the NSMB series has become so formulaic and repetitive in its graphic style and music that the games just aren't innovative. Assuming both games were made today, and disregarding all of this said above, then yes, New Super Mario Bros. U wins on many counts. But after 25 years it would be pathetic if it didn't.

I make Pixel Art on occasion.

3DS Friend Code: 2277-6645-7215

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Ralizah

1,796. Posted:

SMB 3. Of course.

Friend Code: 3351-4294-3552

AuthorMessage
Avatar

Emaan

1,797. Posted:

Winner: Super Mario Bros. 3

Untitled

New: Nintendo Land vs. Wii Sports

It's a launch title showdown! Which game better represented the system's main concept? Better yet, which game did you enjoy more?

Nintendo Land: 1
Wii Sports: 0

Start voting now!

I believe in make believe~
[20:48] Emaan dances the pikpik emaan;
[20:48] Sensei_PikPik does the pikpik emaan
The Emaaloggery
✰ I'm not really here that often anymore ✰

3DS Friend Code: 0559-6948-0467 | Nintendo Network ID: Emaann

AuthorMessage
Avatar

CrazyOtto

1,798. Posted:

This is a hard one. They're both great but I'm going for Wii Sports.

Rest in Peace ShiftyLook
I help keep these threads updated: New 3DS VC games in Japan, Missing 3DS VC and Wii U VC between regions, and Full of list first party Game Boy, Game Boy Color, and Game Gear games missing from the 3DS VC.

3DS Friend Code: 4511-0465-7453 | Nintendo Network ID: MrSRArter

AuthorMessage
Avatar

CapnPancakes

1,799. Posted:

Nintendo Land by a country mile.
They both show off their system's potential quite well, but Nintendo Land is just the better game. It's much more immersive to me and there's a lot more to do and it's just so charming.

Nintendo Land: 2
Wii Sports: 1

Runs the NintendoLife Best VGM Tourney Come Vote!
The Pancakeloggery
Keep it frosty people.
My Super Mario Galaxy Bio courtesy of Dark-Luigi.

3DS Friend Code: 3523-2096-8169 | Nintendo Network ID: Capn_Pancakes

AuthorMessage
Avatar

DestinyMan

1,800. Posted:

I vote for Nintendo Land. Wii Sports did its job well for the Wii, but the only thing I really enjoyed in that game was Bowling. Nintendo Land has minigames that are not so "mini" and it also features Miiverse, a huge feature of the Wii U, very well and probably has the largest community on Miiverse. Plus, the overall experience has a lot more depth.

Most wanted Smash Bros. newcomers
1. King K. Rool
2. Mii
3. Takamaru
4. Kat & Ana
Little Mac was on the list, but he's been confirmed.
Miiverse
https://miiverse.nintendo.net/users/DestinyMan

Nintendo Network ID: DestinyMan