http://gamewise.co/games/top-rated

Pretty good list imo, it's rated by the users which is why I guess. Lots of classic Nintendo games on there, 6 out of the top 10 were on big N consoles.

That was a good list. I'm surprised Portal 2 wasn't higher up there though.

Super Mario Galaxy 1 and 2 at #5 and #2 respectively? Both fine games but no way. Also, Skies of Arcadia is somehow on there twice.

I don't agree with the list at all
I mean is "Zelda a link to the past" really better than Zelda majoras mask?!
And paper Mario on place 97?
Kid Icarus uprising on place 82???
And my favourite game of all time on place 34?!

Well, I can't agree with that list pretty much at all. Kid Icarus: Uprising was WAY too low, Skyward Sword was WAY too low, aLthP too high, the Galaxies too high...Nope. Don't agree at all. Sorry.

Plenty of great games in that list,most of them were either too high or too low on the list.

Uncharted 2 could have been above SMGs and why is Unchrted 3 not on the list?! And also, why no Arkham City?!

Love topics like these. Nothing but endless whining about someone's favorite game not being included or such and such game being too high or low on the list.

It's pretty silly to even use this list to have a discussion for a few reasons, and none of them have to do with the content of the list itself.

First, the list is always changing because it's ranked based on user ratings on a scale of 1 to 5. As new people rate games, the games will shift order. In fact, earlier today someone mentioned that Mario Galaxy 1 and 2 were ranked #2 and #5. In a matter of hours, those games had secured the #2 and #3 spots.

And why do the rankings change so quickly? Because a number of these games (at the time of me posting this) have under 40 total ratings! Right now you could flood a game with positive ratings and drastically changes it's ranking. Sample size is far too small.

LOL, this list is not meant to be an end-all be-all list of Top 100 games. It's meant to give you a snapshot of what users on that site think of games.

We could destroy any semblance of credibility to this list by simply agreeing to all give a 5 star rating to some crappy game and watch it skyrocket up that chart. We could all go give Deal or No Deal 5 stars and watch it become one of the Top 100 games of all time, if we really wanted to.

this is about as good as this type of list is gonna get

Xenoblade's appearance and some other cool stuff like Shenmue and Deus Ex more than makes up for people still thinking OOT is the best game ever

Can't say I agree with this list much at all.

Yes, yes it is.

Whoa, a user list that actually rates Uprising somewhat accurately. Good to see Xenoblade Chronicles get its well deserved recognition.

Really? Are you serious?

@I-U So basically you're saying that your opinion = other people's opinions? Because I'd say it's waaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too low. But then again, you're still going on that I-won't-listen-to-what-other-people-say-when-they-say-you-can-change-the-controls rampage.

A Link to the Past IS better than Majora's Mask. Why is that hard to fathom?

The execution of the controls is only one issue I have with the game, and I have been listening, I just haven't had the urge to pick up Uprising again yet. Will probably do so after I beat Nostalgia, so that I can finally have Uprising beaten.

Why is it better? Can you explain it to me? is it a fact? or is it your opinion?

A fine mix of old school and new school.

It's funny because people still actually think Ocarina of Time is the best game ever. Definitely no nostalgia blindless there guys...