Forums

Topic: Kinect vs Move

Posts 41 to 60 of 115

Slapshot

@Winslow.... exactly.... Ive stated previously that the Wii is incredible when its good. Galaxy 2 is freaking amazing hands down. I dont see how anyone could disagree that the game isnt. If the Wii had more horsepower to push the controls even further it would be incredible what it could achieve. With MOVE using a camera to motion track its just a better way of capturing the input and its working better. Bottom line is that it works, and a guy Ive talked to at GDC who played the games said its incredible and well worth the investment. The software lineup is already getting deep, they are saying like 50+ titles by the end of the year.

..... Preordered my extra controllers as well this weekend lol.

But, Im a disc golfer. Me and my wife and family all play in sanctioned tournament every month and are gearing up right now for the annual Southern National Tournament with the Pros at watch. Sports Championship (pack-in game) has disc golf included and finally got the info that it works perfectly. The disc physics are spot on and the multiple disc fly different just like in real life. The motion controls are supposed to be dead on as well from what I got from a tester. I was sold right there, hands down. Didnt care what the cost was!

Edited on by Slapshot

3DS FC: 4382-2029-8015
All my News and Reviews in One convenient place!

My Nintendo: Slapshot82 | Nintendo Network ID: Slapshot82 | Twitter:

LinktotheFuture

I think I am going to pick up the Move bundle with Sports Champions and the Brunswick Bowling game as well. They look fun, I am going to have to find out for myself if they are more fun than Wii Sports and Wii Sports Resort.

The chickens are restless.
3DS Friend Code: 1547-5282-6926

LuWiiGi

I will buy neither, but I prefer Move, even if it is a shameless copy of the Wii.

No animals were harmed in the making of this post.

WarioWare: DIY: FC - 0904 7088 3011
Favourite users: PunnyGuy, StarBoy91, cloudcult10, Xkhaoz, Dragoon, DannyBoy, NintyFan, NintendoPurist, Sadman, Wooperman1, Golgo, GamesX99, turtlelink. The rest of you are cool too, though.

Slapshot

Move has now shown and proven with lots of hands on time that its a long way from a Wii ripoff. The way you can interact with environments is amazing. 18 days!

3DS FC: 4382-2029-8015
All my News and Reviews in One convenient place!

My Nintendo: Slapshot82 | Nintendo Network ID: Slapshot82 | Twitter:

Hokori

Well I think that move is better if they use it right, for me though im not totally all for motion control anywhere even on wii, to me its not about how accurate the controls are, its about how fun the game is, look what Nintendo's doing... with Epic Yarn, DKCR, Other M, NSMBW

Digitaloggery
3DS FC: Otaku1
WiiU: 013017970991
Nintendo of Japan
niconico community is full of kawaii!
Must finish my backlagg or at least get close this year
W...

castlehominid99

It depends i will be picking both up but they both are a lot better than the wii. THe wii beat them to motion but it isnt precise at all like u cant angle ur wiimote or hav the screen do the exact motion u do. i wud still say kinect even tho im looking forward to move aswell because it is a new idea and ps move is just making the wii a lot better

PSN ID: castlehominid99

3DS Friend Code: 0731-4849-6143 | Nintendo Network ID: theironmango

castlehominid99

slapshot82 wrote:

Move has now shown and proven with lots of hands on time that its a long way from a Wii ripoff. The way you can interact with environments is amazing. 18 days!

I get my move in 6 days haha

PSN ID: castlehominid99

3DS Friend Code: 0731-4849-6143 | Nintendo Network ID: theironmango

turtlelink

LuWiiGi wrote:

I will buy neither, but I prefer Move, even if it is a shameless copy of the Wii.

But, it isn't a shameless copy of the Wii.

TurtleLink's backloggery
Brawl FC: 4425-1340-4519
The Sister Complex Kingpin of Steel!

OldBoy

If this thing has been in development for 6 years!! they should sack their R&D team.Why would it take them so long to release it?The Wii was a first day hit.You think Sony would of got it to market a bit quicker if that's the case.
Anyhoo I'm actually considering a PS3 myself, mainly as a blu ray player, but I'll be keeping and eye on how Move games progress.The launch line up is pretty appaling by the looks of it but I'm sure there will be some good stuff down the line.Move does seem to do what the Wii promised to but couldn't ,but it all comes down to the software when all is said and done. At least now I've got a trusty website to look at reviews cough Movemodo*cough still think MoveMojo would have been a better name though

What's this bit for again?

Stuffgamer1

@Luigi78: Because Sony wasn't satisfied with the quality of the hardware they could make at a reasonable cost at the time. The reason the Wii's motion controls are so bad is that it was what was affordable at launch. By waiting four years, Sony has come up with a product that meets their standards.

