Topic: Game vs. Game

Posts 1,301 to 1,320 of 2,067


Winner: Kirby Super Star


NEW: Paper Mario: Sticker Star vs. Super Paper Mario

Alright here's the two controversial entries in the Paper Mario series. Which one did you like better? Did the sticker system and difficulty break the experience for you in Sticker Star? Was the parting from the traditional RPG experience in Super Paper Mario too much for you? I guess we'll find out which one is deemed better among the community.

Paper Mario: Sticker Star: 1
Super Paper Mario: 0

Start voting now!

yoshi's disco
pink ness -quik backloggery
✰ not around as much as I used to be :o ) ✰

Nintendo Network ID: Emaann


Sticker Star is more of an RPG than Super Paper Mario. It's different in ways, but it still has the traditional Paper Mario humor and good music while still keeping a turn-based battle system. While Super Paper Mario also has good humor and music, all it has going for it against Sticker Star is original characters in my book.

I vote for Paper Mario: Sticker Star.


Sticker Star. Screw SPM's awesome story, Sticker Star did something completely new in the gameplay.

[16:08] LordJumpMad Hides his gut with a griddle
[16:08] Reala: what ljm does for cash is ljm's business
[16:08] LordJumpMad: Gotta look good my my next game u_u


Yep Sticker Star for me as well. It's really a great game. Still not 3ds game of the year though.

John 8:7 He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone.

MERG said:

If I was only ever able to have Monster Hunter and EO games in the future, I would be a happy man.


Nintendo Network ID: SpoonyTech | Twitter:


SPM. Had awesome gameplay and the characters were great. Sticker Star felt more like a rehash in my opinion. The stickers didn't really add or change too much about the game series.

Edited on by Zowolffo

Never Gonna Give Mew Up!

Nintendo Network ID: NJanders


Happy_Mask wrote:

Sticker Star. Screw SPM's awesome story, Sticker Star did something completely new in the gameplay.

Um, didn't Super Paper Mario do something completely new in the gameplay too? I don't see how "it's different" can be a good reason for liking either more or less, since they're both very different from the original and Thousand Year Door.

Anyway, my vote's for Super Paper Mario. Instead of attatching a gimmic to a battle system and by doing so not making it as effective as its predecesors (my opinion), Super Paper Mario threw it all out the window and did something unique from the ground up. Also, SPM made fun of nerds, which was something that was funnier than anything else in the series (although I loved the hipster jokes in Sticker Star).

Edited on by moomoo

Best thread ever
Feel free to add me on Miiverse or PSN.
Miiverse is Moomoo14, PSN is Moomoo1405390

Nintendo Network ID: Moomoo14


Classic Game Room's review is pretty much spot on what I think about Sticker Star. Sticker Star is what Super Paper Mario wanted to be.

Forget the Nintendo seal of approval
I only see GC 4.0 happening if I become a English major. Yeah, it is happening now. GC 4.0 will be released in 2020.
My Bio by True_Hero
My Soundcloud



I personally love both these games despite some of the mixed reactions they got. Sticker Star is fantastic and I actually enjoy the sticker mechanic a lot, not to mention the absolutely delightful soundtrack. Super Paper Mario really did things differently though, and no other Mario game is quite like it.

I think i'll go with Super Paper Mario because it is so unique, has great writing and characters, and you can play the game as Bowser. Sold.

Edited on by ThePirateCaptain

VISIT MY NEW BLOG 16-Bit Heaven.
Runs the NintendoLife Best VGM Tourney Come Vote!
The Pancakeloggery
Keep it frosty people.
My Super Mario Galaxy Bio courtesy of Dark-Luigi.

Nintendo Network ID: Capn_Pancakes


SPM, It's terribly underrated, has best story and music so SPM

mods delete me

Nintendo Network ID: Shadowing27


I vote Sticker Star.
It's one of the best games I've played.

Some of my favorite games:
Ghost Trick, StarFox 64, WarioLand: Shake It, Kid Icarus, The Legendary Starfy, Endless Ocean: Blue World, Zelda: Minish Cap, Pokemon Snap, Diamond Trust of London, Gyromite, Katamari Damacy, EarthBound, Mario Kart 7, and Sonic Generations(PS3).


i didnt really care for either one but i guess ima go for stickstars
but TTYD and the first paper mario will always be the best paper mario games

You smell


Gonna go with SPM. That game got so much emotion out of me when I first played it.

You don't die until you're dead!

Nintendo Network ID: TysonOfTime


Sticker Star~

Style Savvy Shop Code: R22M60G78 | XboxLive: Nick kun13 | Steam: Nick_kun13
Console history 1998 - today: N64 & PS1, GCN & PS2, Wii & 360, Wii U & XBONE
Handheld history 1999 - today: GBC, GBA SP, og DS, og 3DS & XL,

Nintendo Network ID: Nick-kun13


Please login or sign up to reply to this topic