Showing 1 to 20 of 26
1. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 07:10 BST
Hey I think the reviews here are great but anybody else notice that they give like half the games here a 9 out of 10? Just putting that out there its kind of bothering me.
Edited on Fri 26th June, 2009 @ 07:14 by ColdPizza
2. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 07:16 BST
I guess you haven't met Corbie yet!
Nintendo Network ID: WolfRamHeart
3. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 07:21 BST
4. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 07:23 BST
Well out of 798 scores, we've given 117 9's. that's not too bad. About 1 game out of 7 gets a 9. And as has been stated, many of those are retro reviews, and we're mainly doing the games we like right now when we get time.
Edited on Fri 26th June, 2009 @ 07:25 by Corbs
Retro Editor, Nintendo Life
Vita Editor, Push Square
5. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 07:24 BST
No, obviously not. What exactly is bothering you? Look at the lists of games on this site and sort them by review score if you really want to know how the scores break down.
Nintendo Network ID: Edwicket
6. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 07:26 BST
Well I think they hand out 9's too often. GTA: ChinaTown Wars and the Legendary Starfy recieved the same score. The Legendary Starfy is a good game, I have it but I think it deserves a different score than a game like ChinaTown Wars.
7. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 07:29 BST
Two completely different types of games. I can't believe that's an actual argument you are using, but you have the right to your opinion
8. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 07:34 BST
A quick glance will tell you that most of those 10s and 9s belong to highly critically acclaimed retro titles. As for the Starfy thing, the reviewers at NintendoLife are obviously huge Starfy fans so it's natural that the game might have gotten an extra point because of that.
Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars World of Goo Paper Mario Super Mario 64 Super Mario Bros. 3 Super Mario WorldSuper Metroid The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Adventure Resident Evil 4 Resident Evil 4: Wii Edition Super Mario Galaxy Super Mario Sunshine The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask Banjo-Kazooie Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles: My Life as a King LostWinds Mayhem in Monsterland Toki Tori Castlevania III: Dracula's Curse Last Ninja 2: Back with a Vengeance ActRaiser Contra III: The Alien Wars Devil's Crush Donkey Kong Country Donkey Kong Country 2: Diddy's Kong Quest Donkey Kong Country 3: Dixie Kong's Double Trouble! DoReMi Fantasy: Milon's DokiDoki Adventure F-Zero F-Zero X Gate of Thunder Ghouls 'n Ghosts Gunstar Heroes Last Ninja 3 Landstalker Lords of Thunder MUSHA Mario Kart 64 Mario's Super Picross Mega Man 2 New Adventure Island Phantasy Star IV Mega Man 9 Ristar Samurai Shodown II Shining Force II: Ancient Sealing Sin and Punishment Soldier Blade Sonic the Hedgehog 2 Star Fox 64 Star Parodier Streets of Rage 2 Super Castlevania IV Super Ghouls 'n Ghosts Super Mario Bros. Super Turrican 2 Ys Book I & II Advance Wars: Days of Ruin Beyond Good & Evil Bleach: Blade of Fate Boom Blox Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow Chibi-Robo: Park Patrol Chrono Trigger Contra 4 Elite Beat Agents Essential Sudoku Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem Final Fantasy IV Final Fantasy: Crystal Chronicles Ikaruga MadWorld Mario & Luigi: Partners In Time Mario Kart WiiMario Kart: Double Dash!! Mercury Meltdown Revolution Metal Slug Anthology Metroid Prime 3: Corruption Metroid Prime: Hunters Okami Picross DS Pikmin Pokemon Diamond & Pearl Pro Evolution Soccer 2008 Resident Evil Sonic Rush SSX 3 Super Monkey Ball Super Paper Mario Super Smash Bros. Brawl
The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker Trauma Center: Second Opinion WarioWare Touched! Wii Fit Zack & Wiki: Quest for Barbaros’ Treasure Grand Theft Auto: Chinatown Wars Rhythm Heaven Swords & Soldiers The House of the Dead: Overkill Secret of Mana Mega Man 3 Samurai Shodown Anthology Terranigma Punch-Out!! Ogre Battle: The March of the Black Queen NyxQuest: Kindred Spirits Bit.Trip: Beat Bomberman '94 Klonoa Boom Blox Bash Party Onslaught Virtua Tennis 2009 Excitebots: Trick Racing Art Style: AQUITE Virtual Boy Wario Land Mighty Flip Champs! Tiger Woods PGA Tour 10 New Play Control! Donkey Kong Jungle Beat NPokemon Platinum Valkyrie Profile: Covenant of the Plume Professor Layton and the Curious Village Art Style: PiCTOBiTS Conker's Bad Fur Day Pokémon Red and Blue Lufia II: Rise of the Sinistrals The Legendary Starfy Little King's Story Rune Factory: Frontier Pic Pic Shantae Disgaea DS
Scared of the future, but bored with the past.
9. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 07:36 BST
Try not to focus on the numerical score so much. Read the whole review. People have a tendency to just look at the score and bypass the review. You got to take the whole review into consideration.
EDIT: I agree with you that both GTA: Chinatown Wars and Starfy are good games. Clearly you have excellent taste!
Edited on Fri 26th June, 2009 @ 08:27 by WolfRamHeart
10. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 07:36 BST
Yeah your right, they are pretty different but I'm just saying. They should get a 9.5 rating in here because it looks to me like they really need that.
11. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 07:49 BST
Not THAT many games here get 9's. They're mostly 7s, duh!
Just Because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!- Homer SimpsonNintendolife Chat. I'm never in it, but it's good to ptomote these things.VC-Forums. We're desperate. Please join.My Backloggery
12. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 08:18 BST
If you think here there are too many 9's, i should reccomend you the Spanish magazines Hobby Consolas, Nintendo Acción and Micromania(all of the from the same publisher :rolleyes ). It's nearly impossible to see a review under an 8'5 score. Not to mention the reviews that are about a quarter part of a decent review.
13. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 08:44 BST
Lol maybe once if I knew how to read Spanish. But IGN often rates games far too high compared to other sites, but IGN is way too sold-out.
14. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 08:51 BST
Little King's Story got a 9. AND I WILL NEVER FORGIVE YOU PROSODY
10! 10! 10!
15. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 08:57 BST
The funny thing is that Prosody really loves Little King's Story! I wonder what stopped him from giving it a perfect ten? Oh well, I'm still getting it obviously!
16. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 09:00 BST
I wanted to give it a 10, I really did. In fact, in hindsight, I don't know why I didn't. I think it was the lack of 60Hz mode which made the graphics a tiny bit blurry for my poor ageing eyes.
It's interesting to hear feedback on our review scores though, particularly when we've received criticism in the past for not giving certain games 9/10.
I am not ignoring you. I just do not post much.
17. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 09:05 BST
I bet someone thought CID The Dummy diserved a 9 didn't they.
Edited on Fri 26th June, 2009 @ 09:05 by y2josh
18. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 09:08 BST
I'd just like a bigger scale to judge games on. Icarian is no where near as good as Tiger10, which isn't quite as good as LKS, but they all got a 9, instead of say.... Icarian -85, Tiger -93, LKS 100 (or 99 if your gonna insist no 60hz diminished the utter joy of living in Alpoko, which I miss like a dear friend now).
Note to self, change avatar as the lil fella is haunting me now. KING!
Edited on Fri 26th June, 2009 @ 09:10 by Machu
19. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 14:54 BST
I think the scores are generally high, too, but I don't want a wider scale. Most people reading a review are going to round it, anyway. If I see a 9.2, I think 9. I don't think, man, this game is so much better than that 9 game, I better get it. People should just learn to ignore the score completely. Unless you don't trust their writing, there's no need to even look at the number. The score chart shows that they just mean things like "good" or "great," and you can easily pick up on that from the review.
Come on, friends,
To the bear arcades again.
20. Posted: Fri 26th Jun 2009 14:59 BST
I tend to look at the numerical score as representing not how good the game is, but how much the reviewer is recommending it. A 10 is a must get, a 1 is "I wouldn't recommend this to my worst enemy."
You can argue about Starfy and China Town Wars not deserving the same quality rating, but sharing a recommendation is something quite different, and might help you to reconcile them.
NL Forum Moderator / Part-Time Reviewer / One-Track Lover
Noiseless Chatter, my pop culture blog that will change your life
Wii U Account: ChickenBrutus (add me!)
Mega Man No Damage Runs, and more