Sakura Samurai
Dillon's Rolling Western
Tokyo Crash Mobs
The Denpa Men
Ketzal's Corridors
Pushmo
Pokèdex 3D Pro
3D Classics: Kid Icarus
3D Classics: Kirby's Adventure
3D Classics: Twinbee
VVVVVV
Mutant Mudds
Gunman Clive
Mighty Switch Force!
Liberation Maiden
Aero Porter
Crimson Shroud
Ikachan
Fractured Soul
Marvel Pinball 3D

Gunman Clive. Only game worth mentioning, all the others are either very overrated, or are just meh..

Just a reminder that all nominations must be in before 20:00 CST tonight!

NightSky

Liberation Maiden

ketzal corridors
pushmo
Swapnote

Bird Mania 3D is amazing for $2.
You could also consider Fluidity: Spin Cycle and Kersploosh!

Nominations:
Colors 3D
Mutant Mudds
Pushmo
Liberation Maiden
Bomb Monkey

Nominations:
Gunman Clive
Crimson Shroud
The Denpamen
ATV Wild Ride

Sadly enough, there is nothing of interest for me on the eshop, but if I had to choose one it would be monster shooter, there are others but I haven't played as long as monster shooter.

Pushmo
Mighty Switch Force
VVVVVV
Denpamen
Liberation Maiden
Zen Pinball
Crimson Shroud

Dillion's Rolling Western.
Pushmo.
Crashmo.
Crimson Shroud.
The Denpamen.
Nano Assault EX.

No nomination limit... OK.
Dot Runner
Family Tennis 3D
Gunman Clive
Zen Pinball 3D
Liberation Maiden
VVVVVV
Crimson Shroud
Art of Balance: Touch
Pushmo
Dillon's Rolling Western
Picross e
ColoUrs! 3D

EDIT I've narrowed it down to 12...

Cave Story
VVVVVV
Pushmo
Art of Balance: Touch
Nano Assault: EX
EscapeVektor

I know it's down to opinion, but how can you argue any third-party game is more overrated than GC on the eShop other than Mutant Mudds?

GC is a good game, but the level design can be bland at times, and it is extremely short (to the point where I feel it would be too short for even $2 or $3 more). There are many superior games on the eShop, and the only ones I would call overrated are some of the early games like Mutant Mudds and Pushmo (or any ports).

NightSky, easily the best eShop game
Dillon's Rolling Western
Mutant Mudds
VVVVVV
3D Classics: Kid Icarus
Crimson Shroud

Remember, Just ONE HOUR left for nominations!

EDIT: Nominations are now closed!

1. Pushmo 15
2. Crimson Shroud 10
3. VVVVVV 10
4. Mighty Switch Force! 9
5. Gunman Clive 9
6. The DENPA Men: They Came by Wave 7
7. Mutant Mudds 7
8. Dillon's Rolling Western 7
9. Liberation Maiden 6
10. 3D Classics: Kirby's Adventure 5
11. Sakura Samurai: Art of the Sword 5
12. Crashmo 4
13. Cave Story 4
14. NightSky 4
15. Zen Pinball 3D 4
16. Colors! 3D 4
17. Nano Assault EX 4
18. Ketzal's Corridors 4

Due to how many titles recieved 4 noms, we have 2 more titles than needed. Which 2 titles (with 4 noms) should be kicked off, so we can get things underway?

I'm thinking Colors! 3D (because it's technically not a game), & Crashmo (because Pushmo is already doing a fantastic job representing the series in this poll), but I want some feedback to be sure.

Even though Colors! 3D is my favorite download from the eShop, I agree with your reasoning for it and Crashmo being excluded.

Remove Pushmo instead of Crashmo. It's a much improved game, and it makes more sense to include.

If I would argue to remove 2 games though, it would be VVVVVV (because it would be awful to have the top eShop game being a stripped-down port) and Cave Story (too many ports, it already clogged up DSiWare)