Forums

Topic: Why Sticker Star fails and why Nintendo should stop making worse Paper Mario games

Posts 21 to 40 of 191

3dsplayer

WhiteNoise17 wrote:

Sticker Star was what it should have been PORTABLE Paper Mario easy to jump in and out of on the go or anywhere at least thats what it was for me...

No, especially for the ds there's so many solid titles out there.

League of legends username - 3dsplayer ( 2pacEn0t0ri0u3cr is currently banned)
Neopet shop - http://www.neopets.com/browseshop.phtml?owner=bosswario
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxeklRO7qWw

OptometristLime

3dsplayer wrote:

SCAR392 wrote:

I agree with you. I think Sticker Star is better than Super Paper Mario, but both of them aren't as good as the first one or TTYD. I'd say it's a tie between the 1st 2, because they both had good elemnts that weren't available in one or the other.

Yeah Super Paper Mario and Sticker Star are completely different so its all dependent on the player's personal intertersts and opinions.

But the original is still better then all 3, and the original is 12 years (almost 13) older then sticker star, yet far superior.

Good points, yes to both of you.

I think the Paper Mario franchise has a very strong legacy, yet the games have strayed from their original concept. Sticker Star isn't that bad though, the RPG elements (as mentioned) fail to stand out in comparison with other games. Had the sequels been made in a different universe, I might have liked them better or at least not minded their existence as much...

Aside from the title, your message was fairly positive so I don't understand the haters.

Edited on by OptometristLime

You are what you eat from your head to your feet.

3dsplayer

Zizzy wrote:

The more complaining people do, the less likely a good, new Paper Mario will be released. Focus on things you like, rather than things you don't like, life might surprise you and give you more things you enjoy.

This is a review on all Paper Mario games, I'm a little Paper Mario fanatic so I can leave my opinion if I want to. And it's not complaining, it's the truth, why does Nintendo have to keep disappointing on the Paper Mario series? Also you should be more respectful on other people's opinions especially for video games, instead of blanting uselessness like saying i'm complaining.

Edited on by theblackdragon

League of legends username - 3dsplayer ( 2pacEn0t0ri0u3cr is currently banned)
Neopet shop - http://www.neopets.com/browseshop.phtml?owner=bosswario
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxeklRO7qWw

3dsplayer

8BitSamurai wrote:

3dsplayer wrote:

WiiULoveSquid wrote:

I like Sticker Star, so for me it's no failure. I highly recommend it to anyone who hasn't played!

I still gave it a 7.9/10, which is still good and is a good buy. But I'm just saying, why not make a better game when you had it, what, 12 years before?

I think Nintendo just made a lot of mistakes with the concepts of the game. When some people (Not me, I loved SPM) complained about too much text in SPM, they just wanted it to go back to TTYD levels, instead Nintendo removed the plot and characters entirely. Same thing with the battle systems, the people complaining about the turn-based battles being gone wanted a more refined TTYD with some fresh twists, not really what SS offered. Although I think people would have warmed up to the sticker system some more had it been executed properly. The battles were almost completely pointless in the game, and the stickers littered around the world just looked junky IMO.

The game has a load of other problems as well, on top of just feeling uninspired, cheap, and generic, but those are my thoughts.

Nintendo should just listen to me Paper Mario master veteran. Untitled

Edited on by 3dsplayer

League of legends username - 3dsplayer ( 2pacEn0t0ri0u3cr is currently banned)
Neopet shop - http://www.neopets.com/browseshop.phtml?owner=bosswario
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxeklRO7qWw

SCRAPPER392

Ya, the dojo master was awesome.

Qwest

3DS Friend Code: 4253-3737-8064 | Nintendo Network ID: Children

WhiteNoise17

3dsplayer wrote:

WhiteNoise17 wrote:

Sticker Star was what it should have been PORTABLE Paper Mario easy to jump in and out of on the go or anywhere at least thats what it was for me...

No, especially for the ds there's so many solid titles out there.

To be fair to the game I didn't go in with the mindset that this was gonna be the new TTYD or like the original but a separate experience all together. The only main gripe with the game were the way stickers were used in battle because if you ran out during one you were screwed and like @8BitSamurai said some battles were pointless. But yeah some games were better like DQ9 to me anyway.

Edited on by WhiteNoise17

Capcom at E3: Guys we're sorry about how we've been treating Mega Man so we're gonna make it up to you by releasing the Mega Man Cancelled Collection with all the titles we cancelled in the condition they we're in just before we pulled the plug. Now who wants Street Fighter X Monster Hunter?

3dsplayer

SCAR392 wrote:

Ya, the dojo master was awesome.

Agreed, also had to grind hard to defeat him lol.

