General Discussion Forum

Topic: Sonic and the Worst Fandom Ever

Showing 41 to 59 of 59

AuthorMessage
Drawdler

Drawdler

41. Posted:

You know, the Spyro fandom reminds me of the Sonic fandom
And the Crash fandom
... And every fandom ever

Void wrote:

Machamp_King wrote:

You people may think that Sonic has bad Fanart,but i'm gonna compare it to a Series that has even worse fanart...
Untitled
Untitled

I don't get it, that Gyarados looks pretty good.

I think that MC is trying to make fun of the fact that everyone tries to draw Pokémon really realistically, and I agree, and it's really annoying when I go on Google Images to look for regular art of Pokémon I like, but I'd say that's actually one of the best Pokémon drawings I've ever seen... The "realistic" and "epic" Pokémon art throws me off of looking at any of it at all.
I also think that Sonic art looks good for what it's going for.
Unless he's just trying to say he actually likes it.

Edited on by Drawdler

Myland's Dream Address: 6500-2329-0504 | darkSpyro | Ghostroaster | Reddit

Nintendo Network ID: Nibelilt

AuthorMessage
Raylax

Raylax

42. Posted:

  • Take something with enormous community.
  • Find negative points of community (of which there will be, invariably, hundreds).
  • Ignore strong points of community (of which there will also be many).
  • Tar over all individual details as the though the fandom is one large, squelchy amorphous grey blob and not in fact thousands of individual people.
  • Declare WORST FANDOM EVER!!!1!

Sonic fandom's certainly not without its problems, I won't deny. But they're neither the best nor worst fandom out there. They're just a fandom. It will be a joyous day indeed when the various internet factions stop pretending to be political giants on the verge of mass warfare and just get on with doing whatever it is they do without feeling it necessary to point at each other and go MY FANDOM IZ BETTAR THAN UR FANDOM LOLZ.

Also, that 'realistic Pokémon art sux' argument going on above me is ridiculous. Somebody combining something that they enjoy with something that they're good at? UNHEARD OF! All fan projects must fall within guideline procedures! Please consult your copy of the Fandom Handbook for details on artistic styles and talent levels that fall within regulation protocol.

Edited on by Raylax

ACNF: Visit Somni! DC: 7000 3442 7110
theblackdragon: ahaha perfect response to that thread, raylax
theblackdragon: eff your other responses, though
theblackdragon: all of them
theblackdragon: in the entire history of ever >:[
theblackdragon: they've all sucked

Nintendo Network ID: RaylaxKai

AuthorMessage
moomoo

moomoo

43. Posted:

CanisWolfred wrote:

I've seen worse...articles. It was overly long, really petty, and just...not that good. :/ The fandom really is terrible, though, but I don't think even half those "reasons" were worth mentioning. He's muddled his own point with loads of useless information.

Pretty much this. I read it for a while and just... didn't feel like reading after a short while. It was pretty repetitive and got off topic way too often. Never use "awesome" unless in quotes when it comes to articles, by the way. Never a good word to use unless you're talking about something that is actually like that, like being at the top of a mountain and seeing the beauty of creation in your sight. Then it's okay. Also, this... bothers me:

"A modern day E.T., Sonic 2006 was so bad it sent shockwaves through the industry and developers almost never rush their titles for Christmas anymore in the dreaded fear that they would produce the next Sonic 2006."

That sounds like something you'd see in a forum post, not an article. I just can't see that as true, since you've got plenty of games still rushed out the window today that pretty bad.

Sonic fans may not be particularly good ones, but frankly a lot of Sonic games are not good. Sonic and the Black Knight isn't really a solid game in terms of game design and Sonic '06 is a genuinely bad game. If that game released today, we'd be seeing a 2.5 average on Metacritic. Yeah, there are good games too, but it's not like the fanbase has no reason to be upset either.

You've got to keep in mind, too, that most people aren't like that and it's not hard to really just ignore the fanbase and just play what you like. See: every fanbase ever. There's tons of jaded fans when it comes to any property. Just ignore them.

Edited on by moomoo

Best thread ever
Feel free to add me on Miiverse or PSN.
Miiverse is Moomoo14, PSN is Moomoo1405390

Nintendo Network ID: Moomoo14

AuthorMessage
SheldonRandoms

SheldonRandoms

44. Posted:

Austroid wrote:

Untitled

I'm still waiting Sega.