My Backloggery Updated sporadically. Got my important online ID's on there, anyway. :P

Nintendo Network ID: Stuffgamer1

Mabbit

from my viewpoint, kinect is going to fail...hard. a lot of the people who own Xbox 360s are people who play Halo and Gears of War. i dont think that the Sci-fi bloody FPS gamers will want anything to do with a virtual baby tiger. kinect is obviously aimed at the less serious gaming group, but the thing is, everybody in that group has probably already bought a wii and they prolly wont want to pay 400 dollars for a new console + add-on. and then come the games. a ton of reviewers are already fed up with the amount of party/mini-game games on the wii, and thats what a lot of the games on kinect will be. kinect cant really make any action adventure games because kinect has no controller. this means you basically cant walk in the game. also it must feel really weird to hold an imaginary gun. this basically limits kinect to party games, sims, racing games and possibly on-rail shooters. yeah, theres been a lot of those type of games on wii. if i was a critic and i had to write a review on ANOTHER motion controllered mini-game collection, id be pissed! this would result in low review scores and overall less sales. i have a few more points, but i don't want to make my post any longer and im pretty sure im gonna get a few critical replies already.

VERDICT!:
Move wins!

Edited on by Mabbit

Heisenberg says "relax!"
The user formerly known as briunj04
PSN=mabbit04/Summoner name(LoL)=briunj04

Magi

briunj04 wrote:

i dont think that the Sci-fi bloody FPS gamers will want anything to do with a virtual baby tiger.

You're correct: I don't want anything to do with a virtual baby tiger.

My kids do though.

Magi

Sean007s

In terms of sales. Kinect will most likely win due to Microsoft's aggressive marketing. The 360 also has more casual players than it does compared to the PS3.

The MOVE will sell good but not as good as kinect. Quote me on it.

Playstation Network ID:Sean007s
Wii Friend Code:8597 6921 2179 2755. Add me please..
Skype:Sean007s
Currently playing:Uncharted 2,Soul Caliber 4,ModernWarfare2,Final Fantasy XIII.
Excited for: Fallout New Vegas,Gran Turismo 5,CoD:Black Ops.

Aviator

Sean007s wrote:

In terms of sales. Kinect will most likely win due to Microsoft's aggressive marketing. The 360 also has more casual players than it does compared to the PS3.

The MOVE will sell good but not as good as kinect. Quote me on it.

You do know Sony have outnumbered Microsoft in the console market.

QUEEN OF SASS

It's like, I just love a cowboy
You know
I'm just like, I just, I know, it's bad
But I'm just like
Can I just like, hang off the back of your horse
And can you go a little faster?!

Bankai

Magi wrote:

briunj04 wrote:

i dont think that the Sci-fi bloody FPS gamers will want anything to do with a virtual baby tiger.

You're correct: I don't want anything to do with a virtual baby tiger.

My kids do though.

You mean kids really do exist and they really are consumers of video games?

Wow, I thought the only consoles that families ever, ever had were Nintendos, and the only xbox 360s and PS3s that are sold go to the 18-30 year old single yuppies.

The thought of a child playing an Xbox 360 is mind blowing!

James

This thread is about to implode under the weight of the sarcasm on display.

James

Nintendo Network ID: DaddyNewtsUK

LzWinky

Sean007s wrote:

In terms of sales. Kinect will most likely win due to Microsoft's aggressive marketing. The 360 also has more casual players than it does compared to the PS3.

The MOVE will sell good but not as good as kinect. Quote me on it.

And how exactly do you know this?

Current games: Everything on Switch

Switch Friend Code: SW-5075-7879-0008 | My Nintendo: LzWinky | Nintendo Network ID: LzWinky

mnementh

Move IS a huge rip-off.. at the very least, Sony should admit that the SUB quality navigation controller is a rip-off of the Nunchuk and pay Nintendo some royalties for that, but the whole thing is a rip off. Having a colored wand with the eyetoy doesn't disprove this.. motion has been there for many many years, but copying the design is just embarrassing really, and bundling it with a SPORTS game.. wow.

Literally this move by sony makes me sick. I've played PS3 games, but this turns me off big time. By the way, to those who love sony or this new accessory, you don't need to respond and argue... you're entitled to your opinion. I'm not convinced, not about the technology either. There are many reports about lag, recongition and lighting condition problems etc, and there are some nice features you can do with the wii remote and the nuncuk that Sony failed to copy for their own reasons (though they CONSIDERED them - even the speaker...)

So yeah, Wii wins here. IMHO.

So ends a saga older than time itself.
The World's oldest and fiercest army has been led to victory, and a lost generation
is delivered from its fear of extinction. As the sun sets over the
field of conflict the dinosaurs disperse, hoping never to set foot
in this place a...

LzWinky

turtlelink wrote:

LuWiiGi wrote:

I will buy neither, but I prefer Move, even if it is a shameless copy of the Wii.

But, it isn't a shameless copy of the Wii.

You're right. It's a shameful copy of the Wii

Current games: Everything on Switch

Switch Friend Code: SW-5075-7879-0008 | My Nintendo: LzWinky | Nintendo Network ID: LzWinky

This topic has been archived, no further posts can be added.