Edited on by 3dsplayer

League of legends username - 3dsplayer ( 2pacEn0t0ri0u3cr is currently banned)
Neopet shop - http://www.neopets.com/browseshop.phtml?owner=bosswario
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxeklRO7qWw

Zizzy

3dsplayer wrote:

This is a review on all Paper Mario games, I'm a little Paper Mario fanatic so I can leave my opinion if I want to. And it's not complaining, it's the truth, why does Nintendo have to keep disappointing on the Paper Mario series? Also you should be more respectful on other people's opinions especially for video games fool, instead of blanting uselessness like saying i'm complaining.

I never said it isn't the truth, it's very possible to complain about the truth. I do stand by the fact that complaining gets nothing done, I try my best not to complain about things I can't help change. I'm sorry you feel I disrespected your opinion (I don't believe I did, though), let me just say that you are on the internet where people will challenge your opinions, so no need to get so defensive. They are, in fact, your opinions and can only be affected by your thoughts, not mine or anyone elses!

Edited on by Zizzy

Zizzy

3DS Friend Code: 4425-1585-6021 | Nintendo Network ID: Zizzy147

3dsplayer

Zizzy wrote:

3dsplayer wrote:

This is a review on all Paper Mario games, I'm a little Paper Mario fanatic so I can leave my opinion if I want to. And it's not complaining, it's the truth, why does Nintendo have to keep disappointing on the Paper Mario series? Also you should be more respectful on other people's opinions especially for video games fool, instead of blanting uselessness like saying i'm complaining.

I never said it isn't the truth, it's very possible to complain about the truth. I do stand by the fact that complaining gets nothing done, I try my best not to complain about things I can't help change. I'm sorry you feel I disrespected your opinion (I don't believe I did, though), let me just say that you are on the internet where people will challenge your opinions, so no need to get so defensive. They are, in fact, your opinions and can only be affected by your thoughts, not mine or anyone elses!

Its a review not a complaint, idk how silly you have to be to not understand that. No disrespect was felt .
Please refrain from name-calling and the use of offensive slurs — TBD

Edited on by theblackdragon

League of legends username - 3dsplayer ( 2pacEn0t0ri0u3cr is currently banned)
Neopet shop - http://www.neopets.com/browseshop.phtml?owner=bosswario
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxeklRO7qWw

The_Ninja

Says the game is a disaster
Gives it a 7.9

The_Ninja

3DS Friend Code: 1891-2599-4796

yyyy89786

I think Sticker Star is a very good game, maybe not on par with the original, but they threw in some unique things to make it a fun experience.

yyyy89786

Tobiaku

With exception of the final stage, I enjoyed sticker star. Its certanly unique.

Tobiaku

3DS Friend Code: 1977-0291-4355

6ch6ris6

i got the game from a friend and played it for a few hours. really hate the stickers. worst rpg fighting system i have ever played

Ryzen 5 2600
2x8GB DDR4 RAM 3000mhz
GTX 1060 6GB

kingston589

I just couldnt get into it. The sticker mechanic was super annoying. Atleast it came with donkey kong.

Currently Playing: Smash Bros, Ducktales Remastered and Bayou Billy
Youtube: PlatTheFormer
Steam: PlatTheFormer

Nintendo Network ID: kingston589

Tobiaku

kingston589 wrote:

I just couldnt get into it. The sticker mechanic was super annoying. Atleast it came with donkey kong.

Was donkey kong in sticker star?

Tobiaku

3DS Friend Code: 1977-0291-4355

kingston589

Tobias95 wrote:

kingston589 wrote:

I just couldnt get into it. The sticker mechanic was super annoying. Atleast it came with donkey kong.

Was donkey kong in sticker star?

If you got the digital version of sticker star before like january, they gave you a download code for donkey kong arcade edition. I cant remeber if this was through club nintendo or just nintendo themselves.

Currently Playing: Smash Bros, Ducktales Remastered and Bayou Billy
Youtube: PlatTheFormer
Steam: PlatTheFormer

Nintendo Network ID: kingston589

Tobiaku

kingston589 wrote:

Tobias95 wrote:

kingston589 wrote:

I just couldnt get into it. The sticker mechanic was super annoying. Atleast it came with donkey kong.

Was donkey kong in sticker star?

If you got the digital version of sticker star before like january, they gave you a download code for donkey kong arcade edition. I cant remeber if this was through club nintendo or just nintendo themselves.

Probaly Club Nintendo, cause its not aviable in Norway. Its a bit annoying actualy, knowing about goodies you cant get. (I did not know arcade dk was given out outside of Japan)

Tobiaku

3DS Friend Code: 1977-0291-4355

This topic has been archived, no further posts can be added.