He's arguably your best bet for a sucessful spin-off.

Eggman should get his own spin-off, the man can run faster then Sonic, and just imagine when you collect all the chaos emeralds, best super ever, also Ristar should be in the spin-off somewhere.

Untitled

SUPER SMASH CLASH: A MOBILE MULTIPLAYER PLATFORMER FIGHTING GAME FEATURING MR.RANDOMS AND SOMEBODY HE KNOWS, ZIGGURAT!!!(But he's coming soon, via an update) http://www.smashclashapp.com/

I like to rev up those fryers, I play games, I make stuff with stick figures named Sheldon and Mr. Randoms.

Nintendo Network ID: SheldonRandoms

AuthorMessage
Knux

Knux

45. Posted:

Sega already released a spin-off about Eggman.

Untitled

As for the fanbase...the best way to sum it up is every time I google ''Sonic fanart'' or ''Sonic fanfiction'', I cry over what this new generation has done to my childhood. They did far more damage to Sonic than Sega ever did. :(

Edited on by Knux

Knux

AuthorMessage
LordJumpMad

LordJumpMad

46. Posted:

Can we agree that all fandom is bad.

For you, the day LordJumpMad graced your threads, was the most important day of your life. But for me, it was Tuesday.
University of ⓂⒶⒹness
LordJumpMad's Theme

Twitter:

AuthorMessage
SheldonRandoms

SheldonRandoms

47. Posted:

Knux wrote:

Sega already released a spin-off about Eggman.

Untitled

As for the fanbase...the best way to sum it up is every time I google ''Sonic fanart'' or ''Sonic fanfiction'', I cry over what this new generation has done to my childhood. They did far more damage to Sonic than Sega ever did. :(

That's just Puyo Puyo, with classic Eggman/Robotnik, it would be cool to see a spin of of modern Eggman/Robotnik..........with Ristar somewhere in it.

SUPER SMASH CLASH: A MOBILE MULTIPLAYER PLATFORMER FIGHTING GAME FEATURING MR.RANDOMS AND SOMEBODY HE KNOWS, ZIGGURAT!!!(But he's coming soon, via an update) http://www.smashclashapp.com/

I like to rev up those fryers, I play games, I make stuff with stick figures named Sheldon and Mr. Randoms.

Nintendo Network ID: SheldonRandoms

AuthorMessage
Knux

Knux

48. Posted:

Puyo Puyo or no Puyo Puyo...it's still a spin-off of Eggman. ;)

But I would like to see a non-puzzle spin-off game of Eggman...if it can be done right. After Shadow the Hedgehog, I don't know if having any more good Sonic spin-offs is even possible.

Knux

AuthorMessage
Drawdler

Drawdler

49. Posted:

Raylax wrote:

Also, that 'realistic Pokémon art sux' argument going on above me is ridiculous. Somebody combining something that they enjoy with something that they're good at? UNHEARD OF! All fan projects must fall within guideline procedures! Please consult your copy of the Fandom Handbook for details on artistic styles and talent levels that fall within regulation protocol.

And people are also entitled to their own opinion. All I said is that I don't like it. I'd rather see my Hydreigon with thick lines instead of feathers.
People commenting with their thoughts! Unheard of! :|
Sorry, but I'm not going to say IMO before everything I say. Unless you're trying to clarify facts, everything is just an opinion. I shouldn't have to point out that I'm posting an opinion.

IMO I IMO think IMO realistic IMO Pokémon IMO art IMO looks IMO bad IMO.

Edited on by Drawdler

Myland's Dream Address: 6500-2329-0504 | darkSpyro | Ghostroaster | Reddit

Nintendo Network ID: Nibelilt

AuthorMessage
CanisWolfred

CanisWolfred

50. Posted:

With that argument, isn't he entitled to his opinion of your opinion? And really, it sounds to me that he's pointing out the flaws in people's logic than anything else. What's wrong with that?

Edited on by CanisWolfred

I Hear Your Heart Beat to the Beat of the Drums~

I am the Wolf...Red
Backloggery | DeviantArt
Wolfrun
Arooo~

I Have Furry

AuthorMessage
Drawdler

Drawdler

51. Posted:

But to me, it just seems like he barely read over my post...

that 'realistic Pokémon art sux' argument

I said nothing of the kind that bluntly. I'm merely tring to clarify that I just threw in my opinion. And I don't see how my post can be confused like that.
sigh I can already tell that I'll get too deep into this /leavethread

Myland's Dream Address: 6500-2329-0504 | darkSpyro | Ghostroaster | Reddit

Nintendo Network ID: Nibelilt

AuthorMessage
CanisWolfred

CanisWolfred

52. Posted:

Anyways, Raylax, Moomoo, and yes, even Jumpmad pretty much said everything I have to say on this topic. Just sayin'. Really good posts.

I Hear Your Heart Beat to the Beat of the Drums~

I am the Wolf...Red
Backloggery | DeviantArt
Wolfrun
Arooo~

I Have Furry

AuthorMessage
shingi_70

shingi_70

53. Posted:

Reading the sonic is comics is like a furry version of DBZ

Untitled
Untitled
Untitled
Untitled

WAT!

Hey check out my awesome new youtube channel shingi70 where I update weekly on the latest gaming and comic news form a level headed perspective.

Nintendo Network ID: shingi70

AuthorMessage
LordJumpMad

LordJumpMad

54. Posted:

Are there really hardcore sonic fans here that are really arguing about this?
These are the fans who are into those comix and fake fanfic of sonic, making him into something that hes not.

I blame the internet for ruining sonic.

For you, the day LordJumpMad graced your threads, was the most important day of your life. But for me, it was Tuesday.
University of ⓂⒶⒹness
LordJumpMad's Theme

Twitter:

AuthorMessage
shingi_70

shingi_70

55. Posted:

Sonic was bad before the internet.

WAT!

Hey check out my awesome new youtube channel shingi70 where I update weekly on the latest gaming and comic news form a level headed perspective.

Nintendo Network ID: shingi70

AuthorMessage
Auracle

Auracle

56. Posted:

I think I will just continue to ignore the fanbase. It's unfortunate that it's so messed up, but I'm frankly sick of dealing with it. I'll just continue to enjoy Sonic, whether it be games, comics, or TV shows. I still think that Sonic gets undeserved hate, but whatever. I personally think that those people are missing out. As for the article, sorry if you didn't like it. I thought it was pretty interesting.

I foresee what you'll do there.
Amiibo: Mario, Lucario (2), Toon Link, Luigi, Diddy Kong, Zelda, Gold Mario, Mario (SM), Silver Mario, Inkling Squid, Lucina, Ness, Wario
-The truth is incontrovertible, malice may attack it, ignorance may deride it, but in the end; there it is. ~Winston Churchill

Nintendo Network ID: True_Hero

AuthorMessage
CanisWolfred

CanisWolfred

57. Posted:

Sony_70 wrote:

Reading the sonic is comics is like a furry version of DBZ

Dragon Ball Z was basically an over the top version of Super Man. As far as I'm concerned, the Sonic comics are just an average comic with a terrible, convoluted plot.

I Hear Your Heart Beat to the Beat of the Drums~

I am the Wolf...Red
Backloggery | DeviantArt
Wolfrun
Arooo~

I Have Furry

AuthorMessage
Plusle

Plusle

58. Posted:

May no one forget the hell hole that is SonicPassion.com

3dsFc:2148-9077-4578

AuthorMessage
Final-Starman

Final-Starman

59. Posted:

SheldonRandoms wrote:

Austroid wrote:

Untitled

I'm still waiting Sega.

He's arguably your best bet for a sucessful spin-off.

Eggman should get his own spin-off, the man can run faster then Sonic, and just imagine when you collect all the chaos emeralds, best super ever, also Ristar should be in the spin-off somewhere.

Subscribe to Nintendo Life on YouTube

"Come and get me loser! Spankety Spankety Spankety!" -Pokey
"Yesno It is isn't." -Moonsidian
"Shoot! I missed!" - Loid/Lloyd
Fobbies are... Borange!
TONDA GOSSA!
Nintendo Network ID: The-Ness
ROOOOLIIING STAAAAAART!
↑ & ↓ & ↻
Recently played: Sonic The Hedgehog (IOS)