E-mail just came in. Platinum members get to choose from these two:

Gold members get this one:

I'm patiently awaiting my Mario Hat! Thanks Ninty!

I'll take the hat.

"Your Elite Status Reward will be delivered by November 1, 2009."

Hopefully sooner because I might be living in a new house by then!

Same Here or a Mobile Home...

I think it will be alright. If it's anything like my game and watch collection they will load it in a slingshot and send it right off. That one flew here very quick.

I'm so torn! Argh! I love Punch-Out!! and I could probably get that ASAP! But the HAT!?! Help!

I suspect the Punch-Out might be pirated quickly or go obsolete in a couple years. Hard to pirate the hat! It's one of a kind. No brainer for me. It will be added to my swag collection.

I think it's cheap they won't let us have both. Platinum members don't even get the freakin' calendar, now we gotta choose between a hat and a mini-game? I don't know...

I'd love to get the hat but I'm just a gold member. The calendar will be nice though.

HAT MINE ^^! Going in very special Place :starts scearching for photoframe: i'll keep it in there after wearing it 1 time & go 8 bit Mario jump

I'd choose the Machu hat personally, but that download seems very very very cool!

mine said like a week got here in 4 days i was like O.o Damn Sonic Express Thanks NOA

Fight Louis, or look like Mario? Louis? Mario? Louis? Mario? Oh, man. This is so confusing...

I just ordered the hat... sigrim made a good point... Who knows how long the downloaded game will be active. And 15 minutes of a novelty "dream fight" in Punch-Out isn't worth turning down a "Machu" hat.

Plus, someone may pirate the mini-game or find a way around the code-system... Not that I encourage that, but you never know.

Good Choice you can still beat up the other fighters We both getting the hat ops opens a Water drinks: CONGRATS TO ALL PLATINUM MEMBERS ON NL!

Maybe the hat will be a recurring reward, though...

Possibly, I did kinda read into it a bit...

@Tails86
Get on WiiSpeak in 5 minutes or so if you aren't too busy with Klonoa

I gotted a hat.

Hmm... shopping for a display case for my hat. I won't ever wear it anyway, might as well get something with UV protection.

Yeah I'm a dork :/

Inquiring with a company about a custom made one and having the Nintendo logo engraved on the glass.

I bet after so long they start offering all of these as regular rewards.

The Doc Louis fight gives me hope they may start offering more DLC like this. i.e. SSB: Brawl