Topic: Starfy or Rhythm Heaven?

Well? What should I get? I need some help!

Both are exceptional games. Both?

Sorry... Can only get one... I'll get one or the other in a couple weeks. Mario vs. DK 3 and MFC are keeping me busy.

Do you like rhythm games, like Elite Beat Agents, or Platformers, like Kirby?

If rhythm buy Rhythm Heaven
If platformers buy Starfy

I haven't played Beat agents, but I really like Kirby. I like the Rockband series too... would that count as rhythm? I've read several reviews for each and they're mixed so I don't know. It doesn't help that I'm watching a Starfy commercial at the moment either.

Ahem. I think I'll take a page from Charlie the Unicorn's book with this reply:
Rhythm Heaven:
Pros:

• Simple yet endearing graphics
• 50 addicting minigames, almost all of which are great
• Normally upbeat, memorable soundtrack
• Variety and value
• Wacky charm and distinct Japanese feel
• Understands what the player wants
• Rewarding/fulfilling
• "Skip a minigame if it's too hard for you" option

Cons:

• Sometimes insane difficulty
• Almost strictly for the musically inclined
• Provides little in the way of constructive criticism
• Some vocals and lyrics bordering on awful

Overall: 8.7/10*

The Legendary Starfy:
Pros:

• Packed with content
• Adorable story and characters
• Good soundtrack
• Makes fairly clever use of the DS hardware
• Quality graphics
• Well thought-out levels
• Multiplayer, while scarce, is implemented masterfully
• Just plain fun minigames (once you figure out how to play them)

Cons:

• Extremely easy
• Sometimes too much is happening in the game at one time, though that might be a pro for some
• Cluttered menus and features
• Most collectibles are pointless
• Character voice snippets can get annoying

Overall: 8.5/10*

Feel free to correct me about anything and everything in this post, and note that I am not recommending Rhythm Heaven over The Legendary Starfy, because I don't think these games should really be compared.
*I have not beaten either of these games completely yet, so these are not complete impressions.

Thanks for the help... I still think Starfy might be better. Now to earn the money... SOME ONE SEND ME $35!!

Both games are diff. and i played both, but Rhythm Heaven ..Kicks Adrenaline more but Starfy is also very good!

Since Rhythm Heaven is the most fun I had with a game in a long time, I'd always recommend it above all else.

Now I'm confused again. I might get Conduit because I haven't gotten a new Wii game in a while.

i'd say starfy....unless u get the Conduit

i'm not a big fan of rhythm games so i didn't buy Rhythm Heaven (cue shocking facial expression)

Apparently Conduit isn't very long, but I do love multiplayer shooters. I think Red Steel currently has the best; but I will probably get Conduit.

you mentioned you really like Kirby, so I'd go for Starfy if I were you.

Gah, so you started this thread about Rhythm Heaven and Starfy, but have since decided to get The Conduit?!

@Odnetnin: It's a possibility. I'm not entirely sure yet though; I was just thinking about it yesterday and thought that might be a good game to get.

@minial: If you love multiplayer FPS, buy CoD4 right now. Don't own a 360/PS3/PC? Tough luck, go buy one

As for what you actually care about, I think The Conduit will last you the longest, RH is best if you want a quirky unique rhythm game, and Stafi is a safe bet if you like platformers.

Overall, wait till The Conduit gets some reviews, then decide.

If you can, get both.
If you can't get Starfy. I got Starfy the other day and I love it!
But, I've also heard that Rhythm Heaven is a pretty good game, too!

@Dark Link: I can only get one... and I might pick up both over time, but Its between Conduit, Starfy, and Wii Sports Resort currently, but I'm leaning towards Starfy right now. Plus I have at leasty two weeks to decide so...

Actually, the Wii version of Ghostbusters looks good. Is it worth the cash? I'm a huge fan of the series, and the game sounded good as soon as I heard about it.

Well, I'm back to Starfy after reading some crud reviews for ghostbusters. It [Starfy] sounds like the perfect game so far, unless something good comes out soon that I can't live without. My freind plans to get Conduit, so I'll just borrow it from